There are two kinds of houses on Halloween night. The ones that hand out the good stuff and have a line of kids stretching down the driveway, and the ones that became a cautionary tale somewhere around 2019 and never fully recovered. If you are reading this, you are clearly trying to be the former, which is already a promising sign.
Going non-candy doesn't have to mean going boring; it just means thinking slightly outside the pillowcase. The treats on this list are the ones that still land, the ones that make kids stop and look before they move on to the next house, and the ones that keep your lawn free of toilet paper come November 1st. Consider this your guide to Halloween generosity that doesn't involve a single fun-sized Snickers and still somehow wins the night.
This post may include affiliate links.
#1 Swap Sugar Highs For Rubber Duck Surprises With These Boo-Tifully Cute Halloween Rubber Ducks

Review: "I bought these to give out on Halloween. The kids loved them. They’re good quality. They’re all really cute and well made." - Dylan
Report
21points
#2 Glow Critters Are Tiny Plastic Bugs That Light Up, Cost Almost Nothing Per Unit, And Will Absolutely Be More Exciting To A Seven Year Old Than Whatever Candy Is Sitting Three Houses Down

Review: "I saw a few people say some negatives about these and saying they were small so I was hesitant to purchase them but I ended up getting two bags and glad I did. I handled them out during Halloween and the kids absolutely loved them. It was a hit. And they are not tiny. They are bigger than I expected actually for bugs. I that they were perfect." - Amazon Customer
Report
16points
#3 Halloween Slinkies Have A Thirty Second Window Between Leaving Your Hand And Hitting The Pavement, And Every Single Kid Who Gets One Will Spend The Rest Of The Walk Home Trying To Figure Out The Trick To Keeping It Going

Review: "These are such fun little Halloween favors! I love the variety of bright colors and the different Halloween prints. The designs are really cute, and with 60 pieces in the set, there are plenty for goodie bags, classroom parties, trick-or-treaters, or other Halloween events. When first taking them out, some of the coils seem to be slightly stuck, which I'm guessing is from the printing process. " - Yumi
Report
16points
#4 Beam Up The Halloween Fun With These Out-Of-This-World Glow In The Dark Alien Figurines

Review: "I hand these out whenever I go to a music festival and people absolutely LOVE receiving then. It's even better when I'm handing them out at night because then the person I'm giving the alien to can see that it glows in the dark. Tremendous value and a great product" - Carlos
Report
15points
#5 Halloween Stamps Are The Non-Candy Treat That Kids Actually Use For Weeks After October 31st, Which Makes Them The Rare Handout That Outlasts The Candy Haul By A Significant Margin

Review: "I love this item handing them out at halloween in goodie bag" - tiffany ward
Report
14points
#6 Halloween Bouncy Balls Disappear Down The Street At Approximately The Speed Of A Child Who Just Realized They Can Throw Them At The Sidewalk And Watch Them Go, Which Is Exactly What Makes Them Such A Reliable Crowd Pleaser

Review: "Great little treats for Halloween! They glow in the dark pretty well too! Would buy again! Kids loved them! Would recommend!" - Amazon Customer
Report
13points
#7 Give Trick-Or-Treaters A Hands-On Treat With These Addictively Fun Mini Pop-Its

Review: "These are great! A fun alternative to candy. I'm already a fan of these pop toys, so when I saw a whole pack of mini ones for Halloween I knew they'd be perfect for little treat bags for the kids. They're nice ones too. They're pop well and the colors are vibrant. Great for tick or treat gifts of to add into goodie bags. Also would make great prizes for kids games." - HDT
Report
12points
#8 Glow In The Dark Mini Dinosaurs Are The Halloween Handout That Gets Discovered Again At 9pm When Someone Turns The Bedroom Light Off

Review: "We used these at our daughter’s birthday party just as decor across the table with pizza and cake time and gave everyone a baggie to let the kids bring a bunch of them home after. Super fun extra accessory and love that they glow in the dark." - Emily
Report
12points
#9 Let The Kids Sculpt Spooky Creations Instead Of Munching On Sweets With These Colorful Mini Play-Dohs

Review: "I’m very satisfied with the varied package of mini Play-Dohs. There is an assortment of various colors. I plan to pass them out at Halloween as an alternative to candy for kids who would like one." - Pam
Report
11points
#10 Every Parent Standing At The End Of The Driveway Is Going To Appreciate That Glow Sticks Make Their Kid Visible From Half A Block Away, While The Kid Just Thinks They Got Something Cooler Than Candy

Review: "I bought these as non-Candy item to hand out on halloween for kids who wanted a allergy safe option - These did great, you get quite a lot n the one package I ended up having some left over. and there were lots of kids glowing down the street lol" - naluheart
Report
10points
#11 Mini Bubbles Are The Halloween Treat That Starts Getting Used At The Front Door Before The Kid Even Says Thank You, Which Is The Highest Possible Form Of Approval A Handout Can Receive

Review: "This was a good buy. My 4 year old loved it. It kept him and my 9 months old baby entertained. Love that there were so many. Size is perfect for those spills. Easy clean up." - T.X.
Report
10points
#12 Wind Up Toys Hit The Sidewalk And Immediately Create A Small Crowd Of Kids Crouching Down To Watch Them Go, Which Is Honestly More Entertainment Than Most Of The Candy On Offer That Evening

Review: "Bought these for goodie bags for my son to pass out at school for Halloween. A lot of this type of stuff out there is junk nowadays, but these far exceeded my expectations. They are sturdy and have great designs. No duplicates. The zombie hand and foot are my favorite. The kids are going to love these!" - AJ78
Report
9points
#13 Light Up Halloween Night With These Ooey-Gooey Mini Glow In The Dark Slime Treats

Review: "It’s perfect! No complaints. Great value. Nice size, great amount. Great colors. I have A classroom full of super happy kids that had better not get any on the carpets. Super FUN a great find." - Brandicakes
Report
8points
#14 Catapult Halloween Excitement To New Heights With These Bouncy Jumping Spring Launchers Popper Toys

Review: "What a cute and fun toy! Those I tested worked well. I bought these to go in my bags for Halloween trick or treaters this year. I think the kiddos will really like them and I would definitely buy these again!" - Joanie
Report
8points
#15 Slipping A Set Of Halloween Themed Finger Lights Into A Trick Or Treat Bag Is The Move That Makes Every Kid Stop Walking And Immediately Put Them On Before They Even Reach The Next House

Review: "This projected flash light is amazing. Great for kids, honestly any age past putting things in mouth stage. Great favors for classroom or to pass out during trick or treat. We do some candy and some toy options for kids to pick out each year. These are bright and crisp and clear. Easy on and off. The finger rubber band holds in place. Worth the price. Happy to recommend!" - Zombie Lincoln
7points
#16 If You Simply Can't Make Up Your Mind, A Variety Pack Of Halloween Toys Is Exactly What You Need

Review: "Good for No big expectations:) fun for halloween give away instead of candies. I don‘t expect them to last long anyways but good amount of variety." - Bora Barcin
Report
7points
#17 Finger Skateboards In The Halloween Bag Are The Treat That Immediately Gets Pulled Out On The Walk Home And Guarantees Your House Gets Talked About For The Rest Of The Night

Review: "We've added these miniature skateboards to our mystery bags at the store, and they've been a big hit with teenagers and kids. I'm pleasantly surprised by the quality of the designs and the exceptional grip they offer." - ThePlayersHub
Report
6points
#18 Uncover Secret Halloween Messages With These Mysterious Invisible Pens With UV Light

Review: "We bought these for Halloween treats- best choice ever!! My 10 year olds class went crazy when they got them. Plus there were a few extra so my 13 year old got a few to share with her friends- and they loved them too." - Comice Leet
Report
6points
#19 Few Things Clear Out A Trick Or Treat Bag Faster Than A Pack Of Pokémon Cards That Land With More Excitement Than Anything Wrapped In A Foil Wrapper Ever Could

Review: "10 more packs than were included in the 2022 Halloween bags, and a lower price as well. The card selection is well-varied per pack, so you can give these away on Halloween night or buy a bag or two and attempt to collect all of the cards in the set. Either way, the kids get a kick out of them, and they are a nice addition to the 2023 card lineup overall." - Matt
Report
5points
#20 Cheap Enough To Hand Out By The Dozen And Fun Enough That Kids Put Them On Immediately, Halloween Foam Masks Are The Doorstep Treat That Turns Your Porch Into A Brief Photo Opportunity Nobody Planned For

Review: "These were a great price and a nice non-candy option for Halloween treat bags." - Abby K.
Report
5points



