Bored Panda
“It Didn’t Work”: 43 Stories About What It’s Really Like To Live In A Polygamist Household
Relationships,FamilyJUN 22, 2026

“It Didn’t Work”: 43 Stories About What It’s Really Like To Live In A Polygamist Household

24
12
Most people’s definition of marriage includes only two spouses. But it’s estimated that about 60,000 people in the United States practice polygamy, the majority of whom do so for religious reasons. Despite the fact that this is illegal in all 50 states, the practice doesn’t seem to be going anywhere. But because it has to be done discreetly, it is often shrouded in mystery for those who aren’t a part of the same community.
That’s why many people online are fascinated by the idea of plural marriage, and if you are too, you’ve come to the right place. Reddit users who grew up in polygamist homes have been sharing details about their upbringings, so we’ve gathered their most enlightening stories below.

#41

So I'm suuuper late, but when I was four my birth mom and father, both married at the time, had my sister and "married" my second mom (they were in a triad, not exactly polygamous). All three are pagan of various sorts so I grew up in a different household for more reasons than one. They considered themselves polyamarous, not polygamous. My dad also has a girlfriend that lives in Boston so we don't see her much. It wasn't weird to me I guess, I'd never known anything else. It was however extremely weird to explain and made get mocked and awkward questions. It got better once we moved out of the suburbs.
As for how it worked, It all seemed very turn-based. They had two bedrooms and switched off sleeping together/ alone. Washing dishes was a point of contention, especially after my birth mom started working again. She always wanted to do them and everyone else was always trying to do them, it's quite funny thinking about it now. Other than all the rotational stuff it was pretty much normal, besides not being able to relate to most fictional families. My birth mom and my farther got divorced last year so now I don't have to worry about explaining it,.
Report
2points

#42

Not me but a good friend. He (we) are Muslim. His dad was married to his first wife, friend's bio mom, for about four years and hadn't yet had any children. Mom 1 took it upon herself to find wife No. 2. Dad had a child with wife No. 2 and lo and behold wife No. 1's ovaries kick in and she begins to have kids, too. In the end, wife 1 had six kids and wife 2 had four. They all lived in one compound, moms took turns with chores and kids. Kids called both ladies mom and it seems to have worked out ok. Currently iwfe 1 is still alive and lives with a daughter from wife 2. As far as I can tell they were all treated equally and no messed up kids. Friend would like to have multiple wives but not so easy to do in the US.

I personally suggested to my ex that he take on a second wife because I simply couldnt keep up with school work kid and him. He thought I was nuts as I wasn't Muslim then. It also is uncommon in his family and we don't know of any polygamy in the family for six or seven generations back.
2points

#43

I was raised in a Polygamous family for most of my formative years. My grandfather had 9 wives while I was around, they were essentially my great aunts or something analogous to that. My dad only had one wife, my mom. None of my Grandfathers wives were mormon, non of them were born into that lifestyle and a few of them had college educations.

Its wasn't a cult so much as an alternative to what was viewed as a very corrupt and wasteful rest of the country/world. They homesteaded in the desert of southern Utah until the feds came and destroyed their houses, and after that they started the town that I grew up in.

I feel really lucky. I grew up around a large group of people who loved and supported me in their own way. Some of my uncles are my best friends and some of the most interesting, well adjusted, productive and responsible people that I know. We all learned how to play musical instruments, how to work hard and do right by the people that loved us, which are things that are unfortunately rare in todays world.
Many of my friends from outside the family have visited my hometown and all of them left with a more than positive impression. Some of my friends even consider themselves part of my family because of what my parents did for them, such as encouraging them to graduate high school or giving them food and shelter when they needed it.

Polygamy gets a bad rap because of the places like Colorado City and the injustices of the Mormon Church, but coming from a place of love it can be a wonderful thing.
I'm not interested in the lifestyle of polygamy, but almost everything else my family did, from the family music circles, the big family dinners, the shared childrearing, the midwives and the fruit trees seems beautiful to me now that I am out here in the "real" world.
1point
24
12