Some people believe that there’s always a way out of even the trickiest of situations, and in many cases, they are right. Numerous individuals have found themselves looking for loopholes to get out of certain pickles, be it in school, at work, or even in a courtroom.
The latter is what members of the ‘Ask Reddit’ community recently discussed, when one of them, a netizen going by the name of ‘Meme_Collector_GG’, addressed the lawyers in the group. The redditor asked them what has been the wildest loophole they’ve ever seen exploited in a courtroom that succeeded, and the respondents shared quite a few of them, which you can find on the list below.
#21

NAL. I got a ticket thrown out for running a stop sign. Before it was rewritten, the law stated that all 4 wheels had to come to a complete stop at a stop sign. My 4 wheels were locked up as i slid down the hill and blew straight through the intersection. Technically, the wheels were at a complete stop as my old s**tbox didn't have ABS. The judge threw it out.
26points
#22

The wildest loopholes I've seen are really tame - the cops made mistakes.
A truck driver given a ticket for driving an overweight truck over a bridge, and the cop didn't weigh the truck. A guy given a ticket for failure to to yield at an intersection when he did a U-turn in the middle of a highway causing an oncoming driver to rear end him. Stupid stuff like that.
19points
#23

NAL; just a bibliophile and a fan of American History.
In a book about Coke County Texas by a lady named Yarborough, she mentioned that a young man was taken before the judge in the small town for “firing his gun in the street”.
The young man was brought before the judge who pulled up the statute and read it and it said essentially “it is an offense to discharge a firearm in the streets of Robert Lee, Texas”.
He then asked the boy to describe exactly what he was doing, why, and where he was.
The boy said, “Well… I was standing in the lot on this side of the street and saw a badger in the lot on the other side of the street in the other lot. I pulled out my rifle and shot the badger.”
The Judge said he was free to go as “he had not been standing *in the steet* when he shot, and thus had not broken the law.
In a book about Coke County Texas by a lady named Yarborough, she mentioned that a young man was taken before the judge in the small town for “firing his gun in the street”.
The young man was brought before the judge who pulled up the statute and read it and it said essentially “it is an offense to discharge a firearm in the streets of Robert Lee, Texas”.
He then asked the boy to describe exactly what he was doing, why, and where he was.
The boy said, “Well… I was standing in the lot on this side of the street and saw a badger in the lot on the other side of the street in the other lot. I pulled out my rifle and shot the badger.”
The Judge said he was free to go as “he had not been standing *in the steet* when he shot, and thus had not broken the law.
19points
#24

Not a lawyer. This happened about 10 years ago in Wayne PA. Was in court testify against a former employee for stealing. The case befor his was a drunk driving case. It was open and closed case. Lady blew twice the legal limit after roaming into a parked car at a gas station. The prosecutions case was simply the arresting officers testimony as nd the breathalyzer results. After the prosecutor questions the officer and rests his case you could see the defendants lawyer chuckle. I thought it was odd and then I found out why. Defending lawyer stands up and spouts off some PA code and asks the judge for for an immediate dismissal. Judge grants it but is visibly pissed. He then immediately takes recess and calls both the officer and prosecutor into his chambers. It was about three minutes of the judge beratingvthem both and the whole courtroom could hear it.
It turns out that at some point during the prosecutions case either he was supposed to ask the officer or the officer was supposed to say that he had been specifically trained to use the breathalyzer and detect impaired driving and by failing to do so the prosecution failed to meet the necessary requirements for the conviction. It was wild.
It turns out that at some point during the prosecutions case either he was supposed to ask the officer or the officer was supposed to say that he had been specifically trained to use the breathalyzer and detect impaired driving and by failing to do so the prosecution failed to meet the necessary requirements for the conviction. It was wild.
18points
#25

Not me, but my old roommate was a lawyer and he used to get d**g cases dismissed all the time because the county where he worked never maintained chain of custody.
He got cases dismissed where the cops had pulled the d***s from the person’s pocket, but since they couldn’t prove in court that the d***s were real and were the same d***s that were confiscated the judge would throw out the case.
17points
#26

I once had a $500 ticket thrown out because the cop cited me to appear in court after my 18th birthday for a crime I committed as a minor.
I didn't even have to argue the point. I showed up and the prosecutor apologized and sent me on my way. Shoulda set it for juvenile court, Officer D******d.
17points
#27

My grandpa was a lawyer for an oil company a few decades ago. They had a huge federal case one time, and he simply went up to the judges and told them they didn't have jurisdiction. The oil was drilled in Texas and refined in Texas, had never left the state of Texas. So there was no interstate commerce, and the federal court had no jurisdiction. He got the case thrown out "on bonk".
16points
#28

As people have said. ‘Loopholes’ are rare. But this story jumps to mind. Wouldn’t take much embellishment to make a dramatic tv moment.
Convicted criminal was on furlough. A program with the jail where you can be released on an ankle monitor while still serving your sentence. He cut the monitor, ran and was caught. Indicted for Escape.
Case gets to trial and the prosecutor puts on a pretty straightforward case. people from the jail and ankle monitor company and arresting cops testify. Then the defense moves to dismiss. Prosecution has failed to prove escape.
There was actually a different law called unlawful evasion that applied to escaping off furlough program. this was extra confusing because escape is the correct charge for cutting an ankle monitor if you are serving your sentence on ankle monitor. Which you can do sometimes. But if you start in jail and get out on an ankle monitor as part of a furlough program then the crime is unlawful evasion.
Prosecutor was furious. Because the defense could have dismissed the case at any point. Arraignment up to trial. But he never said anything. So the guy sat in jail for months awaiting trial on a charge he could get dismissed. Judge ordered the case dismissed.
There was some small debate about whether he could be retried or not, because did double jeopardy attach if he was never actually charged with the right crime? But the DA wasn’t going to highlight the embarrassment and just let it go. A crime (and slam dunk case) with a 6+ year sentence dismissed for a few months in jail. .
15points
#29

Not an attorney/courtroom story, but still a kind of legal loophole.
I knew a guy that was drinking a beer while driving home one night. The conditions were snowy and he slid off the road into the ditch. He called for assistance and before the police and tow truck arrived he got out and put the six-pack on the hood. He made sure they saw him take a drink from the open bottle while he was standing outside the car as they pulled up.
He told them sliding off the road like he did shook him up and he decided to drink one of the beers to calm his nerves. They had no way to prove that he was drinking it while driving.
15points
#30

Not a lawyer, but close to one. In law school in Finland, they were taught about a case where a man was on trial for failing to pay back a loan.
His lawyer argued that he shouldn’t be convicted of delinquency (no idea what the actual terms are in English, bear with me) _because he never had intended to pay the loan back in the first place._
And he _won the case._
The reason was because the prosecutor had made a mistake: he had prosecuted the man only for the lesser charge of being delinquent in making payments, and forgot to write up the alternative charge of outright fraud.
So the court had to rule that there was reasonable doubt whether the man actually committed the act he was on trial for.
15points
#31

There really aren't loopholes like that where people dramatically win a case in court based on a word in a statute no one else read or whatever it is you're thinking of.
Closest thing I can think of...I knew of a criminal defense attorney that had a slight foreign accent. When he had a lost cause of a case, in court he would sometimes play up the accent heavily, pretend to understand less English than he really did, generally play dumb, etc. This was juxtaposed with one of the best prosecutor offices in the country who were all very polished. His hope was the jury might feel sorry for his client and acquit him even if they thought he was guilty because it felt like he never had a fair shot.
It was a fine line to walk to do that and not p**s off the judge though lol. .
12points
#32

A lawyer acquaintance knew of a few places where there were 'no parking' signs but the areas were somehow missed in the by-laws. He defeated all the tickets.
10points
#33

Not a lawyer but I got pulled over driving a buddy’s car at 3am on a back road I wasn’t familiar with, daytime running lights on so no brake lights (oops) and drove right by someone else they had already pulled over. Knew I was f****d when they pulled out after me. Said I was acting sus, demanded to search or else the dog was gonna be called in, found my weed and set it on the hood of the car. Filled out a little slip saying it was weed etc etc. Well the court date is here and my lawyer asks the first cop if he did a field test to see if it really was thc weed or just hemp? He said he thought he did. They send that one back and call out the other cop, ask him the same question and he answers that he isn’t sure, and doesn’t remember if it was done or not. I also stated I did not see a field test done to confirm that there was thc present and the judge scoffed at the cops and dropped it. Phew! Only spent a couple weeks in jail for the other charges!
7points
#34

I went to court and watched my lawyer boldly lie... He asked me something before going in that I confirmed and stated the exact opposite to the judges face. When we were leaving a couple other lawyers complimented him on his speech. Most of them lie and everyone knows it... Whoever is the better lier often wins and it is acceptable which is a bit of a loophole if you ask me.
3points

