“Shhh, it’s a secret…” When we hear those words, our minds might immediately jump to the conclusion that something bad must be happening—after all, why else would someone want to keep it hidden? But hey, not every secret is dark, dramatic, or scandalous. Some are funny, heartwarming, completely innocent, or simply little things people have kept to themselves for years.
And that’s exactly what today’s collection is all about. We dove into an online thread asking, “What’s a completely harmless secret you’ve been keeping for years?” The answers range from sweet childhood memories to wholesome things people have quietly held onto for much longer than you might expect. Keep scrolling, Pandas, and you might just feel inspired to finally spill a harmless secret of your own.
This post may include affiliate links.
#41
I was 5 and took the little plastic Jesus from my grandmas nativity on Christmas. I wanted a baby for my Barbie’s to have…I felt so bad about it and I lied when asked about it. I went and buried him in the woods….im probably going to hell for that one.
Report
22points
#42
I have a friend who was trying to gain traction as a cooking content creator on YouTube but was having a hard time so when she was starting out I made a few fake accounts and posted positive comments under all of her videos encouraging her to keep going, asking questions, etc. She has a big following now and I will never, ever tell her.
Report
21points
#43
It was I who ate all the smoked salmon out of spite at the breakfast buffet my ex-boyfriend’s extended family had on a vacation.
They were not nice people.
Report
21points
#44

At a farmers market in elementary school I stole a blueberry. One blueberry.
20points
#45
I eat a lot of goat meat because when I was a kid, a goat at the petting zoo nibbled on my pinky and I didn’t like that. I tell everyone that I eat goat cuz I’m African (it’s true), but it’s 99.8% outta spite cuz of that one goat in 1990.
Report
20points
#46

Four years ago, my husband and I told the kids we were going on a “marriage weekend” together.
We went to Disney World without them.
19points
#47
My husband got a jeep 5ish years ago and he was so excited to get “ducked” and after 3 months he was kinda sad about it so I went and bought a duck and put it on the jeep while he was at work he was so excited when he came home to tell me about it.
Report
17points
#48
My mum got her first car in 1985, a week later she scratched the front of it when parking at the shops.
She didn't scratch it, I did it when it was in the garage and I taped two screwdrivers together pretending to be a ninja with a throwing star and threw it straight at the car.
Nobody tell her, she's still pissed about it.
And I'm still scared of her.
Report
17points
#49

I ate the cherry tomato.
My mother gave each of her five children 2 cherry tomatoes on their small 1960’s salad. My sister discovered one of hers was missing. We were lined up and questioned, no one confessed. My mother said we could not leave the table until the mystery was solved. After much discussion it was decided that I, the youngest would take the blame and receive the, probably softer punishment. My siblings were very nice to me for a week or so and
It was never brought up again.
It was never brought up again.
14points
#50

I replaced my dads pastrami with turkey pastrami.
In secret.
He “hates” turkey.
He said it was the best pastrami he ever had.
In secret.
He “hates” turkey.
He said it was the best pastrami he ever had.
14points
#51
I told my daughter when she was like 3 that her ears turned blue when she lied. She'd always cover them when she lied for years.
Report
14points
#52
I blamed someone for eating my lunch in the break room fridge once. I later realized it was me and I just forgot .
Report
14points
#53

When I was a teacher the kids loved playing “among us” at recess and would always ask me at the beginning of recess to choose if they are safe or the imposter. There was never an imposter. They spent all of recess being sus of each other every. single. day.
13points
#54
No one ever admitted to eating the missing hot dog out of our refrigerator in about 1994. The investigation is ongoing.
Report
13points
#55
Really only a secret from my parents but I've loved girls since I was 4 years old.
Report
11points
#56
As a former nanny:
1. I had no idea what happened if I got to three
1. I had no idea what happened if I got to three
2. I did not actually remember who went first last time we played the game
3. When I said I had an uncanny ability to make desserts perfectly equal by weight, even if one looked ever so slightly bigger visually, that was a lie.
Report
11points

