Making the first move can feel terrifying. People love to say the worst that can happen is getting a simple “no,” so you might as well shoot your shot. But as it turns out, “no” isn’t always the harshest response on the menu.
One Redditor asked men to share the most brutal things women have said to them, and some of these rejections make a polite decline sound downright sweet. We’ve rounded up their wince-worthy stories below—brace yourself.
#21

I asked my crush to go to the prom with me. Her response was "I would rather sit home alone than go to the prom with YOU!" And so began a lifetime of self esteem issues.
ejt159:
I asked my crush to prom too, she said “uuuuuuh no? Go ask (my cousin).” I didn’t even know how to respond so I just walked away
ejt159:
I asked my crush to prom too, she said “uuuuuuh no? Go ask (my cousin).” I didn’t even know how to respond so I just walked away
Report
8points
#22

Not me but I saw it happen in middle school.
Girl has crush on boy.
On April 1, boy asks girl out. Girl can’t believe it. Boy says, “April Fools!” and dips.
Girl proceeds to have a very bad mental health week.
Not3Beaversinacoat:
Happened to me to, though not on April Fools. Of course, by 8th grade I was already so mentally messed up I assumed it was some sort of trick because who'd like me.
Girl has crush on boy.
On April 1, boy asks girl out. Girl can’t believe it. Boy says, “April Fools!” and dips.
Girl proceeds to have a very bad mental health week.
Not3Beaversinacoat:
Happened to me to, though not on April Fools. Of course, by 8th grade I was already so mentally messed up I assumed it was some sort of trick because who'd like me.
Report
8points
#23

I'm a girl. For context, I had feelings for my male bestfriend for years. So I finally confessed. He rejected me, basically saying that he couldnt imagine being in a relationship with me, and then he said that we should be friends with benefits. He also specified that if we would become FWB, it absolutely had to be a secret and that I shouldn't tell anybody.
18 years old virgin me was heartbroken by that, but also was stupid enough to accept being FWB. Not my finest moment lol.
BullHonkery:
I had one of those. "OK, we can go out, but you can't tell anybody."
In retrospect she was trying to be nice and do the right thing, but man was that awkward when I figured it out a couple months later after she told me she was going to prom with another guy.
18 years old virgin me was heartbroken by that, but also was stupid enough to accept being FWB. Not my finest moment lol.
BullHonkery:
I had one of those. "OK, we can go out, but you can't tell anybody."
In retrospect she was trying to be nice and do the right thing, but man was that awkward when I figured it out a couple months later after she told me she was going to prom with another guy.
Report
8points
#24

Nothing. Things have been frosty as home. I said to my wife: "I don't feel like you love me anymore, the way you behave it's like you don't even like me" she just starred and then turned and left the room. 2026 is not my year.
where_is__my_mind:
WAAAAIIITTT. I dated this guy for a year in college and I started going through a hard time and felt like he was just staying with me to be polite. I was crying one night about how I didn't think anyone actually cared about me and eventually said 'i feel like you don't even love me anymore' and he responded with 'actually, I dont' and that's how we broke up.
Im so sorry you are going through the same thing, with a married partner nonetheless.
where_is__my_mind:
WAAAAIIITTT. I dated this guy for a year in college and I started going through a hard time and felt like he was just staying with me to be polite. I was crying one night about how I didn't think anyone actually cared about me and eventually said 'i feel like you don't even love me anymore' and he responded with 'actually, I dont' and that's how we broke up.
Im so sorry you are going through the same thing, with a married partner nonetheless.
Report
8points
#25
In high school, I didn’t have a date for senior prom. A girl I knew said she knew a gal who really wanted to go (she was a Junior so had to be invited by a senior). When she was introduced to me, this girl said “Oh wait, that’s him? Nevermind, I don’t want to go THAT much.”.
Report
8points
#26
I was dating someone in college and I was head-over-heels for her. She was talented, quirky, beautiful. She drew comics for our college newspaper. I don't actually know how we ended up "officially" dating, I have a feeling we both got drunk one night and just agreed to it, but alas, we were dating for a while.
The thing is, she was just not...present. She never had time to hang out, she never wanted to talk, she never really seemed to show any real interest in me or the relationship (we once went 4 days without talking...I asked her if she thought that was normal, she bluntly said "yes")
Anyway. Being younger and dumber, I decided to try and double-down fixing it rather than seeing the forest through the trees, so to speak. So I finally got her to hang out with me, and we decided to go get lunch at some greek spot in Chicago. After a few pleasantries, I started to bring up all the things mentioned above, genuinely attempting to get an answer out of her for why it was like this: in my head, I had done something wrong, because why else would she have said yes to dating in the first place if she wasn't interested?
After a little bit of prodding, I just kind of laid it all out there and waited for her to speak her mind. She simply looked at me and said, "maybe you just like me more than I like you" so casually, as if she was telling a customer service worker what her usual order was. I was devastated, but ended up working up *some* modicum of self-worth and got up and left in the middle of the meal.
Well, obviously that didn't hurt, because I'm not still thinking about it 13 years later.
The thing is, she was just not...present. She never had time to hang out, she never wanted to talk, she never really seemed to show any real interest in me or the relationship (we once went 4 days without talking...I asked her if she thought that was normal, she bluntly said "yes")
Anyway. Being younger and dumber, I decided to try and double-down fixing it rather than seeing the forest through the trees, so to speak. So I finally got her to hang out with me, and we decided to go get lunch at some greek spot in Chicago. After a few pleasantries, I started to bring up all the things mentioned above, genuinely attempting to get an answer out of her for why it was like this: in my head, I had done something wrong, because why else would she have said yes to dating in the first place if she wasn't interested?
After a little bit of prodding, I just kind of laid it all out there and waited for her to speak her mind. She simply looked at me and said, "maybe you just like me more than I like you" so casually, as if she was telling a customer service worker what her usual order was. I was devastated, but ended up working up *some* modicum of self-worth and got up and left in the middle of the meal.
Well, obviously that didn't hurt, because I'm not still thinking about it 13 years later.
Report
8points
#27

She said yes……..then later went over to her ex boyfriend and said “take me back or I’ll actually go out with him. And who knows what would happen to me”.
That was very depressing to over hear.
Edit: and the girl before that told everyone I asked her out and made me a laughing stock for the rest of the day. And the next. So yeah in conclusion there is worst she can say than just no.
AdAppropriate2295:
Demon king origin story
That was very depressing to over hear.
Edit: and the girl before that told everyone I asked her out and made me a laughing stock for the rest of the day. And the next. So yeah in conclusion there is worst she can say than just no.
AdAppropriate2295:
Demon king origin story
Report
7points
#28
"its just not the same in person" after I spent $1500 and flew across the country in the middle of covid to see my long distance gf.
Report
7points
#29
Not exactly what's being asked but in the same ballpark.
In highschool I asked a friend of mine out by asking if she wanted to see a particular movie with me. She said yes, we agreed to see it after school in a few days... and when I came to school the next day she said she spoke to a few of our other friends and invited them to come too.
I didn't muster the confidence to explain that I intended it as a date until we were already walking to the cinema with half a dozen of our friends.
She said she didn't like me that way. The walk was awkward as hell but at least the movie was fun.
In highschool I asked a friend of mine out by asking if she wanted to see a particular movie with me. She said yes, we agreed to see it after school in a few days... and when I came to school the next day she said she spoke to a few of our other friends and invited them to come too.
I didn't muster the confidence to explain that I intended it as a date until we were already walking to the cinema with half a dozen of our friends.
She said she didn't like me that way. The walk was awkward as hell but at least the movie was fun.
Report
7points
#30
I was 14-15ish and setup a double movie date with two girls and my buddy. We plan it out and get the tickets online. Later on she lets us know that the other girl’s parents were not letting it happen and cancelled. Bummer but my buddy and I decided to go since we already bought the tickets. As we pull up to the front of the theater, sure enough, there they both are with two other guys. She noticed me and locked eyes. I just turned and left with my buddy. We ended up just walking to a nearby AppleBees, ate, and tipped the waiter the money we had for the date.
Not 100% sure but I think she married that dude she was with.
Not 100% sure but I think she married that dude she was with.
Report
7points
#31
Probably a good 30 years ago, I was out with two of my buddies and we meet up with a trio of girls. They immediately start talking to two of them, just kind of leaving me with this other girl, I go to chat with her and she just holds up a finger:
"No offense, but I'm tied of my girls running off with the 7 and the 8 and leaving me alone with the 4."
Ouch.
"No offense, but I'm tied of my girls running off with the 7 and the 8 and leaving me alone with the 4."
Ouch.
Report
7points
#32
New middle school for 8th grade and there’s this really cute Asian girl in class who’s name I’ll never forget. one of my “friends” asks me if I think she’s cute and I say ofcourse. About two minutes later he taps my shoulder and I see her reading a note I didnt write, she laughs, looks at me and gets uncomfortable then throws it on the ground…. At which point her friend kneels on her seat like a meerkat and interrupts class to say “FOR THE LAST TIME SHES NOT INTERESTED, you’re fat”
Bruuuuutal 😂 took me about two years (and puberty) to lose the weight and I thought about it every time I was on the treadmill.
Bruuuuutal 😂 took me about two years (and puberty) to lose the weight and I thought about it every time I was on the treadmill.
Report
7points
#33

Nearly 19 years ago and I remember it clearly. After nine months together, we were on a bit of a break. I thought things were starting to pick up again, we go to lunch, I drop her at her house and then she hits me with “I didn’t miss you as much as I thought I would” and ended it.
That was a fun thing to hear and then have to go back to work.
vercertorix:
I went out with someone a few times, and then after a weekend when we didn’t go out, she basically told me she had a great time doing her favorite hobby and hanging out with her brother and sister, and that it made her realize she enjoyed herself more doing all that than spending time with me. At the time, felt pretty unfair that I was supposed to be able to compete with her favorite thing and a couple of her favorite people that early into it, but long after that rejection, I realize it’s valid. Sometimes people will grow closer, but she gave me an honest shot and decided she wasn’t that interested. Just a surprise because it seemed to be going well.
I’ve kind of come to the conclusion that any reason to break up with someone is probably valid or at least there’s no point trying to convince them otherwise. The rejection still sucks, but if they’re not that invested in the relationship, it’s not likely to last, you’d just be putting the ending off if you managed to be persuasive enough to get them to stay. Easier opinion to hold now that I’m married and out of the dating game. If my wife decides she wants a divorce, which I wouldn’t see coming right now, I’d probably think differently for a while.
That was a fun thing to hear and then have to go back to work.
vercertorix:
I went out with someone a few times, and then after a weekend when we didn’t go out, she basically told me she had a great time doing her favorite hobby and hanging out with her brother and sister, and that it made her realize she enjoyed herself more doing all that than spending time with me. At the time, felt pretty unfair that I was supposed to be able to compete with her favorite thing and a couple of her favorite people that early into it, but long after that rejection, I realize it’s valid. Sometimes people will grow closer, but she gave me an honest shot and decided she wasn’t that interested. Just a surprise because it seemed to be going well.
I’ve kind of come to the conclusion that any reason to break up with someone is probably valid or at least there’s no point trying to convince them otherwise. The rejection still sucks, but if they’re not that invested in the relationship, it’s not likely to last, you’d just be putting the ending off if you managed to be persuasive enough to get them to stay. Easier opinion to hold now that I’m married and out of the dating game. If my wife decides she wants a divorce, which I wouldn’t see coming right now, I’d probably think differently for a while.
Report
6points
#34
In high school track, a girl cornered me on the bus, and tried to make me go through every girl between 10th and 12th grade of who I "liked." I told her I didn't want to date anyone at our school really. She wouldn't take no for an answer. One sophomore on our team I told her didn't annoy me, mostly because she didn't talk much. When she did it was sarcastic one liners usually. This girl immediately went up to that sophomore and told her I was into her. I was about 50 feet away, but it was loud enough for me to hear what happened. The quiet sophomore practically screamed, “Oh my god gross! No!” in front of everyone. Yeah that's one that sticks with you.
Report
6points
#35
She said “I’ve already found my prince, I don’t need to kiss any more frogs!”.
Report
6points
#36
Lesbian here. She led me on for a year (kissed me when we first met then proceeded to text and call me everyday like we were in a relationship), then why I finally asked ‘what are we?’ she acted like I was insane and said we were just friends. Insisted she acts that way with all her friends. I’m still recovering a year later.
Report
6points
#37
Not a guy but a girl. When I was 15 I was a cadet. I had a crush on this guy and valentines day that year happened to fall on a parade night. So I got him a card and a chocolate bar. He blankly started at me, took the card, walked into the next room with the other officer cadets and belly laughed loud and hard for a good 5 minutes....he kept the chocolate bar too.
I was a very shy person when I was a teenager and didn't have the best home life so that really messed with my self esteem. Fortunately I've fixed the damage and I don't have a problem with getting a date. But if I ever have the misfortune of bumping into that guy in adulthood, I would probably call him out for that one. Not because it would change anything or matter, but because I want to understand why it was so funny.
I was a very shy person when I was a teenager and didn't have the best home life so that really messed with my self esteem. Fortunately I've fixed the damage and I don't have a problem with getting a date. But if I ever have the misfortune of bumping into that guy in adulthood, I would probably call him out for that one. Not because it would change anything or matter, but because I want to understand why it was so funny.
Report
6points
#38
Female here - First crush at 11 the day after telling me he liked me “I said I liked you but I love Maria” broke my heart! still to this day trying to figure out who this Maria girl is 😂.
Report
6points
#39
Laughed nervously ; then turned to anger ; then to disgust and said "why would you ever think that a subhuman like you could get any girl, let alone me, it's good enough we let you be the funny guy here".
Oh, and she screamed it so everyone around could hear about it and texted everyone we knew to make sure the ones who were not there could get "on the fun" with her.
Oh, and she screamed it so everyone around could hear about it and texted everyone we knew to make sure the ones who were not there could get "on the fun" with her.
Report
6points
#40
Forgot exactly what she said because it was so long ago but she roasted tf out of me and told me how I offended her by even asking her out.
Report
6points

