It’s perhaps a bit strange that so many parents are happy to pass off the task of looking after their children to college students or even teenagers. However, for so many people it was the number one way to make some cold, hard cash when they were young. But, as anyone with even a tiny morsel of imagination can guess, sometimes things go wrong.
So we’ve gathered some of the creepiest stories from current and former babysitters. Get comfortable as you scroll through, upvote the scariest examples and be sure to add your own thoughts and experiences to the comments down below.
#21
I was 14 looking after a 10 and 7 year old, overnight stay at a house In the sketchier part of town. I lived in Winnipeg so there was some gang activity in that area of town.
Everything started out normal, just hanging out watching tv until a kid knocked on the door about 16 years old, asked if the 2 could come and hang out, I said no because i had no idea if that was ok and told him sorry. This guy messages the 2 kids I'm looking after on their phone or whatever, and they want to go hang out with him, but still unsure about it, a bigger teenager wanting to hang out with the 2 young kids seemed weird even at 14 so i said no.
The kids eventually just decided that they were going whether i said yes or not, and left the house while i was in the bathroom.
Im a 14 year old scared of the neighborhood so i never got very far from the house looking for them. I called the mom of the kids right away and she came back from her party very quickly, and found the kids in no time, dragged them back to the house and I witnessed the scolding of a life time. She apologized to me a ton but I just felt bad about the whole thing.
Got paid a hundred bucks for it tho.
TLDR; kids left the house to hang out with weird older possibly gang affiliated teenagers.
Everything started out normal, just hanging out watching tv until a kid knocked on the door about 16 years old, asked if the 2 could come and hang out, I said no because i had no idea if that was ok and told him sorry. This guy messages the 2 kids I'm looking after on their phone or whatever, and they want to go hang out with him, but still unsure about it, a bigger teenager wanting to hang out with the 2 young kids seemed weird even at 14 so i said no.
The kids eventually just decided that they were going whether i said yes or not, and left the house while i was in the bathroom.
Im a 14 year old scared of the neighborhood so i never got very far from the house looking for them. I called the mom of the kids right away and she came back from her party very quickly, and found the kids in no time, dragged them back to the house and I witnessed the scolding of a life time. She apologized to me a ton but I just felt bad about the whole thing.
Got paid a hundred bucks for it tho.
TLDR; kids left the house to hang out with weird older possibly gang affiliated teenagers.
Report
10points
#22

Babysat two kids, an older girl and a younger boy. The boy was adopted (the girl was not) and mentally troubled. As one point he dragged the vacuum cleaner out of the closest into the room plugged it in in the corner and just started screaming. Stuff like that the entire time.
Report
10points
#23

I was about 13 and watching a kid old enough to walk and run, but not really talk. He was happily playing with cars and made a crash knocking his favourite under the couch. The couch had a pretty big gap under it and I was a small 13 year old so sliding under the couch to grab it was pretty easy for me. Well, when I come up from under the couch the kid is gone from the living room. As I sttod there wondering where he got to I could hear a munching noise, like someone was chewing on wet. I headed to the kitchen figuring the kid grabbed some of the apple that I left out on the table earlier when I saw movement from the bathroom. I don't remember if I dashed over or not, but when I got to the bathroom the kid was popping pills like they were candy.
I did my best to scrape the pills from the kids mouth and luckily they were just multivitamins, but young me was still terrified so I called the number his parents left for me. I thought they were going to be so mad with me, but they weren't too concerned. They came home at the time planned, payed me in full and gave me a ride home. The kid was fine and I babysat him a bunch more afterwards.
I did my best to scrape the pills from the kids mouth and luckily they were just multivitamins, but young me was still terrified so I called the number his parents left for me. I thought they were going to be so mad with me, but they weren't too concerned. They came home at the time planned, payed me in full and gave me a ride home. The kid was fine and I babysat him a bunch more afterwards.
Report
10points
#24

Babysat a 1 year old who was very different than me, ethnically. I wasn’t familiar with the food they chose to feed their daughter & parents insisted she eat these sausage links (looked like them). Cut them up as well as I could but she started choking on one ... I thank GOD I was certified in CPR. Had to stick my pinky finger in her throat while she was basically upside down on my arm.
After I couldn’t stop crying and never could she. She was okay and perfectly fine but I had to decline watching her after.
After I couldn’t stop crying and never could she. She was okay and perfectly fine but I had to decline watching her after.
Report
9points
#25
My friend asked me to come with her to baby sit her niece and nephew while their parents went out for the night. We got all set up with our movies and munchies and we were loving having the big tv all to ourselves. My friends sister called her around midnight saying “Make sure the doors are locked..” and explained that her husband had been thrown out the bar for being drunk and violent and was on his way home and my friends sister didn’t want him in the house. So we locked the doors. He arrived at the house, drunk and banging all windows and doors to get in. We just sat tight in our bed (which was a pull out bed on the floor) thinking he’d go away. Then we heard a crash and he had broken the window at the back door, let himself in, covered the entire house in his blood and was shouting and falling about naked. He walked into our room and obviously didn’t see us on the floor in the dark. He tripped over us and landed on top of me. My friend hit the lights and I was horrified to see I was covered in his blood and he was naked and incoherent. 13 year old me was not impressed at all.
Report
9points
#26

They decided they didn't like me, so they locked me out of their room and all three of them climbed out on the roof with the cordless phone. Then they called their grandmother who came over and scolded me.
7points
#27
I was maybe 12 years old and watching two little girls. I had only watched them once before and so I was still really trying to impress their mom, they lived in a bad part of town and we didn’t play outside very often.
This night I was to spend the night and sleep on their couch. In the living room there was a door that led outside to the backyard, the front door was directly across the little townhouse from the back door. Off to the right, looking towards the front door was a kitchen and on the left was the stairs that led to the second floor bedrooms and bathroom. When you opened the front door all the way, the door blocked off the access to the stairwell.
At some point I fell asleep on the couch and was snapped awake. There standing in the house by the back foot is a VERY drunk man. He’s dirty, he’s drunk and he’s walking towards me. My 12 year old mind was panicking and I knew if I called the police, I’d be attached to the wall by the phone and couldn’t prevent him from going upstairs. They didn’t have a cordless phone yet.
I immediately started talking to this man, he says he’s looking for someone and he’s going to go upstairs, I bolt off the couch and beat him to the front door. That’s when I noticed headlights out front. Through the peep hole I see it’s a taxi and I fling the door all the way open and start yelling for the driver to help me. He rolled his window up and shrugged.
I do not know how I did it, but I managed to stand in front of the wide open door and block his way up the stairs. He’s pushing me hard and all I can think of are these little girls asleep in their beds and I remembered he’s looking for someone who doesn’t live here.
I say “hey hey!! Rosie and Trevor are waiting for you in the cab! Look! They’re waving you dude!”
He buys it and walks out the front door just enough for me to slam and lock it. I run the the back door and lock that too. After him banging on the door for a few minutes he goes around back and tries to get back in.
He leaves in the taxi cab and I didn’t sleep for the rest of the night. I never told anyone, never phoned the police and never, ever went to bed without locking all doors and windows again.
This night I was to spend the night and sleep on their couch. In the living room there was a door that led outside to the backyard, the front door was directly across the little townhouse from the back door. Off to the right, looking towards the front door was a kitchen and on the left was the stairs that led to the second floor bedrooms and bathroom. When you opened the front door all the way, the door blocked off the access to the stairwell.
At some point I fell asleep on the couch and was snapped awake. There standing in the house by the back foot is a VERY drunk man. He’s dirty, he’s drunk and he’s walking towards me. My 12 year old mind was panicking and I knew if I called the police, I’d be attached to the wall by the phone and couldn’t prevent him from going upstairs. They didn’t have a cordless phone yet.
I immediately started talking to this man, he says he’s looking for someone and he’s going to go upstairs, I bolt off the couch and beat him to the front door. That’s when I noticed headlights out front. Through the peep hole I see it’s a taxi and I fling the door all the way open and start yelling for the driver to help me. He rolled his window up and shrugged.
I do not know how I did it, but I managed to stand in front of the wide open door and block his way up the stairs. He’s pushing me hard and all I can think of are these little girls asleep in their beds and I remembered he’s looking for someone who doesn’t live here.
I say “hey hey!! Rosie and Trevor are waiting for you in the cab! Look! They’re waving you dude!”
He buys it and walks out the front door just enough for me to slam and lock it. I run the the back door and lock that too. After him banging on the door for a few minutes he goes around back and tries to get back in.
He leaves in the taxi cab and I didn’t sleep for the rest of the night. I never told anyone, never phoned the police and never, ever went to bed without locking all doors and windows again.
Report
7points
#28
I was in highschool at the time and probably 17. I was babysitting for a 4 year old boy, and just before bedtime, I had to let their dog out to pee one last time. I shut the door behind me so the child wouldn't get cold with the door open, but as I try and re-enter with the dog, the door is locked behind me. The boy sees this and we try together to get the door unlocked (the deadbolt was unlocked but the handle had a lock). He could NOT manage to do this and was beginning to freak out. He then tells me with increasing panic that he can smell burning. Obviously I am freaking out on the inside, but on the outside I told him to stay put and immediately went to the neighbors. Luckily they were out drinking in their garage and all came over to help us and wait while the police were called. I didn't care if I had to smash a window, I was getting back to that kid and doing my job. One of the neighbors successfully talked the child through unlocking the door after about ten minutes and I was able to call off the police response. Nothing was burning, he just had a panic reaction. I got him all tucked into bed, the neighbors went home, and eventually I had to tell his parents what went down.
They never asked me to babysit again.
They never asked me to babysit again.
Report
7points
#29
Was caring for a 3 and 5 year old for a week (24/7) while their parents were out of the country and could not be reached. A few days in, the three year old started complaining of pain, multiple symptoms (including severe swelling and bloody stool) landed us in the ER of the local Children’s Hospital. We waiting in triage overnight for 6 hours with both kids exhausted, and one screaming in pain and inconsolable. I was going out of my MIND. We ended up being admitted and she was diagnosed with an autoimmune disorder. Super fun week!!! The other child (5yo) also had severe food allergies so really could not eat almost anything in the hospital cafeteria. It was, hands down, one of the worst times in my life. I had my worst to date migraine afterwards from all the stress. 0/10, would not recommend. 🙃.
Report
7points
#30
In high school, I regularly tutored an eleven year old girl, and the parents had me babysit her and her twin a couple times. One time, the parents were meant to go downtown to a game then be back around twelve.
Around 8 or so, it started raining very heavily. I live in a gulf city, and storms can blow in fast and turn into flooding quickly. Once it became clear we were in for a big storm the parents tried to head home early, but the streets had already started to flood and they ended up trapped in a parking lot. The parents called and we agreed I'd spend the night in their guest bedroom. I had the kids go to bed and set up in the kitchen to do homework and watch Netflix.
After a bit of this I noticed water seeping in from under the back doors. They had a large house with like three double doors to the back, so it was a big area. I got every towel in the house and started wiping up the water and using the towels to block the door. After this had mostly been cleaned up, I went back to the kitchen table to watch more Netflix. Not even 15 minutes later, the power cuts out and all the lights shutoff. This freaked me out a bit, but I tried to stay calm. Then the burglar alarm went off in the other room. II was in a pitch black house with two kids, surrounded by flooded roads no one can drive on. After a minute, I realized I was the closest thing in the house to an adult, so I grabbed the biggest kitchen knife and went to go check all the doors. They were all still closed and no one was in the house, so I called the parents. It turns out the alarm went off when the power cut out, and I just needed to shut it off with a code upstairs. This happened about 3 more times over the next few hours.
After the power came back on, I thought things had chilled out but then we got a tornado warning. I went and got the kids from upstairs and we all hung out in the study for about an hour until the warning passed. At this point it was about 2 am, and I passed out in the guest bedroom. The parents woke me up when they got home around 7 am and I drove home past giant fallen branches and stalled abandoned cars. It was surreal.
Around 8 or so, it started raining very heavily. I live in a gulf city, and storms can blow in fast and turn into flooding quickly. Once it became clear we were in for a big storm the parents tried to head home early, but the streets had already started to flood and they ended up trapped in a parking lot. The parents called and we agreed I'd spend the night in their guest bedroom. I had the kids go to bed and set up in the kitchen to do homework and watch Netflix.
After a bit of this I noticed water seeping in from under the back doors. They had a large house with like three double doors to the back, so it was a big area. I got every towel in the house and started wiping up the water and using the towels to block the door. After this had mostly been cleaned up, I went back to the kitchen table to watch more Netflix. Not even 15 minutes later, the power cuts out and all the lights shutoff. This freaked me out a bit, but I tried to stay calm. Then the burglar alarm went off in the other room. II was in a pitch black house with two kids, surrounded by flooded roads no one can drive on. After a minute, I realized I was the closest thing in the house to an adult, so I grabbed the biggest kitchen knife and went to go check all the doors. They were all still closed and no one was in the house, so I called the parents. It turns out the alarm went off when the power cut out, and I just needed to shut it off with a code upstairs. This happened about 3 more times over the next few hours.
After the power came back on, I thought things had chilled out but then we got a tornado warning. I went and got the kids from upstairs and we all hung out in the study for about an hour until the warning passed. At this point it was about 2 am, and I passed out in the guest bedroom. The parents woke me up when they got home around 7 am and I drove home past giant fallen branches and stalled abandoned cars. It was surreal.
Report
7points
#31
My mum used to run a “private kindergarten” in our house when my siblings and I were young. She looked after kids from a few months to 8-10 years old.
One day, a boy, who must have been around 3-4 at the time went missing. His parents had just arrived to pick him up and when called for, he didn’t show. We started looking for him, the parents, my mum and myself, the oldest of the children too (I was around 7 years old at the time). I noticed that our front door was open, which was a big no-no in our house: in order to be able keep everyone safe, all doors had to be closed at all times. I went out to our garden through the open door, and started walking while calling the missing boy’s name. Just a few steps from our front door, there was a swimming pool and as I approached it, I noticed the missing boy was floating on top of the water, face down.
My memory gets all blurry here, but I do remember feeling shocked and horrified despite the fact that I didn’t fully understand what has happened. I called out to my mum, she and the boy’s parents came running, the boy was taken away with an ambulance and turned out to be fine. We attended his birthday party later that year and my mum and his parents are still friends today. Oh and the door: the boy’s mother forgot to close it when they arrived which means the boy snuck out and got himself in trouble in less than 5 minutes.
One day, a boy, who must have been around 3-4 at the time went missing. His parents had just arrived to pick him up and when called for, he didn’t show. We started looking for him, the parents, my mum and myself, the oldest of the children too (I was around 7 years old at the time). I noticed that our front door was open, which was a big no-no in our house: in order to be able keep everyone safe, all doors had to be closed at all times. I went out to our garden through the open door, and started walking while calling the missing boy’s name. Just a few steps from our front door, there was a swimming pool and as I approached it, I noticed the missing boy was floating on top of the water, face down.
My memory gets all blurry here, but I do remember feeling shocked and horrified despite the fact that I didn’t fully understand what has happened. I called out to my mum, she and the boy’s parents came running, the boy was taken away with an ambulance and turned out to be fine. We attended his birthday party later that year and my mum and his parents are still friends today. Oh and the door: the boy’s mother forgot to close it when they arrived which means the boy snuck out and got himself in trouble in less than 5 minutes.
Report
7points
#32

This was about 25 years ago.
The family I was sitting for had a microwave that was so old you could turn it on with the door open. They also had a six year old. And the kid microwaved his hand. He only did it for 10 seconds (THANK GOD) to "see how it felt" but ust those 10 seconds put him in the hospital for a week because he literally cooked some of his hand. Scared the heck out of me, and his parents, who rushed home from dinner to take him to the hospital. I guess he turned out okay, but I don't really know; they never had me babysit for them again even though it was not my fault at all (I was busy making the 8 year old brush his teeth and the 6 year old snuck out of bed and ran into the kitchen).
The family I was sitting for had a microwave that was so old you could turn it on with the door open. They also had a six year old. And the kid microwaved his hand. He only did it for 10 seconds (THANK GOD) to "see how it felt" but ust those 10 seconds put him in the hospital for a week because he literally cooked some of his hand. Scared the heck out of me, and his parents, who rushed home from dinner to take him to the hospital. I guess he turned out okay, but I don't really know; they never had me babysit for them again even though it was not my fault at all (I was busy making the 8 year old brush his teeth and the 6 year old snuck out of bed and ran into the kitchen).
Report
6points
#33
My girlfriend (now my wife) and I were watching her 2 month old niece for about an hour. The baby just started choking on air. Nothing in her mouth. She hadn’t eaten in a while so I don’t think she could have been choking on puke and in any case none came out. It felt like it was going on for a long time.
She stopped as I was starting to dial 911. The baby was perfectly happy afterwards. We still have no idea what happened. She’s 8 now so I guess she’s been ok :).
She stopped as I was starting to dial 911. The baby was perfectly happy afterwards. We still have no idea what happened. She’s 8 now so I guess she’s been ok :).
Report
6points
#34
When I was a preteen I would help out in the church nursery on Sundays to get out of having to go to sermon. One of the women who ran the nursery asked me to pass out animal crackers to the kids, which were stored in one of those bulk plastic containers you get at Costco. The container was nearly empty, so I stuck my hand in and started fishing around for crackers. The next thing I know I feel a small, circular object and pick it up. It turns out to be a pill. So I bring it to the woman in charge. She speaks broken English and acts like she doesn't have a clue what I'm talking about, so I show her the pill in the palm of my hand. (I believe it was either an aspirin or Tylenol, it was small and white.) She didn't seem to care one bit that there was medicine in the bottom of the container and told me to keep passing out the crackers. I told my Mom what happened and she spoke with one of the youth ministers. I don't know what ever became of the lady, I stopped going to church soon thereafter for other reasons, but I always wondered what the hell that pill was doing in a bunch of crackers and what could've happened to one of the kids if they had ingested it.
Report
5points
#35
Babysitting for my parents to go out to dinner (I’m 20 my little sister is 1.5).
Well they weren’t home when they said they would be, or hours later. Not answering their phones, no one I knew had heard from them. My dad usually checks in on the two of us every hour or two, so no contact for hours was very strange, especially past when they said they would be home. I just remember laying in bed for hours looking at my little sister scared that something bad had happened to our parents and I would be alone to raise her.
Turns out that after dinner they went to an old friend’s house and fell asleep on their couch. They were perfectly safe, just slept through all my phone calls.
Well they weren’t home when they said they would be, or hours later. Not answering their phones, no one I knew had heard from them. My dad usually checks in on the two of us every hour or two, so no contact for hours was very strange, especially past when they said they would be home. I just remember laying in bed for hours looking at my little sister scared that something bad had happened to our parents and I would be alone to raise her.
Turns out that after dinner they went to an old friend’s house and fell asleep on their couch. They were perfectly safe, just slept through all my phone calls.
Report
5points
#36
The family friend who baby sat me and my siblings was watching some kids including some of her own grandkids when her grandson got attacked by a neighbors dog. The family friend was going outside to check on the older kids out back and her infant grandson managed to slip out with her without her knowing. The neighbors had a big black dog (maybe a Rottweiler) that was chained in the backyard and the kids knew to avoid it, but her infant grandson did the opposite and was picked up and shaken like a rag doll. His mom drove him to the hospital crying while he was in the back seat telling her "it will be ok mommy" trying to calm her down and he needed something like 30 stitches or more.
Report
5points
#37
When I was about 17 I babysat this little boy who was about 3 years old. His mom worked at 5am, and she had to walk to work so she always wanted me to be at her house by 4am. So I would show up tired, she would leave for work, and I would lock the door behind her and lay in her bed with the toddler and fall back asleep.
Well one day he woke up before me, went into the front room, unlocked the front door to their upstairs apartment, walked downstairs, sat on the sidewalk and cried for his mom. I woke up to someone knocking on the door, and panicked when I noticed there was no child in the room with me. I ran out of the room and saw a woman standing in the open door-way with the little boy. I said thanks and closed the door. (Later I felt really bad about just closing the door on her but I was freaking out!!)
I didn't know what to do, I was crying and having a panic attack. I called my mom and told her what happened and she told me I needed to tell his mom. Well before I had the chance she had already heard about it and called me. (small town)
Needless to say she was not very happy, but she still let me babysit until I eventually got a different job.
TL/DR the toddler I was watching left the apartment while I was asleep and was returned to me by a complete stranger.
Well one day he woke up before me, went into the front room, unlocked the front door to their upstairs apartment, walked downstairs, sat on the sidewalk and cried for his mom. I woke up to someone knocking on the door, and panicked when I noticed there was no child in the room with me. I ran out of the room and saw a woman standing in the open door-way with the little boy. I said thanks and closed the door. (Later I felt really bad about just closing the door on her but I was freaking out!!)
I didn't know what to do, I was crying and having a panic attack. I called my mom and told her what happened and she told me I needed to tell his mom. Well before I had the chance she had already heard about it and called me. (small town)
Needless to say she was not very happy, but she still let me babysit until I eventually got a different job.
TL/DR the toddler I was watching left the apartment while I was asleep and was returned to me by a complete stranger.
Report
5points
#38
Babysat a friend's kids a few weeks ago. One of them (about 1.5 yo) came wandering out of the hallway pointing and saying "man! man!" There was no one home except me, the kids and another mum. I'm hoping he just saw a picture or maybe a neighbour through a window or something.
Report
4points
#39
I’m not even a babysitter. I worked at a bike shop and the owner told me to take his kids to get ice cream. They’re really young and kept bothering him and he wanted them out of the shop for a bit.
We start going down the street and the boy just bolts - he ran straight across a pretty busy intersection while the light was green.
Thankfully it turned out OK as he crossed back over after the light turned red. We did end up getting the ice cream. I made him hold my hand the rest of the way. But, I was totally unprepared to watch someone’s kids and felt like I had to because my boss insisted.
We start going down the street and the boy just bolts - he ran straight across a pretty busy intersection while the light was green.
Thankfully it turned out OK as he crossed back over after the light turned red. We did end up getting the ice cream. I made him hold my hand the rest of the way. But, I was totally unprepared to watch someone’s kids and felt like I had to because my boss insisted.
Report
4points
#40
I'd lived in NYC for 3 months and was babysitting to make ends meet while going to grad school. It was my second time babysitting an 8 year old with special needs and her 2 year old sister. After dinner, something set the older one off and she ran to the door, flung it open, and ran out of the apartment. It was so unexpected, and I was in just my socks. Initially I ran to the door after her, but I didn't think I could run down the stone steps fast enough in my socks to catch her without leaving the 2 year old for too long. I had visions of her toddling after us and falling down the stairs. I picked the younger one up and went down the stairs as fast as I safely could.
Now thankfully this story has a happy ending. The parents of these kids were actually just one floor below us, so I rushed in as calmly as I could and just said, "I need you to come with me please." To make a long story short, we quickly found the 8 year old hiding in an office on the same floor, but man, that feeling of "I just lost someone's child in New York City." I went on to babysit them for 3 years, but after that I *always* triple locked the door and the few times she tried that move again I channeled my inner Usain Bolt and beat her to the door to hold it closed.
TL;DR always be ready for a child to try and escape.
Now thankfully this story has a happy ending. The parents of these kids were actually just one floor below us, so I rushed in as calmly as I could and just said, "I need you to come with me please." To make a long story short, we quickly found the 8 year old hiding in an office on the same floor, but man, that feeling of "I just lost someone's child in New York City." I went on to babysit them for 3 years, but after that I *always* triple locked the door and the few times she tried that move again I channeled my inner Usain Bolt and beat her to the door to hold it closed.
TL;DR always be ready for a child to try and escape.
Report
4points

