#21

"Because I said so" has a bad reputation and a fairly solid defense. When parents reach for it, they are usually several hundred micro-negotiations deep into the day. Every boundary is potentially a debate, every rule has to withstand cross-examination, and children cannot always process lengthy explanations logically anyway.
Child behavior researchers point out that explaining every decision has value some of the time, but that limits do not always need a full rationale to be legitimate. Sometimes "because I said so" is a parent running out of bandwidth. And sometimes the lesson is that the world will not always justify its rules to you, and learning to function within them is something you are going to need.
#22

#23

1. I almost never got yelled at. Instead, when I acted up or was otherwise an idiot, we had to discuss it. At length. It was excruciating. I was certain that getting yelled at and punished was better.
2. My mom only said she was disappointed with me once. That was nearly 50 years ago and I remember it vividly. She was absolutely in the right to be disappointed in me and I worked very hard to never make her disappointed in me again.
RIP mom and dad. Thank you for all you taught me.
#24

Then there are the white lies, which the thread has complicated feelings about. Plenty of people grew up believing that the toy store was mysteriously closed every Sunday, or that carrots genuinely improved your eyesight. These feel harmless, and in some cases they are. But research from NTU Singapore, led by associate professor Pei Pei Setoh, found that white lies only significantly increased children's likelihood of lying back if the child already knew they had been misled.
Instrumental lies were more damaging regardless: "behave or I'll call the police" or "finish your homework and we'll go to Disneyland" increased dishonesty in kids no matter what. The takeaway is not that all parental creativity backfires, but that kids are tracking honesty far more carefully than most adults give them credit for.
#25

where *only* kids who are potty trained get to go, just to play all day! where theres all kinds of wonderful toys and a big park attached to it and if i was good, then *someday* even i would get to go there.
but, parents arent allowed to come cuz its for kids only...so she told me i had to be ready to not see her for the *whole* day if i wanted to go to this super cool play place.....and she could only bring me if i was *reeeaally* good and worked hard to leave the diapers behind
yall i worked so hard to get out of diapers so i could go to this fabulous fantastical place of toys and fun. when i could finally go i thought it was the best thing ever. i was so excited and i made so many friends and it was awesome. i was really confused about why some of the other new kids were so upset about going to the kids-only-super-fun-club-of-fun. they would cry when they were dropped off but i would cry sometimes when i had to leave
guys.....it was just daycare. i thought *daycare* was a super exclusive theme park for kids. i thought i was hot stuff for being accepted into their cool club. its one of the coolest things my mom managed to do tbh. so many kids were completely devastated and i never had to go through that feeling of abandonment that i saw so many of my (eventual) friends go through when they first started daycare.
#26

#27

I thought they were just really cool parents until much later when they told me and my sister that if they did that, they knew where we were and that we were safe.
Well played parents. Well played indeed.
What the thread captures is the accumulated weight of small, consistent decisions that did not announce themselves as important at the time. Nobody registered the dinner table as doing developmental work, and nobody thought the chore chart was building anything lasting.
It just happened, over years, in ordinary kitchens and ordinary arguments that felt enormous and are barely memories now. Looking back and seeing the shape of it is its own kind of gift, even when it arrives a decade later than anyone would like.
Did you ever have a lightbulb moment where your parents' weird choices finally made sense? Share it with us in the comments!
#28

When I was growing up, I thought my parents did this so we wouldn’t get all our presents around Christmas and we could space out the celebrations. Now I realize they didn’t have the money to get all those gifts in one month, but wanted to make sure we got something eventually.
#29

It cost nothing and I used it for all my pre teen years. Each card was specific to me and my interests and what we had around the house. I loved it and thought it was so fun and cool.
#30
They did similar with music, but to a lesser degree. Mom played violin casually and dad played trumpet in a low-key local orchestra, and occasionally in the pit orchestra for musicals. We all had piano lessons and the option to pick up a second instrument. We listened to all kinds of music on the radio: orchestral, big band, swing, oldies, classic rock, and country (plus the occasional baseball game) and went to orchestra and choir concerts. My favorite were the Messiah productions at Christmas.
These things -- especially the music lessons -- make it sound like we were well off, but we really weren't. We scraped by and got a boost from government assistance at times. But we sacrificed in some areas (very rarely had name-brand anything from cereal to shoes). Mom and dad just prioritized things like reading, music, education, and travel over new cars or the latest fashions. .
#31
#32
#33
#34

Sounds sad but instead she always gave me fruits and nuts . Well I didn't understand it then, but I guess she just wanted her kid to be healthy and I do appreciate it deeply as it improved my gut and kept my physique in check✅
#35
Once they got up, mom wrote out the chore list. There were always five things on the list, some were easy, some were hard. The first kid who had their room clean got first pick, and so on.
This meant as soon as they got up, we jumped up, turned off the TV, and rushed to clean our rooms. After that things dissolved into chaos, so don't think our family life was perfect, but it was a good start.
#36
#37
They had five kids in a small house and on Sundays he’d put the kids in the back yard and throw about $1.75 in various coins around the yard. He told the kids that there was $2.00 in change and what they found they could keep. The kids would spend forever trying to find that last $0.25 and the parents would have alone time in the house presumably to try and make more kids.
#38
They never had to worry about us buckling.
#39
Another thing they did was when we would have garage sales any of our possessions that got sold, we got to keep the money. We also ran a popcorn & lemonade stand but we had to pop the popcorn and make the lemonade. As long as we did all the work we got to keep all of the money. We learned the value of hard work and the value of money.
#40
Second place goes to her faking falling asleep and letting us have the tv remote if we gave her a backrub. Even now I’m in awe of how she played us.

