I'll start first and post mine.
It's all selfmade and fun fact: the skirt is an old bedsheet :D
Anyways, I'm Mary Sanderson because we made a Hocus Pocus 2 Movie Halloween Party (:
#1 Selfmade Mary Sanderson Halloween Costume With Witch Potion Punch
1point
#2 William Afton, Also Self Made, It’s Cardboard Covered In Cloth And Paint
1point
#3 Sorry, Not A Great Picture, But I Was A Crazy Cat Lady!
1point