Bored Panda
Employers Share What Made Them Reject Job Candidates Right Away During The Interview

Employers Share What Made Them Reject Job Candidates Right Away During The Interview

17
4
Looking for a job can be frustrating. It’s an arduous process that requires a lot of time and preparation, and even with all that, it doesn’t necessarily mean that you will get the job.
But being on the other side of the process is arguably not that much easier. The hiring managers, too, have to invest a lot of time and effort into finding the right fit for a certain vacancy. But over time, it becomes easier for them to do; after talking to hundreds—if not thousands—of applicants, they know what to be on the lookout for.
Recently, a group of hiring managers delved deeper into the topic after one member of the ‘Ask Reddit’ community asked them about the subtle red flags that say, "This person won't be a good hire." They gave examples and shared stories, which might come in handy when it’s time for you to look for a job, so you might want to scroll down to find their answers on the list below and read them carefully.

#1

Employers Share What Made Them Reject Job Candidates Right Away During The Interview
A guy i know that works in the IT industry told me when a girl he interviewed for a junior Developer job had a complete meltdown and completely froze. The interview ended akwardly and that was that.

A couple days later the girl sent an email explaining she had issues with anxiety and asked for a second chance. Of course my friend gave her that chance, she nailed it and got hired. She now works as a product owner after 5 years with the company.
30points

#2

Employers Share What Made Them Reject Job Candidates Right Away During The Interview
Men that avoid eye contact or direct communication with women. Lots of men in my field (STEM) don’t want to interact with women and will answer questions from female interviewers as though the man sitting next to her had asked it. I refuse to hire anyone with that BS attitude.
28points

#3

Employers Share What Made Them Reject Job Candidates Right Away During The Interview
My favorite story of red flags was when I screened resumes for a restaurant. A couple walked in dirty, disheveled and reeking of w**d (this is long before it was legal) and asked for applications (they were paper then). They popped at the bar to fill them out and the woman goes "babe, babe, what's my zip code? I'm soooo high right now!" 


Then about 5 min later as they're handing the applications to me the guy goes "hey, are we getting interviewed now? I got kids in the car." The woman interrupted "they're fine, they're in car seats." I was horrified it was JANUARY! Ran the papers up to the owner in her office, repeated both comments. She looks outside, jots down the plate number and called the local cops. When the cops got there the two of them were trying to get free beers from the bar manager. I'm not sure what happened from there. When I clocked out the cops had them outside and CPS was involved.


So yeah. Don't come to apply for a job/have an interview high, smelling and begging for booze while your toddlers wait in the car in the cold. .
26points

In a recent interview with Bored Panda, the OP shared that they have been on both sides of a job interview—the one who wants a vacancy filled and the one looking to fill it.

“I have been giving interviews for my previous job for five years and then interviewing for a year after leaving that position,” they said, adding that, when it comes to being on the company’s side, the most challenging part of interviewing is candidates not showing up. “It’s such a huge waste of time,” they noted.

#4

Employers Share What Made Them Reject Job Candidates Right Away During The Interview
I once had a guy show up (late) with blood all over his face and clothes looking really disheveled. Typically, I don’t waste my time with people who can’t even make it to their interview on time. But this guy said that he was in a car accident on his way to the interview and got there as soon as he could.

After the interview he asked if there was any way he could get a ride back to where his car was. Believing his story, I offered him the ride. This man’s car was nearly FIVE MILES AWAY, legitimately crashed, and it turns out someone had broke into his car and stolen his child’s car seat and his stereo system during the couple hours he was gone.

I hired him. He turned out to be really difficult to work with but the guy was a programming genius. Kept him for years before he moved on.

I don’t hire liars. This guy wasn’t 1.
22points

#5

Employers Share What Made Them Reject Job Candidates Right Away During The Interview
When asked about their experience with a topic, they stick to reciting textbook definitions of terminology rather than demonstrating any understanding of how to apply it.

Had one person who was literally forwarding our questions into ChatGPT, and then reciting rambling answers that provided definitions of keywords in our questions rather than actually answering the question. Like, we'd ask "What's something a previous employer or educator has recognized you for?", and they'd answer: "Examples of things that an employer might recognize an employee for are...".
22points

The OP shared that throughout their career they have seen many “not-so-subtle red flags.” But when talking about the more subtle ones, they said that viewing working with kids as fun would be one of them.

“[A subtle red flag when hiring would be] people who thought working with kids would be ‘a lot of fun.’ While it is fun, it's also challenging, and if you're only in it for the fun, it's going to be rough,” they explained.

#6

Employers Share What Made Them Reject Job Candidates Right Away During The Interview
Showing up to the interview with a parent in tow. I've had this happen twice and both times I refused to go through with the interview. Grow up people! You don't need mommy or daddy with you at your professional job interview!
21points

#7

Employers Share What Made Them Reject Job Candidates Right Away During The Interview
I had a dude just straight up say he doesn't like black people during his interview.
20points

#8

Employers Share What Made Them Reject Job Candidates Right Away During The Interview
I once interviewed someone who told me she technically wasn't allowed to be in the building because someone on another floor had a restraining order against her.
18points

While it’s crucial for the company representative to be attentive to any of the so-called red flags an interviewee might raise, the latter should also listen carefully to what’s being said; or on the contrary—omitted.

According to Forbes, one of the red flags to indicate that the company itself might be something to run away from is the interviewer advising the interviewee against asking questions. In addition to that, they might respond with vague, perfect answers, badmouth other people, or adorn the conversation with inappropriate questions or remarks—all of which are not ideal, either, and should indicate that the company might not be a good fit.

#9

Employers Share What Made Them Reject Job Candidates Right Away During The Interview
When interviewing people I always try to find a way to subtly disagree or challenge one of their positions (whether I really disagree or not) and their reactions mostly fall in 3 categories.

1. They agree with me/take it as a learning opportunity (green flag)
2. They confidently back up their claim with supporting statements (very green flag)
3. They get defensive/territorial that I’ve challenged them (red flag).
18points

#10

Employers Share What Made Them Reject Job Candidates Right Away During The Interview
Candidate submitted a take-home test by email. They forgot to excise the text of the email reply chain with their buddy in which, if you scrolled far enough you could see: a) their buddy helped them with the test (actually, buddy did most of it) & b) the two of them weighing up the finer points of a d**g deal they were participating in.
18points

#11

Employers Share What Made Them Reject Job Candidates Right Away During The Interview
It's a really, really bad idea to be combative with the interviewer. I'm legit trying to help you succeed and I make a concerted* effort to make you feel at ease. If a question or request doesn't make sense to you, that's fine - let's talk about it. If you answer defensively, bordering on aggression, it's *really* not going to go well. And you may get the answer right but the question I'm asking myself is if I want to deal with you every day. Especially considering this was likely your best behavior.
18points

Continuing about red flags on the company’s side, Forbes also pointed out an organization requesting time-consuming, free work, asking you to do an assignment that’s not a part of the job description, constantly rescheduling or ghosting you, not giving you a chance to speak but offering you a job nevertheless, and rushing you to make an immediate decision. All of these warning signs should not be overlooked, even if you really, really, really want to get a job.

#12

Employers Share What Made Them Reject Job Candidates Right Away During The Interview
He cried. Never had that happen before and threw me off. He was unemployed and really needed a job. He was not a good match for the job he applied for, but the recruiter and me gave him tips and tricks for the next interview. Hope he made it.
18points

#13

Employers Share What Made Them Reject Job Candidates Right Away During The Interview
They are wearing pajamas. I had to hire entry level staff to work for an airline - everything from checking people in to pushing wheelchairs and throwing luggage. Over the course of 2 weeks of hiring I had 3 different people show up for interviews wearing their pajamas (one of them had a robe a doo rag, and a beat up stuffed animal and kept sucking on a pacifier).

Needless to say, I didn't hire any of them, but, to this day I still don't get why they bothered to set up the appointment, take the time and effort to get there, get through security, etc, but didn't think it was important to put on actual clothing.
18points

#14

Employers Share What Made Them Reject Job Candidates Right Away During The Interview
I interviewed this lady, and she brought up how she had an issue with an old coworker, and at the end of it she said the coworker died of cancer. Of course, I said "oh I'm sorry" or something similar, and she responds with "she got what she deserved."

Yeah, No thank you.
17points

Talking about the current state of the job market, the OP pointed out that the situation is quite tough at the moment. “While unemployment is down, there are not as many jobs available as there were a few years ago,” they noted. But, as for everyone looking for a job, we hope that the thread started by the OP is something you will find useful.

“I wish everyone currently looking [for a job] some good luck, and hopefully some of the advice listed here helps!” the redditor said.

#15

Employers Share What Made Them Reject Job Candidates Right Away During The Interview
I'm sorry I'm late for the interview it took a bit longer at Starbucks than I'm used to.
17points

#16

Employers Share What Made Them Reject Job Candidates Right Away During The Interview
I’d say not being aware of who you’re applying to is a big red flag.


I once worked for a local retailer in Maine, and at the time they did group interviews for potential employees. This was likely to see how well we’d be able to speak to customers and build team camaraderie.

We had just gotten to the Q&A part of the interview where everyone was asked the most low-ball question of “What do you love about the outdoors?”
Well this one older lady very loudly and proudly informed the room that she does NOT like going outside. She said it was full of animals and bugs, always got her shoes dirty, and she has everything she loves inside her house.

We were applying for L. L. Bean, whose motto is literally “Be An Outsider” so safe to say she didn’t get hired.
17points

#17

Employers Share What Made Them Reject Job Candidates Right Away During The Interview
Was giving an interview, maybe 20 minutes long. The lady being interviewed asked if she could go outside and smoke a cigarette.
15points

#18

Employers Share What Made Them Reject Job Candidates Right Away During The Interview
Subtle: he didn't have enough characters in his CCNA certificate number.

Less subtle: I looked it up while his would-be boss asked him some softball questions. Once Cisco said it couldn't be found/tracked, I asked him what was going on. "Oh I'm working on it, should have it in 6 months."

Yeah, Cisco doesn't give a CCNA cert to someone that's still working to pass the test.
15points

#19

Employers Share What Made Them Reject Job Candidates Right Away During The Interview
Had a management position open and a quality applicant came in on time and was well-dressed for interview. Halfway through we had a great interview and I could sense he was already sure he had the job. His body language started changing and he relaxed more and more, pushing back from the table and stretching his arms, eventually a full backstretch with a yawn. Then he proceeded to order pizza for his daughter and himself so it would be there when he got home. He started discussing the commute and how much time he would have to dock from the workday for that. Shook his hand and never spoke to him again.
15points

#20

Employers Share What Made Them Reject Job Candidates Right Away During The Interview
When I call in a group to interview I give simple instructions. Bring Your ID, a pen, a piece of paper. 90% of the people who show fail to bring those 3 things and immediately get rejected. Can't follow simple instructions then why in the hell would I trust you with #1000's of equipment on jobs where you could cost me 10s of $1000s.
14points
17
4