Bored Panda
These 51 Box Office Hits Faded Into Obscurity A Little Bit Too Soon
Movies & tvFEB 24, 2023

These 51 Box Office Hits Faded Into Obscurity A Little Bit Too Soon

33
3
It's sad to see a box office giant becoming one of the many forgotten movies. It's a fate that can befall any new movie coming out of the factory that is Hollywood. A box office hit today might be shelved tomorrow, with only the hardcore fans left to watch it. There are a few reasons why a forgotten movie gets the silent treatment — the marketing and production decisions behind it.
Brilliant marketing is a common ingredient found in many box office giants. Any marketing is good marketing for box office hits. If it spreads the word — it works. Underrated movies with a great marketing strategy might shine bright with their ticket sales, but when it comes to memorability, they don’t usually reach the same level. Forgettable stories and poor action sequences make them forgettable.
There are a lot of overlooked movies that once roared at the box office but quickly got put onto a shelf, collecting dust until the next rewatch. We have compiled some of these movies in the list below. Be sure to leave an upvote on the films that are worth forgetting. On the other hand, share your thoughts in the comments below on why the film is worth a rewatch.

This post may include affiliate links.

#1 Troy (2004) - $497.4 Million

Brad Pitt looking in movie Troy
2h 43m | Directed by Wolfgang Petersen
 
Starring Brad Pitt, Eric Bana and Orlando Bloom
 
While the poetry attributed to Homer may be timeless, no one will necessarily agree that this nearly three-hour-long Brad Pitt, Eric Bana, and Orlando Bloom production is the best adaptation of Homer's work. Although there are a few excellent performances and solid action set pieces, The Iliad has never been nearly so uninteresting.
31points

#2 We’re The Millers (2013) - $270 Million

Emma Roberts and Will Poulter standing in movie We’re The Millers
1h 50m | Directed by Rawson Marshall Thurber
 
Starring Jason Sudeikis, Jennifer Aniston and Emma Roberts
 
Sometimes, the story might fade out of our minds, but the memes will always survive, no matter how much we strive to forget them. We’re the Millers is the perfect example of this phenomenon. While it did earn $270 million at the box office and became a subject of a couple of memes, the story didn’t stay long in the mind of many watchers.
31points

#3 Finding Dory (2016) - $1.029 Billion

Baby Dory with family in movie Finding Dory
1h 37m | Directed by Andrew Stanton and Angus MacLane
 
Starring Ellen DeGeneres, Albert Brooks and Ed O'Neill
 
Having earned $1.028 billion at the box office, Finding Dory may have been the third-highest-grossing movie of 2016, but other Pixar movies seem more remembered and discussed. It is even more puzzling, given how highly regarded Finding Nemo continues to be. Either way, the film is a must-see.
28points

#4 Green Book (2018) - $321.8 Million

Viggo Mortensen and Linda Cardellini eating in movie Green Book
2h 10m | Directed by Peter Farrelly
 
Starring Viggo Mortensen, Mahershala Ali and Linda Cardellini
 
Green Book is a movie that did quite well at the award ceremonies and the box office, earning an impressive $321.8 million. The only problem the movie had was that it had to compete with other great works of art. While it did win the Best Picture Oscar, A Star Is Born and Black Panther got more attention from the audience.
25points

#5 Hancock (2008) - $629.4 Million

 Will Smith with glasses in movie Hancock
1h 32m | Directed by Peter Berg
 
Starring Will Smith, Charlize Theron and Jason Bateman
 
Hancock might not be on your most-watched superhero movie list. Hancock, which debuted just a few months after Iron Man, generated more money at the box office. Yet Will Smith's intriguing but unsatisfying superhero film has been overshadowed by more than a decade's worth of subsequent entries.
24points

#6 Alice In Wonderland (2010) - $1.025 Billion

Mia Wasikowska with rabbit in movie Alice In Wonderland
1h 48m | Directed by Peter Berg
 
Starring Mia Wasikowska, Johnny Depp and Helena Bonham Carter
 
When it was released, Tim Burton's Alice in Wonderland caused a storm and showed that the director was still more than capable of crafting a blockbuster hit. But, a more-of-the-same sequel suffered severe financial losses, and the audience’s interest in the movie faded away more quickly than expected.
23points

#7 Super 8 (2011) - $260.1 Million

Kyle Chandler and Joel in movie standing and looking in movie Super 8
1h 52m | Directed by J.J. Abrams
 
Starring Elle Fanning, AJ Michalka and Kyle Chandler
 
Although Super 8 made $260 million worldwide on a $50 million budget, J.J. Abrams thought it would connect with audiences in the same way as classic Steven Spielberg movies like E.T. and Close Encounters of the Third Kind. However, Super 8 ultimately performed more like The Terminal and The BFG.
22points

#8 Over The Hedge (2006) - $340 Million

Animals looking at each other and talking in movie Over The Hedge
1h 23m | Directed by Tim Johnson and Karey Kirkpatrick
 
Starring Bruce Willis, Garry Shandling and Steve Carell
 
Dreamworks' adaptation of a comic strip had an all-star cast and received positive reviews from audiences. However, the fact that it failed to spawn a sequel or any significant spin-off has consigned this animated film to the depths of obscurity. It made $336 million worldwide against an $80 million budget.
22points

#9 What Women Want (2000) - $374.1 Million

Mel Gibson looking and smiling in movie What Women Want
2h 07m | Directed by Nancy Meyers
 
Starring Mel Gibson, Helen Hunt and Marisa Tomei
 
While Mel Gibson’s character might have asked the question of What Women Want in the movie, outside of it, the audience asked themselves — what is so memorable about the film they just saw? The movie was able to dominate at the box office, earning an impressive $374.1 million, but it did not win against the pressure of time.
22points

#10 The Day After Tomorrow (2004) - $552.6 Million

Jake Gyllenhaal standing and looking in movie The Day After Tomorrow
2h 04m | Directed by Roland Emmerich
 
Starring Dennis Quaid, Jake Gyllenhaal and Emmy Rossum
 
Disaster films are frequently products of their period, forgotten in favor of the next star-studded Hollywood disaster. The underlying material for Roland Emmerich's climate change disaster film is unusual: a mostly fictional, partially factual book written by paranormal radio personality Art Bell. The movie did well, earning $552.6 million.
22points

#11 Angels & Demons (2009) - $485.9 Million

Tom Hanks walking and talking in movie Angels & Demons
2h 18m | Directed by Ron Howard
 
Starring Tom Hanks, Ewan McGregor and Ayelet Zurer
 
Ron Howard, Tom Hanks, and Dan Brown worked together to create a three-movie franchise. The second movie of this series was Angels & Demons. While it grossed $485.9 million at the box office, it was the complete opposite, with ratings from the critics and reception from the audience. It is one of the most forgettable sequels ever.
20points

#12 Runaway Bride (1999) - $309.5 Million

Richard Gere with glasses looking from movie Runaway Bride
1h 56m | Directed by Garry Marshall
 
Starring Julia Roberts, Richard Gere and Joan Cusack
 
Runaway Bride acts like a reminder of the more famous Julia Roberts and Richard Gere pairing in Pretty Woman. Runaway Bride did earn the studio a whopping $309.5 million. When it came to memorability, it couldn’t rival the more famous and better-written Pretty Woman. You can't defeat a classic.
20points

#13 Identity Thief (2013) - $174 Million

Melissa McCarthy holding sign in movie Identity Thief
1h 51m | Directed by Seth Gordon
 
Starring Jason Bateman, Melissa McCarthy and John Cho
 
This movie might have stolen the attention at the box office, but it couldn't do so with the audience's memories. Identity Thief was a hit in Melissa McCarthy's filmography, garnering an impressive $174 million, but it might be one of the most forgettable movies she was in. It's not a road trip that anyone remembers today.
19points

#14 Mask (1985) - $48.2 Million

Eric Stoltz looking in movie Mask
2h 00m | Directed by Peter Bogdanovich
 
Starring Cher, Eric Stoltz and Sam Elliott
 
Mask, which many people consider to be one of Peter Bogdanovich's finest films, featured a fantastic ensemble that included actors like Cher and Sam Elliott. Regrettably, the movie hasn't survived into the streaming era despite a respectable return and tremendous critical acclaim. The main reason is presumably the film's limited distribution.
19points

#15 Star Trek Beyond (2016) - $343.5 Million

Chris Pine wearing yellow clothes looking from movie Star Trek Beyond
2h 02m | Directed by Justin Lin
 
Starring Chris Pine, Zachary Quinto and Karl Urban
 
Star Trek Beyond made $343.5 million worldwide, roughly on par with its predecessors. However, the franchise enraged a sizable portion of its audience with public lies about Star Trek Into Darkness and J.J. Abrams' departure from the director's chair, making this movie the underdog of the trilogy.
18points

#16 Private Benjamin (1980) - $69.8 Million

Goldie Hawn and Eileen Brennan wearing military clothes
1h 49m | Directed by Howard Zieff
 
Starring Goldie Hawn, Eileen Brennan and Armand Assante
 
The movie was such a box office hit that it gave rise to a brief sitcom that couldn't equal the comedic rhythm of Private Benjamin. Although the performance of Goldie Hawn got universal praise from everyone, the movie got eclipsed by other comedies of that period, like History of the World, Part I.
18points

#17 Stir Crazy (1980) - $101 Million

Gene Wilder and Richard Pryor sitting and looking in movie Stir Crazy
1h 51m | Directed by Sidney Poitier
 
Starring Gene Wilder, Richard Pryor and Georg Stanford Brown
 
The comedic team of Wilder and Pryor is one for the ages, and the film showcases each of their strengths to the fullest. Stir Crazy was one of the highest-grossing films despite having a small budget. It made an astounding amount of money. Yet, it created a tremendous impression upon its first release but faded into obscurity after some time.
18points

#18 That Darn Cat! (1965) - $28.1 Million

Neville Brand holding gun in movie That Darn Cat!
1h 56m | Directed by Robert Stevenson
 
Starring Hayley Mills, Dean Jones and Dorothy Provine
 
Hayley Mills, the daughter of Sir John Mills, produced six films for Disney before this screwball comic thriller. A significant cast included Roddy McDowall, Ed Wynn, and Elsa Lanchester. Mills was "the" celebrity in 1965 and undoubtedly contributed to the movie earning $28.1 million at the box office.
17points

#19 Ruthless People (1986) - $71.6 Million

Danny DeVito wearing suit and looking in movie Ruthless People
1h 33m | Directed by Jim Abrahams, David Zucker and Jerry Zucker
 
Starring Bette Midler, Danny DeVito and Judge Reinhold
 
When you put Danny DeVito in your movie, you know it's going to be great. He brought the needed star power into the film, helping it earn $71.6 million at the box office. Since Ruthless People is a dark comedy distributed through a Disney-affiliated company, it wasn't on the streaming menu.
16points

#20 2012 (2009) - $791.2 Million

John Cusack and Woody Harrelson looking in movie 2012
2h 38m | Directed by Roland Emmerich
 
Starring John Cusack, Thandiwe Newton and Chiwetel Ejiofor
 
Based on mistaken theories about impending Mayan doom, memorability wasn't in anyone's mind when 2012 got produced. But it's unlikely that anyone was severely disappointed, as any film that predicts the end of the world in a particular year isn't going to age like wine. When it mattered, the film did well, earning $791.2 million.
16points
33
3