The last few years have demonstrated that even if you don’t care about economics, it finds its way into every facet of your life. Non-drivers still feel the rise of gas prices, tariffs can alter what’s available in your grocery store, so it can be helpful to actually get a frame of reference for the entire thing.
So we’ve gathered the best questions and answers from an internet community dedicated to helping people understand economics, money and the world around them. Get comfortable as you scroll through, upvote the most interesting posts and be sure to share your own thoughts in the comments down below.
#21 Why Is Japan’s Gdp Relatively Low If They Overwork So Much And Have So Many World-Famous Companies?

There is a multitude of reasons, but crucially, working more hours does not mean producing more. German workers produce 90.9 USD per hour worked and work 1,353.89 hours for 123,069 USD of annual output, while Japanese workers produce 53.4 USD working 1,738.36 hours, for 92,828 USD of annual output.
There is a range of different deciding factors for lower labour productivity, some of which include training, capital inputs, and adoption of technology. But certainly, per hour productivity is also likely to diminish as hours increase.
There is a range of different deciding factors for lower labour productivity, some of which include training, capital inputs, and adoption of technology. But certainly, per hour productivity is also likely to diminish as hours increase.
Report
7points
#22 Nvidia Is Worth Over $4t. Adjusted For Inflation, That's $2.5t In The Year 2000. How Is This Not A Bubble?

How do you define a bubble? How do you determine what a company is "legitimately" worth? The standard theoretical approach to the value of a company is the net present value of future earnings.
NVidia is valued at $4 trillion by the market and is expected to make $100 billion this year. If we expect it to make $100 billion every year, it is definitely not worth anywhere near $4 trillion. But investors have seen it grow incredibly fast and expect it to continue to grow as the AI boom transforms our economy. How fast? If its earnings grow at a little over 20% each year, that $4 trillion value is justified. If it averages 30% growth, which is far slower than it has grown the last couple of years, it is a bargain.
So is it a bubble? I don't know because I don't know how much higher earnings will grow and how quickly that growth will be. I used to think that Apple and Amazon were overpriced, but their earnings growth ended up making them look like they were bargains.
I don't spend any time worrying about it and just buy total market index funds. I'll own the best and worst performing stocks and get on with my life.
NVidia is valued at $4 trillion by the market and is expected to make $100 billion this year. If we expect it to make $100 billion every year, it is definitely not worth anywhere near $4 trillion. But investors have seen it grow incredibly fast and expect it to continue to grow as the AI boom transforms our economy. How fast? If its earnings grow at a little over 20% each year, that $4 trillion value is justified. If it averages 30% growth, which is far slower than it has grown the last couple of years, it is a bargain.
So is it a bubble? I don't know because I don't know how much higher earnings will grow and how quickly that growth will be. I used to think that Apple and Amazon were overpriced, but their earnings growth ended up making them look like they were bargains.
I don't spend any time worrying about it and just buy total market index funds. I'll own the best and worst performing stocks and get on with my life.
Report
6points
#23 What Happens To The Us Dollar If We Continue To Shatter Relationships With Allies?

USD is the largest reserve currency, but not the only one, and it can be used as a reserve currency without active involvement of the US. Maybe there'd be a loss of seignorage but we're talking probably less than $30 billion/year. I don't think diplomacy alone (if it gets into tariffs that's another matter) will lead to lower valuation of the dollar, at least not through this mechanism.
Report
6points
#24 What Is Stopping Anyone From Accruing $100,000 In Credit Card Debt And Filing For Bankruptcy?

I work in banking/finance field
They have models predicting this type of behavior and the companies don't easily give out 100k credit lines. And even if you get a 100k credit lines there are models predicting this behavior and when triggered will go down the line.
So you can try, but will take time to build history and would need to do it stealthily, but I would guess 95% of people could get at most 10-15k
Report
6points
#25 In 2012, The Seventh Richest Man In The World Was A Brazilian, With A Fortune Of 30 Billion Dollars. Today, The Seventh Richest Man In The World Is Bill Gates, With A Fortune Of 128 Billion Dollars. Are The Richest People Getting Much Richer ?

Measuring by the seventh richest is a very arbitrary amount.
Also, Gates's wealth varies significantly depending on what source you read from. Forbes shows him currently at 108M, and at about 61M in 2012. So, he's done well over the past 13 years.
One must keep in mind that this period had a very long, healthy period for stocks. Literally anyone bought into the market for that period would have done very well, as the S&P 500 has increased about 486% since 2012. Everyone got richer, and the rich did too.
There is no guarantee that the current status quo will continue. In fact, we can guarantee that it will not last indefinitely. Another recession is always coming, and no bull run lasts forever.
6points
#26 Can We Trust The Economic Data Coming Out Of This White House?

With the caveat that we're in uncharted territory here, I think the most likely outcome is that the quality of government data degrades and certain data series stop being released. note here that I mean official government numbers, not whatever trump has decided he thinks gas prices are today.
this is essentially what is being proposed with the monthly jobs report (proposed stoppage of the report) and what has happened to the CPI (data quality degradation, largely from budget cuts). I'm distinguishing here from "unreliable due to budget cuts" and "unreliable due to outright manipulation"
it is very hard to convincingly fabricate data, and the trump administration is unusually incompetent. for something like inflation statistics, you will have the might of the bond market pouring over whatever is produced because inflation protected bonds are a major piece of many portfolios and those are indexed to the CPI.
For something like GDP, all the various subcomponents have to add up in ways that are really, really challenging to fake convincingly (GDP by industry, by geography, by geography by industry, etc. -- all those have to agree and all those components get analyzed individually by third parties). Doing something like releasing a headline GDP number and no subcomponents would be tantamount to doctoring the data, but would also be very obvious.
I would also expect that if there were secret methodological changes, or data not being reported faithfully, that this would be exposed fairly quickly by whistleblowers. Edit: To further state this, the people at the assorted government statistical agencies are highly competent and ethical (for instance, see the across the political spectrum condemnation of trump's pick for the BLS). I fully expect the statistical agencies to continue to operate with the ethics they have demonstrated thus far. I will also trust the data released until given a reason to think otherwise. With that being said, I think there are large risks to data becoming less reliable, both from budget cuts, and outright political hackery (e.g., trying to only count citizens in the census, or certain data series not being released)
Between those two factors, I suspect that we will know if data have become untrustworthy, but as I said, I think the most likely outcome is that the data get higher variance and certain data series stop being released.
As a side note to people in the comments who are saying "the data are already untrustworthy/being altered" -- I have seen no evidence that this is true and parroting conspiracy theories will result in a ban. There's plenty of reason for concern and no reason to make things up.
this is essentially what is being proposed with the monthly jobs report (proposed stoppage of the report) and what has happened to the CPI (data quality degradation, largely from budget cuts). I'm distinguishing here from "unreliable due to budget cuts" and "unreliable due to outright manipulation"
it is very hard to convincingly fabricate data, and the trump administration is unusually incompetent. for something like inflation statistics, you will have the might of the bond market pouring over whatever is produced because inflation protected bonds are a major piece of many portfolios and those are indexed to the CPI.
For something like GDP, all the various subcomponents have to add up in ways that are really, really challenging to fake convincingly (GDP by industry, by geography, by geography by industry, etc. -- all those have to agree and all those components get analyzed individually by third parties). Doing something like releasing a headline GDP number and no subcomponents would be tantamount to doctoring the data, but would also be very obvious.
I would also expect that if there were secret methodological changes, or data not being reported faithfully, that this would be exposed fairly quickly by whistleblowers. Edit: To further state this, the people at the assorted government statistical agencies are highly competent and ethical (for instance, see the across the political spectrum condemnation of trump's pick for the BLS). I fully expect the statistical agencies to continue to operate with the ethics they have demonstrated thus far. I will also trust the data released until given a reason to think otherwise. With that being said, I think there are large risks to data becoming less reliable, both from budget cuts, and outright political hackery (e.g., trying to only count citizens in the census, or certain data series not being released)
Between those two factors, I suspect that we will know if data have become untrustworthy, but as I said, I think the most likely outcome is that the data get higher variance and certain data series stop being released.
As a side note to people in the comments who are saying "the data are already untrustworthy/being altered" -- I have seen no evidence that this is true and parroting conspiracy theories will result in a ban. There's plenty of reason for concern and no reason to make things up.
Report
6points
#27 Can Someone Explain How A Town Can Have A Median Home Price Of 7 Million Dollars And A Median Income Of 60,000 Dollars?

Answer: The situation in Telluride, Colorado, where there's a significant disparity between median home prices and median incomes, is not unique to this town but is a common phenomenon in many high-cost areas, particularly those with desirable real estate.
First, many homeowners in Telluride are very wealthy individuals, often from out-of-town, who own second homes or vacation properties. These individuals do not necessarily earn their income in Telluride, so their earnings are not reflected in the town’s median income. This means that a significant portion of the housing stock may be owned by people who live elsewhere most of the time, such as vacation homes or investment properties.
Also, many high-cost areas have programs to provide affordable housing for local workers. In Telluride, there are government sponsored housing initiatives to ensure that people working in essential services can afford to live locally.
First, many homeowners in Telluride are very wealthy individuals, often from out-of-town, who own second homes or vacation properties. These individuals do not necessarily earn their income in Telluride, so their earnings are not reflected in the town’s median income. This means that a significant portion of the housing stock may be owned by people who live elsewhere most of the time, such as vacation homes or investment properties.
Also, many high-cost areas have programs to provide affordable housing for local workers. In Telluride, there are government sponsored housing initiatives to ensure that people working in essential services can afford to live locally.
Report
6points
#28 Why Are UK Salaries So Uncompetitive At A Global Level?

As Paul Krugman said, productivity isn't everything, but in the long run, it is almost everything.
UK productivity growth has basically stalled since the early 2000s. Real output per hour worked in 2026 is only marginally higher than it was in 2007 before the recession, and the typical current-day UK worker is about 20% less productive than their German counterpart, and about 30-40% less compared to the U.S. depending on what metric you use.
The reason why the UK is unproductive is a much longer discussion. I would note that it was hit harder by the GFC than most countries due its relatively outsized financial sector, and Brexit was a huge shock right when most countries were pulling out of the aftermath of the recession.
UK productivity growth has basically stalled since the early 2000s. Real output per hour worked in 2026 is only marginally higher than it was in 2007 before the recession, and the typical current-day UK worker is about 20% less productive than their German counterpart, and about 30-40% less compared to the U.S. depending on what metric you use.
The reason why the UK is unproductive is a much longer discussion. I would note that it was hit harder by the GFC than most countries due its relatively outsized financial sector, and Brexit was a huge shock right when most countries were pulling out of the aftermath of the recession.
Report
5points
#29 Does The Idea That The Rich Is Destroying The Us Economy To Buy Up Everything Make Sense At All?

It’s highly unlikely. Trump thinks (rightly or wrongly) the US consumer will weather his tariff strategy better than the consumers in our trade partners’ markets. Ultimately he believes the pressure from these tariffs will force other leaders to negotiate more US favorable trade terms.
He and his team believe other nations reliance upon exports to the US is a bigger piece of their overall economy. This can be backed up with data when you look at exports to the US as a percentage of GDP and vice versa. However, this does not mean the trade policy will work as planned.
I don’t know how this will play out, but much of the media discussion has been around how the US consumer will be impacted, but make no mistake it will severely impact our trade partners as well.
Once again before some of you warriors jump on me, I am not defending or criticizing the Trump admin, but simply explaining their strategy.
He and his team believe other nations reliance upon exports to the US is a bigger piece of their overall economy. This can be backed up with data when you look at exports to the US as a percentage of GDP and vice versa. However, this does not mean the trade policy will work as planned.
I don’t know how this will play out, but much of the media discussion has been around how the US consumer will be impacted, but make no mistake it will severely impact our trade partners as well.
Once again before some of you warriors jump on me, I am not defending or criticizing the Trump admin, but simply explaining their strategy.
5points
#30 Why Is The Output Of 300 Million Educated Indians Not Even A Tenth Of 300 Million Americans ?
Questions like these are what Adam Smith was pondering when he wrote "Wealth of Nations" about 250 years ago. Productive output is shaped not just by the education level of individuals but by the institutions that allow labor, capital, and resources to be efficiently allocated. The U.S. has highly developed financial markets, legal systems, property rights, and infrastructure that allow businesses and individuals to maximize their productivity. India, despite having educated people, is not as efficient in these areas, leading to underutilization of its labor force.
There's also capital accumulation. The U.S. has significantly higher levels of capital investment, including advanced technologies, machinery, and infrastructure, which dramatically boosts worker productivity. Even highly educated Indians may lack access to the same level of resources that Americans have, limiting their ability to generate comparable output.
There's also capital accumulation. The U.S. has significantly higher levels of capital investment, including advanced technologies, machinery, and infrastructure, which dramatically boosts worker productivity. Even highly educated Indians may lack access to the same level of resources that Americans have, limiting their ability to generate comparable output.
Report
3points
#31 Wouldn't Ubi Just Cause The Price Of Everything To Surge?
The actual financing aside, it depends. UBI is ultimately not really a flat payment, because we tax as well. Usually it's financed via some kind of income tax, and since income taxes are progressive, the net benefit from UBI falls with income. So if you earn $0 you get the full $2000, if you earn $500 you might only get $1900, and so on. For high incomes, it's something more like -$4000.
So it's ultimately redistribution.
This can definitely change inflation, but it's a one time change, because it's a one time change to the income distribution.
The bigger problem is how to actually finance such an UBI because it would necessitate quite massive taxation.
So it's ultimately redistribution.
This can definitely change inflation, but it's a one time change, because it's a one time change to the income distribution.
The bigger problem is how to actually finance such an UBI because it would necessitate quite massive taxation.
Report
3points
#32 If The Us Wants To Shrink Their Debt Then Is A Temporary Tax Increase On The Wealthiest People Not The Best Solution?

Taxation is partly an economic issue, however it is partly an ethical and political issue.
Who it is "best" to tax depends on your definition of "best". It depends on what your moral goals are. Some people believe that the rich should pay more. If that's your moral view, then why not advocate taxing the rich more?
There are plenty of ways to do it whomever is targeted. The rich could be targeted by higher Estate taxes or by eliminating the step-up basis. The rich could be targeted with a wealth tax. A wealth tax has various economic problems that we have discussed here before. Both would change incentives, of course, as any tax does.
Alternatively, a sales tax or VAT would provide a broad based way for the government to obtain more revenue. That does not target the wealthiest specifically. A permanent sales tax or VAT will hit all people fairly equally in percentage terms if it were charged on all goods and services. A time-limited sales tax or VAT is more complicate and the poor would pay at a larger percentage.
Then there are simple possibilities like increasing income tax or capital gains tax. Those systems are already designed to tax the wealthy more than the less wealthy. Despite what you may have heard, we have a lot of evidence that they do just that. Federal income tax revenue depend on relatively high income people (not on Billionaires, but on people in the top ~10% of income).
Then there's the possibility of reducing government spending. Just like taxation this comes down to morals and beliefs about people. Do you believe that people should be able to retire with state funding at age X? Well, that X could be higher than the current retirement age.
Who it is "best" to tax depends on your definition of "best". It depends on what your moral goals are. Some people believe that the rich should pay more. If that's your moral view, then why not advocate taxing the rich more?
There are plenty of ways to do it whomever is targeted. The rich could be targeted by higher Estate taxes or by eliminating the step-up basis. The rich could be targeted with a wealth tax. A wealth tax has various economic problems that we have discussed here before. Both would change incentives, of course, as any tax does.
Alternatively, a sales tax or VAT would provide a broad based way for the government to obtain more revenue. That does not target the wealthiest specifically. A permanent sales tax or VAT will hit all people fairly equally in percentage terms if it were charged on all goods and services. A time-limited sales tax or VAT is more complicate and the poor would pay at a larger percentage.
Then there are simple possibilities like increasing income tax or capital gains tax. Those systems are already designed to tax the wealthy more than the less wealthy. Despite what you may have heard, we have a lot of evidence that they do just that. Federal income tax revenue depend on relatively high income people (not on Billionaires, but on people in the top ~10% of income).
Then there's the possibility of reducing government spending. Just like taxation this comes down to morals and beliefs about people. Do you believe that people should be able to retire with state funding at age X? Well, that X could be higher than the current retirement age.
2points
#33 Why Should I Care About Economic Growth If Most Of The Wealth From Said Growth Will End Up Going To The Upper 10% Of Society?

Even if some publications want to suggest otherwise, productivity growth and income growth (for the average person) are generally well correlated.
Debates about if and when productivity and pay diverge aside, economic growth is a necessary but not necessarily in of itself sufficient condition for a higher standard of living. Plainly put, if your country only produces (the equivalent of) two bananas per person, you can't eat three.
Meaning that you need to produce what you want to consume, your consumption, and in turn standard of living, is limited by all the goods and services that are produced (including production so you can make goods other countries want and import the ones you want).
The distribution of productivity/economic growth gains is a bit of a different matter. Some of the increases in inequality are down to economic factors, like how automation acts differently on different jobs, some are a political matter. Countries can decide how much they want to redistribute, how much to tax the "top", how much to give to the "bottom" of the income distribution, in most countries this is down to how much political support there is for how much redistribution.
Debates about if and when productivity and pay diverge aside, economic growth is a necessary but not necessarily in of itself sufficient condition for a higher standard of living. Plainly put, if your country only produces (the equivalent of) two bananas per person, you can't eat three.
Meaning that you need to produce what you want to consume, your consumption, and in turn standard of living, is limited by all the goods and services that are produced (including production so you can make goods other countries want and import the ones you want).
The distribution of productivity/economic growth gains is a bit of a different matter. Some of the increases in inequality are down to economic factors, like how automation acts differently on different jobs, some are a political matter. Countries can decide how much they want to redistribute, how much to tax the "top", how much to give to the "bottom" of the income distribution, in most countries this is down to how much political support there is for how much redistribution.
Report
2points
#34 Are Snap Benefits Essentially Subsidies For Corporations Who Don’t Pay A Living Wage?
No because SNAP benefits don’t push labor supply upwards. If anything they might slightly lower labor supply since SNAP can allow for slightly more time to search for a new job when unemployed.
The way a subsidy works is that the payments would make it cheaper for employers to hire workers.
It is a subsidy for farmers and food sellers since it does boost demand for food. Hence why it is part of the farm bill
The way a subsidy works is that the payments would make it cheaper for employers to hire workers.
It is a subsidy for farmers and food sellers since it does boost demand for food. Hence why it is part of the farm bill
Report
2points
#35 Can Corporations Like Starbucks Really Afford To Pay Significantly More?

This is one person’s view so welcome criticism. Like always the answer is yes, but.
Let’s talk about Starbucks specifically. For FY2025 (which ended in Sept) Starbucks generated about $4.75bn in operating cashflow (net of all expenses including salaries), invested about $2.5bn (new locations, equipment, etc), and paid dividends and some refinancing for about $2.23bn. So when it was all said and done, the company kept almost no money in the bank ($4.75-$2.5-$2.23 equals roughly $0).
So from a financial standpoint they can’t just give everyone raises without giving something up. If they want to pay their employees more money, they could either raise their prices, invest less money in the business, reduce their dividend, or take out more debt to pay the dividend and or salaries. Each one of these options will either hurt the consumer, the company, or the shareholders. At the end of the day these companies (Starbucks and others) are businesses and are run as business.
Now you could argue that the folks who run the company (CEO, CFO, etc) should be paid less and have their pay distributed to the rest of the employees which is an entirely fair argument to make. However, it would be helpful to put things into context. Starbucks’ general and admin cost for 2025 was $2.7bn (including executive compensation and everyone else’s salaries) and the total executive compensation for 2024 (2025 hasn’t been determined yet) was $139m (a lot of that was stock but let’s assume it’s all cash for discussion purposes) which means the executives got paid about 5-6% of the total company G&A. For a company that has 381,000 employees this isn’t much money in the grand scheme of things.
Edit: I should not have said kept almost no money in the bank as that’s not entirely correct. I meant to say kept no extra money in the bank aside from the cash they already have).
Edit 2: someone commented that they can just cut the dividend in half so I thought it would be helpful to provide some color here. The board would need to approve such drastic cut to the dividend, and that would never happen simply because the board’s job is to look after the shareholders’ best interests. Unfortunately there is no clear evidence that cutting the dividend in half to give the employees raises would be in the shareholders’ best interest.
Let’s talk about Starbucks specifically. For FY2025 (which ended in Sept) Starbucks generated about $4.75bn in operating cashflow (net of all expenses including salaries), invested about $2.5bn (new locations, equipment, etc), and paid dividends and some refinancing for about $2.23bn. So when it was all said and done, the company kept almost no money in the bank ($4.75-$2.5-$2.23 equals roughly $0).
So from a financial standpoint they can’t just give everyone raises without giving something up. If they want to pay their employees more money, they could either raise their prices, invest less money in the business, reduce their dividend, or take out more debt to pay the dividend and or salaries. Each one of these options will either hurt the consumer, the company, or the shareholders. At the end of the day these companies (Starbucks and others) are businesses and are run as business.
Now you could argue that the folks who run the company (CEO, CFO, etc) should be paid less and have their pay distributed to the rest of the employees which is an entirely fair argument to make. However, it would be helpful to put things into context. Starbucks’ general and admin cost for 2025 was $2.7bn (including executive compensation and everyone else’s salaries) and the total executive compensation for 2024 (2025 hasn’t been determined yet) was $139m (a lot of that was stock but let’s assume it’s all cash for discussion purposes) which means the executives got paid about 5-6% of the total company G&A. For a company that has 381,000 employees this isn’t much money in the grand scheme of things.
Edit: I should not have said kept almost no money in the bank as that’s not entirely correct. I meant to say kept no extra money in the bank aside from the cash they already have).
Edit 2: someone commented that they can just cut the dividend in half so I thought it would be helpful to provide some color here. The board would need to approve such drastic cut to the dividend, and that would never happen simply because the board’s job is to look after the shareholders’ best interests. Unfortunately there is no clear evidence that cutting the dividend in half to give the employees raises would be in the shareholders’ best interest.
Report
2points
#36 If An Unemployment Rate Of 4-6% Is Considered “Healthy” And We Are Currently At 4.2% Why Is The Job Market So Trash?
The job market is healthy overall. Yes, there are pockets of weakness in some industries and physical regions. Yes, there are irritating trends for new hires. Yes there's a complicated relationship with wage growth vs. inflation. But truly the job market is strong in the US so far.
Report
2points
#37 Why Is Unblocking The Straight Of Hormuz So Important Economically To The Us If Only 2.5% Of Its Oil Come From There And It's A Net Exporter Of Oil?

I don't know what you mean by "so important" but,
1. the U.S. is not a net exporter of oil but instead a net exporter of "oil and oil products". We import oil and export diesel, gasoline, or etc.
2. It is a global market. Now that the Europeans aren't able to get arab and persian oil they are looking to buy oil that would normally come to the United States. Additionally the lengthening of global trade routes will increase the rates you have to pay for oil tankers increasing spreads and end costs for delivered oils.
1. the U.S. is not a net exporter of oil but instead a net exporter of "oil and oil products". We import oil and export diesel, gasoline, or etc.
2. It is a global market. Now that the Europeans aren't able to get arab and persian oil they are looking to buy oil that would normally come to the United States. Additionally the lengthening of global trade routes will increase the rates you have to pay for oil tankers increasing spreads and end costs for delivered oils.
Report
2points
#38 Are There Any Clear Cut Predictions We Can Confirm Will Happen Now That Trump’s Bill Is Passed?
Google "Big Beautiful Bill CBO Analysis". The CBO, or Congressional Budget Office, is a non-partisan government agency tasked with evaluating the budget and economic effects of major legislation. They're particularly well known for their rigor, accuracy and impartiality. You can do the same for any major piece of legislation. They'll even return to major legislation over the years and reevaluate their actual effects in the budget and economy.
Report
2points
#39 Why Does Recession Always Pop Up With Republican Presidents?

Presidents don't have enough of an influence on the economy to cause recessions. Well, the vast majority of the time. Trump didn't cause the pandemic, Bush didn't cause the GFC, Bush didn't cause the dot-com bubble. Reagan didn't cause oil price shocks. You can't blame these presidents for happening to be president when those recessions happened.
Report
1point
#40 Bernie Sanders Claims That Elon Musk Owns More Wealth Than The Bottom 52% Of Americans. How Is That Possible?

"When Bernie Sanders went on Joe Rogan the other week, he claimed that: "...one man, Mr Musk, own[s] more wealth than the bottom 52% of American families". However, when I did a little bit more digging, the bottom 50% of Americans own about $4 trillion in wealth (according to the Federal Reserve) whilst Elon Musk's personal net worth is in the vicinity of $400 billion (according to Forbes). At least from these numbers, that would indicate Bernie is off by a factor of ten so I'm wondering how he would have arrived at this statistic? Personally, I think this level of wealth inequality is extremely problematic whether its 50% or 5% of the population but I am curious if anyone knows how he arrived at this statistic. Perhaps it's only taking into account specific forms of debts and assets? He also used to mention that the three richest people in the United States owned more wealth than the bottom 50% but that would also run into some similar calculation issues so I feel like there is a hidden factor I'm not seeing here."
"I feel like there is a hidden factor I'm not seeing here."
Because Bernie draws on a rather questionable definition of net worth that excludes automobiles and durables. Even so, the original study finds that it takes ~25 individuals to match the combined wealth of the bottom 50%, and as others have pointed out, the bottom 30 percent are in net debt.
The bottom half by wealth is overwhelmingly young people in school or just entering the labor force (the SCF samples representatively through age 18). They're not supposed to have a lot of assets. It should be also pointed out that being in debt is also not necessarily a bad thing. 40% of U.S. college graduates take out student loans, the expected payoff of which is many times the cost.
"Personally, I think this level of wealth inequality is extremely problematic whether its 50% of 5% of the population"
Why? Musk and co's wealth are just numbers. it's locked in unrealized gains that due to collateralization he cannot possibly hope to liquidate at their prevailing valuation. If I own a million tokens in some weird cryptocurrency and someone paid $1000 for a token, that doesn't automatically make me a billionaire.
It's generally meaningless to measure wealth inequality because you can't really talk about asset values without talking about liquidity, and mostly all you're doing is measuring how little money young people have compared to old people. But people can't eat off of their house or borrow against their future social security checks or sell 5% of a public company without the stock collapsing immediately.
"I feel like there is a hidden factor I'm not seeing here."
Because Bernie draws on a rather questionable definition of net worth that excludes automobiles and durables. Even so, the original study finds that it takes ~25 individuals to match the combined wealth of the bottom 50%, and as others have pointed out, the bottom 30 percent are in net debt.
The bottom half by wealth is overwhelmingly young people in school or just entering the labor force (the SCF samples representatively through age 18). They're not supposed to have a lot of assets. It should be also pointed out that being in debt is also not necessarily a bad thing. 40% of U.S. college graduates take out student loans, the expected payoff of which is many times the cost.
"Personally, I think this level of wealth inequality is extremely problematic whether its 50% of 5% of the population"
Why? Musk and co's wealth are just numbers. it's locked in unrealized gains that due to collateralization he cannot possibly hope to liquidate at their prevailing valuation. If I own a million tokens in some weird cryptocurrency and someone paid $1000 for a token, that doesn't automatically make me a billionaire.
It's generally meaningless to measure wealth inequality because you can't really talk about asset values without talking about liquidity, and mostly all you're doing is measuring how little money young people have compared to old people. But people can't eat off of their house or borrow against their future social security checks or sell 5% of a public company without the stock collapsing immediately.
Report
0points


