Bored Panda
56 Underrated Fan Theories To Add Some Spice To Your Favorite Fictional Worlds
CuriositiesAPR 24, 2023

56 Underrated Fan Theories To Add Some Spice To Your Favorite Fictional Worlds

30
3
We all know that sinking feeling when a great movie comes to an end or when we finish another season of our favorite show, leaving us with that nagging question: “What now?” Well, fret not, fellow fiction lovers, because we’ve got just the remedy for your entertainment hangover — a comprehensive collection of fan theories that will add extra spice to your favorite fictional worlds! We’ve included everything from movies, TV shows, cartoons, and even video games, ensuring there’s something for everyone. After all, as any true fan knows, the story never really ends. It just finds new ways to surprise and enchant us.
As avid participants in fan theory discussions, we can attest there’s no better way to keep the magic of your favorite stories alive than by diving headfirst into the world of speculation and imagination. Rest assured, these underrated fan theories will take you on a rollercoaster ride through intriguing plot twists and mind-bending revelations that’ll make you see your favorite characters and stories in a whole new light.
From the hidden depths of video games and cartoons to the swirling vortex of TV show fan theories, we’ve scoured the farthest corners of the internet to bring you a curated collection of interesting, bizarre, but always utterly entertaining speculations. These little gems have flown under the radar, just waiting for you to discover them and share them with fellow fans.
Prepare to have your mind blown as we delve into unexplored character motivations, crazy plot twists, and other details of the stories you thought you knew inside and out. We’ll explore everything from the darkest corner of character backstories to the most unexpected crossovers. Who knows? You might just find yourself starting a movie theory or two!

#21

56 Underrated Fan Theories To Add Some Spice To Your Favorite Fictional Worlds
zoatir wrote:
"Ty Lee is a non-bender descendent of air nomads."
snapwillow added:
"I'll take it a step farther. The creators at one point clarified that only the audience can see Aang's air bending. Airbending is invisible to people in the show.
Ty Lee is an Airbender, but no one realizes it, not even her. It's why she's so uncannily springy and floaty in her acrobatics. She's air bending to make herself lighter. She started doing it without realizing while training her acrobatics skills."
Report
22points

#22

56 Underrated Fan Theories To Add Some Spice To Your Favorite Fictional Worlds
"That Dora the explorer is visually impaired. She needs the viewers help to see something that's literally 3 feet away from her, and she doesn't look at things directly."
22points

#23

56 Underrated Fan Theories To Add Some Spice To Your Favorite Fictional Worlds
"Dumbledore was manipulative and intentionally left Harry to be raised in an abusive household so he would be trusting of anyone who showed him kindness and would be easier to manipulate."
Report
22points

#24

56 Underrated Fan Theories To Add Some Spice To Your Favorite Fictional Worlds
Mecmecmecmecmec wrote:
"Courage the dog is exaggerating normal occurrences into scary things cuz he’s a dog."
HaMiLtOnBoI69 responded:
"And the dog has separation anxiety. Can't forget about that."
Hot_Shot_McGee added:
"He lives in the middle of nowhere because his owners are too old to take him out so he's not sure what is beyond the walls of his house."
21points

#25

56 Underrated Fan Theories To Add Some Spice To Your Favorite Fictional Worlds
"Mad Max folktale theory: The movies and games all have different narrators and different takes on Max because they're all stories being told by people in the wasteland. All of these great deeds and accomplishments are being attributed to one man who may or may not have ever really existed."
21points

#26

56 Underrated Fan Theories To Add Some Spice To Your Favorite Fictional Worlds
AlphaNepali wrote:
"Mr. Bean is an alien. That would explain his weird behavior and why he falls out of the sky at the beginning of every episode."
vale_fallacia commented:
"Not an angel instead? He falls from the sky to the sound of a choir."
20points

#27

56 Underrated Fan Theories To Add Some Spice To Your Favorite Fictional Worlds
"My favorite Pokemon Conspiracy is that Nurse Joy and Officer Jenny are actually humanshape Pokemon like Mr. Mime and Jynx."
Report
20points

#28

56 Underrated Fan Theories To Add Some Spice To Your Favorite Fictional Worlds
"Andy's parents are in the middle of a divorce when the first Toy Story is taking place."
19points

#29

56 Underrated Fan Theories To Add Some Spice To Your Favorite Fictional Worlds
Iboughtcheeseonce wrote:
"Inception.
Leonardo's wedding ring is his totem. Not the spinning top.
If you watch, he only wears it in dreams, never takes it off or puts it on, and no one ever touches it. The top was Mal's and doesn't work for him which is why he always picked it up before a full spin."
Trinitykill added:
"Also when he introduces the concept of the Totem he explains how it has to be something only you know intimately, so that if someone crafted a fake dream only you would be able to tell it apart from the real one.
So why would he then explain what his totem is and exactly how it works?
The wedding ring would work because he would be able to know exactly how much it weighs, how smooth the metal is, how tight the fit is."
Jan_17_2016 responded:
"My interpretation is that his kids are his totem. When he thinks of them in his dream state he never sees their faces. At the end, he is in reality as he sees his kids’ faces."
19points

#30

56 Underrated Fan Theories To Add Some Spice To Your Favorite Fictional Worlds
"At the end of The Thing, MacReady has gasoline in the whiskey bottle. He made all the bottles into molotov cocktails. He knew he was going to die with the thing, or likely from it, so there was no reason for him to save an entire bottle of just whiskey on his person when that could have been another weapon. At the end, he offers the bottle to Childs, who drinks it as if nothing was wrong. The Thing wouldn't know what whiskey tastes like, and reveals Childs as being replaced. MacReady even gives a smirk after he drinks from the bottle."
18points

#31

56 Underrated Fan Theories To Add Some Spice To Your Favorite Fictional Worlds
A user wrote:
"Joker from The Dark Knight was former military/CIA, which explains his skills in weapons and interrogation, as well as that comment about the truck full of soldiers."
sneezing_chimp replied:
"Also his ability to keep his true identity undetected probably wasn't by accident either."
toramac added:
"This makes me think of something similar for the Joker but he is the result of a MK Ultra-style experiment that went sideways. He gets trained at destabilizing governments with anarchy and chaos but the drugs and electroshock make him insane, one of the reasons why he doesn’t really know why he has the scars and can’t tell the same story twice."
17points

#32

56 Underrated Fan Theories To Add Some Spice To Your Favorite Fictional Worlds
"Peter Parker wasn't screwed out of his pay by that wrestling promoter. The promoter cut his pay because Peter didn't understand how wrestling worked.
Wrestling isn't actual combat sport, it's putting on a show. The pay was for lasting 3 minutes in the ring, that makes it the match's time limit. If he did only that, it would have been fine. But not only did the match go under 3 minutes, he also defeated Bonesaw, the promotion's top guy. So the promoter not only had to send the crowd home earlier than he planned, but now his top guy looks weak too, because he got beat by a nobody amateur.
Bonesaw's ability to draw a crowd was hurt by losing to Peter, negatively impacting that wrestling promotion's business."
17points

#33

56 Underrated Fan Theories To Add Some Spice To Your Favorite Fictional Worlds
Random-Rambling wrote:
"Ditto are failed Mew clones."
midnightwolf19 wrote:
"I thought this was cannon."
Random-Rambling responded:
"It was never officially confirmed. Many claim it's just coincidence that Mew and Ditto have the same color (in both normal AND Shiny forms), same height, same weight, and are the only two Pokemon in existence who can learn Transform."
16points

#34

56 Underrated Fan Theories To Add Some Spice To Your Favorite Fictional Worlds
shronkey69 wrote:
"Willy Wonka knew what he was doing. There was no seat for Augustus aboard that boat. He knew Augustus Gloop would fall in there."
RatRob responded:
"Oh yea this is absolutely true. It’s why each kid had their own downfall specifically programmed into the “tour”. That’s why he seemed bored by the end too. He was just weeding out the kids that weren’t worthy.
It’s been a while since I watched it but did they ever get to one to test Charlie? The fizzy lifting drinks thing was uncle joe being a bad influence wasn’t it? I don’t think that was meant to be Charlie’s downfall, otherwise how was there still room for him in the tour past that and what not.
This also brings up the end game of the movie into question though. Was there a challenge meant for Charlie we didn’t see or was it actually just giving back the gobstopper? Slugworth was going to pay handsomely for it so I assume if poor Charlie gave it back to Wonka that was him passing his test. The fizzy lifting drink just p*ssed off Wonka I guess, that was never supposed to happen I don’t think."
15points

#35

56 Underrated Fan Theories To Add Some Spice To Your Favorite Fictional Worlds
"I’ve heard the theory that Ted put all his one night stand stories on Barney so he doesn’t look bad/manipulative in front of his kids, meaning like 50% of the stories of Barney manipulating women are Ted lying to women to get laid."
15points

#36

56 Underrated Fan Theories To Add Some Spice To Your Favorite Fictional Worlds
Worried_Ad2589 wrote:
"Caillou is a cancer patient. There's no other explanation for why his parents put up with the little sh*t and his incredibly terrible behavior."
Lurker3340 responded:
"It’s actually because Caillou was originally a book. In the book he was a toddler, which explains his sh*t behavior. They never changed this in the show, so he is basically a toddler in a four year olds body."
15points

#37

56 Underrated Fan Theories To Add Some Spice To Your Favorite Fictional Worlds
Bev-Low wrote:
"In Disney's Ratatouille, the old lady in the beginning of the movie living in the house next to the river is the food critic, Anton Ego's, mother. In the flashback scene where he eats the ratatouille you can see similarities of the house from the beginning, her face and I think the bridge."
Mystigore responded:
"That explains Remmy being able to make the ratatouille that tasted exactly like his mother used to make!"
CannedRoo added:
"Imagine Anton Ego taking his mother to his new favorite restaurant and introducing her to the chef."
Report
15points

#38

56 Underrated Fan Theories To Add Some Spice To Your Favorite Fictional Worlds
"Little late to the game, but the theory is that the kyber crystal in Luke’s green lightsaber is the same one from Qui Gon Jinn’s.
After Kenobi defeats Darth Maul with his master’s lightsaber, he would have kept it as a keepsake, despite rebuilding his own saber. It’s likely he would have retrieved it and kept it with him after the Order 66 attack.
After the empire takes over, they destroy all artifacts and memory of the Jedi in their purge of changing the history, and most Kyber crystals go towards powering the D*ath Star. Because of this, any lightsaber crystal would have been very difficult for Luke to find after he loses the Skywalker saber.
BUT we know he returns to Tatooine to complete his new lightsaber, likely returning to Ben Kenobi’s home for components, where he would have found Qui Gon Jinn’s lightsaber and recycled its crystal."
Report
15points

#39

56 Underrated Fan Theories To Add Some Spice To Your Favorite Fictional Worlds
Sir-Tiedye wrote:
"The velociraptors in Jurassic Park were genetically modified to be larger so they would bring more visitors."
GreatJanitor responded:
"My theory is that none of what we saw in Jurassic Park were real dinos, but rather, genetically engineered monsters to the appearance of dinosaurs based upon what the population was lead to believe dinosaurs looked like. Which is why none of them had feathers.
This also explains why the Jurassic World movies have super-advanced monsters."
14points

#40

56 Underrated Fan Theories To Add Some Spice To Your Favorite Fictional Worlds
"Squilliam plot every Squilliam inspired episode.
He doesn't actually have a band to play with, he just did that to embarass Squidward.
He doesn't actually teach a prestigious music school, he just did that to get Squidward arrested.
His clique aren't his actual friends, they're paid actors to piss off squidward.
Wither Squilliam is jealous of Squidward for continuing to follow his dreams and having "real" friends rather than abandoning them to make money, or they were once lovers.
I prefer both."
Report
14points
30
3