Bored Panda
49 Stories From Medical Professionals Who Caught Patients Faking It
Funny,FailsSEP 26, 2025

49 Stories From Medical Professionals Who Caught Patients Faking It

44
6
We’ve all faked being sick at least once, whether for school or work. And if done right, getting away with it without raising suspicion is almost a guarantee. 
However, faking an illness with a medical professional is a different scenario, and a foolish one to be in, at that. However, that didn’t stop these individuals from engaging in such behavior, as evidenced by this Reddit thread from a while back. 
From feigning seizures to using a prop pebble to claim a kidney stone affliction, these stories may just make you shake your head in utter disbelief.

#21

49 Stories From Medical Professionals Who Caught Patients Faking It
When I was a junior medical student without much experience on the wards, a homeless patient came in who was 'unconscious'. Except, she wasn't. I mean, obviously wasn't.

The doctor would hold up her limp arm, position her hand over her head and let go. If she was truly unconscious, her hand would hit her in the face. Somehow, every time he let go of her hand, it would swerve at the last minute and miss her face.

In an effort to rouse her, the doctor loudly asked me to go and get 'the biggest needle you can find'. When I returned, he asked me if I'd ever taken blood before. I replied that I had not. He said that as Miss X was unconscious, this would be an excellent opportunity for me to have some one-on-one teaching on the subject. He also said that this would ordinarily be extremely painful for someone with such a large needle being used.

Unfortunately, she 'woke up' at that point, so I didn't get to learn how to take blood.
20points

#22

49 Stories From Medical Professionals Who Caught Patients Faking It
"I'm allergic to ibuprofen, tylenol, aspirin, and zofran. I swear."

Also, one time I had a patient who was complaining of severe abdominal pain and the symptoms of cholecystitis. Typically we would do a CT but based on his reported medical/surgical history and allergies we were limited in the tests we could do. He was refusing the tests we could offer. He was from another town and didn't have a physician we could get records off of. His blood work and vital signs were normal. It was all very suspicious but they admitted him to the ICU until we could figure out an action plan.

I'm doing his admission and he says he knows that it's his gall bladder because he's had issues before. He keeps apologizing for being so dramatic but he's never felt such bad pain. The resident orders him a concoction of the good stuff until the intensivist makes it up to the floor to see him.

Finally the physician walks in. I give him a report and then he does his assessment. The patient writhes in bed while the doctor asks him questions and palpates his stomach. The doctor says it sounds like a bad case of gallstones and cholecystitis. The patient agrees and asks for something for the pain.

The physician responds, "Yeah for gall bladder troubles like yours I would recommend it." The patient stopped writhing and smiled. Thd doctor continued, "however, you don't have a gall bladder, I remember I took it out a few years ago when I worked at XYZ hospital. It's nice to see you again."

The patient's smile turned into the most disgruntled look I have ever seen. He sat up in bed, removed his IV, gathered his things and made for the door. I chased him down the hall telling him he was leaving AMA. His response was, "F. that. Obviously you know I'm fine.".
20points

#23

Female lawyer presenting evidence in courtroom as judge listens, illustrating cases of people faking illnesses exposed.
Well, I'm not a doctor or nurse, but I am a disability attorney. I've seen a few obvious fakes. My favorite was at this hearing office that's a single courtroom sort of tacked onto the back of one of the satellite offices. Judges come down from the main ODAR office every so often to do hearings there. However, the entrance is around the side of the building so people often go in the front of the building and sit there waiting (even though I told them it's around the side).

So, I have this client that did exactly that. She's claiming disability in part because she can't walk more than a few steps without falling over in extreme pain. Uses a cane or a walker to get around everywhere. Of course, none of this is in her records - she originally claimed it was because she couldn't afford to see a doctor so I believed her.

Well, it gets close to her hearing time and she hasn't arrived, so I go out to the parking lot to give her a call. No answer - phone already off. I figure that she went in the front entrance. Sure enough, as soon as I start heading toward the front of the building, I see her *running* around the side of the building. Cane in one hand. She doesn't even notice me in the parking lot. I go back in to talk to her ahead of the hearing. Suddenly she can't walk anymore.

Yeah there are a ton of cases where people can do short bursts of walking or even running but can't do sustained standing/walking to hold down a light exertional level job, but this wasn't that. This was straight up faking it for the hearing. Now, luckily she had other (mental) things that were going on with her which were actually pretty well documented, but it was still pretty funny seeing the miracle cure come running around the side of the building.
18points

#24

Woman holding newborn baby by window, illustrating moments related to faking illnesses and being exposed.
Had a mother come in and INSIST that her child had Silver-Russell syndrome. You can go read on it. It's not that easy to fake, as it's a bunch of metabolic conditions mixed with congenital abnormalities.

The kid was small, but not that small (around 6th percentile). He didn't weight much (5th percentile). All of this, with a right arm length 2 cm more than the left side, were borderline criteria for Silver-Russell. Did genetic testing, which came back negative, but 30% of cases are negative.

So the deciding factor was one of the "soft" criteria of hypoglycemia. Once she heard about this (she printed out 30-40 articles on the disease), she came back with the kid in a coma. But when the kid was in the hospital, he was never hypoglycemic. He went home, and came back in a coma a few weeks later. Again, as soon as he was eating normally at the hospital, he was never hypoglycemic.

She starved her child into comas repeatedly for the diagnosis of Silver-Russell. She was also a "bougon", people who live off welfare and make a game out of it. By the way, she was in a wheelchair when at the hospital. Once I had enough of her and walked into the room after only knocking once. She was walking around normally and jumped into the wheelchair as soon as she saw me.

I believe it was for money since in Canada/Quebec, you get money when your child has a genetic disability... God, if it was legal, I would have slapped some sense into her.
18points

#25

Firefighter sitting in uniform with helmet on the floor, related to people trying to fake illnesses and getting exposed.
My husband is a firefighter and EMT and he told me about a time where they were called for a man seizing. When they got there a guy was lying face up on the floor not moving and then started faking a seizure. They stood there saying things like "Oh wow. This is a bad one. But if they did [insert specific behavior] then we should really be worried!" and the patient would suddenly start doing that behavior. Apparently this went on for a while until he miraculously woke up in the ambulance asking for opiates.
17points

#26

Man with towel on shoulder using elliptical machine while woman in purple shirt spots him in gym, illustrating fake illness exposure.
Student nurse, but this happened when I was at the gym.

Guy next to me fell off the elliptical, somehow got his foot trapped between the foot pedals and went sideways. The surprisingly inept PTs (Personal trainers are usually well trained in first aid) were freaking out and this guy is really hamming it up. Talks of calling an ambulance are thrown about. I offer to step in.

"AHHHHHH MY ANKLE" He's on the floor grabbing his leg. I kneel next to him.

"Hey bro," I greet him. He's so surprised that I'm there (came up from behind) that he forgets to groan. "How much does it hurt on a scale of 1-10?"

"Erm... 8" he says. I look at his ankle. There's a scratch on it the size of a penny and superficial, hardly any blood. Little red around the scratch, ankle not swollen. I ask him if he can point and flex his foot and rotate his ankle, which he can do with zero difficulty, not even a grimace. I figure he's probably hamming it up cuz it's embarrassing falling off a machine in front of everyone, so I get him an ice pack (mostly for show tbh), tell him he'll be fine, and tell the PTs not to call an ambulance. His sister comes to pick him up in her car and he limps out on the wrong leg.
17points

#27

Patient in hospital bed talking to doctor and nurse during a medical checkup about faking illnesses being exposed
Happens every day. Alot of patients in the hospital are in pain, and many for a good reason. We tend to treat them with varying strengths of narcotics. Not uncommonly people like to take advantage of that. Numerous times I will ask someone to rate their pain with 10/10 being the worst they have ever had and it's always 10. Usually accompanied with alot of moaning and writhing. Now I make it a habit to stand outside their door and listen and watch before I walk in. Almost always they are chilling watching TV or on their phone and as soon as I walk in, "ohhh God it hurrrtss soooo baddies. Ahhhh!!" Pretty funny to watch sometimes :).
15points

#28

As a resident, I had a patient who had a blood clotting disorder, but also who was addicted to IV pain meds. He figured out how to get admitted for an extensive workup for a possible blood clot in the lung and iv pain meds for his "chest pain". He came in all the time, but it was very difficult to block the admission, because he actually did have a risk of this problem, never took his blood thinner correctly, and his symptoms always bought him a couple of days at least while we ruled out a clot and got his blood levels where they are supposed to be. But it meant he had accumulated >30 high resolution CT scans of the chest over his life, as part of the workup, which is not good for you.

I had this one question I would ask people who tended to come in complaining of every serious sounding symptom they could think of: "Does it ever hurt behind your eyes when you pee?".

I was very salty at that point, and this guy was a nightmare when he ended up on your service, and it really bothered me that this guy was buying himself a lung tumor with all those PE protocol CTs just to get a days worth of IV pain meds and benadryl. With him, I started asking the "pain behind your eyes when you pee" question like it was extremely important, and quickly he started answering "yes", and I acted like it was an extremely serious condition that warranted evaluation - once it was clear I couldn't avoid the admission anyway. I considered it one of my greatest achievements in residency that he one day showed up in the ER with "pain behind my eyes when I pee" as his chief complaint. Heard a colleague talking about this crazy dude who came in demanding to be admitted because he had excruciating urination-related eye pain. Made my day.
15points

#29

49 Stories From Medical Professionals Who Caught Patients Faking It
I work in a psychiatrist's office. Curious how many people "lose" their prescriptions, or even their whole bottles of Adderall, Valium, etc. We've heard some good ones – lots of them "lose" their bottles by dropping them into the toilet. One guy told that story and the very next week, the RX apparently flew out of his convertible on the highway LOL. We now tell all patients – especially college age patients – that they need a police report stating that their meds were stolen to get a refill if it's too early. It's always the same people who do this time after time.
15points

#30

Nurse attending to a patient in a hospital bed, illustrating attempts to fake illnesses and getting exposed.
I have so many of these!!

--Male patient, 18 years old, rolled in unconscious. Mom says he's been like that for the past four hours. Go to check his lungs when I hear something interesting. I place the stethoscope near his mouth and hear him breathe in normally, but then breathe out by saying 'breath'. No joke.

--Male patient, 21 years old, admitted with inability to speak for last two hours and respiratory distress. Lungs clear, but we hook him up to oxygen for a few minutes. After he's taken off, his father comes running and drags me over, saying his sons tongue refuses to go back in after receiving the oxygen. I look at the kid and he's seriously just lying there with his tongue poking out like a child. I tell them to push it back in. A few hours later the dad tells me the boy is convulsing. I go to see without making my presence known and he's lying there just fine. The moment I ask the mom how he's doing, he starts 'convulsing'. Think of an odd version of the worm, but on his back.

--Female patient, 16 years old, admitted with complaints of recurrent seizures and frothing from the mouth. I look at her and she is literally blowing spit bubbles. I check her reflexes, everything is intact. The moment I turn away to check on another patient, she suddenly becomes 'rigid' and the spitting intensifies.

--Male patient, 30 years old, unconscious and completely unresponsive for six hours. This guy was totally dedicated to his act. I initially approached it as a stroke, but when the blood pressure, ECG, reflexes, pupils, etc all are normal....I start checking pain sensation. He slowly began to open his eyes and groan as I asked him to tell me his name, but the moment his Achilles' tendon was pressed, he suddenly sat up, stated his name, and declared himself cured.

--Female patient, 17 years old, complained of respiratory distress and convulsions. Everything's normal on admission, and she's conscious but refuses to eat. Parents are worried out of their minds, and every few minutes she has a 'fit' where she would just basically shake from side to side. She let slip to a nurse that she didn't want to go to school that week, so she was faking an illness. Since she was refusing to eat, the attending wrote up an order for a nasogastric tube (which was inserted and then removed by her in a matter of minutes), and we prescribed her sugar pills because her parents wouldn't let us transfer her to psychiatry or discharge her. She finally left after four days.
14points

#31

Paramedic in ambulance providing emergency oxygen to patient, illustrating fake illness attempts instantly exposed.
Had an employee that was "allergic to everything" and a huge hypochondriac. She was such a headache that we ended up moving her desk waaaaaay away from pretty much anyone else so she would stop complaining. One day, a lady walks by with a strong perfume, and our lovable hypochondriac falls out.

Predictably, EMS is called, and by this point our employee is laying on the ground rolling her eyes back in her head. Scary stuff if you didn't know she was literally insane.

So EMS arrives and they come over, put the O2 meter on her finger, and she's choking through her speech when they're asking her if she can breathe or not. O2 saturation was at like 97% or something like that. Medic goes "ma'am, there's no reason why you should be having trouble breathing right now."

They hung around for another couple minutes, then bounced.
14points

#32

Female doctor examining brain scans near MRI machine, highlighting cases of people faking illnesses and getting exposed.
I am an X-ray tech. All the time in the ED you will have patients that come in seeking things. These patients will have a bunch of X-rays ordered. So when you first start the exams they will be in all sorts of pain. They cannot position any bod part. Fighting and begging you to not do it. Then after about 15 minutes, when they notice you're going to do your job. They stop the charade and get through the stack of images ordered on them. It's quite incredible really.

The other thing that blows my mind is when people want the worst possible outcome of their disease. Like you can feel the craving for sympathy emanating from them. With phrases "Ohhh that's really bad isn't it" or "Oh man is that the worse you've seen?". Not said with dread, but barely hidden excitement.
13points

#33

I was an intern in a busy trauma ED when a guy walks up the ambulance bay and screams he needs to be seen immediately. They take him back and he starts telling everyone he was in a car accident last night going "100+ mph" on the interstate but did not go to the hospital because he was worried about his friend, the driver. But now he's losing feeling in his legs and has severe back pain and needs to be seen.

So of course the story is super fishy but we put him on a backboard/collar and get some xrays of chest and pelvis (our protocol for any severe trauma). The radiologist who is stationed in the ED flags me and asks when out patient got a CT scan. He showed me his pelvis x ray and his bladder is super bright: it's filled with the iodine contrast agent they inject in your veins when you get a CT which is then excreted by the kidneys over the next few hours.

So we confront our patient about why he didn't tell us about being seen at another hospital and getting a CT. He launches into a rambling explanation about concussions and amnesia. He has, of course, also exhibited several other substance seeking behaviors in his short time in the ED. He decides to leave AMA but not before asking the nurse directions to the nearest hospital, presumably to try the same trick.
13points

#34

Another paramedic piping in! One day I went out to a "no tell motel" at about 3:30 pm for seizures. When we get there a ~25yo guy is sitting on the bed, his girl friend describes "his whole body shaking, it stopped just before you got here". He's completely alert and oriented (people who have seizures generally take a while to 'wake up'), and they describe a vague seizure history, no diagnosis or meds, he hands me his drivers license for ID (if you have a legit seizure the first thing they do is take your drivers license away). We finally walk him out to the ambulance and the girlfriend asks if she can come too. I tell her of course, and the real reason comes out. Apparently she's on a pass from the same hospital we're transporting to and has to be back by 4pm. There's only one unit that does passes like that... psychiatry!
13points

#35

Not exactly what you're wanting, but I'm reminded of this story: I once had to go to the ER for *horrendous* stomach pain. I thought my appendix burst. Doctors loaded me up on pain meds and took scans, but found nothing wrong. Then, while lying in the bed waiting for a specialist, I let out a massive fart. Pain went away.
Report
12points

#36

Patient lying in hospital bed pretending to be ill while nurse attentively checks and interacts during a medical examination.
Faking seizures is super common. Faking unconscious is also super common and very embarrassing for the both of us.
12points

#37

EMT here. The one that sticks out is the most textbook example of substance seeking behavior.

Get called out to a residence at 2 am (because of course, it's always 2 am). Guy says he's having 10/10 finger pain and gingerly holding his hand in the air. Says there was no trauma, just started suddenly and it's unbearable.

So we load him up, take him the 25 minutes the the hospital. Entire time he's holding his hand in the air. But we had a full conversation, talked about Football, never once did he complain about pain.

We wheel him into the ER and literally the second we walk through the door, this guy starts *writhing* in pain. Says he can't sit still the pain is unbearable, he has to stand up, screaming at the nurse to help. Then he turned to the nurse and said:

"I had this same issue at a different hospital 2 weeks ago. They couldn't tell what was wrong. They gave me morphine but that didn't work so then they gave me dilaudid. That worked. So maybe you should just start with dilaudid tonight". And then he went back to moaning in pain.

Nurse and I just looked at each other, we put him in a bed and I drove the 35 minutes back to station. Highly doubt he was given any pain less that night, was just a colossal waste of everyone's time.
12points

#38

"I'm allergic to all pain medications except that one that begins with a D. I don't remember the name though.".
12points

#39

My mother was the school nurse when I was in high school, but she's been a nurse my whole life. She's told me a few good stories (obviously without names). But I was lucky enough to overhear one of the students trying to fake an illness to get out of class. The kid, we'll call him Derrick, was a skud. White trash, moody, and destructive. Not my favorite classmate. But I was laying there when I heard him come in and start his routine of attention seeking. (mom used to let me skip seminary and nap on the empty beds).So my mom runs through all the basics, temp, blood pressure, etc. Well Derrick finally just cuts to the chase, obviously frustrated with the procedure, "Look Mrs. S, something is seriously wrong here and I'm not faking it this time!" He screeched, defenses already 10 feet high.

"OK Derrick, what's the problem this time?" She asked.

"Well, earlier this morning, I started feeling sick, so I went to the bathroom to throw up. After I was done I looked at the toilet...(dramatic pause) and there where over a dozen whole baby carrots...(another pause, this one I think was for any gasps that might be coming) AND I DON'T EVEN EAT CARROTS!" He nearly shouted.

Well, after about a 10 second pause and what I'm guessing was the hardest straight face my mother ever had to keep. She said, still fighting back laughter, "Well, Derrick your body is producing carrots at an alarming rate. Weird that it only seems to happen during gym, though. Here is a Gatorade and a hall pass to get back to class, see you tomorrow, Derrick."

He left, stunned to be written off so easily and we had a good ol' laugh.

"And I don't even eat carrots!" has become a family favorite catchphrase.
12points

#40

Not me, but my dad works in A&E (accident and emergency) and gets a lot of people wandering in for attention.

So one time a guy is driven in pretending to be unconscious, the same guy who'd pulled this nonsense the week before but they're not allowed to turn these people out. My dad, knowing this, says something like "hey isn't this the jerk from last week?"

The guy then miraculously wakes up and starts hurling insults and has to be held back. Charming but makes for good stories at least.
12points
44
6