Bored Panda
45 Wedding Breakups That Were Messy, Emotional, And Completely Justified

45 Wedding Breakups That Were Messy, Emotional, And Completely Justified

50
11
As the hours wind down before a wedding, the full weight of committing to someone forever can really start to settle in.
And for some, that realization is more sobering than reassuring.
That was the case for these Redditors, who chose to call off their engagements before making it to the altar.
Scroll down to hear what made them change their minds—and don’t miss our conversation with breakup coach Chloe Bines, who shares how to move forward and learn to trust again after ending a relationship.
More info: TikTok

#1

45 Wedding Breakups That Were Messy, Emotional, And Completely Justified
He refused to set a date. Then he refused to make me coffee (same pot, it was big enough for both of us, he just wouldn't make enough for both of us). Then he refused to turn off the giant overhead light in the bedroom when left for work earlier than me so I had to get up to turn it off and couldn't sleep in a few more minutes. He just didn't like me much after the excitement wore off and I wanted more than that. 


He did however stalk and harass me for weeks after I broke it off, threatening my job and my housing, and repeatedly telling me he'd k**l himself or sexually a*****t me. Which just seems like a lot more effort than making slightly more coffee and turning off a light and not screaming at me. .
84points

#2

45 Wedding Breakups That Were Messy, Emotional, And Completely Justified
He hit me one time. I was gone the next day, left the ring on the kitchen counter and had my friends come over and move all my stuff out.
83points

Approximately 20% of engagements are broken off before the wedding. That means about one in five couples who get engaged never make it to the altar.

That’s a significant number. But is it really such a bad thing if you realize your partner isn’t right for you? Walking away from a relationship that no longer feels healthy takes courage, and choosing yourself is rarely the wrong choice.

Still, not everyone is able to admit that to themselves, especially under the pressure of an approaching wedding.

That’s why Bored Panda reached out to Chloe Bines, a breakup coach who specializes in integrated attachment theory, to explore how people can recognize toxic dynamics and start the healing process.

According to Bines, the ability to make the right decision for yourself often begins with how secure you feel within.

When you have a strong sense of self, it is much easier to recognize when a relationship no longer aligns with your needs and to act on that realization.

#3

45 Wedding Breakups That Were Messy, Emotional, And Completely Justified
I ended my very short lived engagement because of Reddit. I kid you not. I posted on engagement rings about hating my ring, and then people started asking questions about my relationship and after figuring out that he was much older than me, made me understand I was being manipulated. It was mind blowing. I received so many messages from concerned women of that sub that I could barely keep up. In the beginning I thought every one was exaggerating, but then I started reading stories and links they sent me and finding so much in common. I told him I needed some time to think and he changed 180 degrees and made me realize what a f***k he was. Haven’t looked back honestly. I am applying for Medical school and I am so happy I didn’t stay with him.
78points

#4

45 Wedding Breakups That Were Messy, Emotional, And Completely Justified
It occurred to me that we never had one honest fight. If I did something to upset him, he’d stew and grumble and WEEKS later blow up over something unrelated.

I had wanted him to visit me and he kept saying he couldn’t, but wouldn’t say why. (We had graduated college at this point, living in separate cities). I had time off at this time, he wasn’t working—I couldn’t understand why he wouldn’t come see me. I offered to pay for his trip, said he could pay me back if he wanted but of course he didn’t have to since it would be our money anyway—still no.

Turns out he had a boys’ trip to California planned for that week and didn’t want to tell me until after he came home, knowing I’d be angry and hurt he didn’t choose to see me when he could have. He figured I’d forgive him and get over as I had always done once he got back.

And I suddenly understood that would be my future with him. I’d do something to annoy or infuriate him and walk in a minefield for weeks, waiting for an explosion. He’d upset me and then just wait for my forgiveness. A perfect repeat of my parents’ marriage.

I ended it that day.
74points

#5

45 Wedding Breakups That Were Messy, Emotional, And Completely Justified
I was driving over a bridge and thought about how easy it would be to floor it into the river so I wouldn’t have to go home. So I wouldn’t have to be trapped. This was just a month before our wedding. Nearly 10 years ago now. I’m grateful every day that I walked away.
71points

In healthy relationships, this sense of secure attachment means both partners feel emotionally safe, supported, and comfortable with closeness. They’re able to communicate openly, navigate conflict constructively, and trust that their partner will show up for them.

This emotional security often takes root in childhood, shaped by consistent and attuned caregiving. When those early needs are met, it creates a stable foundation—an internal blueprint—for how we relate to others later in life.

But when those needs go unmet, that foundation can be shaky. And over time, it can lead to patterns that quietly sabotage our adult relationships.

Take anxious attachment, for instance. People with this style often feel unsure about where they stand with their partner. They may constantly worry about the relationship’s stability and find it hard to let go, even when they’re being mistreated, manipulated, or gaslighted.

In contrast, people with an avoidant style tend to distance themselves emotionally. They may struggle to express their feelings, avoid vulnerability, and find deep emotional connections difficult to maintain.

#6

45 Wedding Breakups That Were Messy, Emotional, And Completely Justified
I realized he was a much better person than me and deserved way better. After we broke things off, I worked really hard on improving my temper and just dedicated myself to being a good and kind person. It has paid off and I'm not the person I was 20 years ago. We both moved on and married other people and I still stand by my decision.
68points

#7

45 Wedding Breakups That Were Messy, Emotional, And Completely Justified
He cheated on me and tried to convince me that I was getting the wrong idea about her, that she was just a coworker and her text of "I had fun last night" was about them doing inventory at work. Then I found his dating profile. Then he stopped payment on the rent, threatened to k**l me, and called the cops on me, saying I was crazy. They didn't agree.

I remember feeling so small and so betrayed. But my life turned out to be happy, and I'm sure he's still a lying piece of trash. Beyond this post, I don't really think about him at all.
61points

#8

45 Wedding Breakups That Were Messy, Emotional, And Completely Justified
I was 18 and he was 26 and he groomed me from 15. I had gotten pregnant and had a miscarriage. He blamed me and said i got an abortion. I was tired of being alienated from my family, friends, he didnt want me to go to college, he didnt want me to work, he was emotionally and mentally a*****e and he cheated soooo d**n much.

He ended up getting married 3 months later to a 17 year old he met at a club and had tricked him into believing she had gotten pregnant from a one night stand. Supposedly she was 2 month further along than he thought and she married him to get papers. They ended up getting a divorce a year later.

He then brought over his 1st cousin from Honduras and she was 17 as well, he was in his 30s at this point. Married her in 6 months. Had 2 kids and now theyre getting a divorce because of how controlling and a*****e he was.

I dodged a f*****g cannon.
56points

“Our early attachment experiences shape the way we relate in adulthood, and when those patterns go unexamined, we can mistake anxiety, control, or intensity for love,” Bines explains.

“For example, someone with a controlling partner may interpret that behavior as care or protection, simply because they’ve never experienced love that didn’t come with conditions.”

“These kinds of internalized beliefs can be hard to identify because we’re often operating on autopilot, playing out old patterns without realizing it,” she adds.

Often, fear of being alone or the belief that “I won’t find anyone else” keeps people stuck in relationships that are no longer serving them. Staying feels safer than the uncertainty of starting over.

“Building a more secure attachment to ourselves—through understanding our patterns, challenging limiting beliefs, and learning what healthy love actually looks like—helps us feel confident in our ability to walk away when something doesn’t serve us. That inner security gives us the clarity and the courage to choose better,” says Bines.

#9

45 Wedding Breakups That Were Messy, Emotional, And Completely Justified
Well, he cheated on me with his best man. When I caught them he insisted vehemently that he isn't gay. Last I heard he has a new girlfriend now, so still in the closet. Joe, if you're reading this, happy Pride!
54points

#10

45 Wedding Breakups That Were Messy, Emotional, And Completely Justified
Can't speak for myself, but my mom did, in about 1953. She dated Richard through the last 2 years of college and was engaged. Her best friend had a double blind date arraigned, but the other girl got sick, and she asked my mom to go in her stead. Casual dates for going dancing as a group were more common then, and my mom agreed to fill in. She said by the end of the night she wasn't sure exactly what she wanted, but she knew she couldn't marry Richard. She called it off the next day. She married my dad 6 weeks later. She made jokes to me about crossing one name off the invitations and writing in my dad's. No idea how accurate that was but i do believe they used the same date, and she already had her dress (Chantilly Lace, according to the article in the paper) and bridesmaids. I did end of life caretaking for them 65 years later and every night before going up to bed, my mom would look up at him, big hug and kiss, and say "thank you so much for marrying me". She absolutely meant it. We had one purely ornamental plant, as my dad was quite practical. A rose bush, in direct line of sight of the kitchen window.
47points

#11

45 Wedding Breakups That Were Messy, Emotional, And Completely Justified
He was an amazing man and would’ve been an amazing husband. At that point in my life I was a closet lesbian and only an evil person would’ve gone forward with the wedding. .
47points

Many people believe their attachment style is set in stone—that how they were raised will always dictate how they behave in relationships. But attachment isn’t fixed. It can evolve.

While early experiences lay the groundwork, the relationships and events we encounter later in life can gradually change those patterns. Some people grow more secure over time, while others may drift toward insecurity, depending on what they’ve been through.

Cheating is one experience that can leave a deep mark. Research confirms that it often takes a toll on self-esteem and makes it harder to trust in future relationships.

After being hurt, it’s only natural to wonder if it could happen all over again.

#12

45 Wedding Breakups That Were Messy, Emotional, And Completely Justified
Ended my engagement after 3.75 years together. The wedding was 3 months away. Basically, I spent the whole relationship taking care of his emotional needs, his family drama, his health issues. He would never express his feelings, and we would have huge blow-up fights until he told me what was wrong finally, and then I would feel like a crazy person. All our fights ended with me compromising. It was never him resolving problems.

Im a grad student currently, and I had basically an impossible semester where I had expressed to him multiple times that I felt like I was drowning and I needed his support. Nothing even changed. By the time the semester was over, I resented him a lot. It still took me another 3 months to have the guts to end things. But at the same time, I had given up putting effort into our relationship. Then, all of a sudden, he realized that I had stopped putting in effort, and he had a problem with that. I would tell him that I needed to see him putting in effort for me to feel like I should be trying. Nothing ever changed. So finally, I just told him I wasn't happy and resented him. Tried to make him see he wasn't happy either, but he refused to accept it.

None of this drama includes how he picked an engagement ring that looked like none of the design ideas I had given him. It just felt like he said, f**k what you want, Im buying this. How he barely paid for any of the deposits for the wedding, then immediately after we ended things, told me to give him his money back. Or the time when we started planning for the wedding and he said, "Oh, isn't the brides family supposed to pay for everything?" As someone who claimed to be super liberal. Had very outdated views on weddings.

It's been a few months, and the wedding date we had set will come up in a few weeks. But at least I feel like I can breathe. Was more of a relief than anything.
46points

#13

45 Wedding Breakups That Were Messy, Emotional, And Completely Justified
My buddy and his ex-fiancee ended an engagement about 4 years ago. Six months ahead of their wedding. Basically both of them on their own felt like it had run its course and they weren't supposed to be together, one of the most mature break-ups I've ever seen...

Within two months - both of them had new partners.

Flash forward three years. My buddy and his ex both got engaged to those partners within weeks each of other.

Flash forward to last Saturday - both of them got married - on the same day - to the people they had met within months of ending an engagement 4 years prior.

Meanwhile...I've been single this whole d**n time!
44points

#14

45 Wedding Breakups That Were Messy, Emotional, And Completely Justified
I felt like i was his mom. asking him to help out around the house, making sure he wasn’t sleeping thru his alarm for work, setting up a “chore chart” so i wasn’t the only one keeping up with household tasks, apologizing to my friends and family for him skipping out on events because he was sleeping thru them, asking him not to stay up until 3am playing video games because we had something important going on the following morning….
43points

Still, Bines encourages people to rethink what trust really means.

“One of the hardest things to accept—but also one of the most freeing—is that we can never fully guarantee the behavior of others,” she says. “So if our ability to trust again depends on being promised that we’ll never be hurt, we’ll always struggle.”

Thoughts like “How can I trust again when it could all fall apart?” are valid—and scary—but, Bines says, they miss the point.

The real question is: What can I trust?

And the answer, she says, is: yourself. Your judgment, your resilience, and your ability to survive the pain.

#15

45 Wedding Breakups That Were Messy, Emotional, And Completely Justified
Really started watching how she treated her parents while she was stressed. I was not impressed. Didn’t want that in a permanent partner.
42points

#16

45 Wedding Breakups That Were Messy, Emotional, And Completely Justified
He wanted to play video games for 18 hours a day, I had to schedule an hour a day for us to just hang out and he made it seem like I was an inconvenience. When I said he never wanted to do things I wanted to do, like just go get mail together he told me he didn’t like the things I did and didn’t understand why he had to do them. He also got fired from 4 jobs that year cause he rather game. Even his parents started asking why I was with him. I thought I couldn’t do better, but I left him and 7m later after starting over found my husband.
42points

#17

45 Wedding Breakups That Were Messy, Emotional, And Completely Justified
He is a narcissist and let the mask slip too soon. He thought I would put up with it just to be married, but boy was he wrong! Took me 7 years to pay back wedding debt, but it was alot cheaper than paying for a divorce to the wrong person.
42points

I’ll be honest—when Bines said that, it completely reframed how I understood trust. I’d always believed it was something that lived between two people, built through mutual effort.

But as she explained, when you build a secure relationship with yourself, two important things start to happen.

“First, you start choosing partners for the right reasons—not to fill a void or calm your anxiety, but because they truly complement your values, needs, and emotional health.”

“Second, you build resilience. You stop fearing heartbreak as something that would destroy you, and start seeing it as something you could handle.”

“Painful, yes, but survivable,” says Bines. “This shift in mindset is where your power lies. Once you trust yourself to navigate whatever comes, the pressure to control the outcome disappears.”

#18

45 Wedding Breakups That Were Messy, Emotional, And Completely Justified
My ex and I both had injuries around the same time and both ended up addicted to Vicodin after having way too much of it prescribed by doctors. After a couple years of a*******n and barely making it through, she decided that the only way she was ever going to get clean was to go back to live with her family, around 4 hours away.

I didn’t want her to go but knew she was right, so I agreed. We planned to continue long distance until we could reunite, but it was much harder than we ever expected. It was very difficult going from being with each other pretty much 24/7 for 5 years, to visiting each other once a month at best. We drifted apart. Reluctantly, we started having discussions about taking a break and seeing other people and things like that. I think at the time even though we both agreed, we both believed that we’d ultimately still end up together.

Not long after those talks, I reconnected with an old childhood neighbor. The last thing I wanted to do was jump into another relationship so soon as I was still processing what happened with my ex, and I still had *a lot* to work on personally. I was a walking red flag at that point. I have no idea what this childhood friend saw in me as I was a broken human being at that point, but I took the leap and jumped into this new relationship. I knew it would devastate my ex even though we both agreed splitting up was best at the time. It was very difficult for a long time, but ultimately the best decision I’ve ever made in my life. That former childhood friend is now my wife of 5 years (together 10), and the mother of my child. My ex is a mother herself and thriving. We’ve both been “clean” from pain pills for several years.
41points

#19

45 Wedding Breakups That Were Messy, Emotional, And Completely Justified
Called mine off two weeks before because he was so rigid about the prenup that was regarded as unconscionable and instead of trying to work through it he said take it or leave it. So I left it. I realized at that moment this guy didn’t want a partner, he wanted someone who thought he can control and was convenient. I personally did not matter to him.

His mom was also extremely manipulative and awful. I couldn’t run faster from that family.
41points

#20

45 Wedding Breakups That Were Messy, Emotional, And Completely Justified
He called me when he was drunk at 3 am and told me that he only asked me to marry him because he didn’t think he could do better.

Denied it happened the next day despite there being a call….
40points
50
11