There is a thin line between practical frugality and being a cheapskate. But because everyone has a different definition for these two concepts, the distinction will depend on who you ask.
That’s why it’s no surprise that a Reddit thread from a year ago discussing these differences received a flood of responses. A user simply asked, “When does ‘frugal’ become ‘cheap’?”
Some commenters narrowed it down using the fundamental idea of needs versus wants. Others based their responses on how such behaviors affect other people.
#21

Frugal is cutting the ends off your onions to plant and grow more onions. Cheap is grabbing a bunch of straws/condiments from a restaurant to use at home. One helps the world, the other mooches from it.
Report
11points
#22

I knew a guy in the '80s that made his kids have water on their cereal. That's cheap. He would also turn off the pilot light on his water heater...
Report
11points
#23

Cheap: buying the cheapest shoes. Frugal: buying more expensive shoes that'll last. Neither: buying all sorts of shoes to match different outfits.
Cheap: saving expired food. Frugal: planning meals so your food doesn't expire in the first place. Neither: doordash.
Cheap: taking cold showers. Frugal: taking a regular shower- there are other ways to save without being cheap. Neither: long, hot showers.
Cheap: not dating or having hobbies. Frugal: knowing what's worth your time and money to make your life feel fulfilled. Neither: spending on things that you don't even like, wasting time, or just never doing anything.
I don't think cheap and frugal are even close, actually. Frugal is just being thoughtful with your time and money if you ask me.
Cheap: saving expired food. Frugal: planning meals so your food doesn't expire in the first place. Neither: doordash.
Cheap: taking cold showers. Frugal: taking a regular shower- there are other ways to save without being cheap. Neither: long, hot showers.
Cheap: not dating or having hobbies. Frugal: knowing what's worth your time and money to make your life feel fulfilled. Neither: spending on things that you don't even like, wasting time, or just never doing anything.
I don't think cheap and frugal are even close, actually. Frugal is just being thoughtful with your time and money if you ask me.
Report
11points
#24

Frugal is when it is an inconvenience to you. Cheap is an inconvenience to others.
Report
10points
#25

When it impacts comfort.
I buy store brand things, but I'm a snob on somethings like ketchup.
I buy Costco toilet paper, but if its thin 2 ply, I'm going to splurge.
1200 thread count sheets. You spend 1/3 of your life there, spend the money.
I buy store brand things, but I'm a snob on somethings like ketchup.
I buy Costco toilet paper, but if its thin 2 ply, I'm going to splurge.
1200 thread count sheets. You spend 1/3 of your life there, spend the money.
Report
10points
#26

Frugal is making the best of what you have. Cheap is refusing to make the best of what you have when there is an option to scrimp harder.
Report
8points
#27

Frugal is shorting yourself, to save for later.
Cheap is shorting others, to benefit yourself.
For example, frugal is bringing a brown bag lunch to work every day, for months... to save up for something you need/want.
Cheap is offering to take someone out on a date; you order the most expensive $50 steak for yourself, but tell them you will only pay for them to have the cheapest item a $10 salad. Then you refuse to tip the waiter because tipping is optional.
Frugal is a hardship you put on YOURSELF. Cheap is one you put on OTHERS, when you could put it on yourelf.
Cheap is shorting others, to benefit yourself.
For example, frugal is bringing a brown bag lunch to work every day, for months... to save up for something you need/want.
Cheap is offering to take someone out on a date; you order the most expensive $50 steak for yourself, but tell them you will only pay for them to have the cheapest item a $10 salad. Then you refuse to tip the waiter because tipping is optional.
Frugal is a hardship you put on YOURSELF. Cheap is one you put on OTHERS, when you could put it on yourelf.
Report
8points
#28

Frugal becomes cheap as soon as your choices start to affect others.
EX: Your friend has a birthday and is having dinner at a restaurant to celebrate. Because you are frugal, you set yourself a spending limit; you buy an entrée but no drink, and get them a card and a small gift.
EX #2: Your friend has a birthday and is having dinner at a restaurant to celebrate. Because you are cheap, you go in wanting to spend as little as possible; you buy an appetizer while complaining about how expensive everything is. Perhaps you give a gift or you don't.
EX: Your friend has a birthday and is having dinner at a restaurant to celebrate. Because you are frugal, you set yourself a spending limit; you buy an entrée but no drink, and get them a card and a small gift.
EX #2: Your friend has a birthday and is having dinner at a restaurant to celebrate. Because you are cheap, you go in wanting to spend as little as possible; you buy an appetizer while complaining about how expensive everything is. Perhaps you give a gift or you don't.
Report
7points
#29

When it costs 1/2 as much but doesn't even last 1/2 as long.
Report
7points
#30

I think frugal is a more philosophical meaning of "not wasting resources" meanwhile cheap is just "I don't want to waste money. Period"
Report
7points
When we think about different perspectives, we might come across intriguing debates and cultural misunderstandings. For example, the controversy surrounding MSG often mentioned in culinary discussions is a great example of how varied opinions and viewpoints can be.
Delving into thematic debates can also be seen in diverse dietary preferences and how they play out in workplace dynamics.

