Food is pretty subjective, we all have our preferences, our comfort dishes, smells and textures we can’t stand. But some people take this concept to such an extreme, that their preferences start to border on downright wild.
We’ve gathered stories from servers (and others) sharing the most bizarre, unhinged and unusual things people have ordered like it was a standard menu item. So get comfortable as you scroll through, maybe write down the ones that seem intriguing and be sure to share your own thoughts in the comments down below.
#1

Walked in 5 minutes before close, ordered the Beef Wellington. The server explained that it takes 30 minutes to cook. They said that's fine.
Point of advice: If you walk into an empty restaurant at the end of the night, and the server mentions a long wait for food, maybe reconsider your order. Everyone wanted to go home except that guy.
jim_br:
I had a manager (banking) that was an absolute PITA to work with. On one business trip, we landed 3 hours late and every restaurant in town is closed/closing. He convinced a Pizza Hut 15 minutes before closing, to let us dine in — four people. They reluctantly agreed.
After being seated, he asked how many people are on duty, the waitress replied three. He opened his wallet and counted out $300 and asked her to distribute it as a thank you.
After dinner, the bill came and it’s about $50-60. He dropped another $100 and thanked the waitress. My coworker looked at him and quite seriously said, “I had no idea you could be kind!” He laughed and acknowledged he worked in restaurants while in college and that’s where he reserves his kindness.
Point of advice: If you walk into an empty restaurant at the end of the night, and the server mentions a long wait for food, maybe reconsider your order. Everyone wanted to go home except that guy.
jim_br:
I had a manager (banking) that was an absolute PITA to work with. On one business trip, we landed 3 hours late and every restaurant in town is closed/closing. He convinced a Pizza Hut 15 minutes before closing, to let us dine in — four people. They reluctantly agreed.
After being seated, he asked how many people are on duty, the waitress replied three. He opened his wallet and counted out $300 and asked her to distribute it as a thank you.
After dinner, the bill came and it’s about $50-60. He dropped another $100 and thanked the waitress. My coworker looked at him and quite seriously said, “I had no idea you could be kind!” He laughed and acknowledged he worked in restaurants while in college and that’s where he reserves his kindness.
51points
#2

I once had a guy ask if we could “sear the steak rare but without any pink.” He wanted “cooked blood.” I still have nightmares.
moosebeast:
I saw a guy in a restaurant order a steak rare, then when it arrived he complained that it was pink in the middle.
I honestly think some guys don't know what rare means but have heard that it's how you're supposed to ask for your steak.
moosebeast:
I saw a guy in a restaurant order a steak rare, then when it arrived he complained that it was pink in the middle.
I honestly think some guys don't know what rare means but have heard that it's how you're supposed to ask for your steak.
Report
33points
#3

At a Tex-Mex restaurant - Cheese nachos without the chips.
Yes they did receive a plate of shredded cheese microwaved onto a plate.
Yes they used the free appetizer chips to eat that cheese.
unclemikey0:
I worked at a Mexican restaurant for a few years in college, and had a customer just trying to invent his own dish. Like not even "can I have that burrito, but with chicken instead" or "throw some jalapenos on it". But more like, just skipping around the menu and picking different ingredients from all over the places to create his own dish that we don't have. I had to tell him there was no way I was going to be able to communicate to the kitchen what he wants, or figure out how to charge him. Unless he wants me to order eleven different sides of things and he can't put it together himself, so he should just order something from the menu please.
Almost worse, and I bet everyone that's worked a restaurant can relate to this, was when former employees would come in and try to order their old favorite thing that they had created back in the day because as a waiter they knew all the modifiers on the computer. Bro, I get it, and I do that now too, but we're really busy, please just order something from the menu. I ain't in the mood right now to order Beef and Bean burrito (sub steak) (sub queso (inside)) (no tomato) (no lettuce) (sub pico) (green Chile (half)) (sour cream sauce (half)) (no onion sub fajita veg) + ((no rice and beans) sub kids nachos(no cheese sub guac)). You could get away with this when it was your employee meal at the end of your shift, and I bet the cooks hated you for it back then too.
Yes they did receive a plate of shredded cheese microwaved onto a plate.
Yes they used the free appetizer chips to eat that cheese.
unclemikey0:
I worked at a Mexican restaurant for a few years in college, and had a customer just trying to invent his own dish. Like not even "can I have that burrito, but with chicken instead" or "throw some jalapenos on it". But more like, just skipping around the menu and picking different ingredients from all over the places to create his own dish that we don't have. I had to tell him there was no way I was going to be able to communicate to the kitchen what he wants, or figure out how to charge him. Unless he wants me to order eleven different sides of things and he can't put it together himself, so he should just order something from the menu please.
Almost worse, and I bet everyone that's worked a restaurant can relate to this, was when former employees would come in and try to order their old favorite thing that they had created back in the day because as a waiter they knew all the modifiers on the computer. Bro, I get it, and I do that now too, but we're really busy, please just order something from the menu. I ain't in the mood right now to order Beef and Bean burrito (sub steak) (sub queso (inside)) (no tomato) (no lettuce) (sub pico) (green Chile (half)) (sour cream sauce (half)) (no onion sub fajita veg) + ((no rice and beans) sub kids nachos(no cheese sub guac)). You could get away with this when it was your employee meal at the end of your shift, and I bet the cooks hated you for it back then too.
Report
31points
#4

As someone who worked in sushi restaurants for the better part of a decade, you will never believe the number of people who get mad when you serve them raw fish. At the sushi restaurant.
Report
31points
#6

A whole onion. Ate it like it was an apple.
28points
#7

Pepsi with a glass of water and extra sugar. Watched the guy pour like 5 sugar packets into his Pepsi and a bunch more into the water. Wtf. He worked at a gym. His teeth were completely rotten.
SunShineNomad:
Some d**g addicts really crave sugar. I've seen one pour sugar into Minute Maid orange juice which is already like 27g of sugar in a serving.
SunShineNomad:
Some d**g addicts really crave sugar. I've seen one pour sugar into Minute Maid orange juice which is already like 27g of sugar in a serving.
Report
26points
#8
Once I had a customer in the drive through order a dozen chocolate donuts.
Sounds pretty normal, except I worked at a burger king and we did not have chocolate donuts.
I asked him to repeat himself, and he confidently said again, "a dozen chocolate donuts"
I said "sir we don't have donuts here."
He said "...where am I?"
I said "this is burger king"
Then I heard his wife in the passenger seat start cracking up then he sheepishly said "I thought this was Tim Hortons" and he sped away 😂.
Sounds pretty normal, except I worked at a burger king and we did not have chocolate donuts.
I asked him to repeat himself, and he confidently said again, "a dozen chocolate donuts"
I said "sir we don't have donuts here."
He said "...where am I?"
I said "this is burger king"
Then I heard his wife in the passenger seat start cracking up then he sheepishly said "I thought this was Tim Hortons" and he sped away 😂.
Report
24points
#9

A lady walked up to the counter and asked for chicken tenders.
"Ma'am, this is an Edy's Ice Cream".
"Ma'am, this is an Edy's Ice Cream".
Report
24points
#10
I had a customer who aparently had a very restrictive health diet. I spent about 15 minutes telling her all the ingredients in everything. She kept getting upset that we didn't have USDA-certified organic produce (We weren't in the United states, so USDA...isn't a thing)
She finally settled on a vegan salad bowl, with numerous alterations. After reading out every ingredient, the kitchen made her food. She ate half of it, then brought it back and said "I forgot that I wasn't going to eat rice any more, can you remake it without rice"
I simply said "I'm sorry that you forgot that, but you were informed of all ingredients".
She finally settled on a vegan salad bowl, with numerous alterations. After reading out every ingredient, the kitchen made her food. She ate half of it, then brought it back and said "I forgot that I wasn't going to eat rice any more, can you remake it without rice"
I simply said "I'm sorry that you forgot that, but you were informed of all ingredients".
Report
24points
#11

Was in a vegetarian restaurant and overheard a patron ask if he could have his dish with a steak.
24points
#12

With a friend at Bob Evans in grad school before classes. As we were getting ready to leave a man came in, asked for 2 bowls of sausage gravy and a Country time Lemonade. Waitress asked how many biscuits he wanted. “None, just bring two bowls and a spoon.” We left before we could watch that horror occur.
Report
24points
#13

Working at a TCBY and this fancy older gentleman (he was Italian and had gold chains, a deep tan, open shirt, and a equally fancy lady with him) asks to buy the “painting” we had hanging on the wall. This wasn’t a special painting, it was probably what they send to all TCBY stores when they open. I got my manager, she haggled a bit and in the end he got it. They get their FroYo, pull the painting off the wall, and in the most outrageous Italian accent says as he’s walking out the door, “When I see something I like, I BUY IT!” 🤣 I still quote that guy all the time.
Report
23points
#14

Worked at a fairly upscale restaurant in rural area. Customers always tried to sound fancy or better educated. One wanted her food with a side of Béarnaise sauce. I'll never forget the sous chef b******g about "people who learned to be classy from a f*****g Bugs Bunny cartoon".
Report
23points
#15

Once worked at a stand that sold burgers and hot dogs. This one guy wanted peanut butter and jelly on his dog in addition to the slaw, chili, onions, mustard, and ketchup. We happened to have some there so I got it for him. He said it was the best thing ever.
23points
#16
Not a restaurant, but my wife and I owned and ran a B&B for about 10 years.
We served a 3-course breakfast on the weekends, and I cooked.
One weekend morning, I was doing custom omelettes to order.
One guest asked for her omelette to be cooked using no fat of any kind - no oil, no butter, etc., apparently for health reasons.
Now, that's pretty difficult to pull off, even with a non-stick pan.
At least for me - I don't have any actual food service training.
So, I wound up putting a little bit of water in the pan, and it turned out ok.
She loved it, and the couple became repeat customers.
So, whenever they booked, we did omelettes:-).
We served a 3-course breakfast on the weekends, and I cooked.
One weekend morning, I was doing custom omelettes to order.
One guest asked for her omelette to be cooked using no fat of any kind - no oil, no butter, etc., apparently for health reasons.
Now, that's pretty difficult to pull off, even with a non-stick pan.
At least for me - I don't have any actual food service training.
So, I wound up putting a little bit of water in the pan, and it turned out ok.
She loved it, and the couple became repeat customers.
So, whenever they booked, we did omelettes:-).
Report
21points
#17

I was expo'ing at the time. Woman sent her burger back 5 times because it was too rare. She was only satisfied when the patty actually caught on fire on the grill and was broken down into it's chemical components. The whole restaurant smelled like a fire but she was happy as a clam eating it.
Judge_Bredd3:
My dad is weird about food borne illnesses. As a result, when I go over and grill burgers, I'm putting his on 10 minutes before the rest. It's like a hockey puck but it's the only way he'll eat it.
ThelatestRedditAct:
I am this weirdo. Not with burgers but with chicken and bacon. I think it’s a texture thing but I love dry chicken. I wouldn’t send back juicy, moist chicken, but I like mine dry. Bacon I like it practically burnt, if it will simply crumble when touched it’s good.
Judge_Bredd3:
My dad is weird about food borne illnesses. As a result, when I go over and grill burgers, I'm putting his on 10 minutes before the rest. It's like a hockey puck but it's the only way he'll eat it.
ThelatestRedditAct:
I am this weirdo. Not with burgers but with chicken and bacon. I think it’s a texture thing but I love dry chicken. I wouldn’t send back juicy, moist chicken, but I like mine dry. Bacon I like it practically burnt, if it will simply crumble when touched it’s good.
21points
#18
I was the customer. I had just moved from Boston to Ohio and asked our waitress for a "fork". The waitress thought I was asking for something entirely different. After asking me to repeat my request, it became clear that she was really upset. I couldn't understand why she was so upset until the other members of our party jumped in and let her know that my accent caused certain words to sound differently than what I intended. From then on I always requested a "four-pronged eating utensil" instead of a fork.
Report
21points
#19

Reading glasses, they were mad we didn’t have a pair for them at our small restaurant that’s open 4 months out of the year.
Report
21points
#20

She only ate food that was white.
Different_Beyond9872:
Had this once as well. Would only eat anything "with no color". Exasperated, I tried to clarify and the husband explained their spouse had just had their terth cleaned.
But there was no way I was going back to the kitchen with that request.
Different_Beyond9872:
Had this once as well. Would only eat anything "with no color". Exasperated, I tried to clarify and the husband explained their spouse had just had their terth cleaned.
But there was no way I was going back to the kitchen with that request.
20points



