Bored Panda
“It Is Not The 1950s”: 79 People Who Turned Down Marriage Proposals Explain Their Reasoning

“It Is Not The 1950s”: 79 People Who Turned Down Marriage Proposals Explain Their Reasoning

31
2
Proposing to someone you love can be incredibly nerve-wracking. Even if you’ve been together for years, you’ll want the big day to go perfectly according to plan. Make sure they show up to the location at just the right time, hire a photographer who will be waiting on the sidelines, and if you’re proposing to a woman, you might want to sneakily ensure that her nails are on point.
But one thing that you should be confident about before getting down on one knee is that your partner will actually say yes. Otherwise, you might be in for an uncomfortable ride home. Redditors have been opening up about moments when they had to reject a loved one’s proposal, so we’ve gathered some of their juiciest stories below. Good luck getting through these tales without experiencing too much second-hand embarrassment, and be sure to upvote the ones that you find particularly painful!

#41

I was in my first year of college and a guy friend from Brazil got a reckless driving charge for going 30 mph over the speed limit. He proposed to me because his lawyer said it would be a good move. I considered it, but once I figured out that helping him to stay in the country would be considered a felony I Noped the f**k outta that situation.
Report
7points

#42

I was 16, he was 19. He did it at our high school graduation knowing I didn't like to be the center of attention. Oh and we we're only dating for 4ish months. It wasn't really him, I just wasn't ready for marriage and he decided if I didn't say yes we weren't staying together.
7points

#43

Young woman looking away with a ring light shining behind her, capturing moments of popped the question embarrassment.
Boyfriend of 2 years at the time. I was 18 and visiting him while he was stationed in another state. I thought he was joking when he told me we could go to the courthouse and get it done. When I laughed and said no he tried pitching all the benefits we would get. When I said no again he stormed out angrily and called me later drunk telling me I was a [jerk] for rejecting his marriage proposal. I broke up with him soon afterwards.
6points

#44

My wife refused my first proposal......

We just got home from the bars and we were eating chicken wings in bed after [intimate] time. I got up to get a napkin and when I came back in I held out a flat wing that I had eaten everything I could of off of it and asked her to marry me with it. She laughs about it to this day.
6points

#45

My ex asked me to marry him, and I had to turn him down.

My reason? I was 13 at the time...
Report
6points

#46

I turned down one because I was 19, the guy was drunk, and we hadn't been dating that long. Also, what he said was: "I want to marry you and make you have, like, 10,000 of my babies. What do you think?" I thought we should break up. Apparently, this worked on the girl after me, though. He married her after about a month and they only have 9,999 babies to go.
Report
6points

#47

An ex once proposed as a last resort to hold on to me when I was breaking up with him. I tried not to laugh (he seemed hurt enough), but I did say something along the lines of, "seriously? I'm breaking up with you and you think that proposing will make me stay?" Apparently he did.
6points

#48

I've been proposed to by two different people.

The first was on my 16th birthday. It was a stupid high school relationship, so I had no trouble just walking away from that one... in fact, it barely counts imho.

The second was a bit more complicated. My junior year of high school, I started dating one of the Chinese exchange students at our school. He was a tad clingy, but a very sweet guy just a year older (or so I thought; he was actually 23) than me who had already seen the world. That summer, I myself went to China to study and teach English on the western side of the country, and came to visit him in his city right before I was supposed to head back to the USA. When I arrived, he tearfully proposed with the biggest ring I had ever seen in my life.

I was shocked, and hastily blurted out how I would think about it (which he took as a yes even though I was starting to have second thoughts about our relationship in general). The next few days I was whisked across the city being shown off as the white trophy fiancée, much to my mortification. He and his parents gave me no space to raise any objections.

Finally I got him alone and ohhhh so awkwardly explained how I wasn't ready to get married, using my desire to go to college as an excuse. He then offered to purchase me a seat at the Chinese school that he would be attending (did I mention his dad was a billionaire?). I finally put my foot down... and he freaked out. He had been very accustomed to getting his way, and my refusal devastated him. He started making threats to jump off the balcony of his apartment (42nd story), report me for working off of my visa (oops), impound my passport, start rumors, etc. He even followed me to the airport and got on a plane back to the USA ostensibly to go to college here in a sudden change of plans.

For the next few months I got a few tearful messages on my phone begging me to be his girlfriend again and even a few snapshots of him harming himself or looking generally sad. I genuinely felt bad about it all, but didn't know what to do. He's doing quite well now, though, studying engineering in the US and dating another Chinese national.

Needless to say that put me off of dating for a while.

tl:dr missed out on the golddigging chance of a lifetime.
5points

#49

My boyfriend and I were once in the awkward situation of being simultaneously homeless AND planning a trip to study abroad. But that's a whole other story.

While in china, we took a day trip to "the summer palace" where my boyfriend proposed in Irish (I have Irish heritage). I burst into tears (the bad kind) and sobbed out a "no!". It was made worse because he had hidden the ring (Irish made) the entire trip until then and told everyone he was going to ask.

We had just had a long talk the night before about not getting married on the account of when we got home there would be no place for us to live and we couldn't really plan a wedding. I guess he figured he had already come this far and asked anyway.

I also caught him with the ring one other time and told him it still wasn't the right time.

5 years later we are very happily married, have a son, and own 3 houses

Tl;Dr I said sobbed no, he wasn't discouraged. Turned out good in the end.
5points

#50

The first time: We were both 19. I was planning on spending a summer in New Zealand, but he reeeeally wanted me to stay and go on a trip with him instead. I debated for two weeks and finally chose to stay. He asked to borrow a few hundred and proposed a couple months later. I actually said yes at first, because I loved him and figured we'd be together forever, so why not. The second I had a ring on my finger my mind completely changed. I realized he wasnt who I tried to convince myself he was. I didn't wanna give up so I said lets get through college. But we were on two completely separate paths so I called it off for good.

Person number two: he was just crazy. He proposed as a last resort to save the relationship. Nononononono.

*Edit. My only regret in life so far is that I didn't go to New Zealand.
5points

#51

Not me, but my wife.

While she was at BCT for the National Guard, (before we were married, but we had been dating about 5 years at that point) a guy with a very thick accent told her that he needed to speak to her father. Well, she has not had contact with her father since sometime early in high school (hell, I've never met him, never plan to either) and she told this guy such. He then went on and said that he must speak to her father. Eventually it comes out that he wants to speak to her father about her dowry. Something about his father has many cattle and he could provide for her very well. I think she told him something about how that's not how things are done in the US, her father had no say in who she married, and she was happily dating someone. Dude backed off and apparently was otherwise pleasant for the rest of the time there, just a monstrous amount of culture shock. I still laugh about it every time I remember her telling me about it.
Report
5points

#52

My mom turned down my dad’s original proposal.

My parents had been dating for roughly three months when they got pregnant with me. They had moved in together and things had been going well. My mom was making dinner and my dad was on his knees fixing the kitchen door and out of nowhere he asks her to marry him. She thinks he’s kidding and tells him he can’t be serious. His exact line was “well I’m already on my knees.” He had married before but had been separated from his ex wife for a number of years, but they were still technically married. So my mom told him he needed to get that figured out and propose in not such a dopey way.
Report
4points

#53

There was a weird guy who worked at a thrift store where a friend of mine worked when we were in high school; he was in his early 20s. I was about 16 when this happened; I became friends with a few members of the staff and he was a part of that group. He was always weird and kinda creepy but we had similar tastes in music and hung out with some of the same people. Teenage priorities. He was pretty upfront about finding me attractive from the get-go although I made it clear I wasn't into him in that way. Because I was so young and inexperienced with these things and pretty live-and-let-live I didn't see any reason to not be nice.

I agreed to go over to his apartment one time while [[assing] time waiting for another friend to get home from her job so we could hang out. I thought we'd drink some beer and listen to music. He kept complimenting me and talking about how "perfect" I was. I cut the visit short because it wasn't sitting well with me.

The next time we hung out he tried to convince me to run off right then and there and elope with him. I thought he was joking at first. He wouldn't come off of it and then I realized he was actually serious. He had this weird intensity that was extremely off-putting. I left immediately when I realized he was actually serious and managed to never see him again. It's been 20ish years and I still feel gross typing this out. Was he actually joking? I hope so but jfc that was awkward.
Report
4points

#54

Lol my girlfriend did it to me 2 years ago ...

i had been planning on asking her to marry me for a few months but wanted to have an amazing night and time doing it so i saved up money, bought the ring and then spent 500 quid on a 5 star hotel on the south bank in london along our favourite walk. everything was set, i had a dinner booked and planned on proposing to her at our favourite spot along the walk. the whole night was gunna be a lovely surprise for her and i was gunna pack her bag and makeup whilst she was at work, pick her up and take her right to london.
i was very excited at the prospect of getting engaged to the woman i love and figured it was a certainty she'd say yes. we'd talked a bit about marriage, kids and our future together etc and it all pointed to us getting engaged, she even showed me the kind of ring she liked!

so a week before i was due to surprise her i brought up getting engaged and all of a sudden she was like "oh noo noo not yet, i want to marry you one day but i'm not ready to get engaged just yet". i was a bit miffed at it, she couldn't put 2 and 2 together and just dropped the whole thing. so there we have it, a day before our trip i tlld her i had a surprise and took her to london for the night. she thought it was just a nice gesture and didn't even suspect i planned on proposing to her lol.

whole thing cost me like 900 quid altogether just for a funny story!

we did get engaged a few months later in a far less expensive proposal in our living room on christmas day and are getting married next year so it has a happy yet frustratingly expensive ending though!
Report
4points

#55

Young woman sitting in a car looking down, capturing a moment related to popping the question and ring embarrassment.
High school bf had dumped me after two years, revealing that he had never truly loved me. I went to college, and we still had occasional contact over my first semester. When I came home for Christmas break, he asked me to give him a ride home from where we had been with a group of friends, telling me he needed to ask me something. In my car in front if his apartment, he told me that he didn't want an answer right then, to go home and pray about it, but God told him to ask me to marry him. I went home and went to sleep instead, then told him no thank you the next day. He seemed disappointed but totally unsurprised.
4points

#56

**TL;DR:** ex-girlfriend was in the military, went a little cuckoo and eventually proposed causing me to refuse and end our relationship.

Ex-girlfriend of mine was in the military. In short after a few tours in Afghanistan immersed in active combat she was diagnosed with PTSD and was receiving treatment for it. We were working through it as a team and all was good. It was obviously hard at times but we had a good system in place to help deal with it and had awesome communication.

Then rumours begin circulating of her platoon being deployed again. Boom. Suddenly she was given a clean bill of health and cleared to go. She had no issues with it, she wanted to go back, so we talked about it she explained it was mainly due to the adrenaline rush active combat provides. There’s no comparison. Cue us trying to organise our lives with her impending tour and attempting to build a future together for when she returns.

Her behaviour became more and more erratic before she left, she admitted to me that she often pushed her car to 100mph on the motorway and slipped in and out of unlikely spaces in traffic. I was understandably concerned, not only for her but for the general public. Do they deserve to die because you want your adrenaline fix? She was clearly unwell and not fit for active duty (in my eyes, but what the hell do I know?) and discussions about this subsequently created a lot of tension between us.

She left as scheduled and we kept in touch as much as possible through Facebook, Blueys and Skype as we had done in the past. A few weeks in she starts putting up cryptic statuses online about how she’s ‘handed in her papers’ and is leaving the Army. I call her up to question her on what’s happening and the answer is either “I didn’t write that” or some version of “I didn’t mean it that way”. The statuses were invariably deleted afterwards. She also began lying to me about things quite blatantly, when I confronted her about it she again told me it never happened. In hindsight it’s absolutely possible she didn’t remember saying certain things due to the untreated PTSD. It was pretty confusing and only got worse when she started to accuse me of ‘holding back’ her military career. Her reasoning behind this notion was due to the fact I wouldn’t agree to move onto base with her and essentially be a stay-at-home nothing. We clearly had different ideas of what our future was going to be and it became obvious to me that she needed some sort of professional psychiatric help.

I tried, I really did. But there’s only so much screaming one person can take whilst suggesting things that might help and having them rejected every time. She came home on leave for a few days, booked us into a fancy hotel and pulled out an engagement ring. Based on our differing viewpoints and seeing no way to reconcile them I said no, and it was honestly heart breaking. My answer caused the end of our relationship. She was devastated and so was I, we didn’t talk for many years.

She eventually left the military, got help and now works a very good civilian job. We still talk sometimes and I’m so glad to see her life as it is now. She deserves her happiness.
4points

#57

My first boyfriend proposed, I was 18, he was 28. We had only been dating for a month or so when he asked. I was really surprised and said yes but then after thinking about it for a few weeks, I told him I couldn't do and we broke up. I just wasn't ready to get married and we really didn't know each other that well.
Report
4points

#58

Friend's mom intended to take the last name of whomever she married. Guy w/ the last name McLellen proposed to her so she said no simply because she could never stand to be called Ellen McLellen.

(There were other reasons, that's just the joke she liked to tell us about it).
Report
4points

#59

My mother has turned down multiple marriage proposals. She says that she loved them, but she couldn't see herself marrying any of them. When she had dreams of her wedding day the man was still faceless, and that she knew they weren't right. Then her reaction when my father proposed to her randomly in a hotel bathroom was to run screaming down the hallway (he didn't know he was going to do it. Just looked at her and decided he wanted to be with her forever). Love is funny. They've been married 26 years.
4points

#60

Young man standing by a car in a parking lot, reflecting on moments people popped the question with embarrassment.
My then boyfriend and I had been together for more than a year, when his job needed to relocate him to a small town in another state. He didn't want to go badly, but he was on an employment visa and couldn't loose his job if he wanted to stay in the US. He was looking into his options for weeks, I was sad to think he might have to move. I wasn't at the stage emotionally or in life where I could have moved for him.

Anyhow. One day he pulls out this little box in the parking lot of his apartment, and asks if we can get married. I was sort of stunned, but then he followed it up with "because we have a really good thing going, and I'd hate to see it get messed up by long distance". He cared, but he also needed to marry a US citizen to stay in the city that he wanted.

I said no. We did long distance and it fell apart. He ended up losing his job anyway and being deported.

TL;DR. Boyfriend proposes in a parking lot, tries to hedge around the fact that he had visa issues and needed a green card, ends up deported anyway.
4points
31
2