Bored Panda
“Kidnapped My Would-Be Mugger”: 35 Personal Truths That Might Sound Made Up
CuriositiesJUL 2, 2025

“Kidnapped My Would-Be Mugger”: 35 Personal Truths That Might Sound Made Up

46
5
There's a documentary about Trevor Noah called You Laugh But It's True. It tells how he used his childhood experiences as fodder for an upcoming stand-up comedy show. Some of Noah's stories, growing up in apartheid South Africa, seem so far-fetched that they can't possibly be real. But as the saying goes, you can't make this sh*t up.
The former Daily Show host isn't the only one with life experiences that might have people wondering "What in the big, fat lie is this?" Many of us have personal anecdotes that could be construed as nothing short of a lie. But in reality, they are God's truth. Or so we claim. For real.
A curious person once asked, "What is something about yourself that is completely true but that nobody would believe?" and netizens didn't hold back. The question clocked over 8,000 comments, as people shared the things that "allegedly" happened to them. One person even told how the legendary Nelson Mandela walked them to school on a remote island in the Indian Ocean...
Bored Panda has gone through the responses to select the best and you'll find them below. Keep scrolling and feel free to add your own unbelievable tales in the comments section at the end.

#21

Man with a microphone on stage performing, representing 75 people sharing hard-to-believe stories about themselves
Peter Gabriel complimented me on my guitar playing when I was 5.

TDAM:

Were you on your way to making it big time?

pseudomugil (OP):

Nope! We lived near one of his houses and had his family over for tea. His son also pushed me into a pond.
20points

#22

“Kidnapped My Would-Be Mugger”: 35 Personal Truths That Might Sound Made Up
I can wake myself up if I don't like the dream I'm in.

mudokin:

I often can go back to the dream I had if i like to continue the story. I have some favorite dreams and abilities that reoccur.
20points

#23

“Kidnapped My Would-Be Mugger”: 35 Personal Truths That Might Sound Made Up
The great memelord Rick Astley is actually my uncle, he's a legend on and off the internet.
20points

#24

I've died once, I was hit by a car and was left in the street for 20+ minutes, my pancreas liver and small intestines were ruptured, I broke my left elbow, left shoulder, left collar bone, right wrist, pelvis in 6-8 places and my skull. They declared me legally dead for about 10 minutes in the ambulance but were able to resuscitate me. I had Amnesia for a month, and lost the majority of my memories before the age of 13. This year was my 13 year anniversary of it happening. I'm mostly fine now but I have a limp when I get tired most people believe I did in fact get hit they just believe the part of me dying.

Edit: I was also in a coma for a month.
19points

#25

“Kidnapped My Would-Be Mugger”: 35 Personal Truths That Might Sound Made Up
I'm a completely white female from the east of England with a ridiculously rare genetic heart condition that's most commonly found in Asian men. It killed my father when he was 50 and is likely the reason my grandad has had 4 heart attacks and needs an internal defibrillator. Hooray for genetic f*ckiness.
19points

#26

“Kidnapped My Would-Be Mugger”: 35 Personal Truths That Might Sound Made Up
Not nobody, but synesthesia is hard to explain to people without synesthesia and I've had people accuse me of making things up.
19points

#27

“Kidnapped My Would-Be Mugger”: 35 Personal Truths That Might Sound Made Up
It’s always that I was a serious alcoholic. I am a nice 29 year old girl with glasses and 2 degrees, heading to grad school to study psych. About a year ago I was held against my will in the psych ward for 6 days after drinking non-stop for 3 months.

Whenever I tell people I’m in recovery they’re like “oh, like it’s preventative?” Or they compare me (without knowing much about me) to other “real alcoholics” they have encountered. It’s annoying but at this point I’m ok with the fact that I seem extremely innocent, even though I’m generally not.
19points

#28

“Kidnapped My Would-Be Mugger”: 35 Personal Truths That Might Sound Made Up
People don't believe i have tourettes for some reason? Even tho my tics are super obvious???? When I tell them and then twitch they go "NAH THAT WAS FAKE" like???????? Who would WANT tourettes its f*****g awful????????????
18points

#29

“Kidnapped My Would-Be Mugger”: 35 Personal Truths That Might Sound Made Up
I’m allergic to paprika, I live in maryland. Maryland has this spice called Old bay, this has paprika in it.

The amount of people who honest to god do not believe I can be allergic to Old Bay is ridiculous. So much so one of my ex friends who knew about my allergy invited me to her birthday party where all they had was Old bay crabs.

I had an allergic reaction and literally couldn’t even be inside the house without it happening so I just left.

But her and a LOT of people think I lie about my allergy for “quirky” points or something. Not even family believe me despite me having reactions in front of them 🙄.
18points

#30

I have hyper dense muscle and bone mass. Im really strong and hard to break, but also super heavy. Im 6'5", but normal build, and I weigh over 300 lbs, and I do not float. No one believes me until I either a) demonstrate the stronk, b) weigh myself, or c) almost drown for the millionth time.
18points

#31

“Kidnapped My Would-Be Mugger”: 35 Personal Truths That Might Sound Made Up
A whale hit me with her tail and broke my rib while i was trying to save her and her pod. (50+ pilot whales beached themselves on a beach i lifeguarded). I doubt anyone would believe me had there not been witnesses (the beach patrons helping with the whales with the lifeguards).
17points

#32

“Kidnapped My Would-Be Mugger”: 35 Personal Truths That Might Sound Made Up
I am a quarter Cherokee, but I am a redhead with pale skin. Grandmother was from Ireland on my Mother's side. While my grandfather was 100% Cherokee on my Mother's side. My Father's side is 100% English.
17points

#33

I can barely remember details past a few months ago, I have essentially no recollection of what things look like. Big events and things like that work fine, but details are gone and half the time I cant tell if I actually remember something or I remember someone telling me about something.
Report
16points

#34

“Kidnapped My Would-Be Mugger”: 35 Personal Truths That Might Sound Made Up
I had a house with an indoor pool at age 25. Made 15k on the weekends playing blackjack in Vegas. I was retired at 26, and then homeless and bankrupt from divorce at 28.
16points

#35

Man sitting in kitchen with a microwave mess, showing a hard-to-believe story about himself in a frustrating moment
I was the guy who microwaved an entire carton of eggs in the microwave in the break room last month.

Anon:

Had a guy do this on board a deployed Navy ship. 2 dozen, one in each microwave on the aft mess deck. Half of each dozen was hardboiled. It was a f**kin terrible sight. Then the mess crank guy lost his absolute s**t on the dude. Beat the p*ss out of him, they both got busted down a rank and pay taken. Guy that did it was an E-5 prior to this. He went to E-4 and 3 months of mess hall duty. Other dude had some other s**t goin on entirely in his life with a girl back home. He went U.A. in Turkey and as far as I know was never found. They ended up replacing both microwaves because the smell would come back when they were used.
11points
46
5