Since the dawn of the internet, it has evolved at an astonishing rate. We are so used to the world wide web of today that just picturing the early days after its birth is almost like a fantasy. One thing that remains constant, however, is that it was brimming with online mysteries, just like today!
When a netizen asked people to spill these unsolved online mysteries of that time, they didn’t hold back. If you are from that age, a few might be familiar to you, while others might be completely new. Some of these will leave you with an itch to solve them; that’s how compelling they are! Just scroll down to check them out.
More info: Reddit
#21

The identity of Bloodninja, the greatest internet troll of all time. Ahh, those were the days!
edit: [chat logs](http://www.megalomaniac.com/~andrew/funny/bloodcyber.html) for those of you unfamiliar with this legend.
edit: [chat logs](http://www.megalomaniac.com/~andrew/funny/bloodcyber.html) for those of you unfamiliar with this legend.
Report
7points
#22

I was on Stumbleupon and I remember a story about a Russian (?) boy who had knowledge of ancient civilizations even though he was from a small town in Siberia. He claimed to be an alien who was sent down to earth and grew in his host (the mom). Can’t remember why he was sent to earth but I haven’t been able to find that story since.
Report
7points
#23

A long time ago I was chatting with someone over IM and he somehow managed to open my CD tray over the internet. To this day, I have no idea how tf he managed to do that.
Report
7points
#24

C*****d had an article about this (I know, I know) but there was an old forum a girl had about Buffy the Vampire Slayer - I think? Where she had over 40k posts, all by herself. As in, she would make topics and reply to them as the series progressed, or she watched seasons and episodes. IIRC 4chan caught wind and started raiding, so she deleted the site all together. I really wish I had more context, because it seems so interesting.
Report
6points
#25

I remember this random youtube video where a guy kidnaps a girl and after 10 years, he posted a video titled "happy anniversary" and laughed like hell with some mystery puzzle at the end.
cuppateafling replied:
That's the disappearance of Maura Murray and the video was posted on the eighth year. Supposedly the video creator is not involved, just mentally ill and may enjoy the attention.
cuppateafling replied:
That's the disappearance of Maura Murray and the video was posted on the eighth year. Supposedly the video creator is not involved, just mentally ill and may enjoy the attention.
Report
6points
#26

Not from the early days- but the stories and conspiracies of Cicada 3301 sound amazing, shame they havent posted a puzzle in years though (or figured out the last one).
Report
6points
#27

Not early internet, but early Facebook. The developers of Facebook used to look through everyone's photos and make comments on them in a tooltip that with javascript would disappear after being read once. Very few people remember that b.s. now.
6points
#28

All of those posts from a bunch of different accounts from a bunch of different social media sites that were all about Captain Kutchie’s Key Lime Pie. Captain Kutchies was a local restaurant that closed a long time ago. I seriously wonder what all that was about.
Report
6points
#29

There a was a site I found only once and have never been able to relocate.
The whole of it seemed to consist of cryptic text in various patterns, with links to other cryptic text in various patterns. The links would be on whole words or sometimes individual letters.
It's hard to explain how, but going through the pages gave you the sense that you were going *somewhere*, that it wasn't just endless randomness but some kind of puzzle to be solved.
I never solved it and neglected to bookmark it; now that (486) computer is a scrap heap.
The whole of it seemed to consist of cryptic text in various patterns, with links to other cryptic text in various patterns. The links would be on whole words or sometimes individual letters.
It's hard to explain how, but going through the pages gave you the sense that you were going *somewhere*, that it wasn't just endless randomness but some kind of puzzle to be solved.
I never solved it and neglected to bookmark it; now that (486) computer is a scrap heap.
Report
6points
#30

How the f**k have we still never seen a picture of CJayC, the founder of GameFAQs?
Report
5points
#32

The Mayday mystery. There were a load of conspiracy theories like a cult, government recruiting, the illuminati, and etc. Basically, this guy found this weird crypric ad in his school paper, and turns out that they date back to the early 80s, possibly even further, and still continue to this day. The ads included the word Mayday, and a lot of ciphers and math. Apparently, the guy who discovered this was messaged by the mysterious group who made it, although im a little skeptical about that.
Report
4points


