Generally in life, the adage that “you get what you pay for” remains true. But every now and then, either through a lucky good investment or just a second hand seller who doesn’t know what they are doing, people end up striking gold.
Someone asked “What is the cheapest thing you bought that turned out to be very valuable or expensive?” and netizens share their best stories. From lucky cash finds in lost envelopes to folks who got something that ended up being massively popular, get comfortable as you scroll through, upvote your favorites and be sure to comment your thoughts and experiences below.
#21

Bought a nice beach painting in a thrift store in Florida.
The artist was Alfred Hair https://www.floridahighwaymenpaintings.com/highwaymen/alfred-hair/
Of the Florida Highwaymen https://backusmuseum.org/highwaymen
The painting is a twin to one that hangs in the National Gallery. https://nmaahc.si.edu/explore/stories/highwaymen-segregation-era-florida-artists-sold-and-often-painted-roadside
More importantly to me is that the purchase led to me meeting and making friends with several of the Highwaymen. .
Report
122points
#22
I bought a bra for a girl when I was 16, cost about $18 I think.
Well, 25 years and two kids later we joke about it every now and then, and I still think about my idiot self as a teen thinking I'd get to take that bra off some day if I was lucky.
Report
122points
#23

1) studying for finals in college December 1989 I bought a six pack of Diet Pepsi....won a free 2L and the brand new Nintendo game boy (all for spending about $2.75) 2) bought a barely worn pair of Prada Mary Jane's at a thift store in Chelsea NYC for $40. They were going for $800 brand new 2) bought a Russian fox fur hat for $12 At a thrift store...retaiing for $1200 4) won a lot of 6 silver necklaces at auction for $9.25....one was a vintage Tiffany and Co. worth about $300 5) found an inch long pin on the ground going out to catch a bus....cleaned it up, 18k Tiffany and Co. bumblebee pin with ruby eyes. My late father always said, "I'd rather be lucky than good," and that is my motto as well!
121points
#24
I won U2's first single, 1000 of which were released only in Ireland in 1979 and hand-numbered, from the radio show competition that determined which track would be on the A-side. Had I paid for it, it would have been £1.49. Today I'm negotiating selling it for between $3000-$5000. Not too shabby.
Report
117points
#25
Nothing crazy but years ago I was throwing a mad hatter tea party for my daughter and decided to get teacups at the thrift store so kids could take them home after if they wanted.
Found a set of 11 cups and saucers for $0.99 each and loved them. I’d wanted mismatched for the kids but loved the design I bought them for myself. Tried to search them online to see if I could find a 12th and maybe a tea/coffee pot/carafe and found them listed individually for around $20-40 and the pots for over $150.
Didn’t ever buy the 12th and with my luck they’re full of lead but still pretty.
Report
97points
#26

A late 17th century printing of Ben Jonson's play "The Alchemist", found at a thrift store for fifty cents.
Report
88points
#27

Mountain Dew limited edition flavors. Picked up a bunch of 20oz bottles and cases of 12 oz cans around 2005 after seeing collectors pay a lot for discontinued Surge and such. Ended up selling most for $100-200 apiece about a year ago. Ended up using most of the money to fix my drywall and carpet after most of the cans exploded.
82points
#28

I bought a sealed set of the Burger King gold Pokemon cards for like 40$. The person gave me a HUGE binder also full of like 1st gen original cards. I've sold some of the cards and made a couple grand and still have plenty.
81points
#29

I once bought a bag of chips and there was this event on their company where they put random amounts of money in random bags and I bough the bag for like a buck and won 100 pretty worth ngl.
75points
#30

I got a bag for 10 bucks at a thrift store which would cost like 200 in an actual store.
72points
#31
Bought a comic for 2 bucks from a Lyft driver cleaned it pressed it then sent it to get pressed again and graded at cgc worth 2k last time I checked.
Report
57points
#32

Bought a McIntosh receiver and speakers at a garage sale for $500 total. They were from the 90s.
Most likely were $10-$20k brand new.
50points
#33
Got into the Game Stop short squeeze pretty early. Made several thousand dollars without any work or contributing to society. It was nice. I felt like a banker for a short time lording over the peasents
I wish I would have had more liquid money at the time to buy more :/.
Report
49points
#34
I bought a lot of Nintendo DS / 3DS games for either retail or $10-$20 at p**n stores in the mid 2010's.
Now the least expensive ones are going $75+, some over $500.
No, I am not going to sell them.
A few years ago I also got about $200 worth of Lego sets (new in the box/ still sealed) for $25.
Report
41points
#35

About 6.5 NVDA shares at $141.
23points

