Bored Panda
64 Medical Professionals Who Knowingly Or Accidentally Violated HIPAA

64 Medical Professionals Who Knowingly Or Accidentally Violated HIPAA

44
5
If there’s one place that is rife with sensitive personal data, it’s hospitals. It’s why the United States federal government legislated the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) in 1996, which aimed to protect patients’ private information. 
But sometimes, it’s the healthcare workers themselves who disregard these protocols, seemingly neglecting the consequences that would affect them and their patients. 
Recently, people on Reddit discussed some of the most blatant and egregious HIPAA violations, a few of which may leave you questioning the integrity of the system. Fortunately, there is a silver lining: many of these erring individuals got the comeuppance they deserved. 

#21

Laptop on a desk with blurred background, representing cases of medical professionals lacking respect for patients privacy.
Nurse at a private clinic left her laptop facing outwards on the receptionist’s desk. I saw everybody’s names who had scheduled surgery that day and what procedure they were getting

RIP to the lady in for a buccal fat removal.
19points

#22

My mother was a medical assistant for a respected neurologist that was used by the local judicial system for evaluations of individuals either pleading insanity or suspected as being such. When I was in the second grade, there was a local murder case in which a mentally disabled kid in his late teens s****************d and m******d a little girl. He turned out to be the son of a teacher at my school.

One night after my mom returned from work, she was telling our family how exciting her day was because the authorities had brought the suspect in for neurological analysis and she was the one that got to hook him up to the EEG. She went into full detail of how he was wearing a jumpsuit and that he was shackled and had to shuffle everywhere. She even went as far as to do an imitation of him walking around.

My eight year old mind was thrilled with the exciting news I was going to share with my whole class. The following morning, I did just that. I recited word-for-word everything my mom had told me. I even mimicked her shuffle. My teacher stood there with her mouth open and asked me to stop talking about it. She then made the mistake of telling the rest of the class that it wasn't something to share with others. Obviously, the whole school knew about it by the end of lunchtime. Thank God the suspect's mom had taken an extended leave of absence due to the circumstances, or things could have ended very differently. I'm not 100% sure what happened, but my mom found out about it. What I think it was is the school secretary, who happened to be a patient of the neurologist (something else I shouldn't have known, come to think of it) must have caught wind of it and called my mom at work.

However she found out, when she got home that night, my mom was furious with me. She spent most of the evening gaslighting me into believing that I had made it all up. She told me to stop telling lies and to quit making up such outrageous stories. It's the first time I remember her using gaslighting as a manipulation tactic with me.

She's so lucky she didn't end up costing her provider his career.
19points

#23

Not a healthcare worker but a few months ago I was sitting in a quiet cafe and a man at the table next to me was calling patients on speaker phone, verifying their identity via personal information (names, DOB, whole shebang), and informing them of test results and advising on subsequent treatment plans. Couldn’t believe it.
Report
19points

#24

Medical professional wearing gloves holding a patient's arm, highlighting concerns about patient privacy and respect.
I worked in a small rural healthcare clinic. By the time a patient got home after an appointment, her family already knew that she was pregnant. Good thing she was happy about it. She did not want to pursue any action against the clinic. The staff involved had some disciplinary action, but weren't fired.
18points

#25

Medical professional working at a desk during nighttime, highlighting concerns about patients’ privacy in healthcare settings.
A man sending patient data to some woman he met on a dating site. The woman sent proof to the boss. The man was married, not to that woman.
18points

#26

When I was in RN school, one of my classmates was assigned a female patient who had a stage 4 pressure ulcer on her coccyx--this was down to the bone and really awful looking, The wound care team had taken a photo of it and that photo was in the patient's chart.

My classmate removed the photo from the chart and took it home with her where she showed it around to to her family and also a teenage neighbor. The neighbor told her parents who were so outraged that they called the school and reported it.

When our clinical group showed up at the hospital for our next class, which was two days later, the instructor tore into her in front of the whole group. She didn't deny taking the photo, and in fact, had it in her backpack. She said she was going to return it to the chart. She apologized but didn't seem to think she had done anything too wrong.

She was kicked out of the program. We were only a month from graduation, too.
17points

#27

When my late fiancé was in the hospital with brain cancer, he had brief moments of being awake but for the most part was in a coma-like state.

I swear the hand of Fate was on me that day because I just HAPPENED to be in the room when this hospital worker came in and asked,

"Is this Mr. John Doe?"

Confused, I told him yes and he said that he was there to take him for a trach tube surgery!

I told him absolutely not, I had not been told about any surgery and it would destroy any form of communication we had left.

This guy was *pissed*. Started getting loud and arguing with me about it, saying that I just hadn't been informed properly, that he needed to take my fiancé down now, etc.

You bet I 110% sat my happy a*s on that bed where my poor fiance lay dead to the world and told the guy if he wanted to take him, he would be taking us both.

So he stormed off to find the charge nurse and never came back.

About half an hour later the charge nurse came down (bless her, she was amazing) and sheepishly admitted that there was ANOTHER John Doe in the other wing that was going for the surgery. Literally same name, just different birthday.

I assume they would have caught it when they scanned the bands and realized the birthdays didn't match up but at the time it was so stressful and stupid.

And honestly, it wasn't like it was a super common name either!
17points

#28

Not a Healthcare worker, but when I was in university, I shared a name with an oncologist who worked in the medical school attached to my university, so our emails were very similar (think sherry.white@[school].edu and sherry.white-1@[school].edu). Guess who got so many emails chok full of patient information, diagnosis, treatment plans, etc. The best was when I got invited to a very fancy steak dinner at a nice restaurant in town. I seriously considered showing up and acting all confused as to why I was invited, but I figured the doctor might be pissed that she missed out, so I did what I always did in this situation, and replied with a meme of Obi Wan Kenobi saying, "this is not the sherry white you're looking for.".
Report
17points

#29

Person with red nails scrolling on a smartphone, illustrating issues of medical professionals disrespecting patient privacy.
Know a nurse who shared a patient’s birth story in great detail on her Instagram for clout. She was reported and all the hospital made her do was delete it. No other consequences.
17points

#30

I had a coworker who was hired at the same time as me who was using our system to look up her family members. Specifically her sister in law who "thinks she's better than me" and wanted to get dirt on her. Also read through all her children's charts to see what the doctors thought about her. All our computer uses are recorded and I've even heard of people getting in trouble for hovering over a family member's name unintentionally. I'm not sure what she was thinking.
Report
17points

#31

Not a healthcare worker but long ago my husbands ex wife went to a doctor I also went to and they mixed up our charts (same last name, different first names) and called to tell me results of an STD test. It was an awkward call when I had to say I think you meant to call the ex wife, not me since I had not been in for a visit in almost a year.
16points

#32

Had Employee A ask Employee B to look up a patient on Epic for her because she needed the Facesheet and couldn't remember her login.  Then A goes on there and looks through the medical record.  Turns out it was A's baby daddies new chick's record.  A then texts husband that new chick has gonorrhea and starts popping off. B finds out about it because A was being Hella loud about it to anyone who would listen.  Needless to say A was fired and there was a staff meeting about security, passwords, and HIPAA review. .
15points

#33

I was a paramedic in a big county. The worst is the EMS to police information about a patient. You can’t just give that information out and it drives me f*****g crazy when EMS providers do. Stop licking the boots and be an advocate for your patient. The cops will have to do their own investigation and will go down legal routes to do so.
15points

#34

I did consulting at a clinic, one of the docs always took all the lab results (big stacks) home to sign off. One day the doc stopped for lunch and left about 200 patients lab results on the table.
14points

#35

Mine was when a co-worker saw the same last name as mine for a patient. Went into the chart, started going through it and saw it was a relative of mine (our name is uncommon,) and even started telling another nurse that she and I are neighbors! Fun!

No reason for her to be in that chart other than curiosity. Luckily the other nurse told me and the manager pretty quickly.

That girl had several other incidents that were small, but dumb HIPAA things that I was getting on her about. She did not last long.
13points

#36

Social worker literally yelling a minor patient’s PHI (name, DOB, medical history) across the corridor and asking mom very personal questions about the patient like gender identity and sexuality (again, loudly, yelled across the corridor from the work station she was sitting at) in full hearing range of everyone sitting there and walking by. Complaint was filed and went nowhere.
13points

#37

Male doctor with stethoscope on phone looking concerned with patient privacy and medical professional respect issues.
I was with my BIL and niece in the ER b/c they had just been in a car accident. Nothing too serious, but niece was a baby and needed a once over and BIL was having back pain. The ER doc walks into the room to speak with them when he gets a phone call. He takes the call and still in the private ER room with my family, proceeds to give (and spell) the name, date of birth, previous medical history, and current condition of another pt. We all sat there in awe. I worked in a hospital at the time and knew this was a serious violation and regret not at least giving him a courtesy ‘um, you shouldn’t be doing that,’ but I was too shocked to even speak at the time.
12points

#38

Had a celebrity come into the ER discreetly prior to a local performance. Ended up having several nurses and residents access this person's file inappropriately.

The other was a radiologist running for Congress a few years ago who campaigned on his many years of saving lives as a radiologist.. On His social media he shared an image of patient's postmortem xray of their shotgun blasted head disparaging our hospital (where he was a resident in his younger years) and our patient base. The xray clearly had the patients name on it. I got the distinct honor of burying his a*s across all media for the clear violation of patient privacy and lack of medical ethics and filing multiple complains against him.
11points

#39

I’m IT at a hospital. Wife is a nurse at ER, husband was in Radiology. They’re divorcing. Woman comes into the ER complaining of pain in her lower left quadrant, diagnosis: pregnancy. Woman is husband’s girlfriend. Girlfriend’s nurse was husband’s wife. Wife comes into divorce court and says, “his girlfriend is pregnant”


Husband didn’t know, girlfriend didn’t say, husband never disclosed girlfriend’s name. Wife just blatantly destroyed her career and alimony in one go.

Unfortunately we had to fire both of them.
11points

#40

Lots of marketing/business development departments (at least in the behavioral health field) trade patients' basic PHI as well as insurance information with their contacts at other facilities without patients' consent. It's fun calling a patient to let them know you verified their insurance when they've never heard of you nor gave permission for anyone to speak with you on their behalf.
10points
44
5