We all have parts of our lives that we don’t want other people to know about, and they don’t even have to be life-changing. Sometimes, they’re just little white lies that we don’t want to go through the trouble of dealing with.
But when it comes to relationships, is it acceptable to keep secrets, or should couples be completely open with each other? Moral questions aside, if we have something we’re hiding (or forget we’re hiding), our partners might actually find out eventually. And so, we’ve brought you some stories from Reddit about people who discovered their significant others’ big and small secrets.
#1
My wife poops. For some reason, she is embarrassed by this and will always pretend she is doing something else besides pooping. But I know. I always know.
He loves The Phantom of the Opera. Like, several versions of the recordings on his iPod, in among all the indie rock. I think it's hilarious but he seems embarrassed by it and will skip past those songs SO FAST if we're playing his iPod in the car. "What's that?" "Um. Nothing."
My husband waits until I fall asleep and then tells me how beautiful he thinks I am, how much he loves me, etc. I only know because I've woken up a few times during, once I couldn't help but smile and he said "Oops! You're waking up." kissed my forhead and rolled over. He tells me he loves me and what not when I'm awake, but he is rarely overly emotional so it's cute to know he gets mushy when I fall asleep.
Many of us reading these stories are probably thinking, “Nah, I don’t hide anything from my partner. They know me inside and out.” But what if we told you that you’re probably wrong?
Research led by Dr. Michael Slepian at Columbia Business School surveyed 50,000 participants worldwide and found that the average person has roughly 13 secrets at any given moment. About five of these have never been shared with anyone, not even a partner or a therapist.
#4
My girlfriend told me while blackout drunk what she was getting me for my birthday. It was a great present and I never told her I knew, even once she gave it to me. I figured she was excited about it, no reason to ruin it.
dated a guy who told me he was a vegetarian (i was at the time, but i wasnt pushy and did not care if he was. he offered up that information in a "really?? me too!!" context). i walked in on him eating a piece of pepperoni pizza. he threw it out the window. i'm still laughing.
I know my wife had an affair early on in our marriage, though it may have started before we got hitched as it was her work colleague. The kicker is, she was pregnant with our first when we got married (that's why we got married quickly, actually) and, really, the kid doesn't look like me. I love my daughters dearly and, as I don't want anything to come between me and them, I've never told my wife about the Facebook exchanges I stumbled on by mistake (soon after our first was born and all the clues suddenly became plain as day).
Curiously, Slepian’s research also showed that secrecy is an intrinsic part of human nature rather than an anomaly.
So, when someone discovers that their partner secretly listens to show tunes, burps when they think no one is watching, or hides something from them, they’re not witnessing anything out of the ordinary. On the contrary, it’s perfectly common for people to keep things to themselves, especially when they’re something as trivial as these little habits.
#8
So much cheating on here.
Anyway, here’s one- my wife of 15 years (together for 19) has a ‘secret’ savings account. Her family has some bad luck with marriage, and she was really slow to marry me because she didn’t want to be ‘trapped’.
So she saved up several month’s worth of living expenses. She hasn’t really touched it since, and has never mentioned it to me. It’s the only account with statements emailed directly to her, rather than an email we both access.
It’s absolutely there so that she could, if needed, leave. It’s not a fortune by any means, but could keep her afloat for ~3-4 months. I tried to gently bring it up once, as a hypothetical, and she flat out denied it (in a ‘doth protest too much’ kind of way). I told her it would be ok with me either way.
Truth is, I really don’t mind. It makes her feel better, and we’ve built a fantastic life together. I know she views it more as an insurance policy than anything else, and figure if we ever really do need the money we’ll cross that bridge then.
Plus I suppose she’s still married to me because she wants to be, not because she has to be.
My ex cheated on me and I told her all the time how good it was that I could always trust her completely. Eventually she shattered like a mirror and confessed to her petty actions.
I asked her to watch my pet turtle when I went out of town for the week, and she replaced him with a doppelganger with a missing toe and thinks I haven't noticed.
That he sits down to pee every time. I can tell, I can hear him sit down in our home bathroom and if he ever talks while he is in there, I can tell by the sound of his voice which way he is facing. Once I asked him about it, and he lied.
I definitely don't care if he stands or sits. I think it's kinda cute that he refuses to admit to it. He's allowed his privacy and its so trivial, so of course I don't press it.
But what actually makes someone keep a secret that isn't theirs? Even if it’s not something like passing gas or sneaking food while hiding?
Well, Slepian’s research might offer an explanation. The study found that the emotional fatigue of keeping a secret doesn't come from hiding, but rather from repeatedly thinking about it when no one is around. So, if someone discovers their partner's secret, they might realize that unless it's actively causing them harm, confronting them could simply introduce unnecessary anxiety into an otherwise non-issue.
#12
My boyfriend is bisexual. He won't openly admit it, but I've gathered enough clues over the past couple of years to put it together. I suspect he hides it because his parents have very strong opinions against being gay. He's probably afraid I'll look at him differently if he tells me, but I'm not pushing it. He'll tell me when he's ready to tell me. Until then, he should at least do a better job at deleting the Internet history.
He doesn't think I'm as attractive as his ex but is with me because he thinks I'm a nicer person.
Edit: To the people asking "Why is this a problem?" If your buddy were describing two girls and said of one, "She's smoking hot!" and the other, "She's really... nice," which would you objectively be more interested in? To be fair, I think I have more redeeming qualities than just being nice, but I don't think it's out of the bounds of reality to be insecure about this. I'm like a 5. This girl is a 10.
My wife and I started dating when we were fifteen. We broke up here and there, but were on most of that time. We went to different colleges, but were mostly together. Then grad school, same deal, only we ended up renting an apartment together and sharing more than hallways and back seats of cars. We got married, got real jobs, bought a house. We have been together for more than half of our lives, we're 38 and 39 years old now. We have two wonderful kids together, a boy and a girl, five and three years old, and my wife isn't just the best wife in the world, she's also, apparently, the best mom in the world. That said, I know for sure she knows how to use the remote. I caught her switching the tv from cable to PS3, then log into Netflix, then navigate to a movie. When she says, "can you put on the movie, I don't know how," I know she's a healthy, intelligent, successful, athletic, active, funny, caring, loving, kind, generous, selfless phony. I love my wife beyond anything and I'm glad she asks for my help at times, even when not needed.
He occasionally buys cookies when I'm at work and eats them all. It's fine, I sometimes eat candy only after he's gone to bed. Guess neither of us like to share our treats.
Never miss a story that brings joy to the world.Add us on Google
#16
My now fiancé had my engagement ring hidden for almost 3 years. We picked it out together and he wasn't good at hiding that he bought it. He also wasn't good at hiding it because during one of our moves he hid it in one of my boxes... I told him I knew he had it once he proposed and he was so upset but it was really cute. He tried so hard to hide it but he really can't keep a secret.
Edit: I should add that I told him I knew about a week later. I didn't say I knew about it right when he proposed.
She secretly records and watches every episode of Maury - the Maury Povitch show. I have no idea why. She watches them every morning on her commute into work. I brought it up once and she angrily denied it. I said it wasn't a big deal and I was just curious. We haven't spoken about it since. It's been going on for a few years.
Then there's also the secondhand embarrassment that makes many of these stories seem so wholesome. Let's say your partner likes to dance alone in the living room every night but has never told you. You know it happens, but you choose not to mention it. This is called civil inattention.
Coined by sociologist Erving Goffman, the term describes how people actively notice something awkward or private about someone else but deliberately pretend not to see it to preserve the other person's dignity and even maintain social harmony. In long-term relationships, this happens all the time, like when you choose not to call out your partner for definitely eating the last donut.
#18
His last girlfriend who he was completely and totally in love with passed away while they were fighting, and that's why he's so apprehensive about getting serious with me. If he never tells me, I will definitely be concerned, but I can see how that is incredibly hard to talk about. I don't expect it to come up any time soon.
i know that he still talks to his ex all the time, and i know that he says he wants to help and support me through my depression and anxiety but he just wants a way out without completely destroying me.
edit: im going to talk to him tomorrow, it's possible it's just my depression making me think that he doesn't want me, but we'll see
edit again: not sure if anyone else is going to read this but I just want to thank all of you guys again. you gave me the strength to talk to him and it's all been in my head, he actually told me again that he wants to marry me even with my issues:) also he has been talking to his ex because she's going through some hard times too I guess, he told me I could look at their conversations if I wanted but i dont want to or feel the need to. this has been a huge weight lifted off my chest. thanks again, friends:).
My wife and I spent about 4 months apart last year (pending divorce) but managed to get counciling and work it out. I found out through a mutual friend that she slept with 3 other people while we were apart. I can't bring myself to confront her about it becasue I know it would garuntee a divorce this time and I don't want to lose her.
EDIT
I might also add that we have a daughter, who was two at the time. Leaving a cheating GF is one thing, but causing a life of heartbreak for my daughter requires me to think it through. As I said before, we had counseling and therapy which allowed us to come back together. It's been over a year now and things are much, much better than they were.