Bored Panda
29 Creepy Stories From Women Who Gave “Nice Guys” A Chance
Social IssuesMAR 13, 2025

29 Creepy Stories From Women Who Gave “Nice Guys” A Chance

45
17
If you’ve been living under a rock for awhile, first of all, congrats on getting out, second of all, you’d be forgiven for thinking that a “nice guy” means an actually nice young man. As too many people have discounted all too late, it really means the kind of guy who thinks basic human decency should be “rewarded” with romance.
Someone asked “Girls who have been guilted into going out with a "nice guy", how did it go?” and people shared their stories. So get comfortable as you scroll through, upvote your favorites and be sure to add your own examples in the comments below.

#21

Young man in sunglasses and denim jacket outdoors, embodying the "nice guy" vibe.
The date wasn't too bad, although he kept changing pretty much every single sentence he said so it would fit my interest. Something like "I like ice cream" "Cool, I like frozen yoghurt" "oh yeah, that's what I meant. Ice cream is nice but frozen yoghurt is amazing" and so on for 4 hours straight. At the end I had no idea what he was actually like.
He also kissed me in the most awkward way possible. I guess he thought it was going to be romantic and spontaneous but it wasn't. Then kissed me again when he walked me to the train station. He hugged me so hard I couldn't breath and started making weird noises (kind of like what some people do during heavy, pre s*x make out sessions, except it was a rather quick kiss in a public place).
Started texting me before I even got home and when I didn't answer, got upset. Told him he was nice but I don't think we'd work out. Said its cool, asked if we can stay friends. Silly me, I said yes.
We kept talking for about a month, during which he very "friendly" kept checking if I had slept with someone else and making sure I know how much of a s*x god he is ("you know, I once even made my lesbian friend c*m super hard"). This is also the time I met my current BF and was meeting a bunch of new people at uni, so we'd talk less and less each week.
Then one day he asked me out. I said I wasn't sure if he was completely fine with us being just friends so that wouldn't be appropriate. He went on this massive rant about how he'd actually been seeing someone else in that time, but they broke up shortly before that, how he's so over me and didn't even think I'm that hot anymore and how nothing would happen. I said no, because I was broke and couldn't fully enjoy myself while worrying about not spending too much (we were supposed to go to a Metallica concert, apparently his best friend had spent £120 on his ticket but then last minute found something better to do...) but he promised he'd take care of everything and we could chill at his place with pizza and some films, as friends. I said I could consider the concert but there's no way I'd stay over. I mentioned texting someone else to see if they would be fine with me sleeping over at theirs afterwards. He jokingly asked if it's someone I'm sleeping with and I said it's none of his business. Then he told me how much of a b***h I was for sleeping with other people and not sleeping with him, said it's so unfair that he knew me so much better but he felt like other people had more rights to me than him and that we kissed and he didn't expect me to be this slutty (btw, I did not want to kiss him, it was just so random I felt him making out with me before I even realised what his intentions were and stopped it rather quickly). The he called me a few more names, said he's such a nice guy and didn't deserve to be treated like that and we never spoke again.
Fun times.
22points

#22

29 Creepy Stories From Women Who Gave “Nice Guys” A Chance
He offered to take me to a restaurant on campus that he claimed everyone needed to experience. It was just a little sandwich diner so I figured worst case it's an hour wasted. It also seemed like several people at the party would be going because they were all telling me how great it would be and what they usually ordered and when we should go. I didn't know him very well but he seemed like the nice but awkwardly shy and quiet nerd type. Everyone liked him and I'd never heard anything bad about him. We also wouldn't be alone so what could go wrong? He offered to pick me up at my dorm and even though it was only a short walk I accepted the ride because I knew he lived farther away. Get in his van and one of the first things he says is I hope you don't mind but I thought we'd go somewhere nicer. I'm dressed down because this is essentially a flat bread pizza joint with funky artwork on the walls but realize he's in a nice shirt and pants. Feel like I can't say no because I did agree to go eat, I'm hungry, and I'm already in a moving vehicle. He drives me at least 20mins away to freaking olive garden. That's when I realized he clearly thought we were on a date and that no one else was coming.

Cue awkward conversations and just trying to finish mediocre pasta so I can go back to my dorm. Campus buses didn't even go to that part of the city so I had no way to leave without him. But it was only an awkward dinner and not quite red alert abort now. Driving back to campus he mentions his frat house is having a party and we could head over. I've been to the house dozens of time with friends and know most of the dudes so figure why not, a nice party might save this weird evening. But of course we get there and it's actually a party with a sorority so no outsider girls are allowed until after 10/11pm. It's like 8/9 at this point (memory is a little fuzzy on what the rule and actual time was). So we have to go up the back stairs and straight to his room. Get there and see his roommate is avoiding the party and think ok just need to k**l an hour, at least we aren't alone. Roommate leaves after we decide to watch star wars - don't know if dude asked him to leave or he thought we were on a date. Whatever I love star wars this works and now we don't have to talk for the next hour.

Except now I'm locked in his bedroom and he's trying to sit way too close to me. And now he's trying to put his hand on my leg. Then he switched to putting an arm around my waist and started trying to grope upwards. I'm trying to be nice and not escalate things or burn bridges because I know this one guy can get me blackballed from ever returning. (Sounds silly but a lot of my guy friends were from that house and my girlfriends all partied there. Years later I married someone I met there, so it was pretty important place in my life story). Stand up and ask for a drink hoping he has nothing in his room and luckily he only has water. Start texting a few people I know should be out there at the party to rescue me and bring a drink. He answers the door and a group of my friends see me behind him, wide eyed and pantomiming save me. No one knew I was there since we snuck in and the music was so loud you couldn't hear anything happening in the rooms. Dude tries to keep me in his room with the whole you aren't supposed to be out there yet rule but somehow my best friend is already there and pulls me out. Run away and never look back.

I never said anything about what happened except that what I thought was going to be a social dinner turned into a s****y forced date. That is until he started telling the other brothers of the house what a b***h I was and how I led him on. So then they all got to hear about what a f*****g creep he was. It wasn't supposed to be a date, I didn't flirt with him that whole night, and I definitely wasn't putting out lock me in your room and grope me vibes. Luckily everyone who mattered believed my story and not his. It also helped that the others who had been in on the initial let's go to x place together talk remembered and couldn't believe he had forced me to go to olive garden instead. Could have gone much worse but it also never should have happened.

Edit- added in paragraph spaces.
22points

#23

Denim pocket with condom, representing stories about women giving "nice guys" a chance.
I went out with this guy who my friends all loved and thought we would be great together. One night he was round mine and had to walk home. I borrowed him my walking coat so he wouldn't be soaked by the time he got home.

Next day I go to his to get my jacket in time for the weekend and he had put a c****m in the pocket with a note that just had a wink face on it.
22points

#24

Man smiling at woman in dimly lit setting, representing nice guys interacting.
Not outright guilted but more found myself in the situation and couldn’t back out. Bit weird at first given the circumstances of me distinctly not wanting to be there but things gradually got more weirder as the night went on. He made really intense eye contact and told me about how he doesn’t smoke or drink, just goes to clubs sober. Also told me about how he plans to stay in the country (he was a foreign student) but needs to settle down with someone here first. Then he told me he was *really* passionate. My d*****s asked passionate about what and he just stared at me and repeated he was *really passionate*.

It was s**t and I’m more vocal about whether or not I want to be somewhere/do something now.
21points

#25

A bouquet of flowers on a car seat with red upholstery, capturing a "nice guy" gesture.
This will get buried, but I’ll never forget that “nice guy.”

I had been homeless for 2-3 months and I said f**k it and started stripping at a local strip club. I was able to make enough cash a week to finally get a place of my own!

Instead, I wanted roommates so I could use it to go back to school. I found some guys looking for a roommate and I was able to get in there with them.

We all got along. We were all nerds. Me and 1st roommate got along GREAT. 2nd roommate was very quiet and ignored me a lot. After the 3rd month of living together, my 2nd roommate was a complete creep. He would text me ALL the time, asking where I was, who I was with. He would tell me when he graduated (he was 2 semesters away) that we could get married and I would never have to strip again.

He texted me almost every day. I fell asleep once on the couch and this dude groped me while I was asleep. He kissed me without asking. He would constantly take my purse and put it in his room so I had to TALK TO HIM and ask for my stuff was.

After about a month of that stuff, I sort of started sleeping somewhere else (at my boyfriends house or I just wouldn’t go home and stay out until 9am). I would work double shifts at the club, so 2pm until 2am just so I wouldn’t be at the apartment.

I remember this one night I got out of work at 2am and decided to drive to the beach because I didn’t want to go home yet. I’m halfway there when another club calls and asks if I want to work an after hours shift. I say ok and head back. I leave at 5am from that club and head again to the beach to watch the sunrise.

I’m about to hit the bridge to get to the island and creepy roommate calls me. Tells me to come home, that I need to be home and safe, and that he really needs to talk to me. I hang up after I tell him I don’t care and I don’t like him.

I call my other roommate and ask where creepy roommate is. Nice roommate tells me he’s just playing LoL. I flat out sighed and just hung up.

Creepy roommate calls again and tells me he’s going to k**l himself if I don’t go home to him. I hang up and call other roommate again.

Nice roommate tells me that creepy roommate took all the knives into the bathroom and locked himself in there! I’m FURIOUS. Like, this guy was 23 years f*****g old acting like a high school girl having her first break up.

I drive alllll the way back.

I run up stairs, into my apartment and knock on the door. He opens it slowly and I slam it open. I was pissed. I ask him what was SO important that I needed to be home.

He takes me downstairs to his car.

This dude KNEELS DOWN and opens the trunk to his car and there’s a bouquet of FLOWERS. And I’m like: “NO. NO. I DONT LIKE YOU.”

He takes out a paper from his pocket and reads a POEM HE WROTE.

I leave this dude there and just get in my car and take off. Like, I had been telling him almost EVERY DAY to leave alone, that I don’t like him, that I do NOT want to date him, and he just didn’t get the point.

He reached out to me like 2 years after I left that apartment. I told him to leave alone. He then called me a c*m dumpster (I had a baby with someone) and that I was trash and I was the worst thing that ever happened to him.

I hate “nice guys.”

EDIT:
I didn’t get guilted into dating him, but his friends guilted me into being just friends with him. But that’s feeding a fire that leaves permanent marks. I’ll never forget him and everything he has said and done to me.
21points

#26

A woman holding flowers while a man whispers in her ear, capturing a "nice guy" moment.
My story definitely isn't half as bad as what others have posted but my experience did send me into a hole of recluse crapiness. He liked me based on my taste of music, not actually for me. At the time (15years ago), hardstyle/trance was still underground and not like it is now in Australia. I happened to be the first girl he had met who liked this music,so he thought I was cool and wanted to date me.

He guilted me into dating him by being 'depressed' and sulking saying I 'wasn't even giving *us* a chance', that it could be something fruitful but we would never know. Big red flag should have been when his idiot friends were contacting me on ICQ (for you youngens, it was how us oldies communicated with each other back in the 1880s via instant messaging) trying to sell him to me. It was all the typical c**p of 'he's a great guy, he hasn't eaten since you turned him down. He doesn't even laugh anymore...' and all of the usual c**p.

Being naive me, I thought 'why not?'. He did seem to make a good case when he said I was denying us a chance.

He definitely proved his worth after a week of 'dating' . He pulled out all of the romantic stuff no guy ever had (even until this day). We went to different high schools, he skipped his final class of school everyday to pick me up from my school and drove me home (1/2hr drive to get to my house then another 1/2 hr drive for him to get to his home). Bought me 'no occasion' flowers, wined and dined me. I really felt stupid for turning him down at first.

A month goes by and he ends our relationship over the phone. But by this time I thought he was the best thing ever, despite not actually having anything in common. I didn't even find him funny but just the way he treated me made me feel like this is what love is meant to be. He just said he wasn't feeling it anymore. I found out the day after from a friend that there was a new girl at their school and he thought she was hot stuff so his thought process was to drop me, woo her and then live a happy life together. Turns out new girl didn't like him and he and his entourage tried the same guilt trip with her. She was a lot smarter than me to continually turn him down.
At the time, I felt like a had a huge hole in my heart. I had never been so spoilt with love in my life. I didn't know how to handle the pain so I wrote poems and listened to sad music (I remember putting 'Vertical horizon - Everything you want' on repeat). I felt stupid to tell my friends about the situation in fear of them saying 'wasn't that the creep who tried to win you over and you weren't interested in him anyway?'.

After a few months of the idiot failing to win the new girl over, guess who came crawling back. I never told him that I knew about his crush on the new girl and his failed attempts of winning her over. He said s**t like 'I realised how much I missed /love you in the last few months, I didn't know what I was thinking when I broke up with you'. It was at that moment I realised that it wasn't losing him that I was upset over, it was the feeling of being love and being spoilt that I missed. I just said 'well the last few months have made me lose feelings for you like you said you had for me'. It still sucked and took me a long time to get over the short lived month of feeling loved. Took me even longer to get over the fact that I was hurt over a bloody con man who didn't even like me for me.

Edit: holy moly, thank you for all of the messages!! I didn't think anyone would read my response being a massive long roll of text.

This was 15 years ago and this story no longer affects me, but I still remember the emotional roller-coaster ride like it was yesterday. It wasn't my first 'love', but it was the first time I felt so extremely hurt and felt 'grown up' (even for a teenager). I have dated since and am currently in a healthy long term relationship.

We all live and learn. There is a sequel to this event (story #2). After this break up, I confided in a 'nice guy' friend, Fred. Not even going to hide his name cos this guy is a stage 1000 weirdo. I told Fred how ripped off I felt and how I could not absolutely believe that I could not get over a relationship lasting only a month when I handled the break up of my 3 year relationship a lot better. He listened to all of my sorrows and said that I will get back on my feet some day. I didn't know he meant that *he* was the one to prop me back on my feet. I told him of the dirty tactics ex-boyfriend used to get me and how uneasy it had made me knowing he was a wreck because of me denying our potential relationship. So Fred thought it would be genius to ask me out the exact same way ex-boyfriend did. Gee who would have thought that would work....again..... Fool me once, amirite?

At first when I said no, he said he was only joking! He just wanted to see how I would react to his demands of dating me. Um yeh ok,I'll just let that slide. He got creepier by saying things like 'stripeypinkpants, how do you know when you love someone?' I can't remember how I dealt with that situation but I remember feeling very awkward. Anyway, he would say these things and let me stew in it.

On the veeerrryyyyy last day of school, he wanted to hang out with me which sounded like fun. Little did I know he had plans to confess his undying love for me. He leant in for a kiss which I blocked with my hand asking wtf he was doing. He sat there tearfully weeping wanting to know why I would submit to one guys demands of dating them but not his. I had enough of his s**t by this time, told him not to talk to me anymore.

He did the exact opposite of that. Would call my home phone A LOT, send me a lot of emails (yahoo days!) and rocked up to my house once (or twice?) unannounced. My mum played the role quite well of 'stripeypinkpants is in trouble and can't talk to boys!!' so he enlisted his female cousin to contact me instead. I remember her telling me 'Fred is really upset you won't give him a chance and said if you don't talk to him in the next 10 minutes, he will drive off a cliff'. Ok whatever dude, I've got other things to do.
Long story short, he did not drive off a cliff and after he was done stalking my friends and I, he eventually gave up and haven't heard from him since.
18points

#27

Woman in emotional distress, representing stories about experiences with "nice guys."
Guilted into having a 1 year relationship with one. He was super nice at first, and I was young and naive. He flirted, seemed nice and honest so I thought "what the hell? Why not give it a go?" big mistake.

Realised quite quickly that he just wasn't for me, we had very different political views, very different opinions on things, he was very degrading of me: made fun of my weight, made me think I was fat (I was not at all, always had a healthy BMI, always have been sporty) but obviously being my young teenage and vulnerable self, that really crushed my self esteem.

So when I finally decided I had the b***s to say i don't wanna be with you anymore, he guilted me into staying with him, saying "you'll never find a guy who'll love you like I love you" or "if you leave me i'll k**l myself" and all the rest of the typical reasons a "nice guy" will use to guilt you into staying.

In the end I ghosted him, we were supposed to meet up, but I never showed up, I changed my number, deleted social media for a couple of years, moved out. Never heard from him again, which I am very pleased to say.
18points

#28

Man in blue hoodie looking at his phone with a thoughtful expression, related to stories about "nice guys."
I'm a guy and gave a "nice-girl" a chance. She was one of those "I'm not like other girls" girls.

We went out for a casual pizza and beer dinner (this was in college ~12-15 years ago). She kept repeating what we would now call memes, like "OMG pizza is lifestyle choice". Awkwardly charming the first time, but not funny and annoying the 10th time.

She talked about herself the entire time. Most of it was humble bragging about her "faults" like, "Its just that I care too much about my friends" and "I guess I'm just the type of person that's 100% honest and can't accept dishonesty in others". I could have left for 10 minutes and it wouldn't have interrupted her conversation. It was like watching a one person episode of the Gilmore Girls.

Afterwards we left separately and we didn't kiss or anything. The next day over MSN Messenger she asked when our next date was and I polity said I didn't think we had a connection.

She messaged me for about two weeks after that with increasingly desperate things. It started with, "Pick any place, and I'll buy!" to "Feeling lonely tonight, want to come over for some fun" to "[mutual friend who set us up] and I are talking about threesomes and we need your opinion" (a total lie, as I learned from the friend), to a picture of her cleavage.

She started dating some other dude and the messages stopped.
15points

#29

29 Creepy Stories From Women Who Gave “Nice Guys” A Chance
He seemed genuinely nice, and despite a couple of my friends warning me what an a*s he was, I went on a date with him.

Things started out fine, we went for beer and wings. We talked about work and mutual activities. Then he started talking about how he'd like to make enough money to keep a housewife. Which is fine, I'm just not interested in that sort of life and I was happy to know we were incompatible early on. When the time came I asked for the bills to be seperate, and he got very upset with me. The waitress was visibly uncomfortable and I didn't want to argue so I just let him pay. So, he walked me home, we said goodbye and I walked inside. He held the door and said "Where's my kiss?" I asked him what he was talking about and he said "I paid so I deserve a kiss or more." I shook my head, shut the door and locked it.

He went on to tell some of our friends we had s*x and I was in love with him because he's such a gentleman. A couple close friends know what actually happened because I hung out with them after the date, but I didn't bother setting him straight.
13points

In various social settings, assumptions about others and their intentions often lead to misunderstandings. This is evident in many scenarios, just like the unexpected airport interaction where a traveler assumed a stranger would be willing to watch his luggage.

To delve deeper into similar situations and how assumptions can sometimes lead to tension, you might find insights in an article about interactions at airports.

45
17