Bored Panda
32 Creepy And Terrifying Serial Killer Stories From People With Firsthand Experience

32 Creepy And Terrifying Serial Killer Stories From People With Firsthand Experience

32
7
For many people, the era of infamous serial offenders is something they know only through documentaries, podcasts, and true-crime books. But for those who lived through it, the fear often felt much closer to home—changing everyday routines, shaping how communities responded to danger, and leaving behind memories that still feel unsettling decades later.
In this collection, people share personal stories and haunting recollections from a time when disturbing crimes regularly dominated the headlines. Some describe close encounters, while others remember the fear and uncertainty that affected entire communities. Keep reading to discover the stories that reveal what life was really like during this chilling chapter of history.
Content warning: The following collection includes discussions of disturbing experiences that some readers may find upsetting.

This post may include affiliate links.

#21

32 Creepy And Terrifying Serial Killer Stories From People With Firsthand Experience
***First Incident***
In the 1980s I took a business trip to San Fransciso, and on the flight there I read the book Zodiac (chilling and great).

My flight lands very late, I get a cab to my hotel, and as we approach the dropoff I see it's at the intersection where the Zodiac K**ler was known to have caught a cab.

At this point, mentally, I'm deeeep into the world of the Zodiac crimes and manhunt, it's just over a decade since the last known victim, it's late and dark and foggy with empty streets, and he's still not been caught.

To say my head was on a swivel that trip would have been an understatement.

***Second Incident***
I was hospitalized in eastern Pennsylvania, had surgery, and the night before I was to be released I developed severe, life-threatening complications, which I barely survived (got last rites, etc).

Over a decade later I find out that [Charles Cullen](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Cullen) was working at my hospital while I was there. The nature of my complications could definitely have been caused by a malicious actor, and for a time I considered suing but, due to personal complications, ended up choosing not to pursue it.
10points

Kemper was far from the only offender studied by the FBI’s Behavioral Science Unit. Douglas, Ressler, and their colleagues interviewed numerous incarcerated violent criminals in an effort to compare their experiences and identify recurring patterns. Their research helped investigators consider questions that had previously received less attention: What might an offender’s behavior reveal about their motives? Could the way a crime was committed provide clues about the person responsible? And could similarities between cases help law enforcement connect crimes across different jurisdictions? The answers were never simple, but this work contributed to the development of behavioral analysis as an investigative tool.

#22

32 Creepy And Terrifying Serial Killer Stories From People With Firsthand Experience
My dad had to supervise the removal of bodies from John Wayne Gacy's basement. It was on the news EVERY night in Chicago and my dad was always on tv. Years later about 2010, my daughter did a paper on Gacy for a high school class and watched a documentary and yelled out, "Is this Grandpa?" and it was weird to see my dad young, in a shearling coat, with 70s sideburns. I know it affected him. He suffered with depression the rest of his life.

Also, a few years before Gacy, my brother was at his friend's house when sh*ts rang out...it was a neighbor, John Workman, who went crazy and sh*t his mom, dad, I believe 2 neighbors, and my brother's friend mom & sister. It was horrifying!
10points

#23

32 Creepy And Terrifying Serial Killer Stories From People With Firsthand Experience
Barbara Mackle! For whatever reason, I was allowed to watch the TV movie about her 1968 kidnapping by Gary Steven Krist in second grade. Being buried alive with only a small tube to breathe through — that was my fear until, thankfully, peer obsession and hormones took over in middle school
10points

#24

32 Creepy And Terrifying Serial Killer Stories From People With Firsthand Experience
Green River K**ler. Ended up being my soccer teammate's uncle. Her dad was always kinda weird too but not serial k**ler weird.
9points

Today, criminal profiling (also known as offender profiling or behavioral analysis) is used to help investigators interpret information from a crime and develop possible leads. Profilers may examine details such as the location of the crime, the offender’s apparent level of planning, the way the victim was approached, evidence left behind, and any repeated patterns across multiple cases. They may then suggest possible characteristics, behaviors, or circumstances that investigators should consider. However, profiling is not a form of mind-reading, nor can it identify a specific person on its own. It is most useful when combined with physical evidence, forensic science, witness accounts, digital records, investigative experience, and other established methods.

#25

32 Creepy And Terrifying Serial Killer Stories From People With Firsthand Experience
My area’s Signature Serial K**ler was the Trailside K**ler at large in the Santa Cruz Mountains. My dad was super permissive and would see off my sister and me with a cheery “Don’t get m******d!” when we’d head out to the nearby state park to play in the river or hike.
9points

#26

32 Creepy And Terrifying Serial Killer Stories From People With Firsthand Experience
One of my good friend's mother was k****d by Richard Chase in the Sacramento area. I was around 19 when I met her and while it was horrible to hear about it I didn't feel any fear at the time. The fact that I was at that point in life when I was invincible probably helped.

I honestly just remember how much it affected her. It truly damaged her soul. She rarely spoke of it ~~but I believe she may have even been the one to find her (she was elementary school age when it happened, I believe).~~ (I had to edit this because I don't trust my memory of what she said 100%)

We lost touch when our lifestyles diverged. I still think of her and my heart aches with hope that she found peace.
8points

#27

32 Creepy And Terrifying Serial Killer Stories From People With Firsthand Experience
Joseph DeAngelo (the original Night Stalker) and Richard Ramerez (the Night Stalker) from the 70s & 80s respectively, both in SoCal. You better believe we kept our windows closed at night.
8points

Coming back to today’s collection, these posts offer a glimpse into how frightening and uncertain that period could feel for the people who lived through it. Some of the stories are unsettling because they involve close encounters, while others reveal how fear could spread through entire neighborhoods and communities. Which of these accounts gave you the chills, Pandas? Was there one that stayed with you long after you finished reading? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below.

#28

32 Creepy And Terrifying Serial Killer Stories From People With Firsthand Experience
The Yorkshire Ripper

The misogyny of the police and other commentators at the time has been laid bare my more recent documentaries.
8points

#29

32 Creepy And Terrifying Serial Killer Stories From People With Firsthand Experience
I was in Southern California during the Night Stalker years. I just remember not having air conditioning and it being a super hot summer. Our parents WOULD NOT let us sleep with the window open, out of fear. I was so glad when he was caught
8points

#30

32 Creepy And Terrifying Serial Killer Stories From People With Firsthand Experience
My aunt was in college and lost two of her sorority sisters to Ted Bundy. She saw him at one of the parties they had a few days before.
7points

#31

I remember being in Simi Valley at the time of the Night Stalker. A group of us were staying at a friend's home during college in '85 (this was probably in late June) on a group trip to Six Flags, and we were all a bit on edge because he was in the news so much. We were in sleeping bags on the floor in the living room when our friend's brother came home at 2am through the front door. One girl woke up screaming and that got the rest of us screaming and grabbing for any heavy object nearby. Friend's brother stood in the doorway perplexed, watching it all happen. I remember he said very calmly, "you all need to get a life" and then he walked down the hall to his room. Ramirez was caught about a month or two later in LA, about 45 miles away.
Report
7points

#32

32 Creepy And Terrifying Serial Killer Stories From People With Firsthand Experience
I was at UW in their criminology department during the Green River days. The police department would gather us up to do basic crime scene checks where we would stand in a long line, look forward, look right, look left. If we saw anything, we’d put a flag down. Then we’d take a step and start the process all over again.
7points
32
7