There’s just something about a good mystery that pulls us in — stories about people going missing, strange paranormal encounters, unidentified bodies turning up out of nowhere, or events that just don’t add up.
You read one detail, then another, and suddenly you’re deep in it, asking a million questions and trying to make sense of something that might never be solved.
People online have been sharing these kinds of slightly creepy, totally bizarre mysteries, and we’ve rounded up some of the wildest ones for you here. The kind that’ll leave even the biggest skeptics scratching their heads.
#61 Jennifer Harris Was 28 When She Disappeared On May 12, 2002. Her Jeep Was Found Abandoned On The Side Of The Road. Six Days Later, A Fisherman Discovered Her Nude Body Floating In The Red River. Despite Years Of Investigation, Her Killer Remains Unknown

Report
13points
#62 Found In An Abandoned Backpack Along A Hiking Trail In California, Along With An Assortment Of Old World Maps From The Early 1900's

Report
12points
#63 In 2011, Mathias Schepp Kidnapped His Six-Year-Old Twin Daughters Alessia And Livia Schepp In Switzerland To Exact Revenge On His Ex-Wife. He Committed Suicide In Italy, But The Girls Were Never Found

To reconstruct the entire story, we must go back to 2003: Matthias and Irina worked for the multinational tobacco company Philip Morris. He worked in Bologna, she in Lausanne (Switzerland). They met at a mountain gathering organized by the company and, after a brief relationship, fell in love. A year later, Irina became pregnant, and the couple married near Lausanne. On October 7, 2004, twins Alessia and Livia were born. Over time, Irina began to notice strange, obsessive, and disturbing behavior in her husband. When Matthias began to display psychological violence toward Irina, she convinced him to seek couples therapy, which, however, proved unsuccessful. Livia filed for divorce, provoking resistance from some of the husband.
When Irina emailed Matthias in early January 2011, informing him that the divorce papers were ready, he plotted the most atrocious revenge. The girls were to spend the last weekend of the month with their father, who got into his Audi 6 and headed to France, where he turned off his cell phone. Realizing his strange behavior, Irina alerted the police, who rushed to Schepp's home, where they found an alarming note. Having withdrawn some money in Marseille, the man took a ferry with his daughters to Propriano (Corsica). Before boarding, he wrote a postcard to his wife (who would arrive on February 3rd) that read, "It's too late now." Shortly thereafter, he wrote another letter to his wife that read, "I will be the last to die, and I have already killed the girls; you will never see them again; they have not suffered and are now resting in a peaceful place." The most likely theory is that he threw the girls from the ferry into the sea. The little girls, however, were never found, and the possibility that she handed them over to someone has not been ruled out.
On February 3, 2011, Matthias Schepp committed suicide by throwing himself under a train in Cerignola Campagna. Irina Lucidi never gave up hope for the return of her twins, Alessia and Livia.
The last photo shows a reconstruction of the girls if they were 20 years old, in 2025.
Report
12points
#64 John And Michelle Klein, A California Couple On Vacation, Were Found Shot To Death While Hiking On Kuilau Trail Near The Town Of Kapaa In Hawaii – Case Still Unsolved

In March 1981, John L. Klein, a 28-year-old attorney from Encino, Los Angeles, California, and his 25-year-old wife Michelle, a publicist for Sunkist from Sherman Oaks, Los Angeles, traveled to Kaua'i, Hawaii, for a vacation.
The couple was scheduled to leave the island on March 21, but they never checked out of their hotel, and their rental car was not returned.
A search for the couple began, and their rental car was found parked at the base of Kuilau Trail, a popular hiking path on the east side of Kaua'i near the town of Kapaa.
The parking area is a small pull-off along Loop Road (sometimes called Keahua Forestry Road) is a narrow, rough dirt road which is the local access road to the trailhead.
On March 25, search-and-rescue teams with dogs discovered the Kleins’ bodies about 150 feet off the main trail in the forested area.
Both had been shot to death. John was found lying face up, wearing hiking boots and shorts but no shirt, with his wallet still in his shorts, while Michelle was found on top of him.
Michelle’s purse, with its contents intact, had been left in their rental car, suggesting that robbery was not a motive.
During the investigation, police received a phone call from a woman who hung up before providing any details. Later reports suggested the caller may have been from San Francisco, but no further information was obtained, and the lead did not result in any arrests.
Despite several theories about motive or who was responsible, no suspects were ever identified, and the case remains unsolved.
Report
12points
#65 In 2020, 16-Year-Old Owen Harding Vanished After Leaving His Saltdean Home Following An Argument Over Lockdown Restrictions. He Was Last Seen Walking Toward Telscombe Cliffs While On The Phone With His Girlfriend. Despite Extensive Searches And Cctv Sightings, No Trace Of Him Has Ever Been Found

Report
12points
#66 In 2008, 15-Year-Old Amy Fitzpatrick Disappeared In Spain After Babysitting At Her Friend Ashley Rose’s House On New Year’s Night. Around Midnight, She Phoned Her Mom To Wish Her A Happy New Year. That Brief Call Was Their Last Conversation Before Amy Vanished Without A Trace

Report
12points
#67 Found An Envelope From 1937 In An Attic In San Francisco Full Of Mystery Black Powder, What Is The Powder??

VivaNOLA:
So, according to the 1940 census this dude was an actor, writer, labor organizer, and socialist. At the time of this letter’s mailing he was the supervisor of a theater in San Francisco. He was a college grad, and was married to a singer named Wiltrud “Beb” Bratt. Beb was fired from her job years later for not renouncing socialism during the Red Scare. They had six kids, so I’d imagine plenty of living descendants. They all lived in that house that they rented for $20 a month. He died in San Mateo in 1984. There’s a picture of him in this article. Anyway, he was also a furniture and cabinet maker involved in theatrical sets, so the powder could be some kind of dye, varnish, paint mix, or even costume makeup. Could be anything, but given the time period and his background and professions, I’d put my money on a pigment like lampblack.
Report
11points
#68 Just Got This Message On My Phone... What Is It? I Was Washing Dishes And When I Came Back This Message Was On My Phone. No, I Haven't Been On Any Shady Websites Or Anything Like That

(UPDATE!) I am okay! After posting on reddit, I did some more searching to find out if it was a virus or something, but again nothing came up with the keywords. I began getting worried. So I texted my friend groupchat to ask if they got the safety alert too. (They all live in the same city) And they did! After a couple of minutes another alert popped up. I would post it here, but I'm not sure how, as I don't post on Reddit often. This is what it said. "PUBLIC SAFETY MESSAGE, Please disregard the previous message. Accident". So there is your answer. Thank you to anyone worried or sending me messages!
Report
11points
#69 The Boy In The Box . A Child No One Looked For

In 1957, a young boy was found dead in a cardboard box in the woods near Philadelphia.
Beaten. Starved. Wrapped in a blanket.
Beaten. Starved. Wrapped in a blanket.
Police flooded the city with photos and appeals. The story made national news.
No one reported him missing. For decades, no one even knew his name. That’s the part that haunts me not just that someone killed him, but that no one came looking. A child existed, suffered, and vanished so quietly that the world barely noticed.
No one reported him missing. For decades, no one even knew his name. That’s the part that haunts me not just that someone killed him, but that no one came looking. A child existed, suffered, and vanished so quietly that the world barely noticed.
The crime ended in the woods.
The horror didn’t.
The horror didn’t.
It ended in the silence.
Report
10points
#70 Amazon Prime Glitched On The Ps4. It's Probably Just A Loading Error But It's Interesting That Only Certain Phrases Are Readable

Report
9points
#71 How Did My Food Delivery App Know I Was Complaining About Their Milk Selection?

I also posted this in r/RBI because I’m truly baffled. Context is: I’m not a conspiracy theorist (actually very cynical!) but this experience makes me feel like one!
My partner and I were on FaceTime ordering from a snack and drink / household goods delivery service. We were discussing the two options they had available for oat milk. I have the app open while we’re FaceTiming and we have the following conversation:
“Ok, they have Oatly for $7.50 or Chobani for $5.50. Which one should I get? I guess $7.50 is not so bad if we split it, but still, it pisses me off that it’s that expensive!”
“Yeah…Chobani is good, though.”
“Is it creamy enough to cook with?”
“Yeah!”
“Ok.”
I add it to my cart, check out, close the app.
This particular app will text you a little customized confirmation message about the items you ordered. Sometimes it’s “funny” (it’s not but they try to be) and other times it’s pretty normal. I always thought they were using AI or pre-written texts where they swap out the item name. Either way I presumed this was automated and that the custom text was based solely on what is in your cart / what you purchase.
But then I got this text.
“We got your order, but next time, let’s not judge the oat milk.”
?!?!!
How in the fresh hell do they know I was critiquing their oat milk prices? And for reference, I’m 99.99% sure I did not add one milk to the cart, remove it, and then add the other- my cart was empty when I started and I only added the one brand of milk in. So there would not be keystroke / cart activity to support this message. I didn’t even search both brands, I just searched oat milk.
I’m baffled. Is this app recording audio while I’m buying stuff? If so— WHY? And why is the AI message writer being mean to me?! What?!
FYI I have experience in tech writing / marketing so I’m not unfamiliar with the wildly borderline stalkery stuff made possible through technology and e-commerce. But this was actually terrifying and kind of puts me off using the service, so, possibly not their intended result?
Report
9points
#72 The Mystery Of The Icon Preserving Been

For a decade, a beekeeper near Athens, has kept a tradition: every spring, he slips icons of Christ, the Holy Virgin and different saints in his beehives, in order to bless his bees and his yearly honey production. And every year, the very same mysterious phenomenon occurs: bees make their honeycomb cells around the pious images, meticulously avoiding covering them.
Report
9points
#73 What Is This? Keep Finding These Around My Property In The Last Week

mycorona69:
Rat poison
Report
9points
#74 Just Got Back From Egypt And Was Sorting Pictures. Phone Detected A Phone Number In The Hyeroglyphs ?!

Report
9points
#75 In 2017, My Dad Got This Mail Hand-Delivered (He Didn’t See Who Did It & We Have No Cctv), Not Signed. Can’t Crack Who It’s From/Why They Sent It, But The Photo Looks Like His Hometown (100 Miles Away From Where We Live). Does This Look Familiar To Anyone? Is The Writing Intentionally Misspelled?

Report
9points
#76 My Car Got Vandalized At A Gas Station, Should I Be Scared?! What Is This?! I’m Mostly Pissed Off Because It’s Sharpie

Report
7points
#77 In 2002, French Snowboarder Marco Siffredi Set Out To Conquer Mount Everest’s Deadly Hornbein Couloir, Aiming For A Historic Descent. Before Starting, He Told His Sherpa Team, “See You Tomorrow.” He Was Last Seen Carving Down The Slope But Never Returned. Despite Searches, His Body Was Never Found

Report
6points
#78 13-Year-Old Scott And 8-Year-Old Amy Fandel Vanished From Their Alaska Cabin On The Night Of September 4th, 1978. Their Mother And Aunt Returned To Find A Pot Of Boiling Water On The Stove, An Open Can Of Tomatoes And A Package Of Macaroni On The Counter, But No Sign Of The Kids Anywhere

Report
1point
#79 My Son Remembered His Previous Life

I want to share a story from my life. When my son was about 2 years old, he told us something that surprised us. He said he chose us as his parents. He said, "First, I chose my dad because he had a beard, was kind, and funny. Then I chose my mom." At first, I thought it was just a child's fantasy, so I didn't pay much attention. But when he was 3 years old, he told us something that left us shocked. We were lying down one evening before bedtime, and out of nowhere, our 3-year-old said, "It's so nice that I chose you and dad. It's wonderful when your parents love you, hug you, and kiss you. Everything was wrong before." I asked, "What was it like before?" He replied, "I used to live with a woman who wasn't my real mom. She didn't love me at all. She would kick me out onto the street to beg for food. I was very young, walking around in shorts, asking for bread, and sometimes picking up food from the ground. It was dirty, and we lived near a river where I drank water. We often walked, and she had her own son who was older. She loved him, but he would hurt me." I asked, "Where did you live?" He said, "It was a white stone house." I asked, "Can you show it to me?" He laughed and said, "Mom, it was very far away, and it's gone now." I asked, "Where is your other mom? Would you recognize her?" He said, "I found out who she was, but she passed away a long time ago. Her son grew up and became a grandfather, but I didn't even get a chance to grow up. I died when I was little, and then I was born to you." It's hard to explain how this could be possible, especially coming from a 3-year-old. Children often have wild imaginations, but the way he described everything in such detail and answered all our questions without hesitation was astonishing. However, the next morning, he said he didn't remember anything about it.
Report
-3points


