Marriages fall apart. It’s an ugly part of life that many people experience. To put that into context, a 2023 survey by the Pew Research Center found that over 1.8 million Americans have divorced.
The next two-fold question then becomes, “What caused the split?” and “Was it amicable?” These are important queries recently posed by a Reddit user, which received a flood of responses.
People shared what led to the dissolution of their relationships, and whether they ended in peace or became messy affairs everyone would rather forget. If you wish to share your own experience, the comments section below is open for you.
#41
Caught her cheating, I tried to work through it to keep the family together for 3 years. She didn't work through it like she swore she wanted to and she kept cheating. I eventually couldn't take it anymore and told her I was leaving. We didn't have assets or money to fight over really so I just gave her the car and let her keep everything we owned because I didn't care to fight over what little we did have. I left with my clothes, my car and my Xbox. I just wanted to be done. We separated, coparented well and neither of us even filed for divorce until 7 years later when she got pregnant by her current boyfriend. MD law says you have to be separated for a year before a divorce can be finalized but because we were already apart for so long it only took a couple months for the divorce to be finalized. We split custody 50/50. These days we co parent well and We all get along great now. We are so much better apart then we ever were together.
Report
8points
#42
I had a time where I wasn't doing great mentally. Realized that while I had supported her through all of her down times and through all of her problems that she just wasn't interested in putting in that effort for me. Tried to make it work for a while, but she just resented me more and more for being depressed. So I ended up frustrated at her resentment. Spiraled the drain for a little bit until she ended up being emotionally unfaithful, then physically unfaithful (different people).
I made up a list of changes and steps I needed to see if I was going to continue trying or else I wanted a divorce. She agreed to try but was actually discussing us getting a divorce with friends the whole time. We eventually split. The divorce itself was amicable, but we aren't.
I made up a list of changes and steps I needed to see if I was going to continue trying or else I wanted a divorce. She agreed to try but was actually discussing us getting a divorce with friends the whole time. We eventually split. The divorce itself was amicable, but we aren't.
Report
7points
#43
We just ended up not being very emotionally compatible. I did not realize what you need to do to maintain a healthy relationship, and she, with her twice divorced dad as a role model, chose to start having an emotional affair with a new guy.
The fact that we met and fell for each other while she was engaged to someone else, in hindsight, was a harbinger of my own fate.
Fairly amicable as these things go. No kids and not married for very long.
The fact that we met and fell for each other while she was engaged to someone else, in hindsight, was a harbinger of my own fate.
Fairly amicable as these things go. No kids and not married for very long.
Report
7points
#44

Answering for my wife.
The husband went from "he" to "she" and didn't want to raise their child or stay married. Left the country and doesnt pay child support. Used to have a weekly call with the child, then it became monthly, now its every couple months maybe.
The grandparents on that side are nice though and watch the child for a weekend about once a month.
The husband went from "he" to "she" and didn't want to raise their child or stay married. Left the country and doesnt pay child support. Used to have a weekly call with the child, then it became monthly, now its every couple months maybe.
The grandparents on that side are nice though and watch the child for a weekend about once a month.
Report
7points
#45
I had been depressed and she stopped wanting to be around me. Stopped allowing/inviting me to hang out with her friends and coworkers and eventually she got black out drunk and told one of my best friends that she was trapped in a loveless marriage. I tried to make it work by going to therapy and having us go to couples therapy but she didn’t want to try to make it work.
Through couples therapy I was able to see that she blamed me for literally every aspect of the relationship and was unable to take accountability for anything she did to harm our relationship. She wanted the divorce, and I wanted us to work on our relationship, but after doing couples counseling I realized she had just learned to hate me and blame me for everything bad in her life. However she also said she wanted to “remain friends” after telling me some truly vile [things], and I told her I was not really interested in trying to be friends with someone who was that awful to me. So I guess not really amicable at all.
Through couples therapy I was able to see that she blamed me for literally every aspect of the relationship and was unable to take accountability for anything she did to harm our relationship. She wanted the divorce, and I wanted us to work on our relationship, but after doing couples counseling I realized she had just learned to hate me and blame me for everything bad in her life. However she also said she wanted to “remain friends” after telling me some truly vile [things], and I told her I was not really interested in trying to be friends with someone who was that awful to me. So I guess not really amicable at all.
Report
7points
#46
She cheated on me saying she wanted to go on an “intimacy journey”. But was calling another man husband behind my back. We have a kid together.
Report
7points
#47
I had been unhappy for a long time, which is a long story in and of itself, but the last nail in the coffin was that he got drunk and tried to force himself on my sister (who was living with us at the time) while I was out of town. She told me the next day after finding a relative to stay with, and I returned right home to kick him out and change the locks.
Report
7points
#48

To this day I still don’t truly understand why she split up with me. I wish I did. She admitted to me at one point that she’d been lying about what the real problem was for the last few months of the relationship. Wish she’d ever told me the real problem. Maybe I could’ve done something about it.
Report
6points
#49
On paper it was mutual. However in reality, I was emotionally used by him and his mother. Would be locked in a room and be yelled at for hours on certain instances.
Report
6points
#50
Going through it right now after being together for nearly 20 years. Amazingly amicable, thank god. We still love each other tremendously, but we’re just not in love anymore, despite our best efforts. We have different priorities in life. Mine are growing up and being an adult and his are partying and drinking.
Report
6points
#51
He had bad depression issues and no motivation to do anything really. Wouldn't work, didn't want to continue school. I slowly shifted into feeling like his mother rather than partner.
Was just as well, we both ended up gay so it was gonna fail anyways.
Was just as well, we both ended up gay so it was gonna fail anyways.
Report
6points
#52

She wanted an open marriage so she could get laid while I was 1500 miles away watching my father [pass] of cancer. Real peach, that one.
Report
6points
#53
He cheated with a coworker, a probationary trainee no less, while he is a 30-year employee. 25 years younger than he is.
Not only did he cheat with the co-worker, but he set up a group chat with said coworker and one of her friends making fun of his wife and planning things to do to gas light her and cause her emotional distress. Then they would have a conversation about how crazy the wife is and wow can't believe that really upset her.
Of course when this was discovered the only thing the husband had to say for himself was "that was my private account!" Right, that he gave the wife the authenticator code to and the password to.
It's not amicable.
Not only did he cheat with the co-worker, but he set up a group chat with said coworker and one of her friends making fun of his wife and planning things to do to gas light her and cause her emotional distress. Then they would have a conversation about how crazy the wife is and wow can't believe that really upset her.
Of course when this was discovered the only thing the husband had to say for himself was "that was my private account!" Right, that he gave the wife the authenticator code to and the password to.
It's not amicable.
Report
6points
#54
He cheated with a coworker of his that I later found out was a minor. He had her over while I was out with my friends for Mother’s Day on a trip he insisted I go on. It was my first Mother’s Day. It was not amicable.
Report
6points
#55
Age gap too large, ultimately we were at different life stages. Also, he didn’t believe in mental health. Depressed? Just be happy! Yeah, no….
Report
6points
#56
Every split is a story of its own, some wild, some sad. For me, it was just growing apart and realizing we wanted different things in life, but we kept it civil for the kid's sake.
Report
5points
#57

He cheated, I found out. He wanted to keep talking to her as she was his soulmate. I accepted out of fear of losing him. He cheated again, with someone else. I accepted it, I have flaws too. He had a rough childhood. The therapist said cheating wasn’t the root of the problem. He wanted to start again. We did. On Valentine’s he got a call from the first girl he cheated with as he was also still in a relationship with her. I left and never looked back. It was not amicable. I felt like I got my heart ripped out of my chest, not once, not twice, but three times.
Report
5points
#58
Just found out it was an affair- which she denied. Gaslit the [hell]out of me. Her new guy left his wife four days after mine left me.
I just found out two years later after meeting his ex-wife. We had both gone through hell- blaming ourselves.
I just found out two years later after meeting his ex-wife. We had both gone through hell- blaming ourselves.
Report
5points
#59
For two years I asked for change. He treated me like a roommate more than a wife. By the end of the two years I asked to end things. He was surprised, and admitted that he expected me to stay with him even though he knew I was unhappy. Admitted to me later he had been avoiding spending time with me because he knew we had issues he didn’t want to confront.
I always will wonder what could have been if he had just fixed the problems I addressed but it’s better off this way in the long run.
I always will wonder what could have been if he had just fixed the problems I addressed but it’s better off this way in the long run.
Report
5points
#60
The way my mom put it to me the other day is that my (soon to be ex) husband didn’t marry me, he hired me. He thought that as long as he paid my bills and kept me fed he didn’t have to do [anything] else. Meanwhile, I was a full time, live in housekeeper, dog sitter, groomer, and trainer, therapist, [entertainer] chef, I could go on. He’s very emotionally immature and has no idea how to regulate them so I was managing his emotions on top of mine. And with allllll of that, he was still a [jerk] to me.
He’d randomly insult my interests and hobbies, he would dismiss any little problem I had whether it had anything to do with him or not, and when my problems DID have something to do with him, it was hell trying to communicate that to him because he would freak out, hyperventilate, hit himself in the head.
Then when I told him I was finally ready to leave, the very next day he had appointments set for individual mental health counseling for himself, professional dog training, an appointment with a cardiologist (all the men in his family have had heart attacks at one point or another and he knew he was having heart problems but refused to see anyone about it, that forced me to console him at least once a week when he’d convince himself he’s having a heart attack) and all that did was solidify to me that he could have done the work but just didn’t think it was worth it. My misery meant nothing to him, he only cared that he was about to lose His Wife. His Thing. So no I would say it was not very amicable.
He’d randomly insult my interests and hobbies, he would dismiss any little problem I had whether it had anything to do with him or not, and when my problems DID have something to do with him, it was hell trying to communicate that to him because he would freak out, hyperventilate, hit himself in the head.
Then when I told him I was finally ready to leave, the very next day he had appointments set for individual mental health counseling for himself, professional dog training, an appointment with a cardiologist (all the men in his family have had heart attacks at one point or another and he knew he was having heart problems but refused to see anyone about it, that forced me to console him at least once a week when he’d convince himself he’s having a heart attack) and all that did was solidify to me that he could have done the work but just didn’t think it was worth it. My misery meant nothing to him, he only cared that he was about to lose His Wife. His Thing. So no I would say it was not very amicable.
Report
5points

