When I was in middle school, I had a classmate who would look at trigonometric functions and yell, "I will never need these!" A lot of us had similar thoughts but wouldn't say them out loud. But there's a subreddit that proves otherwise.
'They Did the Math' is full of useless yet fascinating calculations for all of us normies who can't crunch the numbers ourselves. From how many flies it would take to lift an average person to how fast a Godzilla-sized snail would crawl, here are some of the most interesting questions—and answers—we found scrolling through its feed.
#61 What Is The Area Of This Shape If The Side Length Is 4?

HAL9001-96: well first lets figure out what the shape is exactly then the rest is pretty easy more specifically what its proportions are if we take the angle of the extension in radians a, the radisu of the inner circle r and the sidelength l we know l=(2Pi-a)*r and l=a*(r+l) so a=l/(r+l) so l=(2Pi-l/(r+l))*r l=2Pir-lr/(r+l) lets set l=1 for now so 1=2Pir-r/(r+1) 1=(2Pir²+2Pir-r)/(r+1) 2Pir²+2Pir-r=r+1 2Pir²+2(Pi-1)r-1=0 quadratic equation solves to (1+root(1+Pi²)-Pi)/2Pi or about 0.1838742 whole thing scales proportionally so r=0.1838742l and a=1/1.1838742=0.844684 so total area is (0.1838742l)²*Pi*(2Pi-0.844684)/(2Pi)+(1.1838742l)²*0.844684Pi/(2Pi) or about 0.68387l² if l=4 that makes about 10.94
Report
5points
#62 Will This Work In Real Life?

ledocteur7: Short answer : yes, but it's more of like localised shredding than a clean cut.
Long answer : any sufficiently large amount of pressure can destroy stuff, no matter the fluid used, hydraulic leaks in industrial machinery are incredibly dangerous, and when moving fast enough, air acts basically the same way as any liquid. But air is very light, even when heavily compressed, and will get redirected in contact with pretty much anything, so rather than getting a clean slice, you're literally blowing things apart until they are in 2 pieces.
Long answer : any sufficiently large amount of pressure can destroy stuff, no matter the fluid used, hydraulic leaks in industrial machinery are incredibly dangerous, and when moving fast enough, air acts basically the same way as any liquid. But air is very light, even when heavily compressed, and will get redirected in contact with pretty much anything, so rather than getting a clean slice, you're literally blowing things apart until they are in 2 pieces.
Report
4points
#63 How To Mathematically Proof That 3 Is A Smaller Number Than 10

(Not sure if this is the altitude of this sub or if it's too abstract so I better go on to another.)
Saw the post in the pic, smiled and wanted to go on, but suddenly I thought about the second part of the question.
I could come up with a popular explanation like "If I have 3 cookies, I can give fewer friends one than if I have 10 cookies". Or "I can eat longer a cookie a day with ten."
But all this explanation rely on the given/ teached/felt knowledge that 3 friends are less than 10 or 10 days are longer than 3.
How would you proof that 3 is smaller than 10 and vice versa?
PreguicaMan: Start from:
A number is smaller than it's successor (a
Saw the post in the pic, smiled and wanted to go on, but suddenly I thought about the second part of the question.
I could come up with a popular explanation like "If I have 3 cookies, I can give fewer friends one than if I have 10 cookies". Or "I can eat longer a cookie a day with ten."
But all this explanation rely on the given/ teached/felt knowledge that 3 friends are less than 10 or 10 days are longer than 3.
How would you proof that 3 is smaller than 10 and vice versa?
PreguicaMan: Start from:
A number is smaller than it's successor (a
Report
4points
#64 How Many Ways Are There To Shuffle A Deck?

52!
8.0658175170943900791e+67
52 cards, the first card in the deck can be any of the 52, the second can be any of the remaining 51 and so on. That is 52!
Report
4points
#65 Which One Is Correct? Comments Were Pretty Much Divided

I-am-the-Vern: If I imagine myself holding the scale from the ring end, I’d have to pull 100N to get the left weight suspended. If I replace my 100N exertion with a 100N counterweight, the scale won’t recognize the difference. That’s as simple as I can figure it.
Report
3points
#66 Wouldn’t You Just Stop At The Core Due To The Earths Gravity?

Terra_B:
No you will: Max out velocity only about 200km Probably hit a wall due to corolis effect / orbital mechanics Actually in the middle of the earth would be little gravity as there is equally as much mass above as below you
No you will: Max out velocity only about 200km Probably hit a wall due to corolis effect / orbital mechanics Actually in the middle of the earth would be little gravity as there is equally as much mass above as below you
Report
3points
#67 I Got 76, My Friend Got 80. Who Is Right?

CoolStuffSlickStuff:
84. There are 4 tiers on each side, each tier having 10 triangles. So that's 80. Then there are 4 wide triangles that span the left and right sides.
84. There are 4 tiers on each side, each tier having 10 triangles. So that's 80. Then there are 4 wide triangles that span the left and right sides.
Report
3points
#68 What Would Be The Answer?

unatleticodemadrid:
It’s 042. Hint 4 rules out 7, 3, and 8. Hint 5 gives you that 0 is part of the code but is in position 1 or 2. Hint 3 tells you that 0 has to be in position 1 and another number is right so it’s 0x2, 02x, 0x6, or 06x. Using clues 1 and 2, you can deduce that 6 can be ruled out too since it doesn’t change position but it’s positioned right in clue 1 but wrong in clue 2. That’s impossible. So it’s only 0x2 or 02x. 8 has already been ruled out from hint 4, so that leaves 0x2 as the only possibility. Finally, from clue 2, we get 042.
It’s 042. Hint 4 rules out 7, 3, and 8. Hint 5 gives you that 0 is part of the code but is in position 1 or 2. Hint 3 tells you that 0 has to be in position 1 and another number is right so it’s 0x2, 02x, 0x6, or 06x. Using clues 1 and 2, you can deduce that 6 can be ruled out too since it doesn’t change position but it’s positioned right in clue 1 but wrong in clue 2. That’s impossible. So it’s only 0x2 or 02x. 8 has already been ruled out from hint 4, so that leaves 0x2 as the only possibility. Finally, from clue 2, we get 042.
Report
3points
#69 Street Hourly Capacity

VincentGrinn: the numbers are more or less right, 6k for busses per hour per lane is abit higher than i normally see but not by much
a lane of car traffic can move about 1,500 people per hour per lane, but traffic lights limit that significantly, 1100 might be an overestimate
walking is particularly hard to work out, some things ive seen say 15,000 per hour in a 3.5m wide space, but its rare to have so many people walking anyway
good street design definitely is just a matter of maths though
a lane of car traffic can move about 1,500 people per hour per lane, but traffic lights limit that significantly, 1100 might be an overestimate
walking is particularly hard to work out, some things ive seen say 15,000 per hour in a 3.5m wide space, but its rare to have so many people walking anyway
good street design definitely is just a matter of maths though
Report
2points
#71 Why Wouldn't This Work?

kirihara_hibiki: Basically, it is true that the Limiting Shape of the curve really is a circle, and that the Limit of the Length of the curve really is 4. However, the Limit of the Length of the curve ≠ the Length of the Limiting Shape of the curve . There is in fact no reason to assume that. Thus the 4 in the false proof is in fact a completely different concept than π.
Report
2points
#72 What Would Be The Volume Of 60,000,000 Pennies?

roge-: At 0.349 cm3 per penny, 60 million pennies would have an aggregate volume of 20.94 million cubic centimeters or 20,940 liters. As for how large of a container you would need to fit all of those pennies, its capacity would have to be greater than that, since discs won't pack perfectly.
Report
2points
#73 Is This Even Possible? How?

Angzt: Since the image shows 8 balls, I'm guessing it's the 8th that's also identical looking but actually heavier. To solve: Take two sets of three balls and weigh them against each other. Option 1: One side is heavier. Then pick two of the heavier side's balls to weigh against each other. Option 1.1: One ball is heavier. That's your pick. Option 1.2: Both balls weigh the same. Then the third one from the previous heavier set is the heavier one. Option 2: Both sets of three weigh the same. Then you weigh the remaining 2 against each other. One of them will be heavier and that's your pick. Oddly enough, you could do the same thing with 9 total balls and it would still work. The first weighing tells you which set of 3 has the heavier ball. Then you weigh two of those against each other and learn which one it is exactly.
Report
2points
#74 What's The Correct Answer?

mdroidd:
3.14^pi is slightly bigger than pi^3.14. It is tempting to generalise that to "higher power beats the higher base". However, numbers smaller than 2.718 (Euler's number) have the opposite effect. So in general, x^(x+dx) > (x+dx)^x when x > e. Proof: x^(x+dx) = (x+dx)^x Rewrite to: x^dx = ((x+dx)/x)^x Take logarithm of both sides: dx ln(x) = x ln(1+dx/x) Expand the right-hand side for small dx: dx ln(x) = dx ln(x) = 1 --> x = e
3.14^pi is slightly bigger than pi^3.14. It is tempting to generalise that to "higher power beats the higher base". However, numbers smaller than 2.718 (Euler's number) have the opposite effect. So in general, x^(x+dx) > (x+dx)^x when x > e. Proof: x^(x+dx) = (x+dx)^x Rewrite to: x^dx = ((x+dx)/x)^x Take logarithm of both sides: dx ln(x) = x ln(1+dx/x) Expand the right-hand side for small dx: dx ln(x) = dx ln(x) = 1 --> x = e
Report
2points
#75 How Accurate Is This?

bassplaya13:
The defense budget is like $1 trillion. So 2% if that is $20 Billion. We have no idea how to construct such a large obsidian sphere, especially in the Sam Francisco bay. Obsidian is like $25 a kilogram, I’m gonna roughly guess that thing is 3km in diameter, which gives us 14.13 cubic kilometers or 14.13E+9 cubic meters. At 2250 kg/m3, that’s 31.8E+12 kg or 794 trillion dollars worth of obsidian. So it’s not even close from that standpoint.
The defense budget is like $1 trillion. So 2% if that is $20 Billion. We have no idea how to construct such a large obsidian sphere, especially in the Sam Francisco bay. Obsidian is like $25 a kilogram, I’m gonna roughly guess that thing is 3km in diameter, which gives us 14.13 cubic kilometers or 14.13E+9 cubic meters. At 2250 kg/m3, that’s 31.8E+12 kg or 794 trillion dollars worth of obsidian. So it’s not even close from that standpoint.
Report
2points
#76 To What Extent Can Black Garbage Bags Actually Heat Up A Pool?

dietervdw:
Apparently the sun outputs about 1kW per square meter. Assuming the bag captures all of that and converts it into heat, that can heat a cubic meter of water 0,86 degrees Celsius per hour, or about 1.5F/hour. So seems plausible.
Apparently the sun outputs about 1kW per square meter. Assuming the bag captures all of that and converts it into heat, that can heat a cubic meter of water 0,86 degrees Celsius per hour, or about 1.5F/hour. So seems plausible.
Report
2points
#77 Is It Possible In Any Way To Either Prove Or Disprove It?

Nerves_Of_Silicon:
Proof by contradiction: *IF* 0/0 = 1. Then 2 * 0/0 = 2 * 1 On the left we can apply the 2 to the numerator (2 * a/b = 2a/b) so (2 * 0)/0 which equals 0/0. On the right 2 * 1 = 2. And that gives us 0/0 = 2 But we already said 0/0 =1 So now we have the result 1 = 2. Which is impossible. Therefore our original assumption must be wrong. And 0/0 does *not* = 1. By following the same logic, 0/0 can't have *any* definite value. Or else all of the maths we use immediately breaks down. So it doesn't.
Proof by contradiction: *IF* 0/0 = 1. Then 2 * 0/0 = 2 * 1 On the left we can apply the 2 to the numerator (2 * a/b = 2a/b) so (2 * 0)/0 which equals 0/0. On the right 2 * 1 = 2. And that gives us 0/0 = 2 But we already said 0/0 =1 So now we have the result 1 = 2. Which is impossible. Therefore our original assumption must be wrong. And 0/0 does *not* = 1. By following the same logic, 0/0 can't have *any* definite value. Or else all of the maths we use immediately breaks down. So it doesn't.
Report
1point
#78 What Is The Odds That This Has Happend In Human History?

MartinGallois:
The odds are so small that if everyone on earth was slapping a table every second since the beginning of civilization, the odds would still be almost zero.
The odds are so small that if everyone on earth was slapping a table every second since the beginning of civilization, the odds would still be almost zero.
Report
1point


