Bored Panda
67 Things That Made Women Turn Down A Guy Who Looked Perfect On Paper

67 Things That Made Women Turn Down A Guy Who Looked Perfect On Paper

33
2
Who is your perfect person? Are they tall, dark and handsome? Kind, caring and adventurous? Or maybe, successful, fit and funny? Many of us have a "list." Even Kim Kardashian once revealed that her "dream man" must provide protection, have good hygiene, and a calm demeanor. Oh, and please, she said, no massive personal drama because apparently she has enough of her own.
Often, our "lists" are so specific and extensive that finding "the one" can be like looking for a needle in a haystack. But sometimes, after kissing a few frogs, we strike it lucky and the universe gifts us with someone who is absolutely perfect for us... on paper, at least. It seems like a dream come true, until it isn't.
Someone asked women, "What is something that made you turn down a date with a guy even though he looked perfect on paper?" and hundreds didn't hold back.
Bored Panda has put together the best responses in case you needed any further proof that dating has gone to the dogs. There's the story of the guy who claimed to be a Turkish prince, a few who couldn't stop babbling about their exes, and the 64-year-old liar who said he was 20 years younger. Don't forget to upvote your favorites and feel free to share your own tales in the comments section below.

#1

A woman talks to a man, suggesting a change of mind about guys she once thought were perfect.
A coworker asked me out, he seemed funny, charming, great worker, no kids etc....yet him approaching me was after i overheard him boasting to male coworkers that "he expects physical affection and/or intimacy" if he is to spend over $100 bucks on a woman!

When he asked me out, i immediately said no, told him why, and snipped at him that there are women in a specialized, yet taboo industry that can/will happily meet his physical transactional preferences without the gentlemen expectation.

He looked mortified, then asked me not to disclose his perspectives to any of the other women in the workplace...i informed every single female in the building and warned them to steer clear of him...7 months later, he SAd a receptionist that went on a date with him!
34points

What's on your "list"? Or do you not have one? Some people swear by writing down the qualities they're looking for in a partner, while others just go with the flow.

Many dating experts believe that lists can be a good thing. They help us to be more intentional, which can save a lot of time, effort and heartbreak in today's fast-paced, digital-led dating world.

"I’ve seen it happen time and time again in my work in which a client gets so swept up in all the excitement of a new person or 'situationship' that they lose sight of the things they really want in a relationship or know are good for them," says Leah Aguirre, a Licensed Clinical Social Worker and psychotherapist.

However, the expert adds that it’s easy to become blinded when there is intense chemistry or a new person seemingly “checks all the boxes.”

#2

A woman with a towel on her head uses a phone, hinting at her changing mind about perfect guys.
Met a guy on a dating app. Had a good job, owned a house, well educated, and good looking. We had a really good connection over text and on the phone with some amazing conversations and witty banter. He was leaving his house to pick me up when he said, over text, that he was expecting at least a goodnight kiss but probably more. I responded with "haha" or "LOL" or something to the effect but then he came back with "if I don't get a kiss there will NOT be a second date." I canceled the date right then and there. Blazing red flags over the statement. And chances were high that if the date went as well as our conversations he would have gotten one!
29points

#3

A couple sits at an outdoor cafe. The woman looks intently at the man. This shows women changing their minds.
Baby talk. I could not- even if he was the very last man on the entire planet.


Every hormone I had fell immediately off my body.
28points

Often, people make the mistake of being too "shallow," when it comes to creating their lists. Yes, maybe you prefer someone with blue eyes and blonde hair, or a tall, dark and handsome dude. But it's important to go beyond looks, careers and money. Focus instead on the traits you'd like your ideal partner to have.

Consider how you would like to feel in a relationship, advises Aguirre. She adds that while no relationship is perfect, you should generally feel good or happy and not anxious or miserable.

"In a healthy relationship, you should feel like you can be yourself and express your feelings and needs," explains Aguirre. "You should feel seen and heard. You should feel confident that you can work through conflict and have difficult conversations. You should also feel secure."

#4

A couple enjoying wine and food outdoors, discussing why women changed minds about guys they once thought were perfect.
He was the handsome man I could dream to date and I was very flattered because he asked me for the date. But he spent his time to criticise and badmouth about his colleagues and almost each person he knew. It was his only topic. By half of the date, I was thinking he was actually very ugly and he didn’t attract me anymore.
28points

#5

A woman looks frustrated at her phone, reflecting a change of mind about guys she once thought were perfect.
He insisted on picking me up from my house after I told him I'd rather drive. After 3 times, I cancelled the date.
27points

#6

A couple at a bar, looking at each other while discussing why women changed minds about guys they once thought were perfect.
I met someone on a dating app once who gave me nothing but green flags all around until we went to dinner and I saw how they treated service staff.

We hadnt even been there more than five minutes before my date was subtly talking down to the waitress and made such a grossly unkind comment about her appearance as she walked away (within earshot) that I immediately let them know that I wasnt comfortable associating with anyone who could treat a stranger with that kind of disregard. I asked them to leave, loose my number and wished them luck in their endeavors and canceled our order. I'll never forget the waitress brought me ice cream afterwards. I'll never forget their walk of shame out of the restaurant (I had a window seat of course), I remember they werent even angry, just embarassed. Sadly, I think they were trying to show off. Lack of empathy on the first date takes bravado, it was a huge red flag.
27points

Some experts believe we should throw away our lists altogether. And there are several reasons: Your list is might be too long, or it might have what you think you want instead of what you really need.

"I will often see couples like this who end up in therapy because they decided to get married because their partner checked all of their boxes, and it seemed like it was the right age to get married and settle down or felt pressure," reveals one of the therapists at the Center for Modern Relationships.

They go on to explain that many of these couples failed to look for the important qualities in each other before getting married. For example, shared values, personality, mutual respect, attraction, and a genuine fondness for each other.

#7

A couple at a cafe, having a conversation about why women changed minds about guys they once thought were perfect.
Expensive car. He bragged about it, I said that I couldn't imagine spending that much on a car - it's just not a priority to me. He refused to believe that because"everybody wants an expensive car." So I said,"Yeeeeah, this is not going to work." 

It's not even the car itself, or our differing priorities. He just couldn't accept that other people feel different than I am. I'm not hand holding someone through the basics of being human.
26points

#8

A woman with brown hair in a pink top looks down at a coffee cup in an outdoor cafe. This shows women changing their minds.
Spent the entire first date calling his ex wife satan, she ruined his life, etc. I’m bored thinking about it.
25points

#9

A woman at a dinner table looking thoughtful, considering why women changed their minds about perfect guys.
He started telling me what to do. No, I make my own decisions and some guy I just met doesn't get a say in them.
24points

The center's experts say that it's better to trust your gut than to rely on a list that limits you.

"When we weed out so many potential partners due to a check-list, you could be missing out on an opportunity to connect with someone who’s really amazing and may challenge you in a meaningful way," they warn. "So please, don’t date someone just because they 'check the boxes,' and don’t partner with someone just because it seems like everyone else is."

The therapists add that remaining curious and open-minded (whether you're single or in a relationship) is one of the keys to a happy life.

#10

A smiling woman and a man in a coffee shop, showcasing dynamics of why women changed their minds about 'perfect' guys.
His voice was so shrill I was done pretty much the moment he opened his mouth. 6’5”, former Green Beret, blonde, ran some kind of medical startup, owned a fancy home he was “just waiting for a wife and kids for”. Could not get past the voice. (Although he got kind of nasty when I declined a second date so maybe there was something subconscious going on.)

Next guy was a foot shorter and did not have that kind of fancy resume, but he has a beautiful voice and I married him.
24points

#11

A woman looking intently at her phone, perhaps contemplating why women changed their minds about perfect guys.
I matched with a guy on Bumble, had a great conversation, and arranged to meet up for drinks. He asked for my phone number and I said I’d prefer to keep it on the app until after we meet—nothing personal, just being careful. He immediately lost it, claimed I was accusing him of being a monster, and insisted that I must be planning to ghost him. I unmatched.
23points

#12

67 Things That Made Women Turn Down A Guy Who Looked Perfect On Paper
He created a fake female profile to befriend me and try to get insider info on me and how he was doing. Sadly for him I'm bi and his female persona was more attractive.
23points

The team over at Thought Catalog tend to agree.

"We sometimes have a list that we can’t even measure up to," they caution. "When you meet someone who does not follow your list but at the same time you can’t find something wrong with them or pinpoint anything that noticeably stands out to you; that’s when you should just trust your gut and throw your list away."

#13

A man with a beard and a woman with curly hair sit at a table with candles. This shows women changing their minds.
This was years back (I'm long since married). Really handsome guy, seemed charming, set up a date.

....he was a white supremacist. Noped right out of there.
22points

#14

A couple having a tense meal, illustrating how women changed their minds about 'perfect' guys.
A full typed out lecture about how selfish I was for not wanting children. 🥴.
22points

#15

A young woman with curly hair looks thoughtful, reflecting on a guy she once thought was perfect and his baby talk.
We had a date scheduled to meet at a restaurant downtown and I asked to reschedule
Because I didn't want to commute in the absolute hell of a storm we were having & also I didn't want to ruin my hair ( curly hair ladies iykyk) first was the pressure to come out , politely said no and He went on and on about how I was missing out, how great he was and I would regret it. It was the grossest adult tantrum I've ever seen. That reschedule turned into a hard no. I have never been so turned off so quickly!
Glad I passed on this 'opportunity of a lifetime'.
21points

Lucie Ebnerova, dating coach and founder of Luvidya, believes it's better to have a wish list rather than a checklist for your future relationship.

"This list should be open-ended and focused on your desire, not your demand," advises the dating expert.

As an example, she says, you could write: "I would love to live a family life and I’m open to having children with a loving partner, ready to invest in a relationship and we have amazing communication."

#16

67 Things That Made Women Turn Down A Guy Who Looked Perfect On Paper
Cringe Lord asked me to justify why he should go on a date with me. Phrased it as ‘you are a very attractive female, you must get asked out a lot. Tell me why I should go on a date with you’.

Me and my lady neck-beard doffed our fedora and continued on our way.
21points

#17

A couple talks outdoors with coffee, perhaps discussing women changing their minds about perfect guys.
He was Turkish, and claimed he was a Turkish prince living in anonymity in the states. I thought he was being playful and I laughed said “I bet you say that to all the girls” and he yelled “NO I DON’T” and got super defensive.

I’ve never dipped from someone’s life so fast.
20points

#18

67 Things That Made Women Turn Down A Guy Who Looked Perfect On Paper
He got angry when I asked for the location to be changed.  I wanted coffee, he wanted to for a night walk through the Botanic gardens.  That was enough for me.  Anyone who doesn't understand the safety issues that women face is an immediate red flag.
19points

Ebnerova agrees that your checklist might be blinding you to the perfect person sitting right in front of you.

"Open yourself to diverse possibilities. Expand your circles and be open to meeting different kinds of people. You might be surprised by unexpected connections," the expert suggests. "Focus on fostering positive connections. Make people feel valued and appreciated in your presence. Even if they’re not your 'one,' they might introduce you to someone who is!"

Do you have a "list"? If so, what does it include? Let us know in the comments below...

#19

A woman with short curly hair looks over her shoulder, holding a glass of beer. This shows women changing their minds.
Immediately started calling himself ugly and talking about his ex wife on the first date unprompted.
18points

#20

Hands play a Jenga game on a table, with a blurred person in the background. This shows women changing their minds.
Met through mutual friend's bosses game night.

On paper, exactly what I was looking for.

But when someone would do something in a board game that he deemed illogical, he'd get irate about trying to convince them they were wrong. Particularly when it disrupted whatever he had planned out several moves ahead. He's take it like a personal attack.
18points
33
2