In recent years, more and more Americans have moved to live in Canada (or have at least been talking about it, especially on social media). In 2021, about 256,000 American-born people were permanent residents of Canada. Interestingly, American women are particularly keen on the idea. If given the opportunity, 40% of women in the U.S. aged 15 to 44 would leave to live there permanently.
Sure, the U.S. and Canada share a continent, but they're different countries at the end of the day. Americans might think that the only differences are the pronunciation of a few words and universal healthcare. However, those who have actually taken the plunge know that there's more to the story. So, when one person online started a discussion by asking, "Americans in Canada, do you feel 'foreign'?" a few more differences came to light.
#21
The only region in the US that reminds me of Canada is New England - not like the attitude, but this collective want to see us all do better. The biggest thing is I feel less individualistic here (I live in Quebec). And while yeah the French part of it is obvious, I also genuinely care about my neighbors in a way I don’t feel when I’m back in the US.
Report
10points
#22
I feel like culturally we’re becoming harder to tell apart from the US. When I was younger there were way more differences. With the internet, streaming services, and the US’s cultural export dominance, those lines have blurred more and more. Add in how much of our media is owned by American companies, and it feels like a slow annexation by culture over time.
Report
10points
#23
From the northeast, tornoto felt pretty identical to nyc or chicago but vastly different than houston, or even SF.
Honestly, i dont think it makes sense to talk about america as one unit. houston, Phoenix, and Vegas more of a different country from boston than london or toronto.
Honestly, i dont think it makes sense to talk about america as one unit. houston, Phoenix, and Vegas more of a different country from boston than london or toronto.
Report
9points
#24
I think neighboring countries that share same language and descend from the same cultures are bound to be very similar and familiar. Like Austria and Germany, or Argentina and Uruguay, or Singapore and Malaysia, or Australia and New Zealand.
Report
8points
#25

I’m from Chicago and Toronto is much more familiar to me than New Orleans.
8points
#26

It feels foreign to me, but I am from Texas, and parts of the US feel foreign. Boston felt really foreign .. so much more civilized. Montreal feels like Europe. Vancouver felt like Seattle or Portland didn’t even notice a difference really. But honestly even with the language difference in Mexico feels less foreign to me than a lot of America, not too crazy since this literally used to be Mexico. But the US isn’t exactly 50 different countries but it’s like 13 different ones. PNW, The Midwestern lake states, the midwestern flat dry states, California, Texas, Hawaii, Puerto Rico, Alaska, New England, Colorado, New Mexico/Arizona desert area, Florida/alabama/Georgia coastal area, and the Deep South everything else in the south. Probably missing something lol. But I have been to every continental state except Minnesota Wisconsin and North Dakota and this is my impression of the US, you can feel foreign without leaving the borders of the US, and depending on where you’re from and where you’re at Canada might feel like home. I will say that one big difference is people self segregate less in Canada. I saw way more integrated friend group and communities in Canada even in Alberta than anywhere I have been in the US. That is the most foreign thing about Canada.
8points
#27

I do feel a bit… *different*. It’s hard to explain, and I don’t know if I come off as American. I probably do in certain circumstances. Hard to fully shake certain expectations and behaviors.
Report
8points
#28

I met a girl in Montreal that I’m currently dating and I’m currently going back and forth from nyc to Montreal. It’s not so much culture shock for me it’s more feeling embarrassed that I don’t speak French lol. I hesitate before going to a restaurant. I do think people in Montreal are less stress than in the states or at least it seems to me. When I’m there, I feel real at ease. I’m considering moving.
7points
#29
Foreign might not be the right word. I don’t know how to describe it but the baseline personality of a Canadian is clearly different. This leads to slight perspective differences, instead of cultural differences. That is what makes me feel “foreign”.
Report
7points
#30

I live in Montréal and my home (Québec) feels very much like a different country and culture. It doesn’t feel « foreign » to me though, just because I’ve lived here so long and speak the language, so it is very much my culture now, and I don’t really feel truly at home in my region of origin in the US any longer.
When I’m in English Canada, however, quite honestly it just feels like I’m in a different region of the US. It feels just as different to me as California feels from Minnesota. That is to say, different but not at all foreign. Canadians will crucify me for saying so, though. It is definitely a different country, don’t get me wrong, but culturally (I.e. popular culture-wise), it really doesn’t feel like it. The two countries (in the regions that primarily speak English, at least) are quite integrated on the level of popular culture. On other planes (politically, demographically, developmentally, historically etc) it is not.
When I’m in English Canada, however, quite honestly it just feels like I’m in a different region of the US. It feels just as different to me as California feels from Minnesota. That is to say, different but not at all foreign. Canadians will crucify me for saying so, though. It is definitely a different country, don’t get me wrong, but culturally (I.e. popular culture-wise), it really doesn’t feel like it. The two countries (in the regions that primarily speak English, at least) are quite integrated on the level of popular culture. On other planes (politically, demographically, developmentally, historically etc) it is not.
Report
6points


