Bored Panda
“He Couldn’t Handle It”: 29 Stories About Priests And Nuns Deciding They’d Had Enough Of Their Lifestyle
LifestyleAPR 29, 2026

“He Couldn’t Handle It”: 29 Stories About Priests And Nuns Deciding They’d Had Enough Of Their Lifestyle

17
16
When you’re about to graduate from school, and everyone is asking about what’s next, they often mean career, not your spiritual world. But to some of us, that’s more important than anything else and inspires us to join the seminary or enter a monastery.
However, time changes and so do we, and what feels like an easy decision in one moment might not hold up five or fifteen years down the line.
So today, we turn to the world’s biggest religion, Christianity, and its most widely followed denomination, Catholicism, to look at something more personal and complex. Specifically, stories we found online from former priests and nuns who realized that life in the Church was no longer for them and chose to leave.
Their honesty serves as a reminder that sometimes our path might twist and turn, and require us to backtrack, before we find where we’re actually meant to be.

#21

“He Couldn’t Handle It”: 29 Stories About Priests And Nuns Deciding They’d Had Enough Of Their Lifestyle
I left after a couple of years in religious life because I became sick and couldn't live the life at the convent anymore. It was really hard to leave, and I was very confused as to why God let this happen. I'm married now and have a child. Looking back, I think that the symptoms I had back then might have been the first signs of the cancer that got diagnosed years later...last year. But who knows, I'll never know. No, I didn't leave the church, why should I?
11points

#22

“He Couldn’t Handle It”: 29 Stories About Priests And Nuns Deciding They’d Had Enough Of Their Lifestyle
I got tired of being treated like a rented mule. I don't want to scandalize people. I don't want to scare away those with a calling from genuine discernment about religious life. I hope that the community of Sisters I discerned with can be salvaged and is working to fix its issues. I also don't want to disappoint the hundreds of people who helped me enter the convent. I don't want the priests affiliated with these sisters to suffer due to actions by the same sisters that they had no direct involvement with. I don't want the lay faithful they minister to suffer any ill consequences from heavy-handed bishops who want to purge their diocese of the whole thing. It's complicated.
10points

#23

Two older nuns in habits; one knits, the other holds a cane. Reflects on priests and nuns leaving the church.
My friend left the convent because she was in her 20s and the other sisters were in their 50s and older. They weren’t interested in her or in forming community or relationships. She drove the older ones to doctors' appointments. So, she left.
10points

#24

“He Couldn’t Handle It”: 29 Stories About Priests And Nuns Deciding They’d Had Enough Of Their Lifestyle
In short: Crippling loneliness and depression. Everything started to lose its meaning. The dynamics between sisters didn't seem worth putting up with in the end. I am very independent, so it was hard for me to give that up. I remember feeling so free the day I left because I didn't have to put my hair in a ponytail anymore.
9points

#25

I went to seminary for a year and a half before being told to leave for various issues that boiled down to some communication/social struggles that were judged to be something best worked on elsewhere, and I haven’t returned since because I haven’t felt ready or called to.
I have to say the experience of being told to leave was by far the most devastating and traumatizing thing in my life, and I’m told I handled it relatively well. Being rejected by someone you like is bad, but this (and I’ve confirmed it with others) feels like you failed at life as God wanted it, and I lost all will to care about my final exams going on then or really do anything for a while. I am told that many find their spiritual lives crater afterwards, and that was definitely true for me after the first month or so, but I am also told it can go much worse into a loss of faith for some.
Because this was going on during COVID I had the exciting pleasure of lockdown and limited job opportunities (plus the whole gap in time since I finished my previous degree and cared at all about it) which combined to produce almost a year of nothing. This is one reason I recommend anyone going to seminary do so after having a degree, unless you like the idea of finishing your philosophy/theology degree from seminary or jumping into a whole new bunch of schooling you hadn’t previously looked forward to.
That said, seminary was incredibly formative and challenged a lot of bad aspects of my thinking, especially about the clergy. I also made some great friends I can talk about the faith with. I learned more in that relatively brief time than many previous ones and the time since.
Report
8points

#26

I know of a former priest who was kind of a family friend. He left the priesthood because it became too emotionally draining when paired with some illnesses in his family. He’s still an incredibly active Catholic, though.
8points

#27

My spiritual director thought it would be a good idea for me to leave and discern marriage - he said that he had the feeling I would become a priest because it was a good thing to do and not because I was called to be one and he was right, if I had have stayed I probably would have went all the way and likely enjoyed it, but here I am now 1 year married. Deo gratias!
Report
7points

#28

My cousin wanted to get married and start a family so he left the seminary.
Report
7points

#29

I wasn't a seminarian, and this is not what you're looking for probably, but I attended a seminary as a lay graduate student with the intention of entering for formation when I had reached the minimum number of years as a catholic required. I ended up discerning out because I got bad vibes from the novice master and vocations director for that religious order (i.e. they were both kind of aggressive and super specific about the personality profile of the guys they wanted), and was worried that I'd end up being kicked out or rejected because of my sexual orientation. I stayed catholic for about six more years after that.
Report
5points
17
16