Such a seemingly harmless formality as “speak now or forever hold your peace” can go either way. Sometimes all it is is a silent pause when everyone holds their breath, while other times it stirs up so much drama that it’s impossible to continue the ceremony.
Wedding officiants are the ones who witness the aftermath of this question more than anyone else. So when netizens on Reddit asked them to share what happened after the pitiful phrase had been spoken, they didn’t hold back. Scroll down to find the most popular and juicy ones that will probably make you feel like you’re in a rom-com movie.
#21

Well...if "speaking now" the day before counts and for your own wedding, then yes, I did.
Ultimately neither of us were ready for marriage as we were pretty immature in a few key areas of our lives. In the weeks leading up to our wedding I kept on feeling more and more uneasy. I told my parents and they wanted to make sure it wasn't just nerves. I assured them it wasn't. This was a feeling of pure dread. Fear and hesitation are a good bit different than anxiousness and excitement. I flew in a week early, she lived in a different state. All the while I had The feeling of "you gotta het outta here!" It was difficult because I hate disappointing people. But I had to follow my gut. I told her the night before and left.
I've had nothing but words of love and support from friends and family. Some people were upset at my choice and execution but when they heard it from my angle, it was easier for them to understand. My ex and I still talk every now and then. Its been good for both of us!!
Report
34points
#22

Only thing close, although I wasn’t the officiant, was the grooms mother coughed when this was asked, as she didn’t like the bride.
Report
33points
#23

I got really drunk at my mother's wedding to a guy she'd known for nine months who was really a jerk. There was no 'speak now' moment but during the pre-ceremony mingling I was loudly expressing how much of a jerk I thought her fiance was and she overheard me. The conversation went something like: 'I had no idea you felt that way.' 'I think we all do, he honestly is a real jerk of a man.' I kept overusing the word 'jerk' while others around the place better articulated my sentiment and the general opinion was that yes, he was an utter jerk. The wedding was called off, he left, mother got extremely drunk and we all showed up to the wake/reception anyway for a night of dancing while the staff stood around awkwardly. We look back on it as one of the best things that has ever happened and she's with a really nice guy now. Her ex collapsed one day and it turns out he has a hole in his heart and he refuses to stop being obese so he'll be dead or in and out of hospital soon anyway. Dodged a bullet there.
Report
27points
#24

We are at a beautiful outdoor wedding with a lot of guests. The preacher gets to the part where he asks for anyone to speak or forever hold their peace and my wife's step-mom raises her hand. All of the focus goes to her, everyone is staring at her, the bride looked straight pissed. When the preacher asked her what she had to say, she yelled ''I'm kidding!" It [damaged] the entire vibe.
Report
20points
#25

I did. My friend for 6 years was going to get married to this girl I was dealing [drugs] to, he had no idea I knew her and suddenly half a year later they were getting married. I decided to "speak now". I just didn't wanna forever hold my peace I guess.
Report
18points
#26

I was the best man at my step brother's wedding. While in the back of the church, I let him know that I parked the car directly outside the door where we were. I explained that I didn't think this was a good idea and he barely knew her. I said something like she is probably a complete psycho the way she smiles like that all the time. He agreed and we opened the door just as her car pulled into the parking lot. He got all nervous and ducked back inside. Years later she is in a mental institution and stuck with 3 kids, two that he's pretty sure are his and 1 that is slightly darker skin toned...
17points

