Bored Panda
30 Marvel Actors That Might’ve Starred In Completely Different Roles
Movies & tvMAR 3, 2023

30 Marvel Actors That Might’ve Starred In Completely Different Roles

24
2
Could you imagine a world where Tom Holland is not Spider-Man or where Emily Blunt portrays Natasha Romanoff? To us, it sounds like a real travesty! However, at the same time, we’d be pretty curious to see these alternate versions of Marvel movies with the main roles played by entirely different actors than we are so used to by now. So, before the imagination and the options for alternate Marvel movie casts run wild here, come take a look at the famous Hollywood actors who also auditioned to become a part of everyone’s beloved Marvel franchise. 
So, as we’ve already mentioned, Tom Holland might’ve not become Spider-Man if not for Timothee Chalamet ‘completely blowing’ his audition way back in 2015. Now, we cannot say that we aren’t intrigued by the idea of Timothee as Spider-Man! In another curious case, Amanda Seyfried might’ve portrayed Gamora if not for the actress' dislike for being, well, green. Yet, however much fun it is to imagine entirely different Marvel actors from those who actually starred in the now-iconic movies, I guess we can all agree that the producers’ ultimate choices were actually spot-on in each case, and each of the famous actors delivered their roles with gusto. And much to our delight!
Now, with the introductions done, it’s time to satisfy everyone’s curiosity and learn which of the famous Hollywood actors aimed to become the next Spider-Man, Captain America, or Thor. As you’re about to see, it was basically the whole of Hollywood! Anyway, scroll on down to reveal the possibilities gone, and once your curiosity is satisfied, share this article with your Marvel Universe-crazy friends!

This post may include affiliate links.

#21 Mark Ruffalo - Was Actually Director Louis Leterrier's First Choice For The Hulk Role In "The Incredible Hulk"

Mark Ruffalo as Hulk and Edward Norton as Hulk
Although Edward Norton played Bruce Banner in The Incredible Hulk, Mark replaced him afterward. And we must admit that it this case, we're absolutely Team Mark!
9points

#22 Amanda Seyfried — Gamora

Amanda Seyfried in movie The Dropout and Zoe Saldana as Gamora
Now, this has to be one of the funniest excuses for not taking up a role - Amanda Seyfried declined the offer to portray Gamora solely because getting green makeup each day on set would've been too much work!
9points

#23 Emily Blunt — Black Widow

Emily Blunt as Rita Vrataski and Scarlett Johansson as Natasha Romanoff
Although Emily was everyone's top choice for the role of Natasha Romanoff, she had to decline due to conflict in contracts. We sure wouldn't minded her in this movie, though!
9points

#24 Lee Pace - Was Reportedly On The Shortlist To Potentially Play Star-Lord In "Guardians Of The Galaxy"

Lee Pace as Ronan and Chris Pratt as Star Lord
We're Team Chris Pratt here! His embodiment of the characters was so spot-on. 
8points

#25 Zachary Levi - Auditioned For Star-Lord In "Guardians Of The Galaxy" And Got As Far As The Screen Tests

Zachary Levi in Thor movie and Chris Pratt as Star Lord
Still, no one beats the charm of Chris Pratt. 
8points

#26 Wilson Bethel - Got Really Far In The Audition Process For Captain America

Wilson Bethel as Bullseye and Chris Evans as Captain America
We wouldn't mind seeing Wilson as Captain America!
8points

#27 Tom Cruise — Iron Man

Tom Cruise in The Edge of Tomorrow movie and Tony Stark with Iron Man suit
Although Marvel producers were a bit reluctant to cast Robert Downey Jr. for the Iron Man role, we sure glad they went with it!
8points

#28 Saoirse Ronan — Scarlet Witch

Saoirse Ronan in Brooklyn movie and Elizabeth Olsen as Scarlet Witch
Everyone's curious about why Ronan declined the role, and we don't have the answer, either. However, it would've been interesting to see her portray the Scarlet Witch!
8points

#29 Michael Rosenbaum - Auditioned To Play Star-Lord In "Guardians Of The Galaxy"

Michael Rosenbaum as Martinex and Chris Pratt as Star-Lord
Again, we're Team Chris Pratt - sorry Michael!
7points

#30 John Krasinski - Captain America

John Krasinski as Reed Richards and Chris Evans as Captain America
A pass from us - no concrete evidence here, but we agree on the producers' choice with on this one!
7points
24
2