Bored Panda
66 Times Family Feuds Shocked Lawyers When People Actually Brought Their Petty Fights To Court

66 Times Family Feuds Shocked Lawyers When People Actually Brought Their Petty Fights To Court

35
3
Sometimes, divorces can be incredibly messy. It’s honestly strange how people can hate someone that they once loved and dreamed about spending their life with. Alas, humans are weird, but they can also be petty. Few folks are extremely petty and even take trivial matters to court.
I honestly don’t know how lawyers deal with such frustrating clients. However, they vented online when someone asked them to spill the pettiest fights that went down in family courts. Some are downright bizarre, while others will shock you with how unhinged they are. We have put together the wildest ones for you to scroll through below. Just sit back and enjoy the drama! 

#1

An open can of macaroni and cheese with a fork, tied to petty family feuds over food and household items.
client once called me with an "emergency." the emergency was that his soon to be ex wife fed the kid chef boyardee for dinner.

I went to law school for this.
12points

#2

A sad young boy leaning closely against his mother during emotional times linked to petty family feuds
The interim court order said that my client (the mom) was not to discuss the court proceedings with the child. During an access visit the child asked her "when will I get to see you again?" and my client responded, "we'll have to see, but hopefully soon."

The father then argued that this was "discussing the court proceedings with the child" and tried using it as an excuse to deny any further access.
11points

#3

Mickey Mouse posing outside a building, representing petty family feuds.
An emergency order to show cause being filed, asking a judge to issue an order preventing dad from taking the child on vacation...to Disneyland. Because if mom isn't happy, no one can be happy.
11points

I don’t know about you, but one thing that’s blatantly evident from most of these stories is how strongly these ex-couples hate each other. When love disappears, relationships can grow extremely bitter. And humans are almost professionals at hurting each other. Or rather, driving them nuts by pulling off something extremely petty. 

What they don’t realize is that it just drags their cases out forever. I mean, they could easily get rid of the previous person by pressing stop on the drama. But sometimes, they care more about their pride. Petty moves can also affect the other parent’s case and give them an advantage, especially in custody battles.

#4

A woman wearing sunglasses standing outside modern houses, symbolic of residential family feuds.
The ex-husband didn't want to pay what he owed his ex-wife. He thought he could mess with her by dragging on the process with appeals. He was not only hurting her but also his children. She desperately needed the money, and he knew that. Him dragging the process caused her to lose her job and have to move back with her parents. But once he paid she not only moved out, but bought a house, no not just like applied for a loan and got a house.. straight out paid cash for a full house. In the end he not only had to pay the full amount of what he owed, but child support, his lawyer fees and her lawyer fees.
10points

#5

Anxious man listening to an arguing woman during family feuds.
(Ex) Husband revoked a citizenship sponsorship - was essentially trying to get his wife to be kicked out of the country so that he'd be get full custody of their infant son. If you read the rest of the file, this wouldn't even be surprising.
10points

#6

Frustrated woman covering her face, illustrating stress from petty family feuds.
Had a mom get called in for not showing up to her 12 year old child with Aspberger's therapy. I quote, "I'd rather take that time to find myself". I've never wanted to throttle someone more in my life.
10points

Divorce coaches Pegotty and Randy Cooper list 4 major reasons divorce makes good people act badly. They claim that marriages often start with unspoken expectations that you never actually shared with your partner. When those hidden assumptions don’t match up, it’s easy to feel betrayed and blame your ex. But the real issue is usually that neither of you was ever on the same page to begin with. 

Also, divorce triggers a primal “fight or flight” response that can make you feel like you’re in danger, even though you’re just navigating a life change. This stress shuts down the logical part of your brain, making it hard to communicate, make good decisions, or even sleep. 

#7

A freezer neatly filled with packaged frozen vegetables and meats, connected to domestic family feuds.
Family law legal assistant here: A client of ours included a chunk of pork in the freezer in her list of assets that she insisted she get back.

The lawyer on the other side came back with "Respectfully, I'm not going to argue over second hand meat in a freezer".
9points

#8

Sick child sleeping in hospital bed, reflecting family feuds over medical care.
Worked in an attorney's office for a little bit. Knew about a divorce case one of the attorneys was involved in where the child had been diagnosed with a terminal disease with maybe a few years left and the parents tried to fight over what the child's "wish" should be for one of those Make-A-Wish type of foundations.

I do know the judge chewed both parents a new one when this issue came up, but ultimately could not make a call on how the "wish" would be granted. I believe the child ending up refusing the wish on account of the argument it caused between the parents.

Just hearing about the details of this case messed me up for awhile.

Edit: formatting.
9points

#9

A mother holding her young child outdoors, reflecting the complex emotional impact of family feuds
I'm just an intern, but I once was sifting through discovery that our client provided, as he was trying to win custody over his son.

One of these pieces of discovery was a "detailed account of the mother's timeliness." Basically, if the mother was late to pick up her son, they would time it and document it. Which would make sense if it was significant. But I'm not exaggerating, over a 6-month period, she was late for a TOTAL of 33 minutes. Seeing as they met to exchange the child three times/week, it means she was late by about one or two minutes once a week. It was the most insignificant piece of data that I have ever seen in my entire life, but the client was adamant that we use it in court to prove that the mother was irresponsible.
8points

They also speak about how divorce often strips away your sense of control, forcing you to make big decisions while relying on expensive lawyers you barely know. This dynamic can quickly turn a difficult situation into a war, where communication breaks down, and both sides feel they’re getting the short end of the stick. 

Lastly, they stress that entitlement also plays a role. They explain that divorce often turns shared possessions and memories into a bitter battle over who deserves what, driven more by ego and emotion than logic.

#10

Tense couple in a bedroom during petty family feuds leading to legal disputes
$3000 between me and another very good lawyer to argue about $13/month versus $30/month child support. They had 50/50 custody. The kid was 13. Even after I did the math for my client explaining they were paying me more than the difference for the entire rest of child support, they still wanted to do it.
8points

#11

Airplane flying in sky, related to petty family feuds over travel costs.
Worked in a law firm dealing in family matters. Couple hammers out a separation agreement over months of meetings, mediation, letters and drafts back and forth. Ended up having to take it to court because they couldn't agree on who would get the air miles. The darn air miles.
8points

#12

66 Times Family Feuds Shocked Lawyers When People Actually Brought Their Petty Fights To Court
This actually happened during my parents' divorce.

My mom worked a boatload to put my dad through school and him not working a day in his life. He got a job with a huge paycheck, nice retirement benefits, the works. So he immediately divorces my mom.

Judge rules that because she financed his school and supported him throughout, my mom gets spousal benefits such as her own retirement plan from the company, a good deal of his money, etc.

My donor knew my mom was pretty broke and he wasn't, so he hired an expensive lawyer and told her he would drag the divorce out until she had not a penny. Fought to get full custody of me when he honestly never wanted to see me again because he had partying to do. A real jerk.

He told my mom that he would stop if she signed away all her rights to a retirement package, income, etc. Eventually she did.

I grew up dirt poor and a lot of nights my mom went without dinner. All because he wanted all the money. I hate him for what he did to her.
8points

According to a study, divorce has negative effects on physical and mental health. Researchers explained that “conflict” was one factor that had a big influence on divorce. 

“Across genders, higher levels of divorce conflict were found to predict worse mental health, even when accounting for other socio-demographic variables and divorce characteristics,” the experts added. 

#13

Stressed lawyer sitting on a couch, shocked by petty family feuds.
I work as a paralegal at a family law firm. The number of people that will fight their ex for months over something like $200 equivalent is too darn high. Just between the email exchanges and asking us to file anything with the court, they've already racked up that much or more in legal fees.

Just. Let. It. Go.
8points

#14

Not family court lawyer, but family friend going through custody battle. She was trying to file for full custody (however she's nuts) the couple has twins. The night before it was her day she texts her ex "hey can I just have twin 1? I really can't handle twin 2."

She's discussed how she likes one twin more, that twin has coped better with this messy divorce. The other one has definitely shown some behaviors (my mom babysat for the husband who is a close friend when he was trying to figure out his schedule) good news is, looks like dad might be getting full custody!
8points

#15

Late to the thread and likely buried, but oh well.

The dad had visitations on every Saturday. Mom would keep the kid up all Friday night so all the kid would want to do during dad day is sleep, as opposed to any bonding father son time.
Report
8points

Research also emphasizes that divorced and separated individuals have significantly higher rates of depression and anxiety than married counterparts, roughly twice the rates. In fact, mental health tends to worsen after divorce for most people, with gradual recovery over 2-3 years for most individuals. The period of highest psychological distress is typically in the year immediately following separation.

It adds that divorce activates sustained physiological stress responses that, over time, affect physical health. It could lead to elevated rates of immune dysfunction, cardiovascular disease, and sleep disorders among divorced individuals. These petty conflicts could also add to the stress.

#16

A thoughtful young person sitting in a hoodie, illustrating personal stress during intense family feuds
As an intern, I saw a couple have long, hateful emails about who was going to keep a designer hoodie. Almost all of their discussions centered on that one hoodie. When in the end the husband got to keep it, the wife cut holes into it which ruined it. It was pretty nice tbh.
7points

#17

Happy couple relaxing in bed, symbolic of relationships damaged by family feuds.
As an intern in law school I saw a case where the father was likely going to get an unfavorable custody and support arrangement so he claimed the mother was unfit. His basis? She's into funky bedroom stuff and has a new boyfriend. He insisted on telling the court specifically what she likes in bed even though he admitted that the children never saw or were subjected to any of these acts. He did it just to embarrass the mother.
7points

#18

Patient reading in bed, highlighting emotional stress in bitter family feuds
Client's spouse of decades gets a terminal cancer diagnosis about half way into a fairly routine medium/high asset divorce. My client is such a viciously horrible person, saying they were glad that the spouse was sick, that the opposing party's literal last wish is to be divorced and never see a spouse of 30+ years again.
7points

Surprisingly, some parents don’t realize that while their petty fights affect them, they also harm their children. Experts highlight that children are particularly vulnerable to insecurity because they rely on their parents and other family members for food, shelter, emotional well-being, and any number of other things. 

“When children see their parents fighting, they may feel less sure about whether their parents can provide all of these important things, including love and emotional support. Worse, when children witness conflicts between their parents, they often worry they are to blame, even if the conflicts don’t involve them at all. If children blame themselves, they may also worry that their parents will reject or resent them for causing problems in the family,” they add.

#19

66 Times Family Feuds Shocked Lawyers When People Actually Brought Their Petty Fights To Court
It wasn't my case, but I was waiting in the courtroom and heard a divorce hearing. The parties were having trouble reaching a full settlement agreement. The problem? They couldn't agree on custody. But not in the usual way. Each one of these self-absorbed adults couldn't seem to fit the four-year-old kid into their schedule. "I work Fridays, your honor, so I can't take him." "Yeah, Fridays aren't good for me, either. In fact, I'm usually on-call all weekend." "Me, too, but I have to miss Tuesdays in order to take him already, so she should have to take Fridays off."

Broke my heart.
7points

#20

Planted glass fish tank representing a unique item involved in petty family feuds
I've seen clients spend $10,000 fighting over a $100 fish tank... It's often not about what you end up with, its about what they don't end up with...
7points
35
3