Looking for a job can be frustrating. It’s an arduous process that requires a lot of time and preparation, and even with all that, it doesn’t necessarily mean that you will get the job.
But being on the other side of the process is arguably not that much easier. The hiring managers, too, have to invest a lot of time and effort into finding the right fit for a certain vacancy. But over time, it becomes easier for them to do; after talking to hundreds—if not thousands—of applicants, they know what to be on the lookout for.
Recently, a group of hiring managers delved deeper into the topic after one member of the ‘Ask Reddit’ community asked them about the subtle red flags that say, "This person won't be a good hire." They gave examples and shared stories, which might come in handy when it’s time for you to look for a job, so you might want to scroll down to find their answers on the list below and read them carefully.
#41

I asked someone in an interview why they wanted the job and they said it was just to fill in until they could find something better.
6points
#43
If every question I ask results in a 10-minute story and I can't get a word in, this is not the position for them.
Report
6points
#44
I don't know if it counts as "subtle" or not but the dude had a bunch of p*rnstar posters hanging up in his home office during the zoom interview. I like p*rn as much as the next guy but I don't want to see that s**t when we're doing standups. Maybe if he was Einstein or Tesla or something but he couldn't even code his way out of a paper bag.
Report
6points
#45
Software engineer. I always keep asking questions until I find something they don’t know. If they don’t say “I don’t know” at that point, huge red flag.
Nobody knows everything, being able to recognize when you’ve encountered a subject outside of your knowledge is essential .
Nobody knows everything, being able to recognize when you’ve encountered a subject outside of your knowledge is essential .
Report
6points
#46
Anyone that leads with how important it is that his or her boundaries need to be respected is for sure going to be a pain in the a*s to employ.
Unless you're some rockstar in your field, you should go into any interview with the assumption that there are 10 other people willing to work harder and for less. If you're comfortable enough walking away from the job, then you can hold out and demand more. But if you *need* the job, know that to distinguish yourself, the employer wants to see someone who is going to help him or her succeed.
Unless you're some rockstar in your field, you should go into any interview with the assumption that there are 10 other people willing to work harder and for less. If you're comfortable enough walking away from the job, then you can hold out and demand more. But if you *need* the job, know that to distinguish yourself, the employer wants to see someone who is going to help him or her succeed.
Report
5points
#47
Called someone up for a phone screening. I was asking her generally easy technical questions to see if she qualified to go through our interview process. She was whispering all her answers and I could barely hear her and I asked her to speak up, and she said she can’t cause she’s in a meeting at work. That’s when I realized that the voice I kept hearing in the background wasn’t a tv but a person speaking, giving a speech or something.
I told her to try to reschedule with us. We ended up not having her in for an interview.
I told her to try to reschedule with us. We ended up not having her in for an interview.
Report
5points
#48
If they no call/no show for an interview and then call me in a panic a day later. Nope. I’ve had plenty of candidates call before an interview to say they were running late, or had an emergency, they were very ill and had to reschedule — no problem, s**t happens. You might be an awesome candidate on paper, but if the position is not important enough to you to double check your calendar, the confirmation email, etc - then I don’t want you. Maybe you had a brain fart, maybe you had a bad day - but who cares, we all do. Communication is the key. Im not going to hold anyone’s hand. Better luck next time.
Report
5points
#52
Main and most common red flags are:
- They treat employees not related to their interview badly - i.e. being rude to reception/admin or HR staff who do checks/emails to confirm interviews. So many people will be rude to them and then act surprised when I phone them and tell them they have been rejected. Only once did I let someone interview after being rude to admin and that was mainly because it was just so strange (they turned up at the office with their parents in tow because they didn't like they date we offered for the interview and insisted we reschedule - after the first 3 interview questions, I had to end it and call a mental health crisis team because it was clear they were in the midst of a full blown psychosis).
- They don't research the company they are applying to - so many people think they can sweet talk their way through a full interview without knowing anything at all about the company. The red flag here though isn't that they don't know anything, it's that they made things up. They try to tell you what they know and get it very, very wrong. Even just admitting you don't know is better than getting caught out. You can sort of scape by and show an interest in wanting to learn more about the company and be honest about the little you do know.
- They avoid giving negatives about themselves completely. Even when I specifically narrow them down to the point and ask them to reflect on a weakness directly - they pick a positive trait and try to downplay it like a weakness. My experience interviewing hundreds of people tell me that this is just a variation of lying and they are usually hiding some big flaws. No one is perfect, I specifically pick out people with weaknesses that we can manage and help them work on. For example I hired someone who said they played off being a perfectionist as a negative and boy were they right. The person couldn't keep up with the workload and eventually quit but the other person I hired who said they had depression and had periods where they struggled with work/life balance was a great fit after giving them flexibility on hours. They were so grateful and happy to be part of a supportive employer they worked twice as hard as anyone else.
Overall - I've found that people who are very confident at interviews and those who generally score really well are what I call a 50/50 hire - often they are the first to leave and take a better offer at a competitor, or have serious baggage and are often much harder to read as they can talk themselves through an interview easily and hide their flaws or problems, which always come out eventually.
I feel most comfortable and confident hiring people who are not perfect, but still have a willingness to develop and improve themselves. Usually people in this range are very good at their jobs and just get nervous or struggle giving themselves praise to strangers.
In the end, the only real way to know is to test them out and see how they get on during probation. The main thing I'd say is make sure you know what kind of person you're looking for and that will guide your decision during interviews. Do you want someone who can hit the ground running and really competent and skilled, but may not last very long or someone who you will likely see much more value out of in the long-term with a bit of development.
- They treat employees not related to their interview badly - i.e. being rude to reception/admin or HR staff who do checks/emails to confirm interviews. So many people will be rude to them and then act surprised when I phone them and tell them they have been rejected. Only once did I let someone interview after being rude to admin and that was mainly because it was just so strange (they turned up at the office with their parents in tow because they didn't like they date we offered for the interview and insisted we reschedule - after the first 3 interview questions, I had to end it and call a mental health crisis team because it was clear they were in the midst of a full blown psychosis).
- They don't research the company they are applying to - so many people think they can sweet talk their way through a full interview without knowing anything at all about the company. The red flag here though isn't that they don't know anything, it's that they made things up. They try to tell you what they know and get it very, very wrong. Even just admitting you don't know is better than getting caught out. You can sort of scape by and show an interest in wanting to learn more about the company and be honest about the little you do know.
- They avoid giving negatives about themselves completely. Even when I specifically narrow them down to the point and ask them to reflect on a weakness directly - they pick a positive trait and try to downplay it like a weakness. My experience interviewing hundreds of people tell me that this is just a variation of lying and they are usually hiding some big flaws. No one is perfect, I specifically pick out people with weaknesses that we can manage and help them work on. For example I hired someone who said they played off being a perfectionist as a negative and boy were they right. The person couldn't keep up with the workload and eventually quit but the other person I hired who said they had depression and had periods where they struggled with work/life balance was a great fit after giving them flexibility on hours. They were so grateful and happy to be part of a supportive employer they worked twice as hard as anyone else.
Overall - I've found that people who are very confident at interviews and those who generally score really well are what I call a 50/50 hire - often they are the first to leave and take a better offer at a competitor, or have serious baggage and are often much harder to read as they can talk themselves through an interview easily and hide their flaws or problems, which always come out eventually.
I feel most comfortable and confident hiring people who are not perfect, but still have a willingness to develop and improve themselves. Usually people in this range are very good at their jobs and just get nervous or struggle giving themselves praise to strangers.
In the end, the only real way to know is to test them out and see how they get on during probation. The main thing I'd say is make sure you know what kind of person you're looking for and that will guide your decision during interviews. Do you want someone who can hit the ground running and really competent and skilled, but may not last very long or someone who you will likely see much more value out of in the long-term with a bit of development.
Report
4points
#53
I interviewed a girl that seemed ok. Alittle weird and quirky (but hey, we are all weird). Could have used some more experience in the field, but if we started her with low and she worked her way up it probably would have been fine.
Another manager took her to your the facility and I got a text from my supervisor to come outside to the parking lot area. He was standing behind this girl’s car and did the quiet loud whisper of “get over quick!” I walk over and there is the LARGEST bumper sticker that says “I EAT A*S”. My supervisor turned and looked at me and said “you are NOT hiring her”. Proceeds to walk away.
Needless to say with a facility that had kids around frequently we did not hire her. I thought it was kinda funny. Maybe not something you publicly announce though. True irony of it all though was the supervisor was a notorious s**t. Was on Grindr all the time and had his lovers come to the facility. Guess he was a top and not a bottom.
Another manager took her to your the facility and I got a text from my supervisor to come outside to the parking lot area. He was standing behind this girl’s car and did the quiet loud whisper of “get over quick!” I walk over and there is the LARGEST bumper sticker that says “I EAT A*S”. My supervisor turned and looked at me and said “you are NOT hiring her”. Proceeds to walk away.
Needless to say with a facility that had kids around frequently we did not hire her. I thought it was kinda funny. Maybe not something you publicly announce though. True irony of it all though was the supervisor was a notorious s**t. Was on Grindr all the time and had his lovers come to the facility. Guess he was a top and not a bottom.
Report
4points
#54
Had one person put down “Instagram and Facebook” in their Skills section. This was for an upper level medical professional position.
Report
4points
#55
Ignoring advice and hints.
In tech it's pretty common for there to be a dialogue between interviewer and interviewee when doing a difficult problem on the whiteboard. Some problems are actually *designed* so you don't have enough info without asking questions.
It's okay to struggle a little and need some guidance, but *ignoring* that guidance is pretty much an instant no-hire, even if your solution ends up being pretty close in the end.
Why? Because we're not just testing your coding skills. We're testing your communication, and how you work with teammates.
If we hire you, the next time we work on a problem together it might be one where neither of us just *knows* the answer. And in that situation, you need to be able to collaborate instead of just charging past to work on your own idea.
In tech it's pretty common for there to be a dialogue between interviewer and interviewee when doing a difficult problem on the whiteboard. Some problems are actually *designed* so you don't have enough info without asking questions.
It's okay to struggle a little and need some guidance, but *ignoring* that guidance is pretty much an instant no-hire, even if your solution ends up being pretty close in the end.
Why? Because we're not just testing your coding skills. We're testing your communication, and how you work with teammates.
If we hire you, the next time we work on a problem together it might be one where neither of us just *knows* the answer. And in that situation, you need to be able to collaborate instead of just charging past to work on your own idea.
Report
4points
#56
I was in management for a daycare and it became pretty easy to identify the red flags. Unfortunately we were always so hurt for employees we’d hire them anyway.
I know it’s kind of a meme but if you immediately let me know your sexual orientation I knew it was going to bad. Like I had several candidates essentially open up with how they were gay, their race, and why their life was tough. Which I get it. We are in the south it sucks. But like how do you feel about changing diapers? And we’d hire them anyway and they’d immediately get into it with a parent.
I know it’s kind of a meme but if you immediately let me know your sexual orientation I knew it was going to bad. Like I had several candidates essentially open up with how they were gay, their race, and why their life was tough. Which I get it. We are in the south it sucks. But like how do you feel about changing diapers? And we’d hire them anyway and they’d immediately get into it with a parent.
Report
3points
#57
Oh and so many people lie or exaggerate their experience on their resume. Then, when interviewed, they can't answer basic questions about key tasks in the role 😭.
Report
3points
#58
They don't listen at all, just giving shrugs or "whatevers" when describing the job and their duties.
Report
3points
While the second article tackles the intricacies of job hunting and the subtle red flags to look out for during interviews, there's a similarity in the underlying theme of attention to detail in processes, as discussed in the quick photo editing tips shared by YuriFineart.
Both scenarios emphasize the importance of making refined choices, be it selecting a candidate or enhancing a photograph with insightful techniques.


