Some things in life just don’t make sense. You try to figure them out, but no matter how much time passes, the answers never come. It’s frustrating, but also the kind of thing that makes for truly gripping stories.
That’s exactly what happened when Reddit users whodunit72 and richterbg asked people to share personal mysteries they’ve never solved. The replies were full of bizarre coincidences, unexplained disappearances, and moments that seem to defy all logic. Scroll down to read them all and see if you’d have done any better at cracking the case.
#41

When I was young, I came home from school and tried to close my bedroom door but it wouldn’t close. The metal part of the door frame (that the latch goes into) was bent and there was a small silver charm inside the hole in the door frame. It was a Native American wearing a headdress.
It wasn’t a charm for a bracelet or necklace, because there was no hole. I asked my mom and she was just as confused as I was- and scared that someone had broken into our home.
She didn’t end up filing a police report because that was the only odd thing. Nothing was missing, all the windows were locked.
It’s been 15 years and I still think about this AT LEAST once a week trying to figure out an explanation. My mom doesn’t have any ideas either and doesn’t know what she did with the charm.
It wasn’t a charm for a bracelet or necklace, because there was no hole. I asked my mom and she was just as confused as I was- and scared that someone had broken into our home.
She didn’t end up filing a police report because that was the only odd thing. Nothing was missing, all the windows were locked.
It’s been 15 years and I still think about this AT LEAST once a week trying to figure out an explanation. My mom doesn’t have any ideas either and doesn’t know what she did with the charm.
11points
#42
My biological father was m******d by persons unknown. 38 years ago and I don’t believe there is any way to get answers. Circumstances were that the people who did it are very likely dead already. This has caused me to have a weird relationship with mysteries. I feel so much for anyone dealing with an unanswerable question and wish that everything could be solved.
Report
11points
#43
When I was a little kid I befriended some other neighborhood kids who were a little older than me but not so old that it seemed odd. They had this strangely dilapidated farmhouse that sat across the street from our neighborhood of three bedroom rambler style homes. The kids could come over to my house no problem, I was just not allowed to visit their home because they had (wait for it): "a rabid mongoose in their garage/barn". I thought about this for years and realized later that it was likely because they were poor and living in substandard conditions and they may have been hoarders/alcoholics or the like. The neighborhood still exists but their house was torn down after they moved away (to where nobody knows) and it's been so long I don't remember their name. The only evidence a home existed there was some old sewer pipes sticking up above the ground and a warehouse was placed there some years back. A very strange situation to say the least.
Report
11points
#44
My uncle, on his death bed confessed to me, that he m******d some people when he was younger. He didn't know their names and he didn't tell me where this happened.
He spent a few years in jail for being a pretty big d**g dealer in my state. He went on to say that the only murder he committed that bothered him was an older teenager that owed him money. He said he drove by slowely next to the teenager's car and shot him twice in the head.
He said he had to do it but it bothered him, the other m**ders...he said was strictly business. And he didn't think twice about it. My uncle is dead now...and I don't even know how to find out who he k**led. I wish I could give some poor family some closure.
He spent a few years in jail for being a pretty big d**g dealer in my state. He went on to say that the only murder he committed that bothered him was an older teenager that owed him money. He said he drove by slowely next to the teenager's car and shot him twice in the head.
He said he had to do it but it bothered him, the other m**ders...he said was strictly business. And he didn't think twice about it. My uncle is dead now...and I don't even know how to find out who he k**led. I wish I could give some poor family some closure.
Report
11points
#45

About 20 years ago my parents, my brother, and I arrived home after being out all day. It was around 7 pm.
As we drove into the driveway, we noticed something sitting on our porch. When we got out of the car, we saw that it was one of those disposable aluminum baking dishes and something else wrapped in foil.
We got inside, opened it up, and inside was homemade lasagna and garlic bread. There was no note left with it. We were utterly confused.
My family decided to eat it despite not knowing its origin. I chose not to. I was jokingly told to call 911 if they started to experience signs of poisoning. They ate the whole thing and everyone was fine.
At the time, we were close to all our neighbors. We asked around to see if one of them made it for us but they all said no. My mom began to think we received it by accident. She checked with the person whose mail we always got because our addresses were similar. They had no idea what we were talking about.
To this day, we still have no idea who was the intended recipient. My thought is that someone dropped it off for a person who just experienced a death or life event that prevented them from cooking. But we would have heard about that from our neighbors. So, either this person was incredibly lost and left it by mistake, or it was a total random act of kindness.
As we drove into the driveway, we noticed something sitting on our porch. When we got out of the car, we saw that it was one of those disposable aluminum baking dishes and something else wrapped in foil.
We got inside, opened it up, and inside was homemade lasagna and garlic bread. There was no note left with it. We were utterly confused.
My family decided to eat it despite not knowing its origin. I chose not to. I was jokingly told to call 911 if they started to experience signs of poisoning. They ate the whole thing and everyone was fine.
At the time, we were close to all our neighbors. We asked around to see if one of them made it for us but they all said no. My mom began to think we received it by accident. She checked with the person whose mail we always got because our addresses were similar. They had no idea what we were talking about.
To this day, we still have no idea who was the intended recipient. My thought is that someone dropped it off for a person who just experienced a death or life event that prevented them from cooking. But we would have heard about that from our neighbors. So, either this person was incredibly lost and left it by mistake, or it was a total random act of kindness.
10points

