Proposing to someone you love can be incredibly nerve-wracking. Even if you’ve been together for years, you’ll want the big day to go perfectly according to plan. Make sure they show up to the location at just the right time, hire a photographer who will be waiting on the sidelines, and if you’re proposing to a woman, you might want to sneakily ensure that her nails are on point.
But one thing that you should be confident about before getting down on one knee is that your partner will actually say yes. Otherwise, you might be in for an uncomfortable ride home. Redditors have been opening up about moments when they had to reject a loved one’s proposal, so we’ve gathered some of their juiciest stories below. Good luck getting through these tales without experiencing too much second-hand embarrassment, and be sure to upvote the ones that you find particularly painful!
#21

A girl asked to marry me in 3rd grade. I said no, I don't have time for marriage, I need to play with my friends.
She said OK. I went on to play with my friends.
All things considered, I think that went well.
She said OK. I went on to play with my friends.
All things considered, I think that went well.
13points
#22

I became friends with a very attractive girl from Turkey over the internet. We would skype and such. She wanted me to marry her so she could move to the U.S. At that point in my life I was broke and a student, so it just didn't make sense to do it. She basically said, "I will be a good wife. Make you food." I also would rather not marry someone who tells me they will be a "good wife," it is not the 1950s.
13points
#23

I was in a relationship with a guy for 3 years. He always told me he didn't want children or to get married. This was fine for me at the time but I was honest with him and said eventually we will break up. So we continued on until it felt our relationship hit a wall. We were fighting constantly and it was just time to end it. We broke up mutually and were able to hang out until I started dating again. He asked to meet me to talk where he begged me to be with him. I said I'm sorry we both want different things you don't want to get married. He said ok let's get married then. I said but you don't want kids. He said ok we can have one for you. I had to explain to him this isn't going to work if you don't truly want them. He could grow to resent me for it.
He ended up married a year later and I'm truly happy that he found someone!
He ended up married a year later and I'm truly happy that he found someone!
12points
#24

My now husband, kinda semi proposed/asked if I wanted to get married after we found out I was pregnant. My family is super Catholic and I think he was just trying to do what was "right". I said heck no, I wasn't getting married because of a baby, I'd get married when I wanted to. This October will be our 10 year anniversary.
12points
#25

I met a Korean woman while in grad school in London. She was studying English. We were both 24 - which I understand to be a little old to still be single in Korean culture. We dated three months.
As the semester wound up and we were getting ready to go our separate ways, she dressed up incredibly beautifully one day - like wedding day hair - and she asked me if I would marry her. She offered to bring me to Korea where I wouldn't have to work. She would take care of me through her pharmacist career. She said I could spend my days playing golf.
I said I couldn't marry someone that I've only known for three months. She said that you know when you're in love and I had to admit I wasn't in love. She didn't take it too well.
We went our separate ways.
I felt like a terrible human being for breaking her heart. She emailed me a bunch over the next month while she traveled Europe, but stupid yahoo mail sent it to spam and I didn't see it for a while. When I finally responded she said she just wanted to be friends.
For years I would email her on her birthday but I never heard back.
Anyway, that's the story.
As the semester wound up and we were getting ready to go our separate ways, she dressed up incredibly beautifully one day - like wedding day hair - and she asked me if I would marry her. She offered to bring me to Korea where I wouldn't have to work. She would take care of me through her pharmacist career. She said I could spend my days playing golf.
I said I couldn't marry someone that I've only known for three months. She said that you know when you're in love and I had to admit I wasn't in love. She didn't take it too well.
We went our separate ways.
I felt like a terrible human being for breaking her heart. She emailed me a bunch over the next month while she traveled Europe, but stupid yahoo mail sent it to spam and I didn't see it for a while. When I finally responded she said she just wanted to be friends.
For years I would email her on her birthday but I never heard back.
Anyway, that's the story.
10points
#26

My current wife proposed to me, not so much down on one knee, but we were in Vegas for a while, and we had already talked about getting married (we had been dating for abou 4 years at that time, but I was still only 25). We were out and about one night and she had the bright idea we should get married that night. My literal response was, "[hell] no". She still brings it up to this day.
We broke up up a year later, and reconciled a year after that when I was finally able to come to terms with everything. Date for another year and a half and got engaged. Been married for around 3 years now. Things couldn't be better.
We broke up up a year later, and reconciled a year after that when I was finally able to come to terms with everything. Date for another year and a half and got engaged. Been married for around 3 years now. Things couldn't be better.
10points
#27

A couple years ago a girl I used to know offered me 14K to marry her so she could stay in my country. She was pretty hot too.
I think she got sent back a year or two ago...
I think she got sent back a year or two ago...
10points
#28

My mother had a sweetheart back in the 50s who got her name tattooed on his arm and *then* proposed. She turned him down. [cue sad trombone]
Last she heard, he had married someone with the same name as her.
Last she heard, he had married someone with the same name as her.
10points
#29

My mom turned down a multi-millionaire because he had some genuinely weird habits. 30 years later and he still hasn't married. My mom was it for him.
9points
#30

Why: I knew in my mind that we just weren't meant to be together long term. I loved her and enjoyed being with her, but for her it became all about the label and the ring. And pressure to do it soon. We were only like 20 years old. And she wanted to have children soon, something I was still very much on the fence about.
Aftermath: a lot of crying and asking why I didn't love her enough to marry her. We limped along for a while but things kept changing for the worse in the relationship. She then dropped on me that she wanted an open relationship so she could explore those feelings with that guy. I recognized it was the end, but agreed anyways. We broke up after that weekend. A few months later she wanted me back, so I tried because of how strongly I felt for her. It turns out that I had become used to not having to deal with her and I enjoyed it, so I broke it off with her a few months later.
Aftermath: a lot of crying and asking why I didn't love her enough to marry her. We limped along for a while but things kept changing for the worse in the relationship. She then dropped on me that she wanted an open relationship so she could explore those feelings with that guy. I recognized it was the end, but agreed anyways. We broke up after that weekend. A few months later she wanted me back, so I tried because of how strongly I felt for her. It turns out that I had become used to not having to deal with her and I enjoyed it, so I broke it off with her a few months later.
9points
#31

A beautiful woman who I loved with all of my heart and I still think about her almost every day. She asked me to marry her but I was afraid and I said no. I still hear the way her voice broke when the word left my lips.
It’s my biggest regret in life, my whole life past my early 20s would be wildly different and probably for the better. I live each day with the choice I made.
She’s married now to a really great guy, they have two children and I talk to her once every several years. I’m in my mid-late thirties, single never married with a beautiful dog. I know my life isn’t over and in a lot of ways I’m in a really good place. That memory never goes away though. I know I made the wrong choice.
TLDR: Never give in to fear.
It’s my biggest regret in life, my whole life past my early 20s would be wildly different and probably for the better. I live each day with the choice I made.
She’s married now to a really great guy, they have two children and I talk to her once every several years. I’m in my mid-late thirties, single never married with a beautiful dog. I know my life isn’t over and in a lot of ways I’m in a really good place. That memory never goes away though. I know I made the wrong choice.
TLDR: Never give in to fear.
9points
#32
Took 6 years of asking for me to agree.
He ended up leaving after finding and sleeping with another woman a week before the wedding.
Dodged that bullet.
He ended up leaving after finding and sleeping with another woman a week before the wedding.
Dodged that bullet.
Report
8points
#33
I was proposed to once at a pep rally in high school my sophomore year, by a rather strange boy that I started talking to three weeks prior. Turned out he had immense attachment issues and thought I was his soul mate. Threatened to [end his life] when I laughed it off as a joke. Was later committed and is now in jail.
Second proposal was from a college boyfriend, but I turned it down because he was about to move and had railed against long distance relationships for most of our relationship. He also applied Axe body spray in the exact manner the commercials do because he claimed it "Got him more [chicks]"
Second proposal was from a college boyfriend, but I turned it down because he was about to move and had railed against long distance relationships for most of our relationship. He also applied Axe body spray in the exact manner the commercials do because he claimed it "Got him more [chicks]"
Report
8points
#34

I was 14 and pregnant. I think it was a pretty legit decision to say no and give the baby up.
The [jerk] then moved to Scotland and I never heard from him again.
I'm sure he would've made a perfect husband.
The [jerk] then moved to Scotland and I never heard from him again.
I'm sure he would've made a perfect husband.
8points
#35
Once upon a time, I had a friend named Dan. Dan was a habitual liar, a closet homosexual, and a chubby, myopic, narcissist.
Every single Summer after I turned 17, he would propose to me and I would refuse. The proposals varied in form and complexity, but they were always consistent in sincerity: *he actually meant it every single time*. I asked him a few times to explain why he kept proposing when he knew that I wouldn't say yes. He told me that he knew that I'd never accepted before, but that didn't mean that I would never say "yes" someday.
Dan eventually came out as gay to his friends and family, and I assumed that the proposals would stop. But, they didn't. Every Summer like clockwork, I'd get a call or a letter, or a visit in-person, and the proposal would come again. At that point, I asked him why he continued when he knew that I wasn't even the gender that he wanted. He told me that he thought that his feelings for me transcended gender, and that if I became his wife, it would "fix" his sexuality.
I wish that I could say that our friendship survived the mutual personality flaws, the irrational attachment and the constant disappointment of proposal-and-refusal, but it didn't. Dan's last proposal was in the Summer of 2008. He called me from the base he was stationed at, and asked me to marry him one last time. I thanked him, and told him that I'd always treasure him, but that I couldn't be his wife. He asked me if I was sure, and I promised him that I was certain. He then said that he was relieved, because he wanted to ask someone else to marry him, but he felt like he owed me one last opportunity.
He hasn't contacted me since.
Every single Summer after I turned 17, he would propose to me and I would refuse. The proposals varied in form and complexity, but they were always consistent in sincerity: *he actually meant it every single time*. I asked him a few times to explain why he kept proposing when he knew that I wouldn't say yes. He told me that he knew that I'd never accepted before, but that didn't mean that I would never say "yes" someday.
Dan eventually came out as gay to his friends and family, and I assumed that the proposals would stop. But, they didn't. Every Summer like clockwork, I'd get a call or a letter, or a visit in-person, and the proposal would come again. At that point, I asked him why he continued when he knew that I wasn't even the gender that he wanted. He told me that he thought that his feelings for me transcended gender, and that if I became his wife, it would "fix" his sexuality.
I wish that I could say that our friendship survived the mutual personality flaws, the irrational attachment and the constant disappointment of proposal-and-refusal, but it didn't. Dan's last proposal was in the Summer of 2008. He called me from the base he was stationed at, and asked me to marry him one last time. I thanked him, and told him that I'd always treasure him, but that I couldn't be his wife. He asked me if I was sure, and I promised him that I was certain. He then said that he was relieved, because he wanted to ask someone else to marry him, but he felt like he owed me one last opportunity.
He hasn't contacted me since.
Report
7points
#36

It was really akward we had been dating a matter of weeks he said while we where out having a meal what would you do if I asked you to marry me. I replied why are you asking me that he proceeded to get down on one knee I quietly tell him to get up and no before too many people notice. I've never eaten food so fast to get out of there.
7points
#37
I used to deliver pizza; I was the only female driver out of the 6 pizza shops in town. I delivered once a week to a disabled guy. Around week five, he finally tells me I'm very beautiful and asked me to marry him. I kind chuckled nervously and explained that I was already married. I had never hightailed it away from a customer so fast.
Two months later, we hired another female driver. He did the same thing to her, and she was also married.
Two months later, we hired another female driver. He did the same thing to her, and she was also married.
Report
7points
#38
This guy once proposed to me on like, our second or third date. He was acting weird and I slowly realized what was going on. He pulled out a ring. In a bowling alley. I literally ran away. I have no idea what happened to him after that.
Report
7points
#39
Where I work has an abundance of homeless people and transient individuals, due to its proximity to the train tracks. About once a week this really old homeless dude asks me to marry him. And for last twelve months he's been doing this. About two weeks ago after I shut him down, he responded, "Will you ever say yes?" And I thoughtfully replied, "Probably not."
I saw him last Wednesday and he didn't propose. :( I was sad because up to this point it felt like a joking ritual each week. Now I worry that I actually broke his heart...
I saw him last Wednesday and he didn't propose. :( I was sad because up to this point it felt like a joking ritual each week. Now I worry that I actually broke his heart...
Report
7points
#40

A friend of mine was rejected when he proposed to his girlfriend. She was pregnant with his kid and she felt that he was only proposing because of the baby, not because of their relationship.
7points

