Working overtime can be a great way to earn a little extra money, if you’ve got the time and don’t mind staying late some days. But when it’s required of you by your employer, regardless of how much you get done during your regular shift, it may seem a bit unnecessary.
Below, you’ll find a story that was recently shared on Reddit, detailing how one employee attempted to maliciously comply with their employer’s mandatory overtime policy, as well as some of the replies amused readers left.
This employee’s boss was adamant that everyone works overtime during the holiday season
Image credits: MART PRODUCTION (not the actual photo)
So they decided to use their overtime hour to do absolutely nothing
Image credits: Antoni Shkraba (not the actual photo)
Image credits: cottonbro studio (not the actual photo)
Image credits: AdMinimum3886
Later, the worker responded to a few comments from readers and provided additional details about the situation
Image credits: fauxels (not the actual photo)
As the employee noted in this post, mandatory overtime might be obnoxious, but it is perfectly legal in the United States. According to Homebase, overtime hours begin once employees start working over 40 hours in one week. At this point, they are entitled to 1.5 times their hourly wage for every extra hour they work. And while employers are allowed to make this mandatory, and workers can be fired for refusing to work overtime, there are a few limitations surrounding overtime work.
The Fair Labor Standards Act does not put a cap on how many overtime hours workers can accumulate, but there are instances where bosses cannot require extra hours. For example, if an employee’s contract explicitly states that they will not be working overtime, demanding so would be a violation of their contract. Workers also can’t be expected to work overtime if it poses a health or safety hazard. If employees are dangerously fatigued or at risk of becoming ill, they cannot be expected to stay any longer.
Image credits: Mizuno K (not the actual photo)
If their employer is not adequately compensating for overtime hours, workers should not stay longer than 40 hours a week. This could happen if their boss misclassified them as employees exempt from overtime pay, their boss decided to deduct overtime pay due to poor performance, their employer deducted payment for breaks to avoid compensating for overtime or they were not paid overtime for mandatory training during work hours.
Employees who have a family emergency are also entitled to leave and cannot be required to stay overtime by their employers. And according to the National Labor Relations Act, members of unions are protected from mandatory overtime if they have come to an agreement with employees through bargaining.
While there can be benefits to working overtime, such as having the opportunity to earn additional pay and being able to be more productive in the workplace, there are certainly downsides to it as well. The University of Phoenix explains that working overtime often can make employees more prone to burnout, can harm their work-life balance and can actually decrease their productivity. If a worker is constantly exhausted and stressed, they might not do their job as well as they could have if they had adequate rest in between shifts.
Image credits: Ron Lach (not the actual photo)
Companies who require their employees to work overtime tend to focus on the benefits they’ll see, but there are some cons for them as well. The University of Phoenix notes that it’s likely for employees to become less engaged while working if they’re burnt out or resentful about having to stay longer than usual. There are also increased costs, when having to pay workers 1.5 times their normal rates, and there are risks that turnover rates will rise if employees are unhappy.
While there’s legally nothing wrong with expecting employees to work overtime, at least in Texas where this story took place, it’s important for companies to fully consider the pros and cons and logic (or lack thereof) behind their decisions to mandate additional hours. We would love to hear your thoughts on this story in the comments below, pandas. Would you have maliciously complied to the employer in this story? Then, if you’re interested in reading another Bored Panda article discussing a similar topic, look no further than right here!
Readers had mixed reactions to the story, as many noted that the boss actually got what she wanted in the end
