Bored Panda
“It Didn’t Work”: 43 Stories About What It’s Really Like To Live In A Polygamist Household
Relationships,FamilyJUN 22, 2026

“It Didn’t Work”: 43 Stories About What It’s Really Like To Live In A Polygamist Household

24
12
Most people’s definition of marriage includes only two spouses. But it’s estimated that about 60,000 people in the United States practice polygamy, the majority of whom do so for religious reasons. Despite the fact that this is illegal in all 50 states, the practice doesn’t seem to be going anywhere. But because it has to be done discreetly, it is often shrouded in mystery for those who aren’t a part of the same community.
That’s why many people online are fascinated by the idea of plural marriage, and if you are too, you’ve come to the right place. Reddit users who grew up in polygamist homes have been sharing details about their upbringings, so we’ve gathered their most enlightening stories below.

#21

Vintage campers parked under string lights at night, symbolizing diverse stories from polygamist families.
I wasn't born in one but I dated a girl for a year and a half who had a polygamist grandfather that lived in arizona. One time she invited me along to go visit them for a week so I did and it was the strangest thing to me the way they dressed how like hidden the place was too it was really wierd the grandfather had 32 sons and daughters they all lived in a trailer park and the grampa lived three double wide trailers he just put together. Other from that though they acted like normal people and the grandpa wasn't the guy to marry young girls he just had three wives.
7points

#22

Hope I'm not too late!

My parents are in a polyamorous relationship with another couple I've known my whole life. They have been in this relationship for a few years, but I only found out a few months ago, and the other couple moved in with us about a month ago. It took me a little while to get used to the idea that my parents are seeing other people but I know that they are all consenting adults so I'm okay with it. They are all noticeably happier not having to hide it. Some points:

-their lifestyle did not rub off on me. I could never see myself in a relationship with multiple people. I'm totally okay with others doing it but I could never share a man :p

-what makes their relationship work out is honesty and communication. Since there are multiple people, they have to work at it harder to prevent drama. But they put a lot of effort into communication so they're good.

-in my opinion, any relationship between consenting legal adults where nobody is getting hurt is fine. Whatever floats your goat.

I'd be happy to answer any questions you have!
Report
7points

#23

I've spent time with (and babysat for) a polygamist family. A mom, two dads, and three kids. They are one of the happiest families I've ever met. The three parents clearly love each other (I'm not sure of the exact logistics of it, but from what another person has told me, it sounds like they are all involved with each other), and the kids, though a little bit wild, have a lot of love and fun to share. They're really open to new things, and really like other people. I've never had issues with the kids' behavior. They don't know which guy biologically fathered which child, so they call one Dad and the other 'Dad' in a different language. The kids are still young, so it's hard to say what kind of impact this will have on their life as they get older, but so far they seem well adjusted to a non-standard family life.
7points

#24

A young man in a black hoodie looking somber, representing stories from people in polygamist families.
I have a friend who grew up with 7 moms. He's 22 now, and the moment he turned 18 he ran away from home to the city, where I ended up meeting him. Apparently he knew about 4 of his moms having affairs, not because anybody did anything wrong, but simply because his dad had a hard time balancing all his wives.

edit: Affair was the wrong word to use; I just used it because the dad had no idea. If he ever found out that his wives were bumping it with other guys, I don't think he'd have much say, and I don't think he'd really be mad either.
6points

#25

A man in traditional attire stands before a white building, depicting a polygamist family context.
Sorry for being late. but as a 16 year old living with a polygamous family in which i have 2 moms, I think my father has done a good job keeping the family happy from each side. You see, maintaining a polygamous family requires lots of work from the father. Don't try running a polygamous family unless you are rich ( and yes I am an arab and I am happy with my situation).
6points

#26

A mother and her three daughters smiling together outdoors, depicting dynamics within polygamist families.
I live in a polygamist family at 17 years old. I go to a private high-school with about 120 kids and the vast majority are plig kids as well. My dad had 5 wives, one of them left. My dad has exactly 30 kids.

There are many advantages to growing up in a polygamist family compared to a monogamist from what I have observed. All of my mothers look out for me just as much as my biological mother and love me dearly. It is hard to express how grateful I am sometimes to have them there. If I need a shirt pressed and my biological mother is gone or too busy to do it ( or if I am too lazy/too busy to do it myself) I know I can go to another mother and she will gladly help me out.

The other thing is, with 3 mothers living in the same house, (one of my dad's current wives lives in a separate house) managing kids works very well. If one of the mothers wants to have a night out, or is gone for work vacation etc, they don't even think about babysitters, and know they can trust that if they are gone from the house, they have someone else there who can take on the responsibility of watching their children. Those are just a few advantages out of many.

There are also disadvantages. With so many children living in a house, it's hard to keep your peace of mind. Often times there is so much confusion in the house from children playing and whatever will take place, I have a very hard time handling myself. Sometimes I wish I could just go live in a house with my own room and just enjoy some quiet time. I would say that's the biggest thing that bothers me. Just the confusion that can happen with such a big home and so many kids.

I do love having the siblings that I do have, and I consider every one of my dads kids my brother and sister, and I try to show them the same love that I would for my biological brother or sister. I feel like I am so blessed to have as much family as I do.

I often think what it would be like to grow up in a typical family and I just can't imagine how lonely I would feel without the constant companionship I have with every one of my siblings.

My dad's house is very large, I'm not sure the exact square footage, but it's fairly big. We have two full kitchens, two washers and dryers, a tv room, 2 family rooms, a play room for kids, 15 bedrooms, (if I counted right) and a dining room. Recently my dad finished the house and pretty much built himself a mancave. He built the house in 3 phases, the first with the dining room, a kitchen, a family room, and about 4 bedrooms. This phase is a two story with a basement. The second phase is the biggest one, with a third floor on the top, containing a second kitchen in the basement, a tv room, a few bedrooms in the basement, about 5 bedrooms in the upper floor, one bedroom on the main, and a library/office. The last phase contains my dad's master bedroom, and a living kitchen area on the upper floor, with 2 bedrooms on the main and a garage, and no basement.

As far as living arrangements go currently, there are two mothers with the majority of the kids. One has 9, and the other 12. My dad's first wife has 4 kids but they are all moved out. The other 2 had previous marriages before they married my dad. One lives in another house as I said, with one kid born to my dad, and the other left, having 3 kids with my dad, and only one still currently living in my dad's house. Each mother has her own room, and it is in the same general area of her kids rooms. Each mother takes care of their childrens laundry etc. They are responsible for their rooms to be clean, that area of the house to be clean, and they are the primary person to pretty much raise their children.

However, I feel like the other mothers have taught me a great deal in my life as well. Each mother has their own night to spend with my dad, and it rotates on a weekly bases. The mothers fight sometimes, and do have a hard time dealing with each other. But for the most part, every one in the family get's along with each other well, and I can say that we are all happy to be in our situation. I feel like polygamy can be such a blessing if you are willing to put the time and effort into it that it takes. It requires every person to put our their own pride and ego, and their jealousies and insecurities. It is a ton of work just as child, and I can't imagine what it would be like to be a parent. I would not have it any other way though. Living in a polygamist family I feel has blessed my life in ways that I can't express.

Sorry if this post was confusing. Just tried to get everything I could in about the lifestyle. Ask me any questions you have and I will feel free to answer.
6points

#27

A man with a surprised expression on a blue background, illustrating reactions to polygamist family stories.
My great uncle had two wives. There's an insane story behind it as well.

We live in Ireland so this kinda thing just doesn't happen to often. My uncle left his first family and ran away to England leaving his wife and kids alone and poor. He left for another women who he then married under a false name.

About 15 years later the his son goes looking for him. He presumes he's passed or far away so goes to the an office where they have all the records and such. He goes up to the man at the desk and asks for my uncle by his name also saying he's his father - hoping to find some information. The man turns around and said 'I didn't know he had a son your age! I'm afraid he's left already for the weekend'. So it turns out his father is actually working at the office.

The craziest part of the story is that weekend my uncle was driving to his home with his second family when the car crashed and they all passed bur one young girl. His son never got to meet him again and the story was heard all over Ireland and about the scandal of a man with two wives.

We still receive Christmas letters from the family of the girl who survived ...
6points

#28

A young man with curly hair and a pink shirt, a modern representation in a story about polygamist families.
I had a friend who was, and he enjoyed it as he could snag a ride almost any-day of the week, or borrow cash and no one thought he did it too often. he said the only bad part was that if he yelled mom, 8 people responding made it difficult to know where the one you need is.
5points

#29

A woman in a yellow hijab looks down with a pensive expression, considering the experiences of polygamous families.
I'm using a throwaway for this.

I'm Muslim, female, and born to the first wife (of three). I have loads of brothers and sisters, ages ranging from toddler to 30's. We get along fairly well and so do our moms, although it did take some getting used to in the beginning.

Being in the US means that we rarely mention our step-moms to others. We just say that we have half siblings and let people guess at how that came to be. Those of us who married plan to remain monogamous, I don't know about the little ones yet.

It used to bother me when I was a teenager because I knew my mom hated seeing her co-wives. After years of urging her to leave, I finally came to terms with the fact that she would rather be in a comfortable place where she had financial security and a husband every third day than to have to rely on herself (or be a "burden" on other relatives). So I quit bugging her to leave him and just tune her out when she complains.

Some people are asking how there will be enough women to go around if men have multiple wives. All the women that I know who married already-married men had left their previous husbands who did not treat them well and/or couldn't provide for them adequately. So yes, that would leave plenty of men without wives, but mostly those who couldn't manage having one.

Personally, I don't care if people are polygamous. Live and let live. I have no sympathy for wives who complain about it though. NO ONE is forcing them to stay. Any idiot who whines that a religious authority isn't allowing a women to get divorced should simply walk out. There are plenty of other reasonable Imams to grant divorces.
4points

#30

Five smiling women toasting with pink champagne, celebrating and sharing stories from polygamist families.
I guess you could say my granddad was a polygamist. He has 10 children all by different women. 5 of the women live together still. My grandma was the second wife.

It's quite weird that one of my aunts is only 10.
4points

#31

A family gathered around a dinner table outdoors, sharing a meal and stories from polygamist families.
My grandfather was married to 2 wives, he recently passed away. It was obvious he liked his second wife more than his first, but it was different kind of love because he had feelings for the first (who is my original grandmother) as well. The family treated both wives almost equally, the first received more attention then the second. I see my aunts and uncles as from the same grandfather, not from 2 grandmothers. When I see my grandmothers I treat them equally. Second grandfather is Hispanic so communication is a bit different. Both wives lived together. Family reunions are massive and normal.
4points

#32

My dad was a fundamentalist Mormon who fathered 19 kids, 12 with his first wife and 7 with his second. I was really young when he married his second wife, so it wasn't hard to adjust to having two moms. Having a lot of siblings was great, but there were *always* fights.

We weren't wealthy, made due with around 20k a year (in rural Missouri) and a 5 bedroom house, later, dad bought a trailer for his second wife. We were all home-schooled and didn't have social security numbers or birth certificates. This was mostly because polygamy is illegal, but they also wanted to shelter us from the world as much as possible.

My second mom left my dad after about 10 years of marriage. She started sending her kids to public school in spite of Dad's objections, and after a year, my mom decided to follow suit so we could be in the same school. I started in 8th grade, so you can imagine how bad that was, coming from a household as sheltered as ours. High school wasn't much better.

I don't resent growing up in a polygamist family, but there's no way I would want to be in a polygamist marriage, and I think most of my siblings feel the same way.
Report
4points

#33

An older man with a fishing net stands by a pond near a house, representing stories from polygamist families.
I grew up in a village where several villagers had 2 and 3 wives. Marrying more than one wife used to be fairly common in rural Nepal until early 1990s when the first wave of democratic reforms, that prohibited polygamy, were introduced. One family particularly comes to my mind. Because they were poor, they would fight over who got more food. So the hubby had an easy solution: he would serve all the food in the house.
3points

#34

A happy, smiling older woman wearing glasses and a red top, listening to stories from polygamist families.
Not me, but my mom did. She had 11 siblings and 2 mothers (her biological passed away and her father married another later). Now, they lived in Baghdad at the time so the housing they were in was quite small, which required them to have two separate houses. Other than that, from what I gathered my mother loved it. She's still in contact with all her siblings and whenever she tells me stories of her childhood it sounded like it worked out pretty well.
But like I said before, they lived in Baghdad where polygamy wasn't necessarily taboo, therefore it might have been normal for her, making it "easier".
3points

#35

I was born into a family with a very rich history in polygamy/Mormonism. My father never had more than one wife (thank God) but he was definitely pressured by his father (my grandpa) and everyone else in the community to pick up a couple more. Being a male and having a wedding ring was no reason to stop dating and looking for more women to marry. My dad was a little more of a rebel though, and my mother, bless her heart, told my dad that if he were to ever pick up another wife, she'd leave him. He always jokes that it was the easiest decision of his life, being that he had no intention of living in a polygamist lifestyle. Although I have never experienced having multiple mothers first hand, I have grown up with it my entire life and my experience has, for the most part, been very positive. But like most fundamentalist religions, skeletons are always hiding in the closet.

I have jealousy ruin lives. Ladies, think about it. You have to share your husband, and everything attached to him, with other women. And women who grow up in polygamist households are more than willing, excited even, to take the plunge and be #3 or #4.

It may seem like a dream world for us guys, being with multiple women and all; but from what I've personally heard from several of my uncles is that it is extremely stressful to be an emotional support system for multiple women. There isn't a lion-tamer in the circus that can compare to some of the men I've met. They are definitely masters in the art of juggling women's emotions. I can't even handle one woman let alone three or four.

Both of my grandfathers practice polygamy and a large handful of my uncles do as well. My grandfather's other wives were treated with the same respect as my biological grandmother, although the bond between generations was much stronger in my ACTUAL grandmother versus her sister wives (yes, that's what they're called and yes, I do know the Brown family from the show on TLC). Family functions are huge, and continue to grow. Polygamist families are tight-knit and respect for other families is a top priority.

Here are a couple basic, unspoken rules as to how it all comes together:

1) Men are on a schedule as far as sleeping arrangements are concerned. Ex: If Man A has three wives, Wife A, Wife B, and Wife C, he spends the night with each wife. See below:

Monday - Wife A
Tuesday - Wife B
Wednesday - Wife C
Thursday - Wife A
Friday - Wife B
Saturday - Wife C
Sunday - Wife A
and so on down the line

2) Siblings who share the same father, but are from different mothers, are regarded as full brother and sister. It is actually very neat to see the bond that siblings have in polygamist settings.

3) The 1st wife to marry is usually, but not always, thought of as the "queen bee" in the relationship and are typically treated better than the other wives.

4) If it can work financially, the whole family will live under one roof. If not, then the separate houses will be in very close proximity to one another.

5) Most men are tradesmen, working in things such as construction, plumbing, cabinet work, concrete, etc.

6) Most newlyweds are encouraged to have children as soon as possible.

Obviously, this is only scratching the surface of the unspoken rules.

One thing that I have seen in polygamist relationships is that jealously can tear through a marriage like a meat hook. It may sound gruesome, but that's really the only way I can describe it. I've seen jealously rip through the strongest of marriages.

I hope this helped! If anyone needs any sort of clarification or specifics, I am glad to do a Q&A/AMA type session with my fellow redditors.
3points

#36

This is my short and botched answer.

I grew up in a polygamist family; my dad has 2 wives(although they never got along). My mother has 16 children, my father has 24. My dad's wives have always lived in separate homes and moved around a lot because nobody was ever happy with the current situation.

My grandfather had 4 wives. After he passed away his oldest son took on one of his wives because she was still able to have children; this is common in the group. The group doesn't live on a compound like many other polygamist groups in Utah. They live all over the state (and spreading) and for the most part blend in with the population.

All of my dad's sons are no longer part of the group, some of his daughters married and are still part of it. We were taught to keep everything a secret as kids going to public school and were discouraged from making friends at school.

The group normally did not take in new members unless they brought women in by marriage. "They have to grow from within to be successful". Some of the leaders have 20+ wives and hundreds of children(8-20 children per wife). Most girls are married by 18 and having kids asap.

There are lots of cousins marrying cousins, uncles marrying nieces, some half siblings marrying one another, older men marrying younger women.

As for my dad's family it didn't work out so great because it created lots of drama and despise between the two families.
Report
3points

#37

In my experience it's something that
Just isn't talked about. My dad was married before he met my mother. 20 years later he is still with his wife and my mother. He goes weeks were he will spend a lot of time with us than I'll go weeks without seeing him. This hurts my mother every time yet for some reason she still stays with him. His family has chosen to have nothing to do with me and blames me for my dad's actions. Growing up this was very difficult and I was often made fun of at school. One thing I've learned from this is that Is definitely not something I want my children to go through.
3points

#38

My grandpa had 7 wife's (the forth being my grandmother). my dad has around 27 brothers and sisters. i wouldn't say i was born into a polygamist family considering that i had only one mom and dad, but i was (sorta still am) around it quite often. i find it funny how most people on this this thread are freaking out at 32 siblings. that's a little bit. a few of my friends belong to the same family of 46, there dad having 3 wife's(4 at one point but divorced only two kids with her). that's also not even the most. theirs one man from the town that has a total of 65+ kids. unfortunately i don't know how many wife's he had. i saw a joke people were making that it would suck to have 6 "moms" because they would tell you to clean your room six times, well that would never happen for two reasons . one being you cant have more that one mom. you have your mom and 5 aunts. second being every wife gets there own house. I've never seen them living in the same house. back in the day there used to be a lot more polygamist in the town but now the newer generation is seeing that its a very hard life to live so only a few are still doing it. another thing interesting is that its a polygamist town of white people that moved to mexico so even though there are many Mexican available for dating a lot of the the people rather keep it in the family by dating cousins. this is considered very normal but not all resident agree with it. if you guys have any questions i'm open to answering. i tried my best at spelling and grammar, my bad. also the lady with the most kids has 20. all from her.
3points

#39

Well, my parents are polyamorous.
They started out monogamous, but when I was maybe 6 or so, my mom really liked my best friend's dad, in addition to my dad (her husband), so they talked about it for a very long time, and basically decided to be polyamorous.

The man she liked, "Albert", was polyamorous, and had a wife, "Betsy" who had two husbands, Albert and "Cyril". And now, maybe 12 years later, those relationships are all still intact (although Cyril now has a girlfriend in addition to his wife, now) And my dad has never shown any interest in anyone other than my mom.

It really hasn't ever bothered me. I figure you can love whoever you want to love, regardless of race, gender, or quantity. It's really none of my business to dictate who you love.

But something happened early on between my mom and Betsy, so there's a lot of resentment there, and my god, it's complicated, and I honestly don't know why my mother puts up with all of it just to stay with her boyfriend, but I guess it's worth it for her.

I'm personally not very interested in polyamory for myself, although I'm not opposed to it. I've seen many people do it, and sometimes it works out, but oftentimes not (that's just what I've seen, don't use my own generalizations as evidence!). It seems to work out better for really casual relationships rather than lifelong relationships. And I'm not really the casual type, so all that, combined with just how much more work and communication is needed, makes me not very interested in it. But if I ever meet someone I like who wants to be polyamorous, I would try it out at least.

Feel free to ask me any other questions you have!
3points

#40

A man in a turtleneck and blazer looks contemplatively out a window, reflecting on polygamous family stories.
Worked pretty well for my dad, 2/3 - I think he'd do it again the randy old codger.

It was a pretty enriching environment for me, really, nice to have the different opinions and points of view and the support structure.

My Biologigical mother eventually went her own way, but that was just sort of the natural evolution of things...she left when I was about 16 - I have always maintained a close relationship with her, and she still participates in family gatherings.

My Dad had married my mother first, then my first "stepmom" , and in a few more years another "stepmom".

There wasn't any religious foundation for this, More just a really handsome, super intelligent man that had a way with the ladies, and was bad with birth control, evidently. In each case, he decided it was best to take his girlfriends in and raise their children in a family environment rather than leave them as single mothers.

In all, I have 9 siblings, and everyone is pretty well adjusted, with a high degree of education and or success.

(my siblings mostly have masters degrees or higher, two are professional athletes, and one is involved in national (entertainment) media, another is a researcher with a PHD in physics specializing in solar energy) One is crazy (happy crazy, but suffers from a birth defect that affects his perception of reality - really too bad, as he is an actual genius otherwise) and others are all at least moderately successful in their chosen fields.

In our community there was no ostracization or negative stigma from anyone who actually knew my father, as he was very well liked and well known over the entire state.

Occasionally, religious fanatics would glance askew, but it really was a non issue mostly. Kids in my high-school just basically thought my dad was "big pimpin" , and I got a little bit of positive notoriety from that.

I am thankful for the cultural flexibility that it gave me, growing up with an intimate understanding that there are widely disparate points of view about almost all social paradigms, both from the intellectual diversity of my mothers, and from our existence at the fringes of the social norm. This has been very useful to me in my travels, as I find it very easy to integrate into different cultures around the globe.

Negative things for me included my school vice principle, who would give any girl that was going out with me ISS for dating me....but that really helped my bad-boy image in the end. There were also some awkward interviews for a very, very thorough background investigation that I underwent as part of a contracting requirement.

In all, I am quite happy with the circumstances of my upbringing.

I think it probably influenced my romantic predilections, as all my long term relationships have been with women who were on the far end of the Bi-spectrum (does that make me a lesbian trapped in a man's body?), and I have had mostly LTR arrangements with multiple female partners in cohabitation...

My first wife wasn't really that happy as she felt threatened (no good reason, I would never have left her) by my significantly younger partners, so she recently went her own way in an amicable separation. Almost an eerily similar situation to my father. I do not think this is coincidence. I think it is very hard for the first. The second enters into a situation where cooperation is the stable norm, and later additions are much more comfortably accommodated. My partners tell me that they think it is a good deal for them, because they enjoy both male and female companionship, and because it is very difficult for them to find males that they consider intellectually suitable to father their children. (not for lack of applicants) . This brings me to another minor side point - Women in my experience are terrifyingly practical when it comes to these things, hardly the wispy creatures of whim as they are frequently portrayed.

I have several children, some of them grown. They are all well adjusted, and are (so far) academically successful, with my oldest now involved with spacecraft engineering from the software side.

I think, done right, with intellectually mature relationships and open, honest communication and expectations, Polygamy / polyamory is very workable - but I have seen a lot more examples of what not to do than positive ones, but also thats what makes the news, I suspect.
2points
24
12