Bored Panda
“It Is Not The 1950s”: 79 People Who Turned Down Marriage Proposals Explain Their Reasoning

“It Is Not The 1950s”: 79 People Who Turned Down Marriage Proposals Explain Their Reasoning

31
2
Proposing to someone you love can be incredibly nerve-wracking. Even if you’ve been together for years, you’ll want the big day to go perfectly according to plan. Make sure they show up to the location at just the right time, hire a photographer who will be waiting on the sidelines, and if you’re proposing to a woman, you might want to sneakily ensure that her nails are on point.
But one thing that you should be confident about before getting down on one knee is that your partner will actually say yes. Otherwise, you might be in for an uncomfortable ride home. Redditors have been opening up about moments when they had to reject a loved one’s proposal, so we’ve gathered some of their juiciest stories below. Good luck getting through these tales without experiencing too much second-hand embarrassment, and be sure to upvote the ones that you find particularly painful!

#61

I had an (I thought) platonic friend ask me to marry him my freshmen year of college when he was comforting me over a breakup with the guy I'd been seeing. I turned it down because I didn't see him that way, we hadn't been dating, and for me, his asking at all in those circumstances (crying my eyes out over having been dumped by the guy I loved at the time) showed that he wasn't as concerned with my feelings and what I'd want as a partner should be.
4points

#62

I said no once I was young because we didn't want the same things in life and I couldn't see it going anywhere positive in the long term. Yes, we loved each other, but there was nothing other than that holding the relationship together. It was not a public proposal and we broke up after that, but remained friends.

Many years later, the man who is now my husband and I each decided independently that we intended to get married to each other on our second date. He asked me to marry him a month later and I said it hadn't really been long enough because the idea of being married that quickly scared the [hell] out of me, not to mention that I had not previously believed in simply knowing on date two that you had met your match. I was in my late twenties, I'd just gotten a promotion I was thrilled about and he was a single father. Getting married would change just about everything about my life. I knew I wanted to marry him, but I needed to *think* about that before committing to it. He said okay, that made plenty of sense.

And asked me again four months in. I said I'd love to but looking at what we'd have to do at that point to make that work given what else was going on financially that year, I wasn't sure how he could pay for it. He said that was an excellent point.

At six months, he asked me again, with a well thought out plan for how we could afford it. I gave up and asked him where my ring was.

He had not only found a jeweler that could locate the really weird cut of diamond that I'd always lusted after in solitaire quality (there were a total of three stones that fit the bill at the time in our entire state), he had reserved a time for me to go in and talk with the jeweler and be able to custom design my own engagement ring using the rock of my dreams.

We're coming up on anniversary/adoptiversary number six later this month. :).
Report
4points

#63

I was 21- I met him in the waiting room of a psychiatrist’s office- I was coming down off a long psychotic episode so was happy to cling to anything.

We were together 1 month when he proposed. Thankfully girlfriends came and got all of my excess junk (clothes, straighteners, etc) from his house and I never spoke to him again.

It was a weird and intense time.
4points

#64

We stayed together another 2 years.

We were "that" couple, the one people liked to see together and we were madly in love. We were 29, had been together about 2 years and had been talking about marriage for one year. We were supposed to move in together in April 2011, and talked about low-key engagement that summer, and low-key marriage that fall, had a destination wedding planned.

We had a trip planned in February of that year, and he decided to surprise me by proposing on the vacation. He told EVERYONE before the trip that we were getting engaged. He went and asked my dad's permission. Our families, all our friends, coworkers, I mean, EVERYONE. I guess I don't blame him, the way we had been talking, it was a sure thing.

On the way to the restaurant, my hand brushed along his pants and I felt something square in his pocket. I knew immediately what it was. When he was a little in front of me I could see the outline of the box.

I remember the feeling of everything spinning out of control; thinking, this isn't right, it isn't time, it's too early. We can't get engaged here at this restaurant. I feel like I can specifically hear my subconcious screaming at me, "This isn't right!" I distinctly remember that I did not specifically say "Yes." But I did hug and kiss him and put the ring on. I cried because I loved him so much. I really did look and act happy.

When we were heading to bed that night, we talked about how he kept it a secret from me to plan. Hearing it all upset me so much, I guess I felt trapped that all these people knew before me.

He fell asleep and I dozed off but couldn't sleep. I was a wreck, knots in my stomach. I sat out of the balcony chair the rest of the night. Not a wink of sleep. I didn't wear the ring. I feel like I had ruined my own engagement. I felt horribly depressed. I had no idea how to keep up the facade of happiness.

This happened the first night of the vacation, so I was freaking out how to maintain the facade the rest of the trip. When he woke up that morning, he came out to find me on the balcony, just staring into space. He had a look of anxiety, noticed no ring, and tried to pass it off as joking, "Not having second thoughts, are you?"

Well from there it snowballed. He was dumbfounded. We had a ton of heavy discussions, fought a little bit. He had ideas like, "we can get a different ring, if that's it." "we can go back home and just be boyfriend and girlfriend yet." "we don't have to get married this fall, and just have a long engagement"

Getting back home, I tried to play the part of the happy fiance. It didn't last a week. And then it turned out everyone was going on our FBs and writing us congratulations, which attracted even more attention. I didn't see any of this because I wasn't using FB or my phone while out of the country. I was living with my mom (as it was still a few months before we moved in), got home from the airport, walked in the house and said, "Hi mom. I'm home from my trip and I'm engaged" in a completely monotone voice.

My mom proceeded to make my life a living hell (right up until I moved out) - constantly badgering me wedding questions and plans. Not only could I NOT get excited, but I did not even WANT to discuss it.

We returned the ring about 2 weeks later. When people would ask about it, he'd tell them, "She thought it was too big, so we're getting it changed," meaning the stone.

We moved in together as planned. I was so crazy in love with him. We lived together for about a year but we never talked about getting married again. Maybe 2 or 3 references ever.

Then I found out he was incessantly texting his exGF. I mean like, 10 hours a day, timestamps on the cell bills showed every minute. I honestly can't figure out how how the [hell] either one of them got any s**t done with the amount of texting that went down. He cut off contact with her. We fought, and he had become emotionally and physically [toxic] with me after I found out about the exGF. We stayed together about 9 more months after I found out, and finally broke up. Things had just became a downward spiral.

It turned out she wasn't the only one. The exGF was just an emotional affair. After we broke up, I found out that there were others.

I guess my subconsious knew somehow that he wasn't the one for me, as much as I loved him and believed he was the one for me. It's been two years since I left him, and it STILL hurts. He's married with a kid now, which is bizarre.
Report
3points

#65

Worked at GAME when i was about 18. This one dude would roam the store for hours at a time. I thought he was just [passing] time, so i didnt mind it too much. I did end up talking to him, and he would then for a few weeks walk past my workplace to see if i was in/or busy, and if i was all free he would drop in to talk with me. Eventually in the middle of a random conversation about pokemon or something he just asks me if i want to marry him. Still not completely sure if he was serious or not, because of how awkward he made it. If it was meant as a joke there was no chance to understand that it was. Laughed and said sorry have a boyfriend, and he didnt show up anymore.
Report
3points

#66

Alrighty then, I was new to US. 26 years old, in grad school. In a small town in Texas. Knew a small community of my minority group. They wanted to help me out. I got to know them. One of them was the head of a pretty rich family. He offered me a quick way out of my problems, which is marrying his 18 year old niece. Under immigration laws, I would get green card and eventually citizenship. Not only that, I was offered a job in the family business, which is some law firm in New York City.

I denied the offer. But,I always wonder what if I didn't. I have no regrets, but my life would have been way easier.
3points

#67

When I was 19 I used to work at a lake selling worms for fishing, giving kayaking lessons, and doing basic park ranger business. Most of the time I’d go in at 6am and work until 3 or so. Alone for most of that time.
There was a man that was in his mid-30s that came to the lake everyday at 6am to buy worms. He was a quiet, large man. He wore dirty overalls and no shirt underneath. I’m certain he worked on a farm as his hands were worn down and he smelled much like a barn does on a hot day.
Anyway I didn’t know if he did because all he would say was, “worms” then go out to his boat.
Everyday, 6am: “worms”. I sell him
Worms. He leaves. That’s it.
One day he shows up with a shirt on and his hair combed- an hour late.
I go immediately without him asking to get his worms from the back.
I return and he is on his one knee, has a ring in his hand, and says, “will you be my wife?”
I look at him and say, “oh that’s very nice!” I thought he was like...practicing his proposal for his girlfriend. I don’t know why but that’s where my head went because the reality was too unrealistic and confusing.
He looked at me and had a smile on his face and I instantly realized what he meant and I had to backtrack.
I said, “oh. Oh no I can’t do that. I’m in a relationship! This is..it’s very nice of you.”
The he put it in his pocket, took the worms, and left.
He came back everyday after that at 6am and never brought it up.

It kind of crushes me to think about it. I feel bad for him.
Report
3points

#68

I once accepted a proposal. The following day I developed an eye twitch. It continued for about a week. Then I broke off the engagement and the eye twitch went away!
3points

#69

I was dating this girl a year ago. She was great but ya know i didn't feel she was the one i could grow old with. Then one day she had this whole thing planned, it was my birthday and she threw a surprise party. Which she also proposed to me at the end of it. Every one went quiet, then i took her hand went into the bedroom and told her no. Then she ran out crying, it was sad.
Report
3points

#70

I was 15. That's probably as much as you need to know, but this is askreddit so story time.

I met this guy on a metal forum on nexopia. We hit it off pretty well and started dating and then met in person. He wanted to get together every day. At first, this was nice. 1 month in he wrote me a poem and got me flowers. Kind of sweet, but that's when I started getting kind of uncomfortable.

Then he started getting upset about my friends and would call all the time to make sure I wasn't with them.

By 3 months in he was the only person I saw other than my sister and my mom for brief periods (she was working 2 jobs). And then he asked me to marry him.

Did I mention he was 18?

I said no and said I needed some time apart. So he kept calling every day to tell me how he loves me. Then I broke up with him and he said his friend has a machete and he's thinking of going to get it. I don't know if he was threatening me, or threatening to hurt himself, or someone else. I didn't really want to know. I had wanted to live with my dad for a while anyways so I just moved across the country.
3points

#71

I did - I actually had to say no to two guys.

The first time: I was 19, and he was 21. We had been dating for 3 years and he and I had moved to a new city together so I could attend university. This was year 2 of us in the new city, he was miserable. He had left all of his friends behind and wasn't having much luck making new ones. He was creative and loved playing music, but had stopped practicing or enjoying himself in any way. I kept encouraging him to get out there and do his thing, but he was clearly just having a bad time. He worked in a warehouse where the hours were atrocious and there were no jobs relevant to his diploma in the city so he plugged away doing his thing, trying to not let on how depressed he was. But I could see it. I knew him, he wasn't himself. He proposed and I broke up with him and encouraged him to move back or find somewhere else to go so he could be happy. So he did, and his life was much better. I eventually moved to the same city as him after I finished my master's. We did get back together a few years later, but did not end up together.

The second guy:

I didn't love but I liked him, and we had some fun together. I made it pretty clear that I didn't want anything serious. He kept on trying to escalate our relationship and I kept on trying to scale it back. In retrospect, I should have just left him sooner. He was incredibly jealous of the ex I mentioned above because he knew us both when we were all in highschool and would get drunk and say he knew 'I would never love him like I loved X'. He put together an elaborate proposal on a private island after we had been seeing each other about 6 months and it was incredibly awkward, but I had to say no. His friend who lives on the island literally had to boat back to get me because he had an anger fit when I said no. The proposal was completely out of place and he pursued me savagely even after I broke things off. Eventually got a restraining order - yay.
3points

#72

We had been dating for five years, after getting together right at the end of college. We wound up having a “where is this relationship going” conversation that ended with him casually proposing. I told him maybe, and that I needed to think about it. I had conflicting feelings about marrying him and it felt wrong to say yes if my answer wasn’t wholeheartedly YES. It took me a few months to realize the answer was “no”.

By that time, he was also expressing dissatisfaction. He never said it was because I was hesitating so much, but I wonder how I would feel if my partner was that uncertain after five years together. We tried making it work, even so. We discussed what we wanted out of the other person, what we wanted them to change. I asked him to be less pretentious. He asked me to lose weight.

Eventually he told me he wanted to sleep with other people. I told him to go for it. And that was it.

Though the question is the reasoning behind the no. There was no one big reason. Just lots and lots of little and medium sized ones that finally had to be reckoned. And sure, it’s easy to look back and demonize an ex or forget our own shortcomings. I definitely had my short comings in that relationship. He had his. It didn’t work out, but we both learned a lot.
3points

#73

My first Boyfriend asked me to marry him when we were both 22 and were just fresh out of undergrad. At that point it wasn't legal and wouldn't be for awhile, but he wanted me to wear his ring and basically be married in everything but the eyes of the law. We had been together and monogamous for three years (which is like a decade in gay years) and he had supported me in coming out and gone through hell with me and the crazy brainwashing I dealt with as a kid. He meant the world to me.

Despite all this, I couldn't say yes. I knew I should've wanted to say yes right away. I knew it would've been the thing that was expected of me, but I couldn't. Part of it terrified me, I'm not gonna lie; when you're told your whole life you're going to hell for liking guys, and your family abandons you for it, the thought of wearing someone's ring as a sign you belong to another man is scary.

I told him I'd think about it, and explained that it was a scary, strange thing for me, and I needed to sort through my feelings. He said it was okay, but was clearly pissed. In the following two months he became really petty and almost bitter. We ended up having this huge blowout fight, wherein he basically accused me of wasting his time when he could've been out partying and hooking up with randoms and he needed to know because he didn't see the point of continuing if I wasn't going to marry him. I told him no, and moved out.

I'm married to someone else now (who is actually an ex of that ex, oops?) When my husband asked me to marry him, it felt *right* and I immediately said yes. There was no hesitation. I didn't have that with him, and I don't think I ever would've gotten to that point with him. He was super important to me and helped me realize who I was as a man, but he was never going to be the end all be all for me.
Report
3points

#74

Not me, but my cousin said no to her boyfriend at the time... three times. They were young so it was understandable that she was afraid of the commitment, but dang was he a tenacious bugger. He asked on four separate occasions, each about a year apart (they were high school sweethearts) and she finally said yes just a couple months before college graduation. I think she felt more confident about him and where she was at in her life at that time. Plus once college is done marriage becomes infinitely more realistic for a lot of people.
2points

#75

I was working in retail in the US. A customer saw my common French name on my nametag. He grabbed my hand and said "you are French! And beautiful! You need to come back to my country with me and marry me!" I declined. He stood there declaring his love for me until his friends dragged him away. Sorry to disappoint, dude, but I'm actually not French in any way my mom just picked it out of a baby book.
Report
2points

#76

Some guy I didn't know asked me to marry him on skype in broken English. I politely declined and then blocked him.
2points

#77

We were dating for about 3 months. I guess he got the feeling that I was going to break up with him so he got desperate and proposed. Thank god it was in the privacy of my bedroom. I didn't tell anyone about it. I said no of course, and broke up with him a week later. He was pretty overbearing.
2points

#78

One night while I was in college an ex-boyfriend called me up drunk at 4AM to propose. After unsuccessfully trying to end the conversation, I had to tell him, "No, I won't marry you." Instead of getting sad, he got extremely angry. I believe his words were, "Fine. I don't want to marry you anyway. You're an ugly troll who should live under a bridge. No one is going to marry you." Then he hung up. Needless to say, he was quite embarrassed when I called him the next day.
Report
2points

#79

21 during an exchange program, and I was studying to be an engineer. He was 18, looking to join the US army.
I’d have to drop college to be alone in a country I didn’t know, and to be with someone I didn’t know well... (the proposal was a plan for me to stay).

Had to say no, and didn’t work out with the distance :/.
2points
31
2