Looking for a job can be frustrating. It’s an arduous process that requires a lot of time and preparation, and even with all that, it doesn’t necessarily mean that you will get the job.
But being on the other side of the process is arguably not that much easier. The hiring managers, too, have to invest a lot of time and effort into finding the right fit for a certain vacancy. But over time, it becomes easier for them to do; after talking to hundreds—if not thousands—of applicants, they know what to be on the lookout for.
Recently, a group of hiring managers delved deeper into the topic after one member of the ‘Ask Reddit’ community asked them about the subtle red flags that say, "This person won't be a good hire." They gave examples and shared stories, which might come in handy when it’s time for you to look for a job, so you might want to scroll down to find their answers on the list below and read them carefully.
#21

"One of my weaknesses is I work too hard,"
Edit: Thank you all for the comments. I think this question is stupid and needs to be rephrased. When I get asked this question, I like to answer it by talking about self-improvement.
Here's mine: if I come up on a problem, my first instict is to dive right in and start figuring stuff out. Sometimes, this causes me to miss something, e.g., there is already a document that exists to solve the exact problem, and if I would have taken 5 minutes to stop, think, and utilize resources, I wouldn't be going in circles.
Edit: Thank you all for the comments. I think this question is stupid and needs to be rephrased. When I get asked this question, I like to answer it by talking about self-improvement.
Here's mine: if I come up on a problem, my first instict is to dive right in and start figuring stuff out. Sometimes, this causes me to miss something, e.g., there is already a document that exists to solve the exact problem, and if I would have taken 5 minutes to stop, think, and utilize resources, I wouldn't be going in circles.
12points
#22

I can teach anything but giving a damn. If your interview doesnt show you give a damn, it was a waste. Ask questions people, like you are sincerely trying to determine what the role is and entails.
11points
#23

I'm a mechanical engineer and I have to interview candidates from time to time.
In general i give them a really simple technical question that I would expect a highschooler to solve. It's literally going to be things like, "calculated the force on this object."
The more you deviate away from, "force equals mass times acceleration," the more i know you are going to be a bad hire.
Not only does it show a fundamental misunderstanding of the material at hand. It also shows me that when you don't know the answer, you're prone to taking up meeting time endlessly pointing out true but impossible to solve problems. .
In general i give them a really simple technical question that I would expect a highschooler to solve. It's literally going to be things like, "calculated the force on this object."
The more you deviate away from, "force equals mass times acceleration," the more i know you are going to be a bad hire.
Not only does it show a fundamental misunderstanding of the material at hand. It also shows me that when you don't know the answer, you're prone to taking up meeting time endlessly pointing out true but impossible to solve problems. .
11points
#24

I used to host Zoom interviews for a bit. The amount of people who would be 10+ minutes late astounded me. It was an immediate no hire for me. If you can’t ~open your laptop and click on a link~ on time, I don’t trust you to show up to shifts on time. Bonus points for being late + obviously laying in bed. .
11points
#25

Many of you dont know what subtle is. A person being openly racist or late for the interview isn't subtle. .
11points
#26

I work in politics and hire a lot of entry level positions. With some firms, the only qualification is a pulse.
In the screening call (pre interview) I ask them about an issue that they care about. This is to first w**d out anyone that doesn't have a clue what is going on and also to w**d out someone on the other side of the aisle (it very much is a partisan position).
One person last year slipped up and somehow passed the screening call. In our office, there were cardboard cutouts of 3 prominent political figures (2 presidents and a VP, all household names at this point). He got to the office, saw the cardboard cutouts, and asked who they were.
In the screening call (pre interview) I ask them about an issue that they care about. This is to first w**d out anyone that doesn't have a clue what is going on and also to w**d out someone on the other side of the aisle (it very much is a partisan position).
One person last year slipped up and somehow passed the screening call. In our office, there were cardboard cutouts of 3 prominent political figures (2 presidents and a VP, all household names at this point). He got to the office, saw the cardboard cutouts, and asked who they were.
10points
#27

If they’re 23 and don’t have 15+ years of experience in their field.
10points
#28

Most of these answers aren't "subtle" at all. An example of a subtle red flag in an interview is someone who can ONLY provide examples of how they helped the group achieve goals. If you give them lots of opportunity to talk about how they overcame challenges, dealt with unexpected results, had to adjust timelines, etc. and they can only give examples of how "WE" solved the problem, I've found that to be a red flag.
You may initially think "this person seems to be a real team player and collaborates on everything", but my anecdotal experience with this type of employee is that they, more often than not, tend to be freeloaders who skate by by just being in close proximity to the action, but not doing much themselves. As soon as you give them direct responsibility for an initiative, they don't know what to do or they try to p**n it off on those around them under the guise of 'being collaborative'.
So my advice during an interview, make sure you explain exactly how *you specifically* took action to solve the issue. I don't care about the end state of your project; I care about the logic, drive, and responsibility you demonstrated in getting there.
You may initially think "this person seems to be a real team player and collaborates on everything", but my anecdotal experience with this type of employee is that they, more often than not, tend to be freeloaders who skate by by just being in close proximity to the action, but not doing much themselves. As soon as you give them direct responsibility for an initiative, they don't know what to do or they try to p**n it off on those around them under the guise of 'being collaborative'.
So my advice during an interview, make sure you explain exactly how *you specifically* took action to solve the issue. I don't care about the end state of your project; I care about the logic, drive, and responsibility you demonstrated in getting there.
10points
#29

I had a perfectly nice woman come in for an interview. Lied about her education. I knew because the diploma mill she listed quite famously doesn't exist anymore, but she said she was a current student set to graduate in 2 years.
Honestly, if she hadn't lied, we would have hired her. But once I pointed that out in the post-game meeting, everyone lost any enthusiasm they had.
Honestly, if she hadn't lied, we would have hired her. But once I pointed that out in the post-game meeting, everyone lost any enthusiasm they had.
10points
#30

I was hiring someone with web development skills. Asked a candidate to tell me about a time they encountered a critical error and how they fixed it. Their response, "Well I was on our website and noticed some information was out of date, a critical error, so I told the web development team we needed to update that critical error.".
9points
#31

Due to the nature of roles I interview for, I often get people with PhDs and they split into two categories: 'I've done my homework and I'm ready to answer any question' (good) and 'I am better than this job and you will give it to me, but I'll join the charade' bad, like... really f*****g bad.
Also: Top tip - if you apply for an information specialist role, don't fudge your own information. We will do due diligence and we will understand whether you are trying to big yourself up, regardless of your background/nationality.
Also: Top tip - if you apply for an information specialist role, don't fudge your own information. We will do due diligence and we will understand whether you are trying to big yourself up, regardless of your background/nationality.
9points
#32
I've done a few interviews, and while not exactly subtle, you'll get passed over if you don't have an answer for a standard interview question. My workplace like many large firms interviews with preprepared questions and a scoring template in an effort to remove bias. If you don't have an answer, you get the minimum score for that section which will often put you behind anyone that didn't bomb the interview.
Folks, always have an example of how you've dealt with workplace conflict, an problem you've found and solved, and a project or task you saw through to completion with how you overcame some challenges. That's some basic stuff right there.
Also, we have a standard question about the importance of DEI at the start of the interview, and everyone that said "I don't see color" through the panel right off. I understand that it can be said in good faith, but its often a cover phrase for folks that don't really believe in the importance of diversity in the workplace by dismissing the benefits.
Folks, always have an example of how you've dealt with workplace conflict, an problem you've found and solved, and a project or task you saw through to completion with how you overcame some challenges. That's some basic stuff right there.
Also, we have a standard question about the importance of DEI at the start of the interview, and everyone that said "I don't see color" through the panel right off. I understand that it can be said in good faith, but its often a cover phrase for folks that don't really believe in the importance of diversity in the workplace by dismissing the benefits.
Report
8points
#33
In IT, not asking any questions. An interview should go both ways. You should ask me about my company and team. Not only does it show interest but it gives you information to make a decision.
Report
7points
#34
I once interviewed a woman that was chewing gum the entire time! I don’t remember any of her answers because all I could think was, “I can’t believe she’s chewing gum while talking. “
Had another lady interviewing for a personal assistant to company owner who said that we could not run a back ground check on her.
Neither were hired!
Had another lady interviewing for a personal assistant to company owner who said that we could not run a back ground check on her.
Neither were hired!
Report
7points
#35
The same ones you look for when making friends. At the end of the day this person will spend a 3rd of their day or more at the job.
That being said,
Super negative
They never do anything wrong or can't think of something they can improve
Trash talking their former employer
Talking more than listening (cutting you off)
Etc.
That being said,
Super negative
They never do anything wrong or can't think of something they can improve
Trash talking their former employer
Talking more than listening (cutting you off)
Etc.
Report
7points
#36
I have a few.
- If they misspell my very common name in the cover letter.
- If they don't follow the clear rules on how to apply for the job. I had someone send their resume through an email change form ~~for~~ for existing customers. IT said they hadn't realized that was even possible. The kicker was the first line of their letter is 'they keep close attention to detail.'
- Any mention of 'they don't want me to waste their time.'.
- If they misspell my very common name in the cover letter.
- If they don't follow the clear rules on how to apply for the job. I had someone send their resume through an email change form ~~for~~ for existing customers. IT said they hadn't realized that was even possible. The kicker was the first line of their letter is 'they keep close attention to detail.'
- Any mention of 'they don't want me to waste their time.'.
Report
7points
#37
I’m not anyone who makes hiring decision but I’m often invited to interviews to give feedback on candidates.
Something that almost always kills the offer letter is negativity. We just had a fantastic candidate but she found a way to complain about everything. The state she was from (too boring), the state we are in that she just moved to (too cold), past jobs (too mundane, bad leadership, etc), even some of her family members received jabs (currently living with sister who is too messy). She said everything with a smile on her face and was generally pleasant, but we couldn’t get past the fact that she had something negative to say about EVERYTHING. Doesn’t really scream team player/good fit.
Something that almost always kills the offer letter is negativity. We just had a fantastic candidate but she found a way to complain about everything. The state she was from (too boring), the state we are in that she just moved to (too cold), past jobs (too mundane, bad leadership, etc), even some of her family members received jabs (currently living with sister who is too messy). She said everything with a smile on her face and was generally pleasant, but we couldn’t get past the fact that she had something negative to say about EVERYTHING. Doesn’t really scream team player/good fit.
Report
7points
#38

Had two interviews for a software dev position this year that stood out.
First one, the guy was well into the interview and going through the coding portion when the door opened behind him. A woman stepped in and asked something about reports and to wrap up what he was doing. When she left he turned back to the screen and said he was sorry but he had to go and ended the call.
Second was a guy who was doing alright but halfway through the interview he just stopped responding to us (call wasn't frozen, he just stopped talking/responding). Then the call just ended and we never heard anything from him again, even after reaching out to see if he had connection issues and wanted to reschedule.
First one, the guy was well into the interview and going through the coding portion when the door opened behind him. A woman stepped in and asked something about reports and to wrap up what he was doing. When she left he turned back to the screen and said he was sorry but he had to go and ended the call.
Second was a guy who was doing alright but halfway through the interview he just stopped responding to us (call wasn't frozen, he just stopped talking/responding). Then the call just ended and we never heard anything from him again, even after reaching out to see if he had connection issues and wanted to reschedule.
6points
#39

Trash talk all their previous jobs & managers.
6points
#40
Arrogance, being unprepared for even minor questions, not knowing what job role they applied to, not being a good fit in general for the team (i.e. they like to work individually in a role that requires a lot of team work, etc.).
Report
6points

