Some things in life just don’t make sense. You try to figure them out, but no matter how much time passes, the answers never come. It’s frustrating, but also the kind of thing that makes for truly gripping stories.
That’s exactly what happened when Reddit users whodunit72 and richterbg asked people to share personal mysteries they’ve never solved. The replies were full of bizarre coincidences, unexplained disappearances, and moments that seem to defy all logic. Scroll down to read them all and see if you’d have done any better at cracking the case.
#21

Back in middle school, I brought a dining room chair into my bedroom so my friend had a better place to sit while we played video games. This room, it was about 4 meters squared. We lost the chair. I don't know how. All I know is that neither of us took it from the room(we were the only ones home) and that we never saw it again.
20points
#22

My grandmother told me a story when I was 12, about 18 years ago. She had a younger sister, Doreen, who was 20 at the time, from a very small community (not really even large enough to be considered a town) in Oklahoma. Doreen decided that she wanted to be a movie star and so she left to Hollywood, this was in the 1960s, not sure the year, and she was never heard from again. Not one single person in the family ever heard from her again. My grandmother has always wondered what happened to her little sister, and since I heard the story, I’ve always wondered too.
19points
#23

There was a Chinese family who lived on my street when I was a kid, and the mom was a teacher at the local community college where my mom was a non-trad student. Mom would go over a lot and cook with her, which was awesome because it meant I got to eat a lot of really good food. She also had a son who was, admittedly, a lot older than me (I was five, he was about fifteen), but I thought he was the most amazing person ever because he was freakin' amazing at basketball. Like, I was a small, chubby white girl who wanted to *be* this super athletic Chinese teenager when I grew up.
Then, one day the son vanishes. Like, he was just there one day and gone the next. No moving trucks, no warning, no nothing. I was tiny and confused, and I remember looking at the article for China in the encyclopedia because I thought maybe it would tell me where he went. After all, encyclopedias know everything, right?
The mom stayed for a couple more years and then she moved away, too. She never made a mention of her son and my mom never brought him up. To this day, I wonder what happened. Did he get deported? Did he move back to China on his own? Did something happen to him and that's why nobody wants to talk about it? Where the hell'd he go?
I was so young I don't even remember his name, but even if I did? Who knows if I'd want to know what I find? Last time I got around snooping for the whereabouts for missing people I loved when I was a kid, two of then ended up m******d and one is a r*pist. :\
**Edit: Solved! I broke down and asked my mom since it'd been years, and it turns out the woman's son was deported because of immigration issues. I was just a jerk kid who kept opening up old wounds whenever I'd ask where he went.**.
Then, one day the son vanishes. Like, he was just there one day and gone the next. No moving trucks, no warning, no nothing. I was tiny and confused, and I remember looking at the article for China in the encyclopedia because I thought maybe it would tell me where he went. After all, encyclopedias know everything, right?
The mom stayed for a couple more years and then she moved away, too. She never made a mention of her son and my mom never brought him up. To this day, I wonder what happened. Did he get deported? Did he move back to China on his own? Did something happen to him and that's why nobody wants to talk about it? Where the hell'd he go?
I was so young I don't even remember his name, but even if I did? Who knows if I'd want to know what I find? Last time I got around snooping for the whereabouts for missing people I loved when I was a kid, two of then ended up m******d and one is a r*pist. :\
**Edit: Solved! I broke down and asked my mom since it'd been years, and it turns out the woman's son was deported because of immigration issues. I was just a jerk kid who kept opening up old wounds whenever I'd ask where he went.**.
19points
#24

I knew this girl that my brother liked and they were adorable. He would ride bikes with her and they were really cute. Then we hadn’t seen her for like 3 days so we went up to their house and knocked on their door. This older dude answered and we were like “hey is this girl here” and he said he knew no one with that name, so we left. I never saw that kid again and she never talked about moving. The house wasn’t up for sale either, no signs or anything. My brother got really sad.
19points
#25

When I was a freshman or sophomore in high school (2003ish?) I received a bubble package in the mail that had no return address on it, although it was clearly marked with my name. Inside was a burnt copy of the Postal Service album, complete with hand drawn album art and all. It was around my birthday so I assumed a friend sent it to me, but no one ever said anything to me about it and I never found out who did it. Innocent mystery.
18points
#27

As a child, a slightly older girl and her father moved in beside us. She and I became friends instantly and taught me how to snow board, I had never been inside of her place but she had been inside of mine.
One day, she was just gone, I knocked on the door, no answer, her fathers car wasn't there and her snowboard wasn't in the back yard like usual. I waited until the next day and knocked on their door again, still no answer, I looked in to the living room window and there was nothing in there. It was just empty. I still wonder what happened, where they went and I feel bad cause I no longer remember her name.
One day, she was just gone, I knocked on the door, no answer, her fathers car wasn't there and her snowboard wasn't in the back yard like usual. I waited until the next day and knocked on their door again, still no answer, I looked in to the living room window and there was nothing in there. It was just empty. I still wonder what happened, where they went and I feel bad cause I no longer remember her name.
18points
#28

One day my neighbor knocked on my door with a letter she’s received. She said she thought I’d want to see what it said. It was a form letter accusing my husband and myself of all sorts of horrible things. As the day went on, the majority of my neighbors on the street brought me more of these letters. All exactly the same.
I called the police. They took the stack of letters and asked if anyone was upset at any of us. My husband and I couldn’t think of anyone that fit that description. The police left without saying much.
I started investigating on my own. One thing I noticed is that all of the street addresses on the envelopes had our old post code, which had been changed. The only place online that listed full addresses with the incorrect post code is the county tax records. One other clue that the county tax records were used for the address was the fact that the only person on our street that didn’t get a letter was not listed on the tax records.
I still don’t know who sent the letters. My first inclination was that it was one of my sisters. This sister has threatened my life on many occasions. I have emails and voicemail saved in which she explicitly details how she will k**l me and my family. I’ve long worked to keep my address from her. Unfortunately my elderly mother shares information that she probably shouldn’t.
I called the police. They took the stack of letters and asked if anyone was upset at any of us. My husband and I couldn’t think of anyone that fit that description. The police left without saying much.
I started investigating on my own. One thing I noticed is that all of the street addresses on the envelopes had our old post code, which had been changed. The only place online that listed full addresses with the incorrect post code is the county tax records. One other clue that the county tax records were used for the address was the fact that the only person on our street that didn’t get a letter was not listed on the tax records.
I still don’t know who sent the letters. My first inclination was that it was one of my sisters. This sister has threatened my life on many occasions. I have emails and voicemail saved in which she explicitly details how she will k**l me and my family. I’ve long worked to keep my address from her. Unfortunately my elderly mother shares information that she probably shouldn’t.
17points
#29

Who left an armed mousetrap outside my back door.
I'm a pretty nice person. So is my spouse. We don't have any enemies. Not that we know of anyway. About 2 weeks after we purchased our new home, I walk out the back door only to find this mousetrap sitting there. My initial thought was that my cat found the treasure and dragged it over here to raid. I went to grab a stick to check it just for good measure, and to my surprise it snapped shut.
Someone had to walk through my gate down this long walkway, past motion sensor lights and into my backyard to place this thing outside my patio door.
My neighbors are nice old people. I don't think it was them. I've lived here 10 years now and have never had another incident. No one has ever shown that they have a beef with us. It made absolutely no sense. Bizarre.
I just wish I had security cameras back then.
I'm a pretty nice person. So is my spouse. We don't have any enemies. Not that we know of anyway. About 2 weeks after we purchased our new home, I walk out the back door only to find this mousetrap sitting there. My initial thought was that my cat found the treasure and dragged it over here to raid. I went to grab a stick to check it just for good measure, and to my surprise it snapped shut.
Someone had to walk through my gate down this long walkway, past motion sensor lights and into my backyard to place this thing outside my patio door.
My neighbors are nice old people. I don't think it was them. I've lived here 10 years now and have never had another incident. No one has ever shown that they have a beef with us. It made absolutely no sense. Bizarre.
I just wish I had security cameras back then.
17points
#30

My biological dad freaked out when my mum told him she was pregnant with me. He didn’t know if he wanted to be in my life or not. The following weeks they talked on the phone, then he had a car accident, but continued to talk to her afterwards until he suddenly stopped. His phone was disconnected, she never got his address, and she also couldn’t remember his last name properly, whether it was Addis or Addison. All I know about him is that his name is Lawrence and that he was nice, good looking and tall.
17points
#31

My mom’s childhood friend Danielle went to a concert with a friend and never came home. Their car was never found. Their bodies were never found. She & her friend just disappeared into thin air. She lived in South Jersey and the concert was in Philly. No camera captured them crossing the bridge. We all fear they were k**led in a highly calculated and neat hit, but we can’t prove it because there is literally zero evidence of their whereabouts. We just have no idea. She and her friend both had children. It’s just so incredibly sad and confusing.
Here’s her page on the Charley a Project.
There’s also a Disappeared episode about her case.
Here’s her page on the Charley a Project.
There’s also a Disappeared episode about her case.
16points
#32
I don't think this is interesting at all, really. But it annoys me to no end.
When I was about pre-school aged my mom would take me over to this woman's house and I'd play with her son. My mom told me eventually that the woman had some severe mental illness and was going through a really bad time because she thought that either the government or the kids' dad was going to take them away from her because of her problems.
I got along with him really well because I was pretty boyish for a girl and we would never argue about anything. I remember near the end the boy's mom was kind of clingy toward my mom and would be around just about every day. The last time we visited her, the kids weren't there and I was bummed out. My mom would never tell me what happened, but I guess that I'd assume her fears were correct and her kids were taken away. I think that my mom served as someone she could vent to and she trusted with the baby while I played with the oldest boy and kept him occupied. I think our company kept her hanging on for just a while longer. I hope that the two boys are okay and I hope that if I'm right and she did lose them, they were able to reconnect and she's doing well now. I can't remember the boy's name, I was almost sure it was Michael, but I don't remember anything else.
When I was about pre-school aged my mom would take me over to this woman's house and I'd play with her son. My mom told me eventually that the woman had some severe mental illness and was going through a really bad time because she thought that either the government or the kids' dad was going to take them away from her because of her problems.
I got along with him really well because I was pretty boyish for a girl and we would never argue about anything. I remember near the end the boy's mom was kind of clingy toward my mom and would be around just about every day. The last time we visited her, the kids weren't there and I was bummed out. My mom would never tell me what happened, but I guess that I'd assume her fears were correct and her kids were taken away. I think that my mom served as someone she could vent to and she trusted with the baby while I played with the oldest boy and kept him occupied. I think our company kept her hanging on for just a while longer. I hope that the two boys are okay and I hope that if I'm right and she did lose them, they were able to reconnect and she's doing well now. I can't remember the boy's name, I was almost sure it was Michael, but I don't remember anything else.
Report
15points
#33

I was sleeping in my room that was on the second floor. I think it was about 4 in the morning when I woke up to the sound of footsteps on the roof. I thought I may have imagined hearing footsteps and went back to sleep. When I woke up to my alarm at about 6 am, I looked out my window and noticed that the screen to my window had been slashed. I always wonder who the hell did this and what they were planning on doing. 15 years later and it still creeps me out.
14points
#34

Anyway, this isn't a real life disappearance, but a couple of years ago I had this friend who I talked to basically everyday, and one day she said something about her mom not being able to pay the internet bill so she may go offline for a day or two until the bills paid and the internet comes back. She never came online again. All of her accounts on every site had been inactive since that day or before because she was mainly active on her facebook, and ever since I've always worried for her safety, since we live in different countries and from what she did tell me, where she lived was kind of messed up, and the fact she hasn't been active at all in two whole years just worries me a bit, even though I probably am over thinking it and she's probably fine, but I'd love to know she actually is okay, whether she'd want to talk to me again or not.
Edit: I should've mentioned this but forgot, but for those curious, she was from Glendale, Arizona.
Edit: I should've mentioned this but forgot, but for those curious, she was from Glendale, Arizona.
14points
#35
A few years back, my cousin was charged with fraud and indecency to a body after my aunt died and she buried her in a shallow grave somewhere. She collected her disability cheques for 3 years before she was caught. She claims that my aunt died in her sleep, then stored her outside in her wheel chair for a couple days and then buried her, but she could of m******d her and I think she had help moving the body. We still have no idea where my cousin buried her and I really wish we could find her, to get closure. It makes me so sad, my aunt had the mentality of a 5 year old and she was so sweet. Such a shame.
Report
13points
#36
I got sick once, like I didn’t feel good but I was still hungry and ate normally. After a few hours diarrhea started, within 3 hours after that I had gotten so ill I collapsed. Never vomited or felt nauseous though.
I was eating, drinking pedialite, drinking water, but I got so sick so fast that I was having heart problems and my potassium fell into dangerous levels.
The hospital ran every test they could on me, nothing came back to say what it was. The next day I was weak but fine. I shared every meal with my spouse, no one around me got sick, but it still drives me crazy years later- wtf was it?
Something within hours took a healthy 23 year old and caused them to need 3 potassium pills and 2 IVs in the ER with constant heart monitors and blood pressure checks. When I left the hospital my bp was 89/50.
Slept for three days after. No one could figure out what it was, no one else got it. I want to know what it was!
8337:
Please don’t think I’m making light of your illness, but the same EXACT thing happened to my dog ten years ago. Same treatment at the emergency vets, same outcome - he just got better. They never figured out what it was.
I was eating, drinking pedialite, drinking water, but I got so sick so fast that I was having heart problems and my potassium fell into dangerous levels.
The hospital ran every test they could on me, nothing came back to say what it was. The next day I was weak but fine. I shared every meal with my spouse, no one around me got sick, but it still drives me crazy years later- wtf was it?
Something within hours took a healthy 23 year old and caused them to need 3 potassium pills and 2 IVs in the ER with constant heart monitors and blood pressure checks. When I left the hospital my bp was 89/50.
Slept for three days after. No one could figure out what it was, no one else got it. I want to know what it was!
8337:
Please don’t think I’m making light of your illness, but the same EXACT thing happened to my dog ten years ago. Same treatment at the emergency vets, same outcome - he just got better. They never figured out what it was.
Report
13points
#37
My grandfather went on a business trip to Florida in the 1950s and disappeared for a month, leaving his car behind and blood on the seat. Eventually, he turned up in California claiming not to remember what happened. Soon after returning home, it came out that he had picked up a hitchhiking airman who attacked him and he fought back, kicking him out of the car in the process. He thought he had k**led him, which is why he ran. I never could find any information on a missing airman in Florida during that time. However, his father was a state senator in Kentucky whose close friends included the governor, AP Chandler. It was suggested that one of his father's rivals orchestrated the whole mess. Unfortunately, all the people who were old enough to remember what was going on at the time have either passed or are not well enough to ask.
Report
12points
#38
Can mine be spooky? I have a spooky one. Grab a bag of popcorn and enjoy.
When I was in high school about 25 years ago, gas was literally $0.88/gallon, and us kids would find loose change to go driving around all day and night to get away from the prying eyes of our parents. One thing that we always liked to do when it got dark was go to the local "haunted" places. The haunted bridge that was supposed to be the site of a witch hanging. The haunted tree they built a road around. The curve in the road where you would flash lights and see a haunted motorcycle come your way. The train tracks where a bus full of kids was hit. I'm sure every town has similar places and I'm sure lots of spooky teens go to them, keeping the legends all alive through the decades.
There was one tale that was a little different than the others, and it was by far my favorite. Just outside city limits there was a fairly remote road that branched off the main road. It was a really creepy, curvy 2 lane paved road that had a few houses here and there. You've seen similar I'm sure, a small neighborhood built on the edge of town so you have convenience and country at the same time. At one point, the road forked into two with a 3-way stop. If you went to the left, the road quickly lost its paving and turned to gravel, and there were three quite exaggerated hills. A few houses here and here, no more than 10, dotted the road until it ended it what looked like a cul-de-sac. The entire cul-de-sac was surrounded by trees, except one small driveway to the right.
We used to park in that cul-de-sac, because what was up that driveway was *scary*. About 20 feet up the drive was a large metal fence that we would jump over. We would follow the overgrown drive until it reached a HUGE clearing in the woods. A field of a few dozen acres that were completely void of trees, with a small house and a large pond. The pond was beautiful and reflected the moonlight. It was great to sit there on nice summer nights... The house was abandoned, full of small holes, no door, and it came with its own story.
Supposedly, a few decades prior, a man invited a group of people over for a dinner party. At one point, he got out his gun and left nobody alive by the end. The man and his dinner guests supposedly haunted the house. The story explained all the holes in the walls, and the reason nobody would live on such a beautiful piece of land. We never saw anything weird happen there, and we went at least once a month for quite a while.
One time, we get back down the driveway to leave and see a police officer, in a very dated looking car, waiting at our car. He asked what we were doing, etc... like cops do. We made up a story, etc... like kids do. He got us into our car, and the last thing he said was, "Hey kids, I wouldn't go up there anymore if I were you; some people say that place is haunted."
WTF.
Adults aren't supposed to acknowledge that sort of thing. Especially not cops. It was super creepy to us, as we all remarked as we started heading down the road. The cop was trailing behind us to make sure we left. Remember the humps in the road? We would go over one, he would follow. We went over the second one. He followed. We went over the third one, which ended us at the 3-way stop and a stop sign.
He didn't follow.
We waited, thinking we were supposed to be visible to him until we left the neighborhood.
He never came over that last hill.
About 15 years later, the internet was in our homes, and technology allowed us to look up old ghost stories and such. One night I decided to go online and look up that old street on a website called The Shadowlands. The entry read:
"(Spooky Road) is a winding back road. In the 1950's a police officer was hit and killed pulling someone over. Local legend says if you drive this road at midnight, an officer will pull you over in his 1950's style cruiser to talk to you, then go back to his car and disappear."
I never found anything about the house supposedly being haunted like I heard, but I'll be damned if we didn't experience a strange cop that night that disappeared. We came for one ghost story, and found another.
I'll admit it is possible that us telling the story created its own urban ghost legend, but it still sends shivers down my spine thinking about it 25 years later.
When I was in high school about 25 years ago, gas was literally $0.88/gallon, and us kids would find loose change to go driving around all day and night to get away from the prying eyes of our parents. One thing that we always liked to do when it got dark was go to the local "haunted" places. The haunted bridge that was supposed to be the site of a witch hanging. The haunted tree they built a road around. The curve in the road where you would flash lights and see a haunted motorcycle come your way. The train tracks where a bus full of kids was hit. I'm sure every town has similar places and I'm sure lots of spooky teens go to them, keeping the legends all alive through the decades.
There was one tale that was a little different than the others, and it was by far my favorite. Just outside city limits there was a fairly remote road that branched off the main road. It was a really creepy, curvy 2 lane paved road that had a few houses here and there. You've seen similar I'm sure, a small neighborhood built on the edge of town so you have convenience and country at the same time. At one point, the road forked into two with a 3-way stop. If you went to the left, the road quickly lost its paving and turned to gravel, and there were three quite exaggerated hills. A few houses here and here, no more than 10, dotted the road until it ended it what looked like a cul-de-sac. The entire cul-de-sac was surrounded by trees, except one small driveway to the right.
We used to park in that cul-de-sac, because what was up that driveway was *scary*. About 20 feet up the drive was a large metal fence that we would jump over. We would follow the overgrown drive until it reached a HUGE clearing in the woods. A field of a few dozen acres that were completely void of trees, with a small house and a large pond. The pond was beautiful and reflected the moonlight. It was great to sit there on nice summer nights... The house was abandoned, full of small holes, no door, and it came with its own story.
Supposedly, a few decades prior, a man invited a group of people over for a dinner party. At one point, he got out his gun and left nobody alive by the end. The man and his dinner guests supposedly haunted the house. The story explained all the holes in the walls, and the reason nobody would live on such a beautiful piece of land. We never saw anything weird happen there, and we went at least once a month for quite a while.
One time, we get back down the driveway to leave and see a police officer, in a very dated looking car, waiting at our car. He asked what we were doing, etc... like cops do. We made up a story, etc... like kids do. He got us into our car, and the last thing he said was, "Hey kids, I wouldn't go up there anymore if I were you; some people say that place is haunted."
WTF.
Adults aren't supposed to acknowledge that sort of thing. Especially not cops. It was super creepy to us, as we all remarked as we started heading down the road. The cop was trailing behind us to make sure we left. Remember the humps in the road? We would go over one, he would follow. We went over the second one. He followed. We went over the third one, which ended us at the 3-way stop and a stop sign.
He didn't follow.
We waited, thinking we were supposed to be visible to him until we left the neighborhood.
He never came over that last hill.
About 15 years later, the internet was in our homes, and technology allowed us to look up old ghost stories and such. One night I decided to go online and look up that old street on a website called The Shadowlands. The entry read:
"(Spooky Road) is a winding back road. In the 1950's a police officer was hit and killed pulling someone over. Local legend says if you drive this road at midnight, an officer will pull you over in his 1950's style cruiser to talk to you, then go back to his car and disappear."
I never found anything about the house supposedly being haunted like I heard, but I'll be damned if we didn't experience a strange cop that night that disappeared. We came for one ghost story, and found another.
I'll admit it is possible that us telling the story created its own urban ghost legend, but it still sends shivers down my spine thinking about it 25 years later.
Report
12points
#39
When I was about 3 I was in daycare and a teacher found me in one of those plastic house things and I was blue and had a crazy high fever. Paramedics came and I was rushed to the hospital, apparently they had to stop the ambulance on the way to take care of me because my fever was getting too high and I had a seizure. I was at the hospital almost a week and the doctors did a spinal tap, ran every test they could think of and never came to a conclusion about what happened. My mom was distraught, but she said one of the most vivid memories was me talking/rambling in complete gibberish for hours and hours and how creepy it was. I don't think I'll ever find out what happened to me, but I am so grateful for the paramedics and doctors who saved my life.
Report
12points
#40
Catholic school survivor here. I was in the 2nd grade when I dropped a personalized ring from my dad during a school Catholic mass. My teacher was a monster so I couldn’t get on the floor to look for it. I was devastated & cried my eyes out. I prayed for days on end to find it to no avail (no s**t of course it didn’t work.) A few years pass & I’m moving my bed to redecorate my room AND THE RING IS WEDGED BETWEEN MY CARPET & THE WALL. I still don’t know how the hell it got there.
Report
12points

