Bored Panda
40 Times People Were Shocked To Discover The True Colors Of A Person They Idolized
CuriositiesOCT 17, 2025

40 Times People Were Shocked To Discover The True Colors Of A Person They Idolized

37
16
Sometimes, we forget that nobody's perfect. We hear an album that speaks to our heart, so we decide to learn more about the artist who made it, and three days of binge-watching their interviews later, we set the picture as our phone screen, convinced they can do no wrong. But there's a reason they say you need to separate the person from the craft. Actually, a bunch of reasons. And they're listed on this Reddit thread where disappointed fans reveal how they learned about their idols' dark side.

#21

Man with long hair and beard wearing a brown coat and patterned scarf, illustrating disappointment in someone idolized.
I thought I was in love with Jared Leto. I came very, very close to getting a 30 Seconds to Mars tattoo. Ick.
19points

#22

Black and white photo of a famous rock band portraying idolized musicians who led to disappointment for many fans.
Pretty much every old rockstar. John Lennon and Jim Morrison were people I looked up to when I was in highschool. Eventually I learned about who they really were and it sucked. Jim Morrison in particular.
18points

#23

Elderly man with a confident expression in a dimly lit room, reflecting moments of disappointment in someone idolized.
James Watson (of Watson and Crick). When I was studying to be a molecular biologist I thought he was all that.

I met him a few years into my career. A complete heel, jerk, and sleaze.
16points

#24

Man with a beard and suit looking thoughtful during a discussion about disappointment in someone idolized on stage.
Man, I was super into Jordan Peterson circa 2017 as a young black woman. 

Like super annoying, flying to lectures, trying to get multiple ppl to read 12 rules.

It helped me so much I wanted other people to feel empowered.

His might be the biggest let down because before he fell into the right wing grift I know for a fact his psychology lectures could have really helped a lot of people learn to understand themselves and pay attention to their behavior in the world.
16points

#25

Young man in a gray suit with arms crossed, looking serious outdoors capturing disappointment in someone they idolized.
Well, I didn't idolize him but definitely looked up to him, guy I went to College with and we're still in the same friend group many years later, kind of. We knew he wasn't the greatest guy in the world and then: Served in Congress and while in DC he cheated on his wife (the mother of his 3 young children) often, she found out when her Gyno told her she had an STD; He became Governor of my state and early in his 3rd term had to accept a plea deal with the feds, resign, go to federal prison; He learned nothing, basically told the feds "Catch me if you can", they did, he went back to federal prison again.
12points

#26

Man in suit and glasses showing disappointment during a meeting, illustrating times people were disappointed in someone they idolized.
A mangaka from Japan came over to Honolulu and opened a manga workshop for potential students. I signed up, and was one of the eight or nine. Since the mangaka was Japanese and didn’t speak any English, and I was the only one who spoke Japanese (my mom’s Japanese), I was made the interpreter/representative despite being the youngest of the group, and I hadn’t even graduated then.

At first, I agreed to the task, but here’s the thing; I didn’t know all these jargons and terms used by mangaka (that’s one of the reasons why I signed up to the class in the first place), and I was new to digital drawing (I didn’t have a tablet back then), so I wasn’t doing a good job at it, and he’d chew me out for “making (his) lessons not go smoothly”. Just to be clear, I wasn’t being paid for it.

He also made me translate documents and such for other things, and I helped out, but over time, I came to the realization that he was just using me. He even tried to make me get a job as a tutor at the place where he held his classes, and tried to take my pay, but since I wanted to focus on my studies, I declined, which he wasn’t too pleased about.

I later confronted him, and when I told him that I’m not his servant, he snapped back at me, saying that he wasn’t being paid to teach us at all. Ultimately, I just dipped from that group and went no contact.
12points

#27

Young Michael Jordan in a suit holding a basketball jersey with his name and number 23, a moment of idolized sports disappointment.
I loooOOOOOooved Michael Jordan as a kid , he was marketed as this almost superhero .

Michael Jordan as an adult? Ugh what a disappointment. By all accounts hes a miserable SOB.
11points

#28

Singer with large bow headpiece performing on stage, illustrating moments people were disappointed in someone they idolized.
I defended Sia's movie on Instagram before it came out, assuming that surely it wouldn't be that bad, until denial faded, I saw the movie, and now I look back and cringe.
11points

#29

Young man looking disappointed and thoughtful while sitting at a desk with papers, illustrating disappointment in someone idolized.
Had a huge crush on James Franco. He was kind of my first celebrity crush. Well, he turned out to be yet another creep. Absolutely loathe that my younger self was all full of butterflies watching him in Spider Man.
11points

#30

Cartoon character with a headset sitting on a blue bean bag, symbolizing disappointment in someone they idolized.
Way back in the early era of Youtube when all the classic big names like Markiplier and Pewdiepie were just getting their start, there was another big Lets Player who went by Cryaotic and would often hang out with them and do videos together. Cry's style of Lets Play was a lot more chill and relaxed and he had a cute voice and funny sense of humor, so I actually liked his videos the most out of the three. His upload schedule slowed down after a while and he didn't seem to transition into the streamer era as well as other creators did.

Then in 2019 he admitted to grooming several teenage girls behind his fiance's back.
10points

#31

Man sitting on couch with hands on forehead looking disappointed, reflecting on times people were disappointed in someone idolized
Never exactly idolized him but my dad. As a kid I knew he had “quirks” but I still thought he was a regular, okay dad like everyone else. Took my adolescence and 20s to realize he’s just not a good person.

He was never a good husband and father per se, but he really checked out on life when his mom passed away (when I was around 17). I’m 26 now, and I’m nearing the stage of cutting contact with him and calling it.

Divorced my mom last year and is already engaged to this woman who he was clearly seeing while he was still married. There’s no blatant horrible thing. Just a…bad person. He’s very selfish and a terrible communicator. He gave me anxiety as a kid and I’m now seeing all the turmoil he put my mom thru.

It’s just not worth it to pretend to have a relationship with him now. Figuring it out each day, but we’ll see ¯_(ツ)_/¯.
9points

#32

Confident man in a checkered suit with a beard, representing moments people were disappointed in someone idolized.
Don’t know if I’d go so far as to say I “idolized” the guy, but I used to be a **HUGE** Conor McGregor fan. His star was rising at the same time that I was getting really into MMA, and my first experience sports betting was when he knocked out Jose Aldo. His fight style was massively entertaining, and his trash talk even more so.

Then he really revealed who he was. Yikes.
9points

#33

Person looking out window with mountain view, reflecting on feelings of disappointment in someone they idolized.
My husband left me nearly 5 weeks ago after 15 years. No warning, except he'd made especially close friends with my son's best friend's mother - who separated from her second husband at the beginning of the year.

They're now dating.
9points

#34

Chef disappointed in someone they idolized cooking in a commercial kitchen wearing a white hat and face mask.
My former executive chef. Dude was an amazing mentor and Chef, but twice now he has burned me at different restaurants, abandoning the project and leaving me to deal with it.
7points

#35

Girl in denim outfit sitting against a wall with face in hands, capturing disappointment in someone they idolized.
My parents. It’s hard to call them “pieces of trash,” but the older I got, the more I really saw how awful they could be. How bad they messed up my brother and me. Thankfully my mom has changed a lot. She still randomly apologizes lol. My dad.. less so.

I remember stumbling on an old journal entry from when I was a teenager, idolizing my mom and wishing I could be like her. I cringed reading it lolol. Thank god that didn’t happen!
6points

#36

A man and woman posing together, illustrating moments people were disappointed in someone they idolized.
Chris Benoit.

Small guy in a big man's world who pushed himself constantly to try and make it. I felt the same was always the smallest dude out all the people around me and it always felt like they were ahead of me, he perseverance was something I wanted to copy. Those last moments of his life as well learning he was actually quite aggressive towards his wife make it impossible to look at him the same.
5points

#37

Three young wizards in robes holding a broom and books, representing disappointment in someone idolized.
I used to think Harry Potter was the height of fiction, the pinnacle but… I grew up. Now I see its flaws and what’s worse is the woman who wrote it has shown herself to be the enemy of all that I love.
5points

#38

Bearded man speaking at a panel event, representing moments when people were disappointed in someone they idolized.
Ben Kissel from the Last Podcast on the Left.

Everyone knew he was an alcoholic but no one knew that he got physical with women while drunk.

I still keep up with some of his stuff but the dude has major issues that he needs to work through.
5points

#39

Smiling man in a blue jacket, representing disappointment in someone they idolized in a popular culture context.
Not as prominent of those here, but Michael Phelps.

I was a competitive swimmer growing up through high school. Was lucky enough to be doing this in Michigan around the time of Phelps' then-historic gold medal wins in the Olympics. There was a special swim camp program hosted but University of Michigan that REALLY drilled you hard and taught advanced techniques. The US Olympic swimmers trained in the same facilities when we weren't using them. There was a point where you got to meet the Olympians too, and I'll never forget that Phelps' wouldn't smile when with these young teenagers who adored him.

Immediate loss of respect. Play the part, you are literally inspiring a generation of athletes behind you - be the role model they need you to be.

(The Vanderkay brothers though - now THEY were freaking cool. We were doing breathing and muscle relaxation/meditation training on the large patio outside the pool room. The Vanderkays came out shortly after we began and snuck around us to another sunny spot and began planking. Our exercise was 30 minutes long. We left - they were still planking, and just smiling and lightly chattering to each other. Huge respect).
4points

#40

Bald man in a suit with a blue tie posing formally in front of American and state flags, symbolizing disappointment in someone idolized.
John Fetterman, when he was campaigning I was all in and voted for him. After he got elected, he switched to a hardcore republican and didn’t so anything he said he would do. I guess he had a stroke which may of caused the sudden switch, but it doesn’t excuse the fact that he’s nothing to me now.
0points
37
16