Bored Panda
"Candyland Invented During The Polio Epidemic": 30 Wholesome Things That Are Actually Disturbing
CuriositiesMAR 5, 2025

"Candyland Invented During The Polio Epidemic": 30 Wholesome Things That Are Actually Disturbing

53
12
You know how bears look fluffy and huggable but you know better than to actually try to hug one? (If not friend, why friend-shaped, right?) Similarly, some things or stories seem wholesome at first, but at their core, they are actually not that fluffy—scary, even.
Members of the ‘Ask Reddit’ community recently discussed such deceitful phenomena, sharing stories about things that are widely considered wholesome, yet to many people’s surprise, have rather disturbing backstories. The thread featured everything from the Drifters’ song “Save the Last Dance for Me” to the beloved mascot Chucky E. Cheese, whose origin story is apparently not all flowers and butterflies. So, if your curiosity has been awakened and you feel brave enough to shatter the wholesome exterior that some things bear, scroll down to find netizens’ stories in the list below and feel free to add more in the comments if you’re familiar with something that looks wholesome, but isn’t.

#21

A bishop stands with a staff, gesturing to two kneeling figures, reflecting wholesome yet disturbing backstories.
Valentine’s Day. St. Valentine was k*lled for being the priest to marry people so men could get out of war. For this he was beheaded.
36points

#22

"Candyland Invented During The Polio Epidemic": 30 Wholesome Things That Are Actually Disturbing
The data, which is used for calculating the chances of naval rescue missions, comes from human experiments in concentration camps. They threw inmates in water tanks of different temperature and measured how long it took until they froze to death or drowned.
33points

#23

CPR mannequin torso in a suitcase, labeled "Resusci Anne," illustrating a wholesome item with a disturbing backstory.
"Resusci Annie" - the rubbery anatomical model we learned CPR on. The face is modeled after the death mask of an unidentified and unclaimed woman who drowned in the Seine River in the late 1800's. Toymaker Åsmund S. Lærdal chose to use the woman's face on the mannequin as he thought male trainees might be reluctant to kiss a man's face. The face was sculpted by the Norwegian-Danish sculptor Emma Mattheisen.
32points

#24

"Candyland Invented During The Polio Epidemic": 30 Wholesome Things That Are Actually Disturbing
Alfred Nobel, the creator of the Nobel Prize, was the inventor of dynamite, and amassed his wealth by developing, manufacturing and selling explosives — the “weapons of mass destruction” of his day. A French newspaper mistakenly published an obituary for his death when another arms manufacturer died, calling him “The Merchant of Death”. Seeing what his legacy was, and how he and his family name were going to be remembered, he changed his will to found the Nobel Prize.
31points

#25

A young boy in a vintage portrait, smiling in a shirt and tie, representing things people find wholesome.
Voice actor for classic Disney Peter Pan died alone of a d**g overd*se in an abandoned warehouse after years of being unable to get work in Hollywood later in life.
29points

#26

A large Hello Kitty statue, wearing blue overalls, stands by a store entrance.
Hello Kitty was made as part of a national movement to cute-ify Japan to distract from the abominable war crimes they committed in the second world war.
28points

#27

A young girl with a red bow in her hair looks concerned, contrasting her wholesome appearance with a disturbing expression.
The little girl who played Matilda, in the movie Matilda, mom died before the movie was released of cancer. I believe the director showed her a rough cut before she passed but jeez that made me sad to learn as an adult
28points

#28

"Candyland Invented During The Polio Epidemic": 30 Wholesome Things That Are Actually Disturbing
Best Friends Animal Society was founded by Scientology members who formed their own cult spin-off, The Process Church. They associated with Charles Manson and David Berkowitz, with the author of Helter Skelter postulating that Manson was heavily influenced by Process.


The rescue was originally a grift to keep their church going. They eventually moved to rescue full time after realizing how incredibly lucrative (and like their church, tax-free) it could be.


With $200,000,000 in assets, $314,000,000 in 2024 revenue, and 2 private jets, you can see just how well their grift has paid off.
27points

#29

"Candyland Invented During The Polio Epidemic": 30 Wholesome Things That Are Actually Disturbing
Milo and Otis is a cute, wholesome film about a cat and a dog on a crazy adventure, Homeward Bound style. But many, many animals were k*lled in making the movie. There’s one scene where a cat falls down a waterfall in a box, and apparently that had to shoot that scene multiple times because the cats kept dying.
25points

#30

Colorful Neopets characters posing together, showcasing a mix of wholesome appearances with potentially disturbing backstories.
For a while, neopets was owned and operated by Scientologists. They wanted to add religion to it while they had it.
12points
53
12